2 ms·
I think that the author was attempting to note that the similarities between these techniques/models/tools are far greater than the differences. For me, machin
by disgruntledphd2 14y ago
I think that the author was attempting to note that the similarities between these techniques/models/tools are far greater than the differences.
For me, machine learning is a particular model set atop the edifice of statistics mixed with coding. I don't agree that big data poses unique challenges, I was reading a psychometric book from the late eighties where a lot of the material was familiar from the big data stuff we read about lately.
Logic is a way of deriving conclusions from propositions/data. Probability is a method for introducing uncertainty into logical reasoning (IMO, clearly). I don't understand your point about probability in culture, can you explain? I would suggest that your last statement in your second last paragraph is rather proving the author's point, but as my perception is noisy, I can't be sure.
And seriously, both probability and logic are related to natural intelligence (or whatever we want to call ourselves) far more than AI. In fact, the reason they have been applied to AI is because they are useful tools for humans. When you say bayesian logic networks do you mean Bayesian belief networks (as put forth by Pearl et al) or something else?
- tlarkworthy 14y ago"I don't agree that big data poses unique challenges" Google does. IBM does too (Watson). Unique algorithms on unique hardware for the sake of ML. I was at a machine learning conference with a speaker from Google (soz can;t remember who). They said they are not interested in any machine learning with complexity above O(nlogn) or that has to visit a training point more than once. That's a hell of alot of literature in the bin for the sake of big data (e.g. SVM, back propagation NNs). So the problems there are solving do have novel constraints (even if the overall function they are trying to approximate is the same) Yeah I agree probability is a logical inference scheme. I was just commenting on the kind of logic people think of on the term "LOGIC". That's classical, but you can also argue any system with symbols is logic. I was just trying to say that the Bayesian people think differently to the formal logic people. Thats what I meant by culture. They are very different sets of people normally (exception, see below) Bayesian Logic Networks:- http://ias.cs.tum.edu/_media/spezial/bib/jain09blns.pdf http://ias.cs.tum.edu/_media/spezial/bib/jain09blns.pdf probabilistic inference upon hard logic constraints. != Bayesian Belief Networks (standard Bayesian formulation)