4 ms·
That is probably just their excuse. I think it's quite reasonable to check if someone fixes a security flaw that puts your own information to the risk. It's lik
by tomp 14y ago
That is probably just their excuse. I think it's quite reasonable to check if someone fixes a security flaw that puts your own information to the risk. It's like trying to open (without the key) the safe at the bank that has your money in it.
- Karunamon 14y agoTry walking into the safe deposit box area at the bank absent escort or previous notification and see how that works out for you. Again, the school is on record as giving him kudos for reporting the error - it's perfectly reasonable to assume that someone will not launch offensive penetration testing tools at your site, without notice or permission, just because they have reported the bug in the past. He could have tested the bug without the pentest software, besides. Just because someone points out a crack in your window doesn't give them carte blanche to try breaking it after you said you fixed it.
- Dylan16807 14y agoThe webserver did escort him into the room with the safe deposit boxes. He has a key, they let him in, that's their job. The problem is that he could open his box, or any other box, without actually using the key.
- Karunamon 14y agoWe're laboring a physical analogy quite hard, here. Again, the problem isn't that he found and disclosed a bug, the problem is that he attempted to exploit that bug after the fact. You do not have the right to do that. Pure and simple. Finding and disclosing a bug is one thing, utilizing it is something else entirely.
- Dylan16807 14y agoHe was not 'exploiting' it. He was checking if it could be exploited, just performing a gentle tug.