7 ms·
Microsoft's ARM blunder: Why Windows RT was DOA
- brudgers 14y agoIf Microsoft was a B2C company, the article would be spot on. They are not, however, Apple. They are primarily B2B. Windows didn't come to dominate the desktop because consumers loved it. It dominates because it provides a value proposition to businesses. Success with consumers is part of that value proposition, and one of the things which gives it an advantage over Linux. RT is a long term strategy. It's not a tablet OS. It's the phone too, just not yet, fully.It's not targeted at consumers. It's targeted at enterprise. As a B2C company, Apple will not offer a roadmap or backward compatibility. Google being an advertising agency, will always seek to read one's data. Microsoft knows what it is.
- keithpeter 14y ago"RT is a long term strategy. It's not a tablet OS. It's the phone too, just not yet, fully.It's not targeted at consumers. It's targeted at enterprise." Comments on the original article point out that Windows RT lacks outlook and active directory integration. Is that the case?
- brudgers 14y agoThey are shipping an MVP. The first iPhones didn't have an AppStore, or 3G.
- rayiner 14y agoA business platform that lacks the only features that differentiate Windows on the tablet from android and iOS isn't minimally viable.
- justsee 14y ago"What's more, it's a poor fit with traditional Windows network environments. Office 2013 RT doesn't include Outlook, and Windows RT's built-in Mail and Calendar apps are lousy substitutes. Neither can Windows RT join an Active Directory domain, so forget about Group Policy and other tools used by Windows IT managers." The missing features listed above all sound like MVP features if Windows RT was targeted at a B2B audience. Their Surface marketing also seems focused on a B2C audience, not a B2B one. Giving employees free devices doesn't indicate anything either way. Nothing in this thread convinces me Windows RT is a B2B-focused device.
- shoopy 14y agoThe bar for "minimum" has been raised since the iPhone's release.
- mixmastamyk 14y agoLooks like they missed the V (as in viable).
- pyalot2 14y agoWinRT/WinPhone are not B2B OSes. B2B lives off the ability of a business to deploy their inhouse software that they (or somebody they contracted like Accenture) deploys on their infrastructure. A lot of these applications did move to the Intraweb. However Microsoft restricts the choice of web browsers that WinRT/WinPhone users can get, so if IE RT/Phone lack the capability you need, you're out of luck. The WinRT/WinPone strategy is aping 1:1 after the Apple B2C business model. Your "analysis" that this was a B2B solution is spot on wrong.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- pyalot2 14y agoThat assumes that a compelling argument can be made that all the legacy stuff you have can be made to work with it. Which it can't. - No application you've written to date will run on it - No application you're now going to write will run on it without uploading it to the app-store and letting everybody else download it. - Your active-directory NT-domain user management will not be able to deal with these machines. - Your own exchange server will not be able to talk to these devices e-mail clients. - Your host of macro-encrusted MS-Office documents will not work on that devices implementation of office. In short, nothing you did up to that point works on them. - It makes porting/supporting these devices extremely cumbersome and expensive - It demonstrates clearly that Microsoft was willing to break their entire backwards compatibility.
- brudgers 14y ago[My deleted post was along the lines that if you need IE6, you're SOL with any Microsoft upgrade path, and that their treatment of IE6 might be construed as an advantage - or disadvantage - when it comes to evaluating Microsoft's commitment to B2B customers] When it comes to legacy application support, Windows RT is not at a disadvantage to iOS or Android. And it's not as if Google Docs is going to handle "macro-encrusted" documents any better. For continuity, I'll repeat here what I have replied elsewhere. Microsoft could kludge RT to work with Exchange and NT-domain management. Or, they could develop those products robustly to meet a future filled with less powerful computing devices and sandboxed operating systems. One is - well, a kludge. The other is a long term strategy.
- jake_D 14y agoBusinesses work on desktops and active directories. WinRT makes no sense on the desktop, and it offers no AD. So MS has nothing to offer here, B2B wise. They made a huge mistake, pretending that desktops and mobile devices are the same beast. And they're gonna pay for it, in sales and market value. At the end of 2013, they should be a even less relevant than today.
- rednukleus 14y ago> At the end of 2013, they should be a even less relevant than today. At the moment, Microsoft own slightly less than 100% of the enterprise desktop market. At the end of 2013 they will almost certainly own slightly less than 100% of the enterprise desktop market. You live in a bubble.
- hippee-lee 14y agoTrue. But also at the end of 2013 even more employees will be bringing their own devices - phones and tablets to work so they don't have the enterprise lap top. These devices will run Android and iOS in a roughly 50/50 share of OS distribution. The enterprise supports the work their employees need to do by giving them the traditional desktop tools - this is Microsofts market and always has been. But more and more those tools are overkill for the job the employee needs to accomplish so they are turning to the tools that work for them in their personal lives.
- rednukleus 14y agoVery few people in the enterprise are going to stop using their Windows desktop/laptop, they are just going to supplement it with their phone/tablet - at least in 2013 anyway. People have been doing that for over a decade with Blackberrys.
- keithpeter 14y agoAnecdote 1: I see iPads on trains to London as often as I see Thinkpads (and the odd Dell) now. That was not the case a few years ago. Trains to London arriving before 9am are pure business I can assure you (£130 return second class). A few Mac laptops in first class, solid Thinkpad/iPad and blue shirt territory in 2nd. Anecdote 2: The middle managers where I work all have iPads and shared access to desktop PCs. They are using an rdp client on the iPads for access to some business applications. This has happened over the last two years. Anecdote 3: Most people visiting my place of work to specify systems (heating; photocopying; interior decoration; networking; compliance with various standards) now have iPads. That has happened in the last 18 months. No hard stats but I have noticed this change.
- kabdib 14y agoXbox is "B2C", in a very big way. The impression I got was that it was intended for consumers. Why else would you only sell it in a Microsoft store? (I did see one in a Best Buy. It was buried in with the other tablets, while there was a shining white table with iPads a few feet away, with actual people around it fondling the merchandise). It's true that MS did give most of their full-time employees free Surfaces. I assumed this was to promote internal use, and hey, who doesn't like free stuff? The hardware is great, but the Windows group really, honestly didn't know how to ship a tablet OS -- they're a B2B group trying to do B2C, but not really understanding what it takes. The result is emabarassingly bad in spots. My wife was having to deal with The Scourge That Is the Windows Registry, using the event viewer and task manager to diagnose some bug in WinRT. They really do not get it . . . or if they do, it's not at the level of design and management where it matters. You don't have to do this kind of mucking around on a Xbox. There are good reasons for this. Yet the Xbox is based on Windows. Interesting. Windows has been institutionalized inside MS to the extent that you can't ship a platform that doesn't use it. You need to use a /lot/ of it, and it's a procrustean bed, at best. Windows is getting really old and creaky; things that you might be able to justify on a desktop (e.g., a corrupt registry, or a service horking and needing some TLC) are just death on a tablet, and having consumers drop into desktop-level tools to fix stuff is just sad. (Don't get me started on WinRT).
- kabdib 14y ago[By 'it' in the 2nd paragraph, I mean Surface, btw.]
- brudgers 14y agoMicrosoft have always eaten their own dogfood. That's where Server and Office and Project came from...and obviously, Visual Studio. Giving RT devices to employees continues this tradition. It's also evidence that this is an enterprise strategy, not B2C. I used Windows 2.0. I was using WordPerfect when the first versions of Word were being developed. Surface is an MVP. [edit] A Note about Xbox. The way Microsoft handled the RRoD issue was pure B2B. They made it right for people out of warranty. Their choice of three years was the same as the period over which businesses depreciate assets. A B2C response would have been, "You should have purchased XboxCare." [/edit]
- technoslut 14y ago>RT is a long term strategy. It's not a tablet OS. It's the phone too, just not yet, fully.It's not targeted at consumers. It's targeted at enterprise. If that is the argument then MS will fail. This isn't 20 years ago where corporate could dictate what tech you used. As it is, half of these arguments in this article are flawed. The Surface isn't as good as what was offered by OEMs or Apple. . How does the Surface weigh more than an iPad 3 when the iPad 3 had a high-res display and was already considered to heavy? Why does the Surface have a kickstand that is useless on your lap when typing? This is what hardware design is about. Other Win RT tablets cost more because of the lack of cash that MS has where they can pay for pre-production costs and, at the same time, they don't have to pay licensing fees for the OS It should be irrelevant to MS if MS is competing with other OEMs. Their goal was to increase revenue. I'm sure MS will get better at hardware and software but they should learn patience first instead of being so quick in attempting to jump both Apple and Google in product development.
- kenjackson 14y agoHow does the Surface weigh more than an iPad 3 when the iPad 3 had a high-res display and was already considered to heavy? Why does the Surface have a kickstand that is useless on your lap when typing? This is what hardware design is about. The delta in weight between the iPad3 and Surface is pretty close to zero (15 grams). Furthermore, while the iPad3 has the HiRes display the Surface does have a USB and MicroSD slot and a better feeling body material. And the kickstand is usable on my lap. Not as nice as a laptop, but I use it on my lap nearly everyday. I'm sure MS will get better at hardware and software but they should learn patience first instead of being so quick in attempting to jump both Apple and Google in product development. Actually they did the exact right thing, IMO. You don't get great at HW design by not shipping. The Surface is a very good product. Not great, but it will get better I'm sure. Much like the iPod and iPad.
- technoslut 14y ago>You don't get great at HW design by not shipping. You also don't get sales by shipping a product too early. The Playbook proved this. There are inherent design flaws within RT that has also plagued W8 usability that MS did not give proper consideration of before release.
- jiggy2011 14y agoThat's a rather ambitious strategy I feel. If it is seen as DOA I don't see enterprises clambering to develop software for it. Enterprise users seem happy enough with their Win7 laptops and the odd iPad. Once they start feeling the need to move forwards , I get the feeling that WinRT will be but a memory.
- rbanffy 14y ago> Windows didn't come to dominate the desktop because consumers loved it. PC users did not hate it. Most DOS users were not ready to move to Macs and Windows provided an easy migration path, with 3.1 being, finally, good enough and able to run multiple DOS applications simultaneously.
- walshemj 14y agoAnd at the time (this is pre OS X) apples OS was not preemptive multitasking which is sort of required for a useful window based GUI
- rbanffy 14y ago> sort of required for a useful window based GUI Not really. At that time, I was programming under Windows 3 and I quickly learned to call yield() from within long-running functions. It was not perfect, but it was good enough.
- macspoofing 14y agoMicrosoft is and wants to be a B2C company. Half their initiatives, from Xbox, WinPhone, to Zune to Media Centers, and yes even Windows OS is squarely directed at consumers.
- pinaceae 14y agoyou should tell that to Microsoft then, because they themselves position RT for consumers. source: we are working with MS on building a Win8 app. i am quoting MS themselves here. RT does not connect to AD. it is not enterprise ready in any form.
- MattRogish 14y agoThe problem is that there's a whole US generation not being brought up in a PC household. You don't think kids of today are gonna make purchasing decisions of tomorrow? That companies are going to be able to sustain a PC-only environment in the face of the fact that the majority of college students are using Mac? That businesses across the board are adopting "BYOD"? This is what should terrify MSFT - this is absolutely devastating. This is why they have XBox. This is why they attempted the Zune. This is why they have a tablet. Yes, the business environment is MS' bread-and-butter, but it's going to suffer catastrophic hits over the next 5-10 years as the "Anything-but-Windows" generation grows up. You seriously think that companies will be able to maintain their MS hegemony when the majority of new employees have grown up with a Mac, iOS, and/or Android? Make no mistake - this is huge, and what will break Microsoft's back. A diversified IT client base breaks Microsoft's stranglehold. You pay a fortune (a definite price premium) for Exchange, Office, SQL Server, Sharepoint, Windows Server, etc. because it gives you labor/cost savings in an all-PC environment. Once you throw iOS, Mac, Android, etc. devices into the mix, you no longer have that advantages. If I was a CIO or CTO and my business users were complaining that IT is too restrictive, that it's impacting hiring and employee retention - there's no way that a "MS-only" policy is going to stand. If you're a startup or other small/medium sized business - why wouldn't you switch to Google Apps for Mail? Oh, and it includes a lot of other things, too (groups, "office-lite" collaboration; oh and a Chromebook that "just works" within this environment). Not that MS won't still be a big player in businesses but a lot of the "demand" for MS business apps are propped up by economies of a homogenous environment. Once that starts to unravel, there's no stopping it. ref http://macdailynews.com/2012/06/06/gartner-apple-macs-invading-the-windows-pc-dominated-enterprise/ http://macdailynews.com/2012/06/06/gartner-apple-macs-invadi... http://plzkthxbai.com/blog/2009/09/24/nearly-58-of-college-students-using-macs/ http://plzkthxbai.com/blog/2009/09/24/nearly-58-of-college-s... http://daringfireball.net/linked/2010/08/08/mac-share-college http://daringfireball.net/linked/2010/08/08/mac-share-colleg... http://tech.fortune.cnn.com/2010/08/07/big-macs-on-campus/ http://tech.fortune.cnn.com/2010/08/07/big-macs-on-campus/
- mittermayr 14y agoto be honest, what fascinates me is that microsoft seems to have invested a lot of work the past few years to bring forward a pretty decent line up of integrated products. if you want windows and office like you had, that's fine. and much of the windows 8 UI disaster was actually made up by the press to have a great story, even that one video with the guy's dad. i was shocked when i saw that. then i installed windows and while setting up my account, it actually taught me about the new things pretty well. there's room for improvement for sure, but compared to apple, they do not only need to come up with a reasonable set of visible features (yes, this is how the masses work, not us here), but also make these mostly visual features feasible for business and consumers. people tend to forget that talking about 'business' does not mean a brooklyn hipster photography shop, or a startup (although there are just as many employees there) - it means a small shop in india, a global giant like boeing or a government system in germany (munich switched back). and, in all that chaos, they need to present a clear thread from the mobile sales guy to enterprise software, from consumer home to consumer mobile. apple is basically focusing on getting the story at home right. now they have the luxury of adding to that, which they become less and less effective at. the iphone was fantastic, and my home is now equipped fully with apple. but it sucks that this is where the story ends, at least for now (i'm sure they've figured this out already). i'd love to see microsoft getting a bit more love, honestly. all these guys working hard, being the 'bad guy' since the 80's and everyone forgetting that there's a reason they're still in business, were never close to being shut down and very rarely every fire more than a few people. when they do, it's even in the news (last firing spree iirc was 2000 employees, 3 years ago or so, with +100k staff). very sad that the 'press' still finds it lovely to tell us all how much microsoft really sucks. i love visual studio, i love c#, i love my iphone but man the windows phone 8 is so smooth and great to use, i love the macbook it beats any other notebook, but I also love windows 8 and the freshness of it. what a drama world.
- mittermayr 14y agoand to summarize what I wanted to say: microsoft should finally split up into two separate entities. a microsoft for business solutions. and a complete separate brand (yes, new name, new logo, new location) that caters to consumers. bridging these is probably easier, than to apply business marketing to a consumer, and consumer marketing to large businesses. if they focused just on business, many of the hater blogs would not even remotely talk about it - and the industry relevant magazines would be as they are, acknowledge the good things, highlight the improvements.
- dschiptsov 14y agoExcellent slogan: Microsoft: The software stinks or it is better suited for Java?
- timbre 14y agoHas Microsoft ever produced a good version 1? Maybe XBox? I don't know much about games. But for the most part I think what MS is good at is slowly improving a turd until it's really quite nice. DOS, Windows, IE, Office, and Visual Studio were all much worse than their competition initially, but successful by their fourth versions or so. But I don't know if MS has the heart anymore to go through a few rounds of failure to reach success.
- rednukleus 14y agoMost big tech products are like that. The first Android and iOS devices were pretty crap (but showed promise).
- visualcsharp 14y agoI swear, if I read the word fondleslab one more time...
- mikecane 14y agoWhat problem does Windows RT solve? Aside from niche use cases for IT types, nothing I can see. Potential customers seem to agree -- they're not buying it.
- zanny 14y agoIt solves the problem of Microsoft not having a tablet. There was a big pie in ipads, they wanted some pie, make a tablet. While they were at it, they could make it one of the most closed platforms ever conceived to try to make that app store money. Because that is where the new revenue is at, after all. That was Microsoft's arguments, at least, I'd imagine.
- mikecane 14y ago>>>It solves the problem of Microsoft not having a tablet. For customers.
- rbanffy 14y agoI'm old enough to remember Apple II's (and personal computers in general) were the BYOD of the late 70's and early 80's.
- SoftwareMaven 14y agoThat's an interesting point, as it shows that today's BYOD could crystallize into another homogenous world. I kind of thing it won't, though, just because, in the late 70s and early 80s, personal computers were rare and relatively expensive things. In today's BYOD, we are talking much greater proliferation at much lower cost.
- rbanffy 14y agoI'm not thinking less about consolidation and more about disruption. BYOD is the personal computer to Microsoft's mainframe.
- Amanda_Panda 14y agoYeah, even as a .Net developer who generally has high praise for C# and VS, I agree that the WinRT Surface was DOA. Its exactly like those Android tablets that came out in 2011 with Android 3.x-really nice devices, definitely not garbage, but aren't worth the price they are being sold at. The difference is that was two years ago and Android tablets are finally moving ahead, after dropping in price (Fire, Nook, N7) and improving massively in terms of the OS on parity with iOS (JB and up). MSFT can't afford to enter the market like this two years late. I'd say that the tablet should'e been priced at 299, with the keyboard cover thrown in. Maybe that'd have increased its popularity. On the plus side it also has file system access, command line, and powershell (for the 1% of the market who are geeky Windows sysadmin types). It also should've been sold at a lot of different stores right out of the gate.
- relaxatorium 14y agoWhat's up with the repeated use of the term "fondleslab" here? Is that actual UK slang, or is the author just a weirdo? I could not concentrate on any points made in this article because the repeated use of that term was wildly offputting.
- btbuilder 14y agoIt is in regular use by all authors on The Register.
- mixmastamyk 14y agoUse of a funny word is wildly offputting? Reminds me of an ancient bit on HBO's "Not Necessarily the News"... guy in the dark complaining bitterly at the TV, they rush him out the door into the front yard, limping in bathrobe, his eyes squinting in the sunlight, narrator loudly proclaims "GO OUTSIDE!". ;)
- relaxatorium 14y ago"wildly" might be overstating it, but I find it gross. Same way some people just don't like the word "moist", I guess. I was curious where the word came from. Anyhow, back to our regular discussions of what Fondleslabs are going to conquer the market in 2013.
- kayoone 14y agoI still think MS are up to something with Win 8. Look at the new Thinkpad Helix for example. Its a full fledged i5/i7 11.6" Laptop running Win8, and if you remove the Display you have a i7 powered tablet running Win8. Basically all your computing needs in one device. Sure they need to sort out a few things here and there, but this is the 1st generation of devices which looks really good. WinRT is DOA though, it needs alot of work and i dont see that worth it.
- trotsky 14y agoI am going to ignore most of this because it's just more of the same (even if a fair amount is true) - it's fashionable to dog on ms right now. But declaring that using Windows RT (and by extension the full NT kernel) as a basis for their tablet line was a fatal flaw ignores a whole raft of significant potential benefits to across their whole product line. I was surprised when I found out that they were doing a port for their tablet instead of basing it on their mobile code base, but once they announced they were going to be using mainline nt on the phone too it all clicked. Let's get real: The core NT kernel team is the unheralded jewel of microsoft. They put together a good base when their legacy16/32 base of 95/98 was clearly close to technical self destruction. In 10 years Windows stability on the desktop went from borderline worst to best in class by a notable margin. And while few people realize it, they have been consistently the first major player with modern security features and systems like nx, boot chain validation, driver signing requirements, default auto software upgrades, heavily improved os/browser sandboxing, document version based backups, 1st party FDE, and on and on. Note I'm taking the NT kernel team. Not microsoft as a business, app developer, marketer, pariah. I have code in the linux kernel, am typing on os x and goog/aapl make my gadgets. All I know is if I saw tablets/phones as an existential threat to my business and my earlier efforts had clear technical problems, I'd want to put my best team thats proven they can evolve on it. It's a perfect time - phones are shipping 4 cores and 2 gigs, meanwhile my server 2012 domain controller has been running great with 2 vcpus and uses on average 700mb. At the same time laptops and servers are making a huge push into super low power operation. This requires more than just hardware changes - the mobile os's work hard on freezing workloads that aren't actively being used and it makes a big difference. Traditional desktop OS's are super bad at this because of history and existing applications, but future laptops and datacenters are destined for similar techniques. Even if WinRT dies horribly, the laptops people buy in a few years will be benefiting from microsoft's shared learning there. And of course, maybe that full windows laptop they buy won't be running on an x86 cpu. I'm not rushing out to buy a surface or lumia it's true, but they certainly have piqued my interest and in my opinion they are currently doing the best technical/product/design work that they've done since... pretty much ever.
- seanmcdirmid 14y agoWhat is sort of weird is that Microsoft is the only company that is doing this with their own kernel. Everyone else (Google, Apple) have appropriated some other open source technolog for that (NetBSD for OS/X, Linux for Android) as if the kernel somehow wasn't a competitive advantage anymore. I have no idea which approach is "better," this is just an interesting observation and might hint at the values of the companies involved.