10 ms·
U.S. Senator Questions Attorney General about Aaron Swartz
- danso 14y agoIt's worth noting that Cornyn, though not an official PIPA co-sponsor, wasn't someone who was much against it either (until after the blackout) http://projects.propublica.org/sopa/C001056 http://projects.propublica.org/sopa/C001056
- LiveTheDream 14y agoThis seems like a good thing, no? A Senator listening to his constituents.
- tptacek 14y agoHis constituents also wanted him to try to ban the NYC "ground zero mosque". He was happy to oblige.
- tptacek 14y agoThis is the same hyperpartisan Senator who was at the forefront of the effort to deny habeas rights to Guantanamo inmates; he was also involved in the Bush wiretapping scandal. Expect to see lots of superficial genuflection from Republicans towards the Swartz case; the GOP is in a constant low-grade conflict with the Democratic DoJ. Here, let me put it this way: what do you honestly think Aaron Swartz would think about this clown using his name to score political points?
- danso 14y agoYes, this is most definitely a proxy in the ongoing political battle between the Senate Republicans and the DoJ. It's a little surprising that he would side with Aaron just to take a potshot at the U.S. attorney's office. It's also worth pointing out that Texas (at least until recently) had some of the best open-records laws in the country. Cornyn argued that the Feds should emulate Texas in this regard -- during the Bush administration: http://gritsforbreakfast.blogspot.com/2005/03/cornyn-foia-should-mimic-texas-open.html http://gritsforbreakfast.blogspot.com/2005/03/cornyn-foia-sh...
- pemulis 14y agoIf he was advocate for more open access to government records, why is it surprising that he would be concerned about the Aaron Swartz case? I agree that this letter could be seen as part a larger battle between Republicans and the Obama DoJ, but does that mean that questions about Aaron Swartz' prosecution are only valid if they come from Democrats?
- anigbrowl 14y agoHis point is that the Obama administration actually did revamp the federal FOIA policy and got no credit for it, I think. But that's kind of by-the-by.
- danso 14y agoThat wasn't my point...and while Obama has opened some new doors, the thinking in the journalism community is that his administration is actually more closed when it comes to raw request numbers: http://www.poynter.org/latest-news/mediawire/156227/obama-administrations-foia-record-worse-than-bushs/ http://www.poynter.org/latest-news/mediawire/156227/obama-ad... This is of course a quantitative measure...but given that Obama wrote a very direct order to officials to err on the side of openness, it's striking that that order is being ignored so casually...I don't think it's hard to make a case that the culture of the bureaucracy is not particularly mindful of openness.
- anigbrowl 14y agoIn that case I can't figure out what your point was, but this is all sort of incidental anyway.
- danso 14y agoYeah, I was just meandering. The parent post had argued that this was little more than a hypocritical political ploy. I was saying, 'probably', because there's not much to politically gain from it other than to give the DOJ a black eye and because, I guess I just see Swartz as still being a "niche" issue to most people outside of the tech/academic senator. But I thought it was fair to point out that Cornyn is no fairweather public-records fan. But of course, Swartz's JSTOR incident was not just a case of open-access (as it was in the PACER case). There's enough nuance here that I would've just assumed that a senator of Conryn's level would leave it be as there are many other political shitstorms going on (gun control, debt ceiling, etc etc)
- gyardley 14y agoOr perhaps he's simply being responsive to his constituents here in Texas, some of whom took the time to urge him to act. I'm proud to have him as a Senator.
- abraininavat 14y agoSeriously? You feel that his thinly veiled threats of violence to federal judges makes him a credit to your state? You think it's representative of the popular opinion in Texas to suggest that "None of your civil liberties matter much after you're dead"? Pretty low standards, eh?
- gyardley 14y agoYes, seriously. Are you bringing up something from 2005 to kick dirt over the rightness of Senator Cornyn's current actions? Whatever could be the point of this, besides counter-productive partisanship? Can a right action be taken only by people with pasts you deem fully worthy?
- chc 14y agoI don't believe anybody is disputing that what Cornyn is doing now is good. Nobody is saying, "These questions are bad because Cornyn did bad things before." They're disputing that he is, as a whole, somebody you'd want to give your unreserved support for just because he did this one good thing.
- tptacek 14y agoThen you're proud to have as a senator someone who compared gay marriage to marrying a box turtle.
- gyardley 14y agoThe other commenter on this thread is right - this is classic poisoning the well. When a politician does something right - and Cornyn's letter asks far more pointed and on-point questions than I expected - the correct response is not to bring up everything you feel the politician has ever done wrong. My views, your views, and Cornyn's views about gay marriage aren't particularly relevant here.
- ddrt 14y agoCite your sources, please. I'd be interested in reading a legitimate claim to this as a link to a credible source rather than taking the top post for face value on a delicate subject.
- chc 14y agoThis hardly seems worth asking for. Do they not have Google in your neck of the woods?
- thoughtcriminal 14y agoNo, I'd say that's a fair request. This Senator is asking some important questions in a very succinct way that could bring reform, and tptacek is publicly trying to discredit and undermine him. tptacek should support that statement.
- IWentToTheWoods 14y agoI think chc's point is that it takes less time to google "Cornyn Guantanamo" and "Cornyn wiretapping" than it does to post the question here, and will produce a better answer to boot.
- mitchty 14y agoAnd I think ddrt's point is that even if one does google as you're saying, they may not end up with the same information that had the person arrive at the conclusion. In this case its valid. Yes we can google it, everyone here knows how to do that. The bigger problem is knowing from where people got their information.
- chc 14y agoHey, if you Googled it and somehow ended up with the impression that Cornyn might have supported granting Habeas Corpus rights and opposed the Bush Administration's wiretapping, that would definitely be worth a post raising the issue. But that wouldn't happen, because this isn't a fuzzy or subjective matter. A Senator's stances on issues like these are simple, objective, easily falsifiable facts. This is one or two steps away from demanding a citation for "Barack Obama is a Democrat." Like, if you can't easily figure out for yourself whether it's true or false, the only possible reason is that you didn't care enough to try.
- smokeyj 14y ago> Expect to see lots of superficial genuflection from Republicans Politicians play politics. News at 11
- brudgers 14y agoBoth parties make hay with the DOJ when they are in opposition. The Democrats with the firing of U.S. Attorneys by the Bush administration. Before that it was the Republicans over Elián González in the Clinton Administration.
- scarmig 14y agoTrue, but so what? Isn't the point of having an adversarial political system that when one side fucks up, the other will call them on it? Even if they're being giant hypocrites in the process?
- abraininavat 14y agoIs a modicum of integrity really too much to ask?
- vec 14y agoGiven the historical record, probably.
- gavinlynch 14y agoNo, the intent was so that both sides were too busy fighting each other to the point that they could never take control of the country to establish and dictatorship :p. And with that perspective in mind, I can confidently assert that the constitution has been a wild success.
- rayiner 14y agoThe Swartz case aside, nobody likes the DOJ. Liberals don't like them because they're tasked with defending laws like DOMA (until recently), drug laws, etc, and people like John Yoo, etc, that are unpopular with their contingent. Conservatives don't like them because they are tasked with defending laws like the Sherman Act, etc, that are unpopular with their contingent. But each side likes the laws that are unpopular with the other side, so they also rag on the DOJ for not doing enough to enforce those laws.
- justin66 14y agoThere are some pretty serious oversimplifications there. I can "like" an office or department even if its current inhabitant is doing something I don't like. For obvious reasons, this is doubly true when we're talking about an office inhabited by political appointees.
- rayiner 14y agoOh sure, people like the DOJ conceptually. But nobody ever likes the actual DOJ that exists at any given time. To a liberal, the DOJ is in the abstract the agency that enforces anti-trust laws or the like against big companies. But the actual DOJ is the one going after people growing weed. To a conservative, the DOJ in the abstract is the agency that goes after drug traffickers. But the actual DOJ is the one meddling in mergers.
- justin66 14y agoIt seems like you're just assuming that everyone has a very simple, AM radio view of their government. Things like disliking the political appointees of an institution rather than the institution itself, or disliking parts of an institution rather than the whole, are not difficult distinctions to make. Similarly, I can judge the work output of any institution and my opinion is not likely to be 100% positive or 100% negative.
- jessaustin 14y ago
- fleitz 14y agoGreat, perhaps Mr. Conryn can recommend a place for Mrs. Ortiz to go waterboarding in Cuba, I hear the water's great this time of year. Maybe once she comes back she can fight for those habeas corpus rights the US DOJ says gitmo prisoners don't have.
- AnIrishDuck 14y ago> This is the same hyperpartisan Senator who was at the forefront of the effort to deny habeas rights to Guantanamo inmates; he was also involved in the Bush wiretapping scandal. This is poisoning the well. There are some good questions in the posted letter. Unfortunately, we are unlikely to get good answers. Whatever their political stripes or past failings, at least someone is willing to press the issue instead of dropping it. Of the asked questions, the ones with veiled accusations of retaliation demand an especially compelling answer. The DoJ should definitely be on the spot for their prior entanglements with Schwartz. Their conduct in this case could easily be construed as retaliatory (we couldn't get you then, so we'll slam you now). The only question that seems silly to me is the last one. Of course a DoJ prosecutor is aware of the concept of prosecutorial discretion. To be fair, it's also a good counterpoint to the current silly "Congress made us be mean" line the prosecution is taking. It's just more of a statement than a question. > Expect to see lots of superficial genuflection from Republicans towards the Swartz case; the GOP is in a constant low-grade conflict with the Democratic DoJ. One of the nice things about an adversarial system is that you can benefit from the conduct of parties whose views don't align with your own. I'm not saying we should act ignorant of the Senator's motivations here. We just shouldn't dismiss his concerns outright because of them.
- tptacek 14y agoI'm happy the questions are being asked, but Cornyn's no friend of civil liberties and I suggest you keep that in mind.
- spigoteater 14y agoOnly a small percentage of Congress are friends to civil liberties. This is the august body that gave us the Patriot Act, after all.
- tptacek 14y agoFunny you should mention that: Voted YES on extending the PATRIOT Act's roving wiretaps. (Feb 2011) Voted NO on requiring FISA court warrant to monitor US-to-foreign calls. (Feb 2008) Voted YES on removing need for FISA warrant for wiretapping abroad. (Aug 2007) Voted NO on implementing the 9/11 Commission report. (Mar 2007) Voted NO on preserving habeas corpus for Guantanamo detainees. (Sep 2006) Voted NO on requiring CIA reports on detainees & interrogation methods. (Sep 2006) Voted YES on reauthorizing the PATRIOT Act. (Mar 2006) Voted YES on extending the PATRIOT Act's wiretap provision. (Dec 2005)
- miked 14y agoThis is the same hyperpartisan Senator who was at the forefront of the effort to deny habeas rights to Guantanamo inmates. The Entitled Party had complete control of the House and a 60 senator supermajority in the Senate for the first year of Obama's presidency, not to mention near complete control of the "news" media, Hollywood, television, the arts, the unions, etc, etc. If they wanted to introduce habeas rights for prisoners of war for the first time in US (or most any other country's) history, Obama et al could have done it anytime they wanted. State-run news media would have dutifully reported the wonderfulness of it all. Television programs and Hollywood movies would have exclaimed over the Nobel Peace Prize winner's greatness in their plot dialogue. They didn't do any of it. Remember, it's Cornyn that's being "hyperpartisan", not you.
- tptacek 14y agoI can't tell if this is a markov generator trolling me or not. All I can tell you is: I'm glad the questions are being asked, but don't go assuming John Cornyn is a friend to hackers.
- crusso 14y agoI'm glad the questions are being asked Maybe, but I hope you can appreciate why you're getting the ad hominem accusations from your words in the original post. Can't we appreciate when justice is done or good questions are asked no matter who is asking them? Personally, I know the national media is going to navel gaze on any opportunity to put any hard questions to this administration. We might as well support the opposition party for at least serving some purpose.
- temphn 14y agoWho defines what a hacker is? The definition certainly does not include fealty to state power, let alone respect for Obama or any political party. You seem to believe that HN is a Democrat Party auxiliary.
- tptacek 14y agoIt is refreshing, at least, for people on HN to assume I'm a partisan of the Democratic party instead of the other one. :)
- jlgreco 14y agoEnemy of my enemy is... well, quite possibly also my enemy.. but at least it is nice to see them fighting.
- johngalt 14y agoDefinition of hyper-partisanship: Attacking the opposing side even when they agree with you.
- tptacek 14y agoI don't believe for a moment that he agrees with me at all.
- dos1 14y ago> what do you honestly think Aaron Swartz would think about this clown using his name to score political points? I'm not sure I understand why the "clown" scoring political points is so bad. Where in the rulebook does it state that doing the right thing must be completely devoid of agenda or beneficial byproducts? Take, for example, volunteering. There are many who "volunteer" because they have to - whether it be for school, punishment, whatever. Do you think the volunteer organizations care why the volunteers are there as long as they work and do their jobs? No. They're just happy they've got people to help. I think the same thing applies here. I never met Aaron nor do I know how he would react, but I know many folks who care deeply about this issue. They really only care that someone is asking the pointed questions and holding the DoJ accountable. They don't much care who it is or why he's doing it. If the end result is the same, what does it matter anyways?
- MartinCron 14y agoIt sounds like you're saying that the means justify the means.
- tptacek 14y agoThere's nothing wrong with appreciating Cornyn's questions. I just think you should appreciate them ruefully.
- dos1 14y ago> I just think you should appreciate them ruefully. This is a perfect description. I agree completely with the "ruefully" portion. I will still support his quest to raise trouble at the DoJ, but I do not support many of the other things for which he stands.
- dos1 14y agoYep. It sure seems like no one in Washington plays the game fairly, so you might as well score what points you can in any way that you can. I know there are many who disagree with that.
- 14y ago
- jacoblyles 14y agoThomas, could you be any more hateful? The guy is doing something right. Who cares if he's a Republican?
- tptacek 14y agoI could be a lot more hateful about John Cornyn, who is repugnant to me and an all-around force for evil. For now, I'll just stick to the bare facts. If Dick Cheney wrote this letter, a big chunk of HN would have no trouble identifying the problem. But very few HN'ers pay enough attention to national politics to understand that John Cornyn is one of the Senate's answers to Dick Cheney.
- jacoblyles 14y agoYou're giving "your side" a bad name. You're heading into self-parody. Mitt Romney and his sons once rescued a family from drowning when the family's boat sunk on a lake. I imagine you could find some ulterior evil motive in that.
- tptacek 14y agoI wouldn't dream of insulting Mitt Romney by comparing him to John Cornyn.
- spinlocked 14y agotptacek, give up already, i think everyone here is in agreement that your views are perverted.
- waterlesscloud 14y agoIf we're going to play that game, let's play it all the way. Ortiz has been talked about as a candidate for senator. With Kerry moving to Sec of State, there's a senate seat in Mass. opening up. Scott Brown just lost the seat for the Republicans and will probably be running for the new opening to gain it back. By taking on Ortiz, Cornyn is removing a potentially strong competitor to Brown. But really, who cares what games are going on in the background? Ortiz shouldn't have a career in politics, and it's not going to be people in her own party that stop her.
- tptacek 14y agoHuh? Ortiz isn't a contender for MA-Senate. That seat is going to Ed Markey. I am 100% with you on the need to stay on top of Ortiz and limit her career. I have the same problem in my home state with Anita Alvarez, who is also being groomed for bigger things. I have no problem with the questions Cornyn is asking. Let's just keep him from being adopted as an Internet Superhero. He's not one of those.
- spinchange 14y agoI am loath to politicize this any further, but since you're highlighting the context, I feel compelled to note it is the Democratic DoJ who is staffed at the highest levels with former IP-industry trade representatives. It is the Democratic executive branch that made these appointments and has made IP enforcement a top priority for said Democratic DoJ, including the Joint DoJ Task Force[1], IPEC [2], and across the Government generally [3] Also, worth pointing out is how SOPA didn't really "die" until Paul Ryan and congressional Republicans abandoned it en masse. (and surprisingly, neither he nor they made scant, if any use of this fact for political purposes during the election) As a self-identified center-left progressive, you can imagine this creates some strong cognitive dissonance for me, but the pragmatist in me can accept the strange bedfellows and opportunism for what it is. Superficial or not, is Mr. Cornyn acting in your interests or against them? [1] http://www.justice.gov/dag/iptaskforce/ http://www.justice.gov/dag/iptaskforce/ [2] http://www.whitehouse.gov/omb/intellectualproperty http://www.whitehouse.gov/omb/intellectualproperty [3] http://www.iprcenter.gov/ http://www.iprcenter.gov/
- OGinparadise 14y ago"This is the same hyperpartisan Senator who was at the forefront of the effort to deny habeas rights to Guantanamo inmates; he was also involved in the Bush wiretapping scandal." So what? Does it mean that he is "wrong" about everything else?
- berlinbrown 14y agoWhy can't you just take the questions at face value and leave it at that. You are doing the same thing that Carmen Ortiz did to Aaron. You are attacking this guy.
- michael_nielsen 14y agoCornyn has for many years been a leader on open access to science. Together with Joe Lieberman he introduced the Federal Research Public Access Act (FRPAA) into Congress in 2006. This Act would, if passed, make almost all scientific publications funded by the US Govt openly accessible within 6 months of publication: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Federal_Research_Public_Access_Act http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Federal_Research_Public_Access_... The act has not yet passed. It was re-proposed in 2010 and 2012, each time with increased support from a bi-partisan group of sponsors, in both Houses. Cornyn is still a sponsor. My understanding is that Cornyn was instrumental in the passage of the 2008 NIH public access policy, which makes NIH-funded research available within 6 months of publication: http://publicaccess.nih.gov/ http://publicaccess.nih.gov/ This is by far the largest victory for open access to date. It would, however, be eclipsed by FRPAA, should it pass. Given all this, I believe it is natural that Cornyn has an interest in the case, and questions.
- tptacek 14y agoJohn Cornyn and science get along great, as long as the science doesn't involve stem cell research (which he has casted Senate votes to ban) or climate change.
- JumpCrisscross 14y agoA discussion, let alone a democracy, cannot function if one requires everyone to agree with them on every sub-point of every item related to the topic of question.
- tptacek 14y agoI agree completely. I'm not suggesting that people can't applaud overtures towards open science or open access or an accountable DOJ. I'd just hope to maybe shape and direct the applause, so we're clear what its real target is. I like Richard Posner, for instance, but I'm disquieted by how quickly the Reddit/HN crowd decided to lionize him once he came to a conclusion they liked regarding patents. Posner for SCOTUS! from people who understand the abstract from one case he worked on. Sheesh!
- temphn 14y agoOne approach is to reflexively attack Republicans even when they are on the same side. Another is to consider this a rare moment of bipartisan comity; if Republicans see the light on open access, copyright reform and prosecutorial abuse on this, fantastic. There are times when Obama and the DOJ are wrong and the Republicans and Democrats in Congress are right. This is one of those times. After all, the US allied with Stalin to beat Hitler, sometimes you do what you gotta do. Re: what Swartz would think, he wasn't exactly a fan of Obama's DOJ or drone strikes either.
- zzzeek 14y agoI'm as partisan liberal-democrat as anyone, just read my posts. But what's the negative outcome here? Nerds start supporting a conservative texas senator? It's not like this is the issue that hinges on Cornyn winning or losing to a Democrat in 2014 - his seat has been republican all the way back to 1961 at least.
- adventured 14y agoThere aren't very many politicians in DC that aren't hyper partisan. A funny thing to hit someone with given the current environment. A Senator involved in a wiretapping scandal? You mean the one where the government has been illegally reading every email for a decade? Or the one where the Obama Administration has done everything in its power to evade constitutional protections on privacy? Or the one where the government is illegally storing as much private communication data as they can? You're going to have to indict nearly every politician in DC, including the President, if that's your standard. And I think that you should (indict them all), but it's ridiculous to use that as some kind of example of terrible behavior: it's the sad status quo in Washington, where privacy violations are now 'legal' and illegal torture is now legal 'enhanced interrogation' etc etc etc etc.
- tlear 14y agoDo you see democrats lining up to ask even 1/10th of this? Anyone? Anywhere?.. Why would that be?
- TWAndrews 14y agoOur political system was built such that the venal interests of politicians would motivate them to check a) over-reaches of the other branches of government and b) the excesses of the other party. It would be nice if progressives were up-in-arms about overreach in the Justice Department of a Democratic president, but it's not to be expected. Even if it's just republican point scoring, it's still someone holding the Justice department to account.
- spinlocked 14y agoYour views are consistent with a paid or otherwise incentivized "shill" with vested interests in taking the opposite view of any positive legislative action regarding the Swartz case. You knocked the earlier legislative proposal, now you are knocking this.
- Kynlyn 14y agoBut if a Democrat were to have written the same letter, that would have been ok with you? Then he wouldn't have been "a clown"? Here we have a Senator who is at least drawing attention to the situation, but that isn't welcome because he comes from the wrong side of the aisle? I'm sure Cornyn is using this for political gain. Of course he is. But if you think there is anyone in Washington who isn't motivated by political gain then your being very naive.
- argv_empty 14y agoTry imagining GP comment as being directed towards those who believe that someone who agrees with you on a few issues is your eternal faithful ally and someone who disagrees with you on a few issues is a partisan demagogue who will oppose you at every turn. There appear to be many such people commenting on HN stories related to this series of events.
- pmorici 14y agoDoes it matter? Your point of view seems to be that unless a politician shares your every point of view then you can't agree with them on any issue. Seems like a good way to never accomplish anything.
- greesil 14y agoI'm sure this senator is doing this for political points (+10 points for Gryffindor), but we can still be glad for the pressure applied to the DOJ.
- rhizome 14y agoPolitics helped get us into this mess, we're going to need it to get out.
- joering2 14y agoI couldn't read beyond: "The Honorable Eric Holder". Seriously now? This should sound like an insult even to Eric himself. http://www.westernjournalism.com/polls-and-petitions/impeach-holder/ http://www.westernjournalism.com/polls-and-petitions/impeach... http://www.policymic.com/articles/9602/eric-holder-should-resign-or-else-congress-should-impeach-him http://www.policymic.com/articles/9602/eric-holder-should-re... http://www.metnews.com/articles/2012/snip081712.htm http://www.metnews.com/articles/2012/snip081712.htm
- rhizome 14y agoIt's a salutation based on his position, not an award.
- msandford 14y agoI don't care if this is blatant pandering or not; At least he's asking some of the tough questions. It's good to see someone other than Lessig saying "I'm not sure this was appropriate"
- politician 14y ago"Finally, the U.S. Attorney has blamed the “severe punishments authorized by Congress” for the apparent harshness of the charges Mr. Swartz faced. Does the Department of Justice give U.S. Attorneys discretion to charge defendants (or not charge them) with crimes consistent with their view of the gravity of the wrongdoing in a specific case?" Interesting game of "hot potato" going on. Nonetheless, I applaud Sen. Cornyn for asking these questions.
- honu 14y agoThe good news is that some good questions have been asked, and the reply will be available for scrutiny. I'm not sure Cornyn was the best member of Congress to write this sort of letter. Yes, he is on the Committee of the Judiciary, but his political leanings might result in posturing that obfuscates the issues we care about. That being said, I'm glad someone asked.
- veridies 14y agoPerhaps, but this letter was focused and, on the whole, loaded with serious and important questions. It looks like his political posturing on this one is going to be aligned with our politics.
- olefoo 14y agoJust keep telling yourself that politics is a branch of biology, not of physics. It's messy, unclear, somewhat random and does not operate by simply observable rational rules.
- smogzer 14y agoPuppets, strings, now it's calling for it's right of FOIA ? Can't they just recognize they should not have the right to mess with individuals, specially if no harm is done. These prosecutors jobs is a dream job for psycopaths, jack the ripper would exceed in a job like this. We need the hacker news party.
- ChristianMarks 14y agoHolder will reply that the prosecution had nothing whatsoever to do with the FOIA.
- d0m 14y agoThese school baby killers should watch and listen more to politics; maybe they'd find a better target for their suicidal idiosyncrasies.
- TWAndrews 14y agoRegardless of eventual outcome, I think it's probably safe to say that Ortiz's post-Justice department political career is probably done. I don't see how she could win a democratic primary in Massachusetts anymore--too many other ambitious Dems who'd have field day with this, and Republican opposition will keep her from being appointed to anything requiring confirmation. It's a lot less than she deserves, but there's some gratification in the thought that the over-aggressive prosecution which was most likely designed to advance her political career will prevent it.
- dmix 14y ago> too many other ambitious Dems who'd have field day with this If they don't at first, the internet will make sure they do.
- MtotheThird 14y agoI wouldn't be so sure of that. Try reading the comments on any Boston globe article about this affair. Ortiz has strong support from law-and-order voters and many people in Massachusetts outside of tech; in addition to Swartz, she's been very aggressive in her prosecution of corruption and misconduct in the state government. She has a compelling back story and (at least before this) was blessed by Deval Patrick. I think she could definitely replace Martha Coakley as state Attorney General, at minimum (Coakley also did many odious things as a prosecutor and has never, to my knowledge, paid a political price for it). And a decade from now, long after Aaron has disappeared from the press cycle, she'll make a run for Senate or Governor and his prosecution will likely be nothing more than a subsection of her Wikipedia bio. These are the sad realities of politics in Massachusetts.
- jimfl 14y agoCornyn has been gunning for Holder for a little while, asking for his resignation earlier last year. http://www.google.com/search?q=cornyn+holder http://www.google.com/search?q=cornyn+holder Edit: spelling
- stox 14y agoThere is nothing new about this behavior, Len Rose went through much the same 20 years ago. Maybe we are finally getting a clue that the system is, in fact, broken.
- denzil_correa 14y agoIF Only, this was done earlier. Any system which requires a health check when the water rises above your head is a bad system.
- mitchi 14y agoDecent letter, I'm glad someone from the Senate stepped up. I would add this : Seventh, really? 35 years for a kid who learned his lesson and didn't do something horrible in the first place? Some decency and common sense people.
- kh1411 14y agoI would like them to question her why after 2 yrs of holding this over Aaron's head, depleting his finances, that they didn't think a plea deal for a misdemeanor instead of felony counts would be sufficient deterrent? When I read below Fri. Jan18th, I was incensed even more at how they treated Aaron: "Last Friday, on the same day that Swartz hanged himself in his Brooklyn, N.Y., apartment, prosecutors from Ortiz’s office stood in a Boston courtroom and allowed a former state representative named Stephen “Stat” Smith to plead guilty to a misdemeanor for rigging absentee ballots in three elections. Swartz’s lawyers asked for the same consideration, that Swartz be allowed to plead guilty to a misdemeanor. Prosecutors refused. So, given that Ortiz will not explain herself, we’ll just have to presume she believes that illegally manipulating the outcome of elections, which are the essence of our democracy, is less serious an offense than downloading an online archive of obscure academic articles." (Excerpt fm article by Kevin Cullen, Boston Globe). http://bostonglobe.com/metro/2013/01/18/taking-heat/L1rfSF472wEPsGX5PWfu5I/story.html http://bostonglobe.com/metro/2013/01/18/taking-heat/L1rfSF47...
- quahada 14y agoRegardless of where you stand on Cornyn's politics, it's important that someone with authority is trying to find answers to this situation in a public forum.