8 ms·
Gates, Jobs and Wozniak were all criminals too, they just did it before anyone could catch them or the laws set them up for felonies. http://news.ycombinator.c
by ck2 14y ago
Gates, Jobs and Wozniak were all criminals too, they just did it before anyone could catch them or the laws set them up for felonies.
http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5078351 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5078351
Far less noble crimes than what Aaron was trying to do though.
sentenced to three years of probation, 400 hours of community service, a fine of $10,050
I dare to say Aaron might still be around if that was what he was facing too.
- jacquesm 14y ago> I dare to say Aaron might still be around if that was what he was facing too. Probably. But, and this is a very big but: Aaron was encouraged by every victory (and the coverage of those victories) to shoot for an even bigger target. In spite of being very sympathetic to Aaron, the goals he fought for and what he stood for, sooner or later that was going to lead to a confrontation. And he was encouraged by the public response to his deeds as well. So even if everything in this particular case is as bad as it looks Aaron definitely was not one to say 'that one is in the bag' and call it quits. If he had stopped after the PACER incident it would have been a very worthy achievement. Serially taking on entrenched interests of this magnitude will sooner or later have consequences, it is as far as I can see unavoidable. The fact that he did that makes me admire him even more but I fear that for someone of his self evidenced emotional make-up this was not a long term sustainable recipe.
- larrys 14y ago"And he was encouraged by the public response to his deeds as well." People are usually eager to cheer you on when they don't have to clean up the mess or suffer the downside.
- rhizome 14y agoWith a goal of "increasing freedom," there is no line to be drawn, and the confrontations you predict are a signal of decreased freedom. One can call it a perverse incentive, but to the point he had reached, the confrontation was way out of proportion to the acts. You can call this unsustainable, but what other choice is there? "Welp, the interests of less-freedom don't want this, so I guess I shouldn't do it." http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boston_Massacre http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boston_Massacre However, that the hammer was brought down so heavily tells me that on the part of the status quo there is a real weakness and a real fear that people might go in the directions he did. Like the Boston Massacre, we will soon find ourselves in a propaganda battle. Ortiz' husband's mockery of Aaron Swartz's supporters, and her hardening of her stance (while parrying responsibility) is just the first step in circling the wagons. Sen. John Cornyn is now asking questions of the Attorney General about all this, so now we know the people at the top have heard the call. Prepare for additions to this story.
- jacquesm 14y ago> With a goal of "increasing freedom," there is no line to be drawn, and the confrontations you predict are a signal of decreased freedom. Agreed. But you should never lift more than your back can handle. > One can call it a perverse incentive, but to the point he had reached, the confrontation was way out of proportion to the acts. We're fully in agreement here. But there are many examples of such extreme overreaches, recall the music sharing verdict and a bunch of other examples in the hacking / media sphere. This is not an isolated case at all. The differentiating factors are: (1) the defendant was for a change an exceptionally nice person, (2) the defendant knew a lot of people and was known by a lot of people and (3) he was clearly acting in what he thought was the best interest of all of us. > You can call this unsustainable, but what other choice is there? Unsustainable for Aaron in particular. > "Welp, the interests of less-freedom don't want this, so I guess I shouldn't do it." No, that's definitely not where I'm heading. I do want this and it is worth something, maybe even worth a lot. > However, that the hammer was brought down so heavily tells me that on the part of the status quo there is a real weakness and a real fear that people might go in the directions he did. Yes, I agree, and this overreach has exposed another weakness all by itself. A just justice system doesn't need scare tactics. > Like the Boston Massacre, we will soon find ourselves in a propaganda battle. Ortiz' husband's mockery of Aaron Swartz's supporters, and her hardening of her stance (while parrying responsibility) is just the first step in circling the wagons. Consider the battle joined. I will not forget about this and it will shape my actions for a long time to come. > Sen. John Cornyn is now asking questions of the Attorney General about all this, so now we know the people at the top have heard the call. Prepare for additions to this story. I guarantee it.
- pretoriusB 14y ago>Agreed. But you should never lift more than your back can handle. "Lifting more that your back can handle" is the very definition for fighting for freedom. If everybody played it safe, and only went as far as they could comfortably tolerate, they would have been no freedom.
- twoodfin 14y agoWho really knows what he would have gotten. rtm could have faced jail time, and the prosecutors apparently wanted it according to this contemporaneous essay: http://potifos.com/morris.html http://potifos.com/morris.html
- koide 14y agoKey point regarding Aaron: "It is hard to imagine Morris doing anything like the Internet worm again, so the need to lock him up is anything but pressing."
- rmc 14y agosentenced to three years of probation, 400 hours of community service, a fine of $10,050 I dare to say Aaron might still be around if that was what he was facing too. Or, y'know you could listen to charities who work with suicide and do what they request and avoid blaming a suicide on one external cause? Often it's more complicated than that.
- sp4rki 14y agoExactly! We don't know what Aaron would have been sentenced to, and it would probably have been a mere fraction of the maximum penalty. There was something else going on in his life that we don't and most probably won't know or ever understand that lead him to take his own life. Regardless the world would have been a better place with him around, and it's a sad state of affairs that the rules and laws regarding computer crimes are so out of context and maybe even unjust. That being said, it was Aaron who took his own life, not the justice system regardless of how fucked up we believe it to be.
- jacquesm 14y ago> There was something else going on in his life that we don't and most probably won't know or ever understand that lead him to take his own life. And you know this how?
- ritchiea 14y agoBecause he wrote multiple times about depression on his public blog?
- jacquesm 14y agoThis has been exhausted I think, multiple times to see it rehashed all the time is a bit tiring. At the risk of boring people: 1) his lawyer and his closest family seem to agree that the lawsuit was the driving force 2) he did it on the anniversary of the start of the lawsuit 3) the actual trial was to start shortly 4) So far when under outside pressure he held up pretty good, but this was pressure far exceeding his previous exposure If you wish to argue the lawsuit was not the reason you're going to have to come up with something better.
- crusso 14y agoGates, Jobs and Wozniak were all criminals too, they just did it before anyone could catch them or the laws set them up for felonies. To be objective, they also did things back when the damage you could do was fairly limited because of our lack of reliance on computer infrastructure. The growth in punishment for computer crimes has grown with the importance of computers to modern society.
- gamache 14y agoJobs and Wozniak were phreakers. America relied on the phone system at that time.
- InclinedPlane 14y agoThey had a business selling blue boxes, which allow people to make long-distance calls for free (among other things). At the time national long distance calls cost roughly $4 (in today's money) per minute, with international calls being even more costly. Woz and Jobs made about $30k (in today's dollars) off of this illicit business and perhaps cost the phone company many many times more than that in potential lost revenue (possibly millions). Compare that sort of "youthful indiscretion" to Aaron Swartz's far more selfless and far less damaging JSTOR hijinx. On the flip side of this, consider that had Jobs and Woz never experimented with phone phreaking and never built those blue boxes they may never have had the guts to build Apple. Being a disruptor is about pushing limits, and sometimes the law runs right through those limits.
- billsix 14y ago> I dare to say Aaron might still be around if that was what he was facing too. That's not all RTM was facing. "Morris pleaded not guilty on Aug. 2. He could face five years in prison, a fine of up to $250,000 and an order to make restitution to anyone adversely affected by the incident.". http://articles.latimes.com/1989-11-04/news/mn-223_1_computer-whiz http://articles.latimes.com/1989-11-04/news/mn-223_1_compute... "Under a second law being studied by Federal officials, the use of a Government computer to commit fraud is a felony punishable by a fine of up to $250,000 and up to 20 years in prison." http://www.nytimes.com/1988/11/08/us/fbi-begins-investigation-of-computer-virus-case.html http://www.nytimes.com/1988/11/08/us/fbi-begins-investigatio...