3 ms·
I wish you would just make the libertarian argument that people should be allowed to do whatever damage they want to themselves, as long as they don't damage ot
by jimbokun 18y ago
I wish you would just make the libertarian argument that people should be allowed to do whatever damage they want to themselves, as long as they don't damage others, and be done with it. I can understand that argument, because it appeals to the idea that government action intended to stop one bad thing can lead to something much worse.
But you seem to be actively defending the idea that there is nothing immoral in a vocation that will inevitably destroy the lives of many people. You point out that the people being destroyed are complicit in their destruction, but I do not see that as a fully qualifying factor. If someone was contemplating suicide, and someone else happily persuades them to go through with it instead of trying to talk them out of it, that's a morally neutral choice?
You also seem to be equating bad camera work and writing with drug dealing, which I will assume is not what you meant because that would be pretty silly. Now, if you are just re-iterating the point that you do not want to incriminate drug dealers, that position can be defended. But if you honestly believe that there is nothing morally wrong with intentionally and actively enabling people into addiction, I doubt that the gap between our views on morality can be bridged.
I suspect there is some misunderstanding about where you are arguing for not criminalizing activities versus defending their morality. If so, could you clarify?
- unalone 18y agoThere's a big difference between drugs and suicide. Suicide is final. Any damage drugs do are usually temporary. I think that people using drugs should talk to people as much as people thinking about killing themselves, because with drugs you can go too far, but that's not the same thing as thinking that the people using drugs are bad people. Similarly, if you're selling drugs, you should only be selling to the people who want drugs. There's nothing immoral about selling to people who want them. My argument was that making crappy products is a harmful thing. I recently broke up with a girl who was as close to a soul mate as I've ever found because she was insistent that everybody was like Sex and the City characters, and that my personality type was incompatible with her character. People who write and produce crap damage people's minds, and I will always find that repugnant. In my mind, making bad things is just as bad as selling bad product, possibly even worse because you ought to know better. That said, I don't think it's fair to persecute people who make crappy things. The best solution is to make better things and lead by example. I'm not a libertarian. I think that there ought to be solutions to the drug problem. I just think that such solutions should be enticing people to do something better with their lives rather than punishing them for using.
- newt0311 18y ago"Any damage drugs do are usually temporary." Bullshit. Addiction is permanent. After withdrawal symptoms have subsided, the hinger for drugs is still there and needs to be continuously controlled by the addict. Thus the insanely high reversion rate among past addicts (from what I have heard, ~95% in the US. From other sources: 50% in harsher countries like Singapore). "Similarly, if you're selling drugs, you should only be selling to the people who want drugs. There's nothing immoral about selling to people who want them." This is a classic Humean ought. I personally think that drugs are addictive and thus the normal rational impulses that limit uses of such products are ineffective here. Thus, if a drug is sufficiently addictive and does not have any other use, it should be banned. Thus, medical uses such as pain killers are fine (as long as the supply chain is secured). The use of the death penalty arises from the fact that drug use is notoriously difficult to limit and anything less would be largely ineffective. We cannot resolve this issue by discussion of facts etc... as these positions do not depend on fact. They depend on our inherent value systems. "I just think that such solutions should be enticing people to do something better with their lives rather than punishing them for using." Point 1: punishing an action is equivalent (empirically, not morally) to encouraging the opposite action. Point 2: People have tried to talk people into not using drugs. Non-addicts think they can avoid addiction (which the lucky ones manage to do but quite a few don't). Addicts want to stop (at least the sane ones do) but can't due to the very nature of addiction. I know the death penalty is extreme. However, in this case, it is one of the few things that will work (at least at significantly reducing the drug trade) and I think the human cost is worth the benefit of not having as many addicts. EDIT 1: Found detailed data from the Singaporean govt. on recidivism rates from drug addicts. Short version: they have been improving and have gone from 81.4% in 1994 to 59.1% in 2000. Still extremely high. Details here: http://www.mha.gov.sg/basic_content.aspx?pageid=74 http://www.mha.gov.sg/basic_content.aspx?pageid=74. Scroll to the bottom. EDIT 2: When we consider drug use in Singapore and China, we must account for their close proximity to the golden triangle -- one of the most active areas of drug production on the planet. Imagine that instead of having Mexico as a buffer against the drug trade (which is becoming reality all too quickly), we were instead right next to Colombia and friends and how much worse the drug problem would be then. EDIT 3: Found sources for recidivism rates for US durg addict rehabilitation centers: Peterson KA, Swindle RW, Phibbs CS, et al: Determinants of readmission following inpatient substance abuse treatment: a national study of VA programs. Medical Care 32:535-550, 1994 (sorry for the firewall). Summary of results on recidivism rates: 25% within first 180 days. increasing to 35% in 1 yr. Rates specifically for the VA program which may have significantly different characteristics from other programs. The 95% rate stated above seems a bit high compared to that. More research needed here. EDIT 4: the Singapore recidivism rates are for 2 years so they are difficult to compare to.
- mcslee 18y agoYou state: "But if you honestly believe that there is nothing morally wrong with intentionally and actively enabling people into addiction, I doubt that the gap between our views on morality can be bridged." Do you believe that liquor stores, grocery stores, corner shops, restaurants, and bars are all immoral? Should their owners refuse service to any customers that they believe to be at risk of alcoholism? Should pharmacies do background checks on customers purchasing Tylenol to determine whether or not they are addicted to painkillers? I think this argument boils down to legality, not morality. I think the point originally being made was that a significant portion of drug dealers are NOT intentionally enabling people into addiction. Certainly this varies by drug dealer, and there is a big difference between selling marijuana and selling heroin or crack. A lot of these dealers are simply supplying people with a product that they are purchasing for personal use because they think it makes their life better. I think it's also important to recognize that morality is subjective, and that it's one of America's founding principles not to legislate morality. Your belief that something is immoral, or even the belief of the majority, is not significant justification for legislation.
- newt0311 18y ago"Should their owners refuse service to any customers that they believe to be at risk of alcoholism? Should pharmacies do background checks on customers purchasing Tylenol to determine whether or not they are addicted to painkillers?" Yes. We can establish some clear legal standard and create systems to enforce this. For example, if somebody is brought in for alcohol overdose 3 or more times, they get a skull and cross-bone tattooed on their right arm and selling alcohol to them is a criminal offense. You can switch that to some federal database if the social stigma of a tattoo is a problem for you (though to me, its a feature, not a bug). "I think this argument boils down to legality, not morality." We are talking about laws here. Morals have no place in the discussion except for determining the end goal of the laws. After that, its an engineering process to determine exactly what laws and enforcement policies will get us closes to our moral ideal. In that sense, your statement is right but rather trivially so. "I think the point originally being made was that a significant portion of drug dealers are NOT intentionally enabling people into addiction. Certainly this varies by drug dealer, and there is a big difference between selling marijuana and selling heroin or crack. A lot of these dealers are simply supplying people with a product that they are purchasing for personal use because they think it makes their life better." I have a problem buying that. Addiction is undeniably a part of the drugs business model. Quite a few dealers even adjust pricing for that purpose. That even companies in the legal truge trade (tobacco et al.) try to leverage addiction makes you statement seem ludicrous. Do you have any evidence to back this up? "I think it's also important to recognize that morality is subjective, and that it's one of America's founding principles not to legislate morality. Your belief that something is immoral, or even the belief of the majority, is not significant justification for legislation." Nice way of saying that anything goes. Not something that I think any reasonable person could agree with. Besides, my argument is not a moral one. My argument is that addiction is a serious market failure and when there are no mitigating circumstances (medical uses etc.), addictive drugs should be banned. I advocate the death penalty because that is the only thing that seems to work in this case -- If you are going to have some law, it should be enforced rigorously or removed from the books (and yes, I know that a lot of current laws fail this test. They should either be repealed if they are not worth the enforcement effort or strictly enforced with the penalties necessary to curb infractions. As I have stated previously, I think that anti-drug laws are worth the enforcement costs).