7 ms·
Agreed. I just moved here from Tucson, and there's virtually no way I'd be here if not for the fact that I'm living with a medical resident in an apartment subs
by jseliger 14y ago
Agreed. I just moved here from Tucson, and there's virtually no way I'd be here if not for the fact that I'm living with a medical resident in an apartment subsidized by her hospital.
Given a choice among SF, NYC, and Seattle, and I'd choose Seattle: It has much of what makes the first two desirable, but at 60% of the cost.
BTW, to the extent that you want to make cities like SF and NYC more affordable, favor the removal of building height limitations and setbacks. The real problem in such cities is with supply, as Matt Yglesias writes in The Rent is Too Damn High and Ryan Avent writes in The Gated City. SF and NYC aren't expensive because of some natural law; they're expensive because of man-made laws, which can be changed. Don't yield to torpor!
- lawnchair_larry 14y agoHaving moved from SF to Seattle, I just want to say that Seattle is terrible, and you should warn everybody you know to stay away. ;)
- davmar 14y agoHaha. Why do you think so? Lets get a beer and I'll show you why it isn't totally awful. Some gems for sure.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- aliston 14y agoSerious question -- did you have trouble adjusting to the lack of sunshine?
- jseliger 14y agoI've lived in Bellevue, WA, then Worcester, MA, then Seattle, WA, then Tucson, AZ, then New York, NY, and I've never had a problem with sun or its lack. Different people react differently, however, and I still a) went running most days, and b) really like the cultural / lifestyle aspects of living in cities. I prefer the Seattle experience of relatively temperate weather, year-round, to the Tucson experience of insane heat for about five months of the year. Obviously nowhere else in the U.S. is going to rival the weather experience of the CA coast.
- hyperbovine 14y ago> Obviously nowhere else in the U.S. is going to rival the weather experience of the CA coast. Did you not read the article? :-) Seriously, summers in the city (of San Francisco) can be miserable, at least insofar as your definition of summer includes wearing fewer clothes and dining outdoors. In general the coast of California north of say, Seal Beach, is not an enjoyable place to be after sunset, anywhere. Even in LA it's usually about 60 at the beach in July at night. I've never understood the massive gap between marketing and reality when it comes to the weather in coastal California, despite having spent half my life here. Medellín, Colombia is the place I have been that comes closest to achieving what California peddles.
- ableal 14y agoThe west coast of Europe has a big advantage over that of the USA: the Gulf stream. It's nice to have an ocean-sized "hot water bottle", running at about 15C in winter. (Also: http://www.snopes.com/quotes/twain.asp http://www.snopes.com/quotes/twain.asp )
- digisign 14y agoJuly is the start of summer and it takes another month for the cold ocean currents from the north to warm up, keeping Santa Monica cool. An hour inland and it could be 110f. LA has maybe 300 sunny days a year, while Medellin is nowhere near the beach... like 1000km away.
- sakopov 14y agoI've been contemplating moving to Seattle. After experiencing both SF (for a short while) and Seattle, i think Seattle offers similar quality of living for far less. So i really hope it's as terrible as you describe it :)
- seanmcdirmid 14y agoWe tend to hype the rain problem to keep the Californians away.
- dr_ 14y agoNYC is a big place and its not all the same. One could, for example, live in Brooklyn, pay a more reasonable rent and be surrounded by interesting people all with access to great food and bars. I suppose you could stretch that a bit further to Queens as well. Manhattan itself is quickly changing into a business district. You go there to work, grab dinner or hit the theater, then leave.
- yolesaber 14y agoThis is by far the best way to live comfortably in NYC. People forget how diverse the city is. Everyone thinks that you just have to be in Manhattan. Yes if you are working for a startup in NYC it will be located in Manhattan (Etsy is an exception), but there's no real good reason to live there. It is a fantastic place to work and dine, that is for certain, but in terms of living it is overcrowded, overpriced, and quite noisy. In Brooklyn or Queens you can have plenty of room for much cheaper than Manhattan/SF/Seattle. There are one bedrooms in Astoria that start around $1200 and with a roommate you can easily be paying less than a grand each for a BIG place in a great part of the City. Almost all of the creative and intellectual activity in NYC comes from Brooklyn/Queens, whether its the rise of new and interesting publications (N+1, for example), art houses being opened, exhibitions being held, wild house shows or rooftoop parties and so on and so forth. It has a great vibe that I have yet to get from any other city. I remember being on a rooftop in Greenpoint with some friends, having a nighttime barbecue, and they had a marvelous view of Manhattan. I mentioned that it would be nice to live there and my friend just laughed, saying "The city looks so beautiful now. Why would you want to ruin it by living there?"
- joonix 14y agoWhat parts of Brooklyn? Isn't it hard to get to work in midtown if you live in Brooklyn? The "nice" parts of Brooklyn always seem just as expensive as Manhattan when I check.
- msellout 14y agoTry Bushwick. It's on the L train. And some parts of Jersey are a faster commute to midtown Manhattan than north Manhattan is.
- starpilot 14y agoEveryone forgets Chicago. In the US, it's the most important financial center outside of Manhattan and is the third place city in number of Michelin starred restaurants (fewer than SF; Seattle has none). Boeing moved their corporate HQ there from Seattle because of its financial prominence. It has a world class university in U. Chicago and excellent bus/rail transit across the metro area. But the Chicago area is seriously undervalued as "flyover country" for most people from the coasts.
- aioprisan 14y agofrom my experience there, it's simply too far from other places (vs Boston/NYC/DC area or) and weather is a lot harsher
- jmnickels 14y agoit's a 2 hour flight.
- jseliger 14y agoWhat's Chicago known for these days? When I think of Seattle, I think of music (grunge was big, and today there's still a lot of it), Amazon, Microsoft, tech stuff, and arts. When I think of SF I think of free-spirits, the 60s, and startups. When I think of New York I think of movies, finance, artists (especially writers), publishing, and fashion. When I think of Chicago, I think of. . . corruption? Commodities markets? I'm not saying this to be snarky or a coastal asshole or whatever. I'm saying it because I genuinely don't have much of an impression of Chicago from the popular culture, or from books, or from sites like HN.
- iradik 14y agoArchitecture to name one of many. Some of the best American architects built many buildings, apartments, and skyscrapers in Chicago. The Chicago skyline is a wondrous thing. It can't be compared.
- deleted 14y ago