3 ms·
this is where the ideology between us differ - the classic example i use when i argue with friends on this topic is 'the wheel'. Some of my friends argue (and
by chii 14y ago
this is where the ideology between us differ - the classic example i use when i argue with friends on this topic is 'the wheel'.
Some of my friends argue (and i assume this is your point of view), that the wheel would've been granted a patent should it be invented today. I argue that even tho the idea is novel, there is no "secret" that you can hide with the wheel invention, and hence, there is no incentive for society to give you a monopoly, because you can't both use the invention, but hide its implementation from society. The price for said monopoly is the devulsion of the secret, and if there are none to give, you do not deserve the payment.
If the patent was for some complicated industrial process to produce better paint, an expert looking at the paint can't work out what went on in the process. But if you look at the sort of "design patents" that have come out, the amazon one-click is the classic example here, there is absolutely nothing that they can hide about the workings of the patent, and thus don't deserve a monopoly.
- alok-g 14y agoA patent is granted for an "invention", whether it is visible or not. I do not see why a visible invention is not an invention. See my separate comment for more on this: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5071287 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5071287