6 ms·
I like the principle, but most patent trolls are small shell companies. If they lose, you can ask for costs, but you'll find nobody to collect from. (And the
by btilly 14y ago
I like the principle, but most patent trolls are small shell companies. If they lose, you can ask for costs, but you'll find nobody to collect from. (And the next shell, with the same lawyers, will be suing someone else with a different garbage patent.)
Also there will be an uphill battle to avoid any Congressional response turning into a symmetric "loser pays" scenario. In that situation, the troll can trivially run up huge legal fees, knowing that you will collect nothing if they lose, but you stand to lose a lot. That change would leave trolls better off and potential victims worse off than they are now.
- rhizome 14y agoForgive me, I'm not an economist or anything, but doesn't this raise a question of shell company regulation? It shouldn't be possible to use a legal structure like that.
- hkmurakami 14y agoIt most certainly does raise the question. Here's an article and HN discussion for Intellectual Ventures being linked to over 2000 shell companies: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4946445 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4946445
- chii 14y agoThat there exists a legal structure for some group of people to avoid responsibility is quite baffling to me. Things like Limited Liability means that someone could potentially do something harmful, and yet not be "personally" responsible for the consequence - and yet, reap the rewards should they succeed, means that the cost is externalized to society at large. This should be fixed (how, i have no idea tho...).
- fleitz 14y agoThe responsible party is fully liable, if you can prove they are using the entity as a sham you can pierce the veil.
- rayiner 14y agoYou can always require plaintiffs to post bond in advance. This is what is done with shareholder derivatives suits in most states. Bond requirements are undesirable in cases where meritorious plaintiffs may have no money at all, but that should not be a concern for patent cases (the idea of an "individual genius inventor" is more or less romantic mythology these days).
- krichman 14y agoAnd surely if the individual genius had a meritorious patent, someone would be willing to fund the lawsuit.
- michaelt 14y agoCongratulations, you've invented patent trolls.
- fab13n 14y agoWith a twist: in this variant, patent trolls risk their money if they lose, hence only enforce patents they truly believe in.
- jhdevos 14y agoWith the assumption that patents are worth having, that would no longer be a bad thing. The biggest problem with these trolls is that there is hardly any risk or cost in suing, and they can disengage at any point if that starts to change. This places the defendants are at a significant disadvantage. With that inequality out of the way, patents could be what they are promised to be: a way to ensure you can monetize to recover a significant investment that you wouldn't have made without the promise of that patent. (I don't subscribe to the idea that patents are a good thing though; especially the kind of patents that seem to make up 99% of the patent pool).
- krichman 14y agoNobody would fund a "method and apparatus for linking users of free app to the paid app" lawsuit if they had anything significant to lose over it.
- amalcon 14y agoI'm not qualified to give legal advice, so I'll just link Wikipedia and let people make of that what they will: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Piercing_the_corporate_veil https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Piercing_the_corporate_veil
- DannyBee 14y agoAlmost certainly won't work in this case. All corporate formalities are followed. They aren't shams, only shells. Don't take this the wrong way, but don't you think they thought of this when they set them up? Patent trolls may be dicks, but they aren't stupid.
- TallboyOne 14y agoStupid question but, if that's true, then wouldnt that destroy the credit of the people who setup shell companies to begin with? That is unless they are all setup illegally I guess?
- jeremyjh 14y agoIt is called "piercing the veil" - go after the assets of the individuals running a shell company to limit their liability. It is possible but not easy to do if they structure and operate the "company" properly. You would spend a lot of money trying to get them to pay...
- beagle3 14y agoFurthermore, if you do it in a series of shells in different jurisdictions (think countries and continents, not just states), it becomes effectively impossible to pierce - it can cost millions or even tens of millions to pierce a series of 50 companies, even though setting them up and maintaining them can be done for as little as $100K.
- jrs235 14y agoBut doesn't the shell company have to OWN the IP/patent in order to sue? If they lose and can't pay, then transfer the patent to the defendant. Guess it still doesn't completely stop the trolls... Definitely need some bonding.
- benmanns 14y agoIf they lose the case, then the IP/patent is likely worthless.
- beagle3 14y agoNot necessarily. They can have a "we're allowed to sue on your behalf" agreement with the owner. Also, the patent owner could sell it to them for $5K, wait a couple of years, claim that the value has ballooned to $2T, and let them sue. (Oh, patent owner also owns troll, but you can't know that without spending a few hundred K$) And if they lose, the patent apparently is worthless, so not much help there.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- pash 14y agoPatent trolls own a patent, at the very least. The court could seize the patent and auction it off (or place it in the public domain) if the troll's string-pullers choose not to pay the loser's penalty.
- visarga 14y agoPutting the patent in the public domain or invalidating it would be a good penalty for frivolous patent suits.
- bloaf 14y agoOr the maintenance cost could be significantly increased. I would love something like this: any failed patent suit doubles the maintenance cost for all patents owned by the entity which owns that patent. The effect would be transferable (i.e. if they sold the patent to some other company, that company's costs would double) and it would stack (i.e. failing with the same patent twice, or owning 2 such patents would quadruple your maintenance costs.) The effect would last for some fixed period of time, so if the patent were truly valuable, a company could opt to keep it anyway. Obviously, that would make any patent involved in a failed lawsuit highly undesirable, so no one would want to buy it. It would also mean that shell companies wouldn't be able to send the patent back to a company dedicated to simply amassing patents.
- jbri 14y agoThis would discourage legitimate patent suits, while not particularly hurting one-patent shell companies.
- benologist 14y agoMight as well just take them off them, it's a lot less messy and it doesn't require anyone to choose not to be a douche even if it's the less attractive option.
- kalms 14y agoI like this one. He understands!
- meh01 14y agoConsidering that patents can just be reassigned, it's almost irrelevant. Patent trolling is a no lose business.
- Ankaios 14y agoWhat are the tax implications of reassignment? If I reassign a patent to a shell corporation, is it taxed? How would such a patent be valued? If the transferred assets are taxed, that would introduce at least a modest loss for using a shell. Also, I would think that the valuation for tax purposes should be something like the value to be claimed in court, at least if the transfer occurs soon before a round of trolling. I can imagine a troll reassigning a patent to a shell, low-balling the value for tax purposes, and then inflating it when wielding the patent in court. In such cases the IRS and/or the court might be interested in the discrepancy.
- lcampbell 14y agoA quick google suggests that the patent sale price can be set arbitrarily, and the proceeds of the sale are simply taxed as either normal income or capital gains, depending on how the IRS feels that day. This corresponds with my thought that it's basically cost-free to reassign patents. The applicable laws I found were 26 U.S.C. §1235 and §1231. I would be interested to know how it actually works, because IANAL.