5 ms·
Ask HN: What's with all the trivial link spam?
I've noticed an increasing trend over the past month: New accounts are created and immediately used to submit a trivial link -- e.g., "Mozilla Firefox Start Page", "Orkut - home", "Google", "Gmail", "Hacker News | Submit", etc.
Can anyone come up with a plausible explanation for this? It doesn't make sense as traditional spam, since the pages in question aren't selling or promoting anything; nor does it make sense as accidental bookmarklet clicks, since (I assume) the bookmarklet doesn't create an account immediately before submitting the page.
For now I'm just flagging such content-free links, but I'd love to understand what's going on here.
- pg 18y agoI've been wondering too. My current theory is that it's spammers testing whether submission is unmoderated.
- thepanister 18y agoHello, I had some doubts that you might think of it like: "If I fight their spam entries, then they will increase the flow". Am I right? EDIT: Are you worried about the server? If you make a spam filter algorithm, then this is more likely to increase the load on the server, which increases the latency... and as a result, increases the headache?
- alecst 18y agoLike DanielBMarkham said, the spammers are likely just looking for easy targets. So my answer to you would be "probably not." But if we assume that they will take HN at any cost, then their course of action will match that of bacteria: attack, mutate, rinse, repeat. Eventually it will be either them or us that survives. And it probably won't be us.
- DanielBMarkham 18y agoMore than anything else this is what will probably drive true artificial intelligence: the need for the internet to survive as a valid information and commercial platform. We're clearly setting up a prey-predator situation which will continue for as far as the eye can see.
- alecst 18y agoI really do like the way the system works here -- I'd much rather have the community moderate than an vicious automated anti-spam script. Lately, however, I think the latter is beginning to seem more practical. I have a much harder time scanning the "new" section with the recent growing influx of junk. Is there a solution to this in the works?
- thepanister 18y agoI have already talked about this problem, but nobody really cares! Even I provided a significant solution to solve the problem: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=506028 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=506028 Guess what? I got down-voted on my comment! EDIT: If pg has no time for it, then why does not he allow us to code a solution, and he can review it? And if he likes it, then he would use it!
- mattmaroon 18y agoYou sure are excitable!
- thepanister 18y agoI am sorry, I don't understand what do you mean? Please forgive me, I am not a native english speaker.
- ksvs 18y agoHe means the exclamation points. In English you don't use those except when you really want to draw attention to a sentence. Otherwise you seem crazy! See what I mean!
- thepanister 18y agoWoW! I feel there is a culture shock here. Even I had to look up the word "exclamation"; I really still have a too long road in learning english. :(
- CalmQuiet 18y agoHey... I give you lots of credit for being open to learning... and for continuing to try to contribute to this English-based forum. Live & learn: that's okay.
- 18y ago
- SwellJoe 18y agoMy theory would be that it is a new spam bot, being tested out by its creator. Just a theory, of course. It could also be a user with a bone to pick with HN; their blog posts consistently got deaded by moderators, perhaps, and now they're angrily trying to prove something. Maybe they're doing it with a spam bot built for the purpose...this is Hacker News, so building such a spam bot would be trivial for most of the audience here. A few lines of Python/Perl/Ruby would do the trick.
- ErrantX 18y agoI've noticed HN appear in a few "spammer lists" over the last month or so. Usually the price to spam into here is very very high because it is, by comparison, quite difficult. Im tempted to agree with you - it is a spammer going after the good money testing a new bot.
- pg 18y agoit is, by comparison, quite difficult Merely difficult? Isn't it impossible? Has a spam ever survived here?
- SwellJoe 18y agoBorderline stuff can last a few hours. I've occasionally seen linkjacked stuff that is several hours old. The story being jacked is interesting, and so it may even have upvotes. Obviously, once a moderator spots it, the link gets changed to the original story...but it'd be hard to spot in a quick peruse of the New page, so I can understand how such links could live so long. Anyway, it depends on your definition of "survived" and whether there is value for the spammer in their story living on the new page for minutes or hours. Our company forums get an onslaught of spam about once per week, and though the spam never lasts more than a few hours (far less these days, as I've added a couple of moderators), it seems to be the same spammer doing it over and over again, so they must consider it worth a shot. When your employees time is almost free (or the work is done by a bot), pretty much any result is a worthwhile result.
- DanielBMarkham 18y agoOn my blog I'm getting comment spam without any links as well. The usual stuff like "Great work! Plan to come back often!" but there's no link to Joe's Sex Shop or anything -- just a bogus email address and fake name. I used to think it was just poor comments, but it only happens on certain pages, which aren't at the top of my most popular list. My theory is that the bots are working in waves -- first identify easy targets, then slowly exploit them. I wouldn't be surprised if the botnet guys are using Mechanical Turk-type operations just to work the CAPTCHAs and get valid logins for later use. It used to be you could make generalizations about the bot wars. Now, with possibly millions of programmers out there with nothing to do but try to work the system? The complexity and nuance of attacks are several orders of magnitude greater than just five years ago. I'm not sure any kind of sweeping statement catches what's going on, except: there are a lot of entities on the web that are looking for doors -- any kind of doors. Once they find them, it may be months or years before they are ever used.
- 10ren 18y agoInteresting. Could it be that it's proof of account existence, and that's how someone gets paid?
- mixmax 18y agoI actually left a comment on your blog a while ago. You submitted an article here which I read and found to be amazingly good. So I wanted to leave a short comment saying just that. I had to retry a few times, and got some pretty weird errors. I tried changing e-mail adress, subject, etc. to see if the error would go away. So your problem might be that there are a lot of errors on the submission process, so people try again, often using different names, etc.
- DanielBMarkham 18y agoThanks. Will look into that. I like your idea about newbies trying out the system. Not as exciting as evil overlord botnets, but perhaps just as plausible. I guess the answers would be in a careful digging through the server logs. Appreciate your trying. I just upgraded to MT 4.2, so hopefully the comment submission bugs have been worked out.
- russell 18y agoHow about banning links in comments until a small karma level, say 10, or a few days registration? Another possibility might be deletion privileges for questionable comments for hackers above a certain karma or registration time. By questionable, I mean comments of a certain form from new users, rather than being completely subjective.
- colins_pride 18y agoAllowing users to: only comment without links up to 10 karma, submit at 20 karma, comment with links at 50 karma, etc. sounds like a pretty reasonable approach. Initially one proves themselves in discussion, then they can bring new ideas to the table. By setting the limits at relatively low levels it doesn't discourage new participants. As a relatively new member of the community, I believe that this is important because you don't want the community to become static any more than you want to get overrun a la digg, reddit, etc. A few days registration won't work, though, because the bad guys will just start setting up accounts, keeping them dormant for the waiting period, and then do their dastardly deeds. Besides, karma is a better measure than seniority.
- thepanister 18y agoEDIT: You should realize something, that spammers might create 10 accounts. 1 account that makes a comment, and the other 9 accounts would vote up for the other account's comments, to increase the karma and pass the karma threshold. This is similar to what I wrote here: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=506028 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=506028 Users should have a history record. But it won't be an effecient solution, according to briansmith's approach. Spammers could hire users to comment. Here is how I imagine it: 1- Spammers crawl the submitted article. 2- Ask real users to read it and comment on it. 3- Copy what users said and submit it automatically here. 4- You will think it's NOT a spam, and you will up-vote what the spammer commented, and this will allow the spammer to submit content and the problem won't be really solved/ but reduced.
- colins_pride 18y ago
- mixmax 18y agoThe answer might be quite boring. When a new user comes to this site he will try out the functionality, click around and see how things work. One of the things that he will probably want to know is how to submit an article. So he goes ahead and tries it, using whatever link he has handy. I know this because I did it myself when I joined. I deleted it right away though. I've seen the same thing on other sites, so it's not that unusual. Edit: tuned down the wording a bit, since PG's reply indicates that this might not be the sole reason.
- pg 18y agoThat doesn't explain the sudden sharp increase in these links. We're growing, but the growth rate didn't suddenly increase 10x like the rate of these links has.
- mixmax 18y agoMaybe it's because the influx of new users are more casual in their use of the site, now that it has grown to a certain size. I could imagine that users that just stumble upon the site will be more willing to engage in this semi-destructible behaviour than users that got the site recommended from you or another early user. Can you see whether the users that do this end up being good citizens? That would shed some light on whether these are malicious accounts or just new users trying things out.
- joe_the_user 18y agoPerhaps the spammers are testing to see if the spam "sticks". The sites where the spams stays will be revisited. Perhaps that spammers think that an account that posts links that don't come up on a black list will considered "safer" later when they can then spam seriously.
- eli 18y agoIt's not just testing the system. At least one popular blog anti-spam system forces comment to moderation only on the first comment from each person. Subsequent ones go right through. I was seeing spam like this over a year ago across a network of sites all with the same set of messages (e.g. "Good site! Thanks!")
- CalmQuiet 18y agoAnd I guess moderators are reassured by the nice (though valueless) words... and permit the comment. If your theory is right it would suggest that moderators set a higher standard (e.g., actual content to the comment) for what they permit?
- jasonkester 18y agoIf you think about how you'd build a script to spam Hacker News, it's easy to see what's going on here. - Step one is getting your bot to reliably create accounts. - Step two is getting it to create accounts and post links. - Step three is feeding it a list of 5000 of your sites. This bot appears to be at step two.