4 ms·
Perhaps defined-benefit retirement plans should not be in the public sector since they haven't been in the vast majority of the private sector for quite some ti
by pc86 14y ago
Perhaps defined-benefit retirement plans should not be in the public sector since they haven't been in the vast majority of the private sector for quite some time.
- rkowalick 14y agoThis is the exact same argument the supporters of Ohio Senate Bill 5[1] used. One reason people in the public sector are willing to be paid less than their private counterparts is because their benefit plans are genuinely better. Saying they should eliminate one of the better benefits public sector employees get is stupid. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ohio_Senate_Bill_5_Voter_Referendum,_Issue_2_%282011%29 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ohio_Senate_Bill_5_Voter_Refere...
- clarky07 14y agoPeople say this all the time, but I really don't see it. I really don't think teachers are that underpaid, and I say that as someone married to a teacher. They only work 9 months of the year. If private sector employees only worked 75% of the time, it's likely they'd make less money too. Would I like it if my wife made more money? Sure. Does that mean I think she should, at the expense of everyone else's tax dollars? No. Contrary to what you say, most people don't choose teaching because of the benefit plans. They might do it because they only have to work 75% of the time, but it isn't the benefits. They choose it because that is what they want to do. Help kids, teach, etc. The benefits do not make sense as a reason to do this job. If that's what you're going for, you'd just take a job in the private sector, work more, and make a lot more money.
- jacoblyles 14y agoUnsustainable benefits are stupid. Of course, when legislators pass pension hikes, they do so knowing that it pleases powerful unions now and the costs to tax payers are decades down the road. So it is one of the more appealing ways for a legislator to screw their state. They may even be out of office by the time the bill comes due! Defined-benefit pensions are a huge drag on many state budgets, and paying them does nothing to improve the quality of current government services. The bluer the state, the more they are screwed: http://money.usnews.com/money/blogs/the-best-life/2012/11/08/5-trillion-price-tag-for-public-pensions http://money.usnews.com/money/blogs/the-best-life/2012/11/08...
- Retric 14y agoBlue states are also richer, so you would expect them to spend more on government services and thus pensions. The real issue is pensions are based on the idea that future growth reduces the burden however in a stagnate economy they become a real issue.
- pc86 14y agoFirst of all, I don't know about you, but I don't come to HN and try to have a somewhat intelligent conversation just to be called stupid for expressing an opinion. Secondly and to your point, I am only speaking of defined-benefit "If you work here for x years you get y% of your salary." This is to say nothing of the health care (which is generally better than the private sector), the hours (which if you don't work for a legislator are generally better than the private sector), the guaranteed pay raise every year, the access to jobs you can only apply to if you already have a state job, and various small perks like free or cheap parking, food, etc. These are all benefits of the job and I had to take a serious look at the health care and hours for a state job when deciding between that and a corporate offer. I'm not here to argue whether or not defined-benefit retirement plans are inherently good or bad. I'm saying it's irresponsible and dangerous for a state to guarantee by law that they'll pay anyone a fixed amount of money for decades at some distant point in the future. This is why it's most dangerous. If the state gets bankrupted by some unforeseen catastrophe 30 years from now, it can't suspend, eliminate or trim pension payouts. Not even $0.01. By definition the fact that pensions offer better retirement income than defined-contribution plans like a 401k should be a giant red flag. The system implodes if you can't at least break even off of it, and if it was possible to make money off of them the private sector would still be using them.
- illuminate 14y ago"First of all, I don't know about you, but I don't come to HN and try to have a somewhat intelligent conversation just to be called stupid for expressing an opinion." He didn't call you stupid for expressing an opinion, he called that particular view stupid.
- 13rules 14y agoSaying that a particular view is stupid without offering any additional information or another viewpoint is... well... This isn't 7th grade — come up with another word that really means what you want to say. There are a lot of ways to disagree with someone and/or an idea without the derogatory language.
- robfig 14y agoI was not under the impression that public sector employees are paid significantly less than private sector. This seems to be the most reputable source I could find: http://www.cbo.gov/sites/default/files/cbofiles/attachments/01-30-FedPay.pdf http://www.cbo.gov/sites/default/files/cbofiles/attachments/...
- illuminate 14y ago"Saying they should eliminate one of the better benefits public sector employees get is stupid" It's not stupid to them, they want labor compliant, they don't want better options available to compare to. "Why worry about retirement? You should be lucky you HAVE a job..."
- outside1234 14y agoOffering deferred benefits is the thing that is "stupid" - it should be all cash to state employees so that their cost is correctly accounted for as part of the current budget. Yes, I understand this might mean we have to pay higher salaries, but it will be far less than these crazy benefits they are getting.
- Domenic_S 14y agoPerhaps so, but that doesn't change the fact that they exist. If the State killed all new pensions they'd still have to pay existing obligations.
- Niten 14y agoIt completely baffles me how any reasonable person could look at the retirement and health benefits situation in our country and come to the conclusion that our problem is being too generous to the working class. Yes, the private sector has been much more effective than the public sector in collectively diminishing workers' wages and benefits in recent years. The logical conclusion is not that the public sector should do more to keep up with the downward spiral.
- notdrunkatall 14y agoIn case you didn't realize it, that costs the states money, and money is what states don't have.
- LockeWatts 14y agoThe states can find other things to cut than middle class benefits.
- rayiner 14y agoLike what? E.g. in Chicago, the infrastructure is crumbling so that teachers can get paid far more than they would earn in the private sector given their qualifications, meanwhile getting 13 weeks off each year.
- rdl 14y agoIt's entirely possible for a state to have reasonable policy w.r.t. current and future expenses given a certain tax base, then lose that tax base and get stuck with unsupportable obligations. If NYC became Detroit over a period of 10 years, just pension liabilities would destroy it going forward.
- Niten 14y agoIn case you didn't realize it, tax rates closer on par with other developed countries are a perfect solution to that problem.
- bubbleRefuge 14y ago