3 ms·
Companies can (and regularly do) ethical, well-controlled studies on HIV treatments. It's not new territory. First, a small-scale phase-I trial is done on oth
by timr 18y ago
Companies can (and regularly do) ethical, well-controlled studies on HIV treatments. It's not new territory.
First, a small-scale phase-I trial is done on otherwise healthy people -- they're just looking for safety, not efficacy. Any indication that the drug makes things worse, or causes significant health problems, and the drug is dead.
Once it's established that the candidate drug doesn't make matters worse, test groups of high-risk individuals are selected from the population: IV drug users, homosexuals with a history of unprotected sex, etc. They're selected for as much diversity/balance of demographic data as possible, then randomly divided into groups by the clinical trial organizer. The participants are given extensive counseling on HIV prevention, condoms, safe sex, etc.
The groups are then used to construct a double-blind trial, where neither the patients nor the physicians are aware of who is given placebos. Outcomes are continuously monitored, and if there's any indication that the drug raises incidence of HIV, the trial is terminated early.
- joeyo 18y agoReally? You can give them a placebo and say, "This might reduce your risk of HIV or it might not. Have fun!" I'm curious because my impression is that most drug trials have been for AIDS treatments (where, perhaps, placebos are more ethically acceptable-- especially before the treatment is known to be better than the placebo) rather than HIV prevention.
- timr 18y agoShort answer: yes. I'm not an expert on the ethics, but pretty much every vaccine trial faces this dilemma. The solution is to make sure that the trial participants are fully informed (i.e. they've got to know that they may not be getting a real vaccine), and to make sure that the vaccine in question doesn't make things worse. If you can do those two things, then in the worst case, the participants are no worse off than if they hadn't participated in the trial at all. But as I said, clinical trials for things like HIV vaccines tend to go above and beyond, and do things like safe-sex counseling for every participant.
- kragen 18y agoThanks for the insightful post! I knew the procedure was something like this, but I wasn't clear on what the established guidelines were. I am still not certain this is actually ethical.
- timr 18y agoI left out informed consent -- that's really a key reason why the experiment is ethical. The subjects are informed that they might not get a real vaccine, and they're given the choice to participate.