7 ms·
> The expectation of rising real incomes was built into the American culture Ah that's the classic propaganda line: "I am not poor, I am just pre-wealthy.
by rdtsc 14y ago
> The expectation of rising real incomes was built into the American culture
Ah that's the classic propaganda line:
"I am not poor, I am just pre-wealthy."
...So I sure don't want to vote for anything that would jeopardize my wealthy position when I get there.
The key in all of this is ability to manipulate the people into believing and voting in a particular way. US has no shortage of zombies who don't think on their won. Blame the education system, blame the system as a whole, I don' t know. As long as people don't base their votes on reality they will end up voting against their own good because they are being manipulated.
Basic health care, tax cuts for the super rich, trickle down wealth, futile wars, all this things are being delegated (via votes) from un-informed people to the politicians via a manipulative process. I see this within my own extended family, I see it on the streets, in the stores, in school and at work.
- acabal 14y agoI've said for a long time the basic problem in the States isn't capitalism vs. socialism or rich vs. poor, but rather educated vs. uneducated. I think I'm not being out of line to claim that on the average an American's high-school-level education is pretty poor. People who are victims of poor education don't know history (which is rich in examples of past policy), can't think critically or reason about potential outcomes, and don't know to sometimes be healthily skeptical of things they're told. Those kinds of people will never be able to vote in their best interests because they have no idea what their interests even are, because they're easily manipulated, and because they're incapable of reasoning critically about even the most basic policy decisions. That's how you wind up with people holding up picket signs saying "Obama=socialism" on one side and "Keep your hands off my Medicare" on the other. The problem is basic education.
- bhntr3 14y ago> I think I'm not being out of line to claim that on the average an American's high-school-level education is pretty poor. The thing is that it's not really that true. Here's a typical article on Huffington Post bemoaning the American education system: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/07/23/us-students-still-lag-beh_n_1695516.html http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/07/23/us-students-still-l... But if you read it carefully, the truth is that we're not getting worse. We're just not getting better as fast as others. We used to be the best. Now we're in the middle. We're not worse than we were 60 years ago. We're better. Other countries have just gotten better much faster. Which is a trend that applies to a lot in America these days. Education IS improving. So, I think anything that tries to relate an absolute decline to "the failure of our schools" is wrong. Maybe that's not your point though. The thing is that what you describe at the beginning of your post is actually typically human. Experiments have shown we all have cognitive biases that make us bad at "being skeptical" and "reasoning about potential outcomes" or using past examples to predict future events (even when we're well educated.) Humans are just not good at doing that stuff. We can overcome our biases but that's not really taught in school. You can read about a lot of it at http://lesswrong.com/ http://lesswrong.com/ So I don't think it's that helpful to bundle up people who struggle with cognitive biases as "Those kinds of people" There's a chance that "our kind of people", aka people who read hacker news, are much better at being rational but it's probably because we've taught ourselves to think like computers! Because that's a big part of what being a hacker is.
- acabal 14y agoI'm not saying education is better or worse than in the past, just that (in general) it's not up to the task of producing an electorate capable of voting rationally. After all, it's often people of retirement age you see holding those anti-Obamacare signs. Their basic education did happen 60-odd years ago and it clearly failed them.
- jeffdavis 14y ago"Those kinds of people will never be able to vote in their best interests" What happened to voting in the interests of the entire population?
- anigbrowl 14y agoNobody knows for certain what the interests of the entire population are; voting is a mechanism for groping towards identifying those interests.
- tsotha 14y agoBut there's a big difference in thought process between "I think voting this way is best for everyone" and "I think my benefits will go up if I vote this way".
- acabal 14y agoI think a person's best interest is often (not always!) the same as the general interest. Education comes in to play when a person is educated enough to be able to rationally reason that case. For example, "I have a perfectly good well on my property, but I understand that contributing to a public water supply system may benefit me in the long run, because maybe my well will go dry." Or maybe, "I have a well, but contributing to a public water system will increase commerce in the area which will directly benefit me." Obviously that's not always going to be the case, and people can and will reason incorrectly, but the important part is that a person is capable of applying some modicum of thought instead of just "The rent is too damn high" or "Obama is a communist, hang him for treason."
- maratd 14y ago> US has no shortage of zombies who don't think on their won. A human being is at the most juvenile when he encounters a view contrary to his own and ascribes it to stupidity. If only everyone was as enlightened, as educated, as brilliant as he ... then everyone would understand. No. Grow up. I will never be wealthy and I will still continue to vote for a fair tax system. A flat tax system. Because everyone should pay the same, regardless of status or income. I won't always be healthy and I will still continue to vote against a socialist healthcare system. Because everyone should pay for what they use, no more and no less. Not just with healthcare, but with everything. You don't believe what I believe? That's fine. But how dare you ascribe my beliefs to ignorance? That in itself, is ignorance distilled. The refusal to even consider anything but your own stunted views.
- anigbrowl 14y agordtsc's not talking about you personally, but about the median voter. Many political arguments are founded in ignorance (in contradiction of available data or in defiance of logic), and observing this fact is not equivalent to a judgment of people who happen to hold the same opinions. Having said that... Because everyone should pay the same, regardless of status or income. [...] Because everyone should pay for what they use, no more and no less. These are perfectly valid opinions to hold, but to express them as if they were facts is to assume the correctness of your premises. I can see why you hold those positions, but I can also think of compelling arguments for the opposite positions.
- ucee054 14y agoBecause your views are stupid. Easy example: a homeless tramp dying of ebola. (You can substitute a bunch of other diseases naturally occuring in the USA if you like) You'd normally want to pack that guy into a medical isolation unit pronto. You probably won't save him but at least you'll stop other people from catching it from him. But no! maratd vetoes this because it's not fair. The hobo should pay for his isolation unit and until he can, he should be kicked out into the streets to act as a plague vector. Rinse and repeat for all the other issues you haven't thought about properly.
- sliverstorm 14y ago
- vor_ 14y agoCalling people names because they disagree with a progressive tax structure or mandated health insurance isn't a convincing argument for your side. There are arguments to be made for and against these policies. In fact, it would be helpful for you to recognize that you are simply one side of a two-sided issue, each side of which believes they are obviously correct and that the other side is too uneducated to know how wrong they are.
- rdtsc 14y agoFrom a rational point of view I can understand how someone with a high income is against a progressive tax structure. How someone how has millions of dollars stashed in an account votes against a socialized basic care. I don't understand why someone living on government's check, and having poor health due to a financial inability to go the doctor, is voting against it. That is the issue. The problem I am describing is people being manipulated to vote against their own interest. Religious, fears, fake promises are all used effectively by those in power to recruit and manipulate others to do their bidding for them. That is what is scary.
- roel_v 14y ago"I don't understand why someone living on government's check, and having poor health due to a financial inability to go the doctor, is voting against it." Because maybe these people actually see the immorality of taking from others by force? "The problem I am describing is people being manipulated to vote against their own interest." So morality has no bearing on your position? "Fuck morality and others, as long as I get mine, and then some?" Seems like your position is in direct contradiction with the values you claim to defend.
- wybo 14y agoMorality has a bearing on it. Not letting die, or for that matter, enabling a minimally humane life for everyone, is as important, or more important than the dictum against (potentially unjust) taxation. I see why in the US one might be against this, as I've lived there (working at a great IT job in central San Francisco), and have seen the poverty, and the human suffering (not to mention the smell of bums on the bus). Probably feels like there'll be no end to it, and then, in order not to feel guilty or bad, one closes ones eyes to it by believing it's their own fault; 'lazy smelly bastards!', but that doesn't change the moral reality of it. When judging oneself, feel free to be ruthless like Ayn Rand, when judging others, please be considerate, and take into account more than economics alone. In a way I evaded it too. Not by borking up my morality, but by voting with my feet when the opportunity presented itself. I am back in the UK now, and happy to be part of a society that treats it's weakest members well (or ok-ish at least). I wonder what it is between the US and Europe, that we have such different notions of (social) justice. Perhaps it is because Europe has more history, that we have seen over and over that wealth is often gained (and lost) by luck, that often it accumulates over dozens of generations in the hands of the few. While the US is only now developing it's own aristocracy. I even heard a British nobleman once vehemently argue that wealth is not deserved. So yes, being pragmatic we do allow the market to flourish, and do allow the wealthy to enjoy their wealth, but we don't confuse economics with morality, and moderate it's excesses through progressive taxation, some redistribution, and universal health-care. Human life and happiness trumps justice on the economic plane.
- tsotha 14y ago>I am not poor, I am just pre-wealthy. Whose propaganda line? I've never heard anyone in favor of small government say that. There aren't people in the electorate who think they're going to wind up wealthy to swing an election. The lack of increasing real incomes doesn't have anything to do with "tax cuts for the super rich". It's the combination of globalization and the importation of ten million poor people. If you're doing a job that can be taught to a Central or South American peasant in a few weeks you simply have no power in the labor market.