9 ms·
Who wrote the 'Death Note' script?
- revelation 14y agoWarning: his whole site is an incredibly wonderful time sink :) I can recommend his extensive research on Nootropics [1] for actionable advice. [1]: http://www.gwern.net/Nootropics http://www.gwern.net/Nootropics
- lindowe 14y agoToo true. Gwern's whole site is an awesome example of applied critical thinking.
- jrogers65 14y agoA few of these are not nootropics but cognitive enhancers. Difference being that nootropics are extremely non-toxic or neuroprotective. Another way to put it is that nootropics are a subset of cognitive enhancers (safe cognitive enhancers, basically). The following are not nootropics: * Modafinil and Armodafinil * Adderall (Amphetamine) * Caffeine * Kratom * Nicotine (this is a border case, in my opinion) * Selegiline Stay away from the above, unless taken very occasionally, if you value your health. Drugs like these rapidly build tolerance and become a liability in the long run. If you insist on using stimulants such as amphetamine, learn about how to reduce tolerance with things such as NMDA antagonists and take things to prevent neurotoxicity. He should also get on with trying Noopept - it's one of the best nootropics of recent times. From experience, anybody who is a programmer or does similarly demanding intellectual work will stand to benefit from learning about and using nootropics. They're not a silver bullet but quite a few of them are most certainly effective.
- driverdan 14y agoAre you intentionally classifying caffeine the same as amphetamines, or did you overlook it?
- jychang 14y agoIntentional, I believe. It is habit forming and addictive, compared to say, taking Omega-3s before bed every day.
- rednukleus 14y agoThe stranger point is including Modafinil, which is not addictive at all.
- thomasbk 14y agoYou do however build up a tolerance to modafinil, and it has various negative side-effects. But I agree that it's weird to make some sort of hard separation between various types of nootropics, and say that you should never touch some. Everything potentially has its use, and I think that Gwern covers this topic exceedingly well at his site.
- jrogers65 14y agoI did not advocate staying away from them but using them sporadically as opposed to regularly: > Stay away from the above, unless taken very occasionally
- driverdan 14y agoJust because something is physically addictive doesn't mean it has negative health consequences. Many studies have shown that long term, low to moderate caffeine consumption (especially coffee) has a positive impact on overall health. Caffeine, amphetamines, and modafinil are not neurotoxic. I believe the others aren't either but I haven't read up on them. Methamphetamine is neurotoxic but non-methylated amphetamines are not.
- jrogers65 14y agoThe problem is that these studies are narrow and only look at a handful of the aspects of consumption. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Health_effects_of_caffeine http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Health_effects_of_caffeine > Short term side effects such as headache, nausea, and anxiety have been shown as symptoms of mild caffeine consumption. When assessing the health impact of a drug, it is important to look at the whole picture. Amp is indeed neurotoxic, though the exact effect is a little nuanced and dose-dependent. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/15019431 http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/15019431 > In addition to the social, cultural and indirect medical complications of amphetamine analog abuse, this class of drugs is also known to have the potential to damage brain monoaminergic cells directly. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/17606768 http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/17606768 > In early studies, high doses of amphetamine, comparable to amounts used by addicts, were shown to damage dopaminergic pathways. More recent studies, using therapeutic regimens, appear contradictory. One paradigm shows significant decreases in striatal dopamine and transporter density after oral administration of "therapeutic" doses in primates. Another shows morphological evidence of "trophic" dendritic growth in the brains of adult and juvenile rats given systemic injections mimicking "therapeutic" treatment. Imaging studies of ADHD-diagnosed individuals show an increase in striatal dopamine transporter availability that may be reduced by methylphenidate treatment. I did not claim that caffeine and modafinil are neurotoxic, just amphetamine.
- jey 14y agoIf you insist on using stimulants such as amphetamine, learn about how to reduce tolerance with things such as NMDA antagonists and take things to prevent neurotoxicity. He should also get on with trying Noopept - it's one of the best nootropics of recent times. Care to expound on those points?
- rms 14y agoMagnesium and blueberries seem to be the easily within reach stack to take with amphetamine. Noopept is quite good. I stopped taking it because for me it seemed acutely enough anxiolytic to cause rebound anxiety.
- jrogers65 14y agoAmphetamine neurotoxicity: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Amphetamine http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Amphetamine >The increase of cytosolic dopamine appears to trigger neurotoxicity, as dopamine readily auto-oxidizes, so that amphetamine or methamphetamine's increase in cytosolic dopamine can lead to oxidative stress in the cytosol that in turn promotes autophagy-related degradation of dopamine axons and dendrites NMDA antagonists such as magnesium (as mentioned by rms), zinc, DXM, MK-801, Memantine and Ketamine can reduce/prevent tolerance as well as nerotoxicity. http://www.acnp.org/g4/gn401000166/ch162.htm http://www.acnp.org/g4/gn401000166/ch162.htm > Methamphetamine toxicity is inhibited by a variety of drug treatments, including: ... 3) NMDA receptor antagonists http://www.socialanxietysupport.com/forum/f30/evidence-for-nmda-antagonists-blocking-tolerance-76216/ http://www.socialanxietysupport.com/forum/f30/evidence-for-n...
- gwern 14y agoIn what way is modafinil not a nootropic?
- rms 14y agoI believe he's using modafanil in the sense of broadly neuroprotective. However selegine in microdoses is a true neuroprotective in that sense..
- gwern 14y agoThen he's using a strange and novel definition of 'nootropic'. 'Neuroprotective'? Heck, lithium is neuroprotective at some doses, but I don't see many people suggesting its use.
- jrogers65 14y agoModafinil has too many side effects to be considered nootropic. It is a cognitive enhancer. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Modafinil#Side_effects http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Modafinil#Side_effects
- gtani 14y agorelevant: http://www.wired.com/playbook/2012/12/pl_ferrris/ http://www.wired.com/playbook/2012/12/pl_ferrris/
- madethemcry 14y agoI`m currently lost in that time sink. So many things to read and learn :)
- JosephRedfern 14y agoThat's an impressive analysis - very interesting!
- w1ntermute 14y agoAh, Death Note, one of my favorite manga. I read it in the original Japanese and it was very thrilling. Unfortunately, the anime adaptation was rather poorly done. The second half, IIRC, really went off the rails. Edit: the author of the linked post also has an analysis of Death Note Endings[0], which talks about some of the reasons for the manga and anime endings and the incentives for why they ended the ways they did. 0: http://www.gwern.net/Death%20Note%20Ending http://www.gwern.net/Death%20Note%20Ending
- trinovantes 14y agoI enjoyed the original Japanese films more than the manga. Despite the mediocre acting, the movie was much better than the anime.
- w1ntermute 14y agoI've never seen the live action films, I'll have to check it out. I see that Toda Erika, one of my favorite Japanese actresses, stars as Amane Misa. Apparently it was her debut film, so it'll be interesting to see how her acting back then compares to now (I just started watching the spring 2012 dorama Kagi no Kakatta Heya yesterday, in which she isn't all that bad).
- neltnerb 14y agoAgreed. The films ended far more sensibly, and the plot was better thought out.
- tinco 14y agoI get the strong feeling I've read this article before, but I can't find a strong indicator this is an old article. Did someone else write about the leaked script?
- nialo 14y agoThis particular post is a new version of an older article, not a completely new article, so it seems mostly likely that you read the old version already.
- tinco 14y agoAh ok that makes sense then :)
- tinym 14y agoThe dates on the sidebar indicate it was first published in 2009 (and last revised today). Most of gwern's site is an indefinite "work in progress".
- jmillikin 14y agoIt's a bit hard to find, but in the left sidebar there's a date string "2 Nov 2009". This would match up to the article's timeline; script appears on the Internet in May, add a few months for the author to discover it and perform extensive research. Inspecting the HTML verifies that that date is probably when the article was first published: <meta name="dc.date.issued" content="2 Nov 2009"/>
- gwern 14y agoYou may've read the much shorter original version back when it lived in http://www.gwern.net/Notes http://www.gwern.net/Notes or read it sometime in the past 3-4 months when I was working on expanding it. (The first version was basically the non-quantitive first third, but about half that size, so I added a ton.)
- adam-f 14y agoA Death Note fan would write an analysis this detailed.
- steveklabnik 14y agoOh? Do you have a stochastic analysis? ;)
- tinco 14y agoIn a barefooted couch hanging sugar rush no doubt!
- gwern 14y agoWhile fixing up the final errors the other night, I consumed a bag of Gummi Bears. And half a box of chocolate.
- umjames 14y agoHollywood, please don't ever try to make live-action remakes of anime. Why can't they just show the anime itself? It was already good. I highly recommend watching Death Note in its original anime form (preferably in Japanese with English subtitles). It's excellent. A little culture never hurt anyone. Every story doesn't have to take place in the U.S.
- Steko 14y agoMy first reactions to this were "Thank god this abomination hasn't been green-lit" and "*@#& you Hollywood!" Getting over that I can see how a looser translation could work. But don't call it Death Note. Calling it Death Note while whitewashing it and getting rid of many of the major plot characters and plot elements entirely is just asking for a colossal failure and fanbase revolt. It's like they didn't pay attention to the DBZ and Airbender fiascos.
- _delirium 14y agoThe anime form isn't the "original", but itself an adaptation of the manga. I don't have a huge problem in principle with media forms being adapted into other media forms, though, so that isn't really a knock against it. Imo whether an adaption is good is more interesting than the status as original/adaptation/remake. Some adaptations and remakes are good!
- gbog 14y agoThe extreme example is when the translation is actually better than the original, for a book. Edgar Alan Poe's tales translated by Baudelaire are said to be one of such cases.
- lmm 14y agoMaybe someone should publish a translation of Baudelaire's translation
- pestaa 14y agoYes, the original format is manga, and I have a few volumes -- the overlap is remarkable. As if Madhouse studios took the pictures, enhanced them, gave them a flow and breathed life into them with excellent voice acting and music. The manga is outstanding because of the plot, but nothing beats the anime.
- tinco 14y ago" the studios initially wanted to give the main character Light Yagami a new background story to explain his downward spiral as a villain. The new background would have had a friend of Light murdered when he was young. When Light obtains the Death Note - a notebook with which he can put people to death by writing their names - he uses it to seek vengeance" This really makes me cringe. This is precisely the sort of thinking that gave us so many mediocre/bad movies. Only someone who has no idea of what the story is about could suggest such a crude alteration of the story. And for what? Do they really think the movie would be better because of it? Or at least draw more audience? Anyway it's great that the director managed to hold off these changes, I saw Kiss Kiss Bang Bang and it was absolutely great so I'm anxious to see what he'll make of it :)
- kysol 14y agoWhen I read that I thought of Kevin Smith's conversation regarding Superman and a Giant Spider - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vgYhLIThTvk#t=8m0s http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vgYhLIThTvk#t=8m0s My current theory about movies at the moment is that all these crappy movies get made just to put a trailer to a big "block buster" at the start. After cost + advertising - box office revenue is taken into account, the end cost is probably less than it would cost normally to mass market the initial trailer. -- The reason why bad movies get made :D
- waterlesscloud 14y ago"how many unproduced screenplays get leaked?" Pretty much all of them, to a greater or lesser extent.
- TallboyOne 14y agoFunny thing about Death Note. My friend who is big into anime recommended this as my 'first time' anime I should watch. To make a long story (very short), I gave him shit about anime for a good 2 years if not longer. It was all light-hearted but eventually he snapped, he just couldn't take it anymore. "FINE!!! F&#$&$ YOU. DONT WATCH IT. SEE IF I CARE". I can see 2 years of pushing his buttons and joking finally caught up with him. I watched it, turns out I loved it more than I could have imagined. We tease each other about that to this day.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- hooande 14y ago> A forger could have randomly changed Charles to "Charley", looked up an appropriate address, edited the metadata, come up with all the Hollywood touches, wrote the whole damn thing (quite an endeavour since relatively little material is borrowed from DN), and put it online. Most people would have used that pile of circumstantial evidence to close the case. But you can't fool gwern (or L). The best thing about this analysis is that it reflects the thinking of the one of the main characters in the anime. This seems like how the detective L would solve the same problem. has always been one of my favorite fictional characters because I greatly admire his (fictional) rigor and inductive abilities. Leave it to gwern to apply the same level of super detective skills to answering a question about the movie. It seems like a lot of work for a small point, but we'd all be better off if more people were this thorough in eliminating possibilities. I saw the japanese movie and it was good, but probably best for people who were already fans of the anime. An americanized version might open up a much broader audience, though they'd have to put a lot of money behind it.
- DeepDuh 14y agoOne thing I found strange about his analysis is that he kept on looking for new approaches after he got an upper boundary of 6.6% for the style result being random. I'd have introduced a more realistic model and looked at whether it get's me below 3% and be done with it (probably). He seems to like analysis just for the analysis sake. Of course it's still refreshing to see after reading tons of today's superficial blogosphere blabber (Google has ALWAYS blocked WP!!!11! ... wait no, sry).
- gwern 14y agoI don't think you can consider the stylometric result as yielding such an upper boundary; yes, that's some strong evidence against one possibility and in favor of another, but we could easily find some more evidence which goes the other way - and indeed did. So, it may be an upper bound _ceteris paribus_, but ceteris is not paribus here.
- mcherm 14y agoA detailed, exacting analysis, worthy of L himself.
- askimto 14y agoLooks like an analysis someone from the Singularity Institute would write...
- nos4A2 14y agoAwesome Article (and site)! Just one correction, look like you used the word memsahib in correctly (I think its a respectable salutation for a woman)..
- alan_cx 14y agoJust an observation: Political threads usually get several comments about being off topic for HN, some times quite strong. However, not one descenting comment for this, which to me seems equally, if not more, off topic. I personally really don't mind either subject, but how is this considered more relevant to HN than politics? Seems people are just as interested. I don't think this is a problem with this topic, even as a non fan its an interesting discussion. Its more interesting to me that the group reaction is different.
- fhars 14y agoThis is an article about Bayesian statistics, which is usually considered as quite hip in these places. You do remember who wrote the "A Plan for Spam"-paper, after all?
- mikedmiked 14y agoEven if the topic is not something you care about the techniques and methods gwern uses are not often talked about here and useful for a variety of text processing tasks. His methodical analysis and scientific rigor is always what I wish other posts could have. If nothing this is a post which will motivate others to write better. The cluster analysis is cool - not seen that before. Wonder what the results of Latent Dirichlet Allocation might have gotten...
- jacquesm 14y ago- Rob Malda joines HN... Check. - anti-ms league attempts to rewrite history... Check. - Anime on the front page of HN... Check. Fears of HN becoming reddit are overrated, but the chance of becoming slashdot instead looks to be > 0.
- marshray 14y ago"probability a fake script will have copies taken down = 5%+5% = 0.10" So the probability that the automaton who combs file sharing sites for "Warner Bros" and spams DMCA requests would both: A. be in a position to know whether or not the script was real, and B. would refrain from issuing a takedown if it were not is 90%? This does not seem to fit historical evidence.
- TommyDANGerous 14y agoI've seen the Death Note anime twice and it is one of the best Animes, with probably only Code Geass above it. I would love a real-life make of it but I believe that is impossible because everything about Death Note can only be captured in a lengthy series. In order to feel Death Note and truly understand the genius behind it, you must submerge yourself into its world for an extended period of time.
- brennenHN 14y agoThis is the most intense fan fiction.