3 ms·
Well, for starters to prove casuation one doesn't only need to show X moves in sync with Y. One also needs to show that it is not because both X and Y are cause
by smsm42 14y ago
Well, for starters to prove casuation one doesn't only need to show X moves in sync with Y. One also needs to show that it is not because both X and Y are caused by some reason Z which influences both even though X and Y are completely independent from each other. E.g. correlation between good lead data and good crime data may be caused by the fact that in cities with better law enforcement both criminal laws and environmental laws are enforced strictly, or because richer folks drive less polluting cars and commit less crimes. It does not mean less lead pollution causes people to be rich.
The whole thing sound like classic fitting the preconceived conclusion. But there's also something like this:
>>>> Not only does lead promote apoptosis, or cell death, in the brain, but the element is also chemically similar to calcium.
How lead is chemically similar to calcium? They are on opposite ends of the periodic table and have very different chemical properties. That, of course, does not prevent lead from messing with ion channels, but saying lead is chemically similar to calcium is wrong.
- pixl97 14y agoHow lead is chemically similar to calcium? They are on opposite... Then you go on to explain how lead is like calcium in its bioavailability, so in relation to the operations of a human body, lead is chemically similar to calcium (only dangerous). http://brain.oxfordjournals.org/content/126/1/5.full http://brain.oxfordjournals.org/content/126/1/5.full For example, lead’s ability to pass through the blood–brain barrier (BBB) is due in large part to its ability to substitute for calcium ions (Ca2+)
- smsm42 14y ago"Ability to replace calcium in certain biochemical processes" is not nearly the same as "chemically similar to calcium". It's like saying if I stole your login for facebook I would look like you and nobody would be able to distinguish between us without DNA test. Completely different things. Biochemical processes are known for accepting a lot of substitutes, that's how a lot of drugs work. That does not mean all those are chemically similar in general - they just play similar roles in certain processes.
- gruseom 14y agoOne also needs to show that it is not because both X and Y are caused by some reason Z which influences both even though X and Y are completely independent from each other How do you show that something is not caused by a hidden Z? All one can hope for is a preponderance of evidence. If the following passage from the article is true, then the preponderance here is stronger than a generic correlation-is-not-causation objection can just dismiss: "In fact, use of leaded gasoline varied widely among states, and this gave Reyes the opening she needed. If childhood lead exposure really did produce criminal behavior in adults, you'd expect that in states where consumption of leaded gasoline declined slowly, crime would decline slowly too. Conversely, in states where it declined quickly, crime would decline quickly. And that's exactly what she found." Thus your hidden Z would have to move in sync not only with X and Y, but also with their widely varying rates in different states. That's a high bar – especially if there are legal and institutional explanations for why leaded gas was phased out at different rates in those places.
- smsm42 14y agoWell, a good first step would be to analyse possible causes of Z and show they are not matching it. Quoting Feynman: For example, if you're doing an experiment, you should report everything that you think might make it invalid — not only what you think is right about it; other causes that could possibly explain your results; and things you thought of that you've eliminated by some other experiment, and how they worked — to make sure the other fellow can tell they have been eliminated. I did not see such explanation done in this case - it looks like everything described talks about what matches the hypothesis, and no effort is done to look for alternative explanations and refute them. >>>> Thus your hidden Z would have to move in sync not only with X and Y, but also with their widely varying rates in different states. Use of gasoline is highly correlated with use of cars, which again is highly correlated with income, population density, business activity, etc. Any of which can be also associated with crime. I.e. if both effects are caused, say, by population density (I do not say it is, I just take it as an example), then gasoline use would raise and crime would raise when population density raises (say, because some economic factors attract people, like it happens now in North Dakota due to shale gas boom) and both would fall when some factors cause population to move away - as it happening in Detroit, for example. There might be also other factors. >>> In fact, use of leaded gasoline varied widely among states, and this gave Reyes the opening she needed. If childhood lead exposure really did produce criminal behavior in adults, you'd expect that in states where consumption of leaded gasoline declined slowly, crime would decline slowly too. Conversely, in states where it declined quickly, crime would decline quickly. And that's exactly what she found. And this is exactly what she would find if both were strongly related to some third cause Z, but completely causally independent from each other. The fact that the MJ author takes it as evidence confirming the causation means they do not understand how causation needs to be proven. It is not evidence for causation, since it equally applies to both when causation exists and when it does not. Yes, this means causation is hard to prove. It is.