6 ms·
Why You Should Join Diaspora Now, Like Your Freedom Depends On It
- shmerl 14y agoA recent interview with one of the leading Diaspora developers: http://podroom.a2zen.fm/podcasts/exposing-the-truth-radio/exposing-the-truth-radio-with-sean-tilley-from-dia#.UOaY1NcU7MU http://podroom.a2zen.fm/podcasts/exposing-the-truth-radio/ex...
- joebadmo 14y agoWed, 2011-09-14 13:30
- shmerl 14y agoYep, it's dated (those issues with Diaspora mentioned there, like no video posting, are already fixed), but at the same time it describes the current situation with problems of centralized social networks very well, and the main point behind the article applies now all the same.
- darkhorn 14y agoThere is http://tent.io http://tent.io
- shmerl 14y agoThat's a base/API, not a service ready for end users. Diaspora is considering using it in some way, but so far it's limiting the logic of the node to one user only, which doesn't look like a logical restriction. See http://www.loomio.org/discussions/1522 http://www.loomio.org/discussions/1522
- PeterisP 14y agoThe article seems to miss the whole point of the social network functionality. For example, it states: "Diaspora has now reached a level of basic functionality, so that it could be used for many purposes we now rely on other services for. [...] You can post text and pictures." In a social network, there isn't an use case "post text and pictures" - the real use case is "post a picture of my kid so that my mom can see it"; and Diaspora fails at that, as my mom isn't there, she's on facebook. An useful use case is "post a morning rant so my friends can see it" and it fails if my friends aren't on that network. "read user posts" is a weak feature, but "read Bieber's posts" is a feature greatly valued by millions of teenagers - and Diaspora doesn't have that feature, Twitter has. The core value of any social site or network isn't in the software, but in the community. If the interesting people aren't there, then the service is useless to me, so I won't read or post. If the facebook site was opensourced and used by Diaspora, even then it would bring orders of magnitude less value to users simply because of the smaller community. What is Diaspora's plan for solving the user acquisition? Facebook replaced university 'facebooks' to get initial 'hot' users; Twitter got the critical mass from a few early adopter celebrities; Google+ is bootstrapping off of gmail contacts. Tech part is 1% of the resulting value, user part is 99% of it. If Diaspora can't show a reasonable path how they will resolve the chicken-and-egg issue to get a critical mass of users, then it's not worth to invest time and emotions in posting there.
- shmerl 14y agoIn a social network, there isn't an use case "post pictures" - the real use case is "post a picture of my kid so that my mom can see it" No, you miss the point. The purpose of social network is connecting people. Posting a picture for mom to see it is just one example of social interactions, there are multiple others which can be done through social network. For example exchanging ideas. Yes, Diaspora needs to add more features to become more friendly and versatile. But it's not about making a Facebook clone. It's about giving people an option of free social network. The point of the article - start using it now if you care about freedom. The more users it will get, the more feedback and more potential developers. It's not yet about "those who post pictures just come now - it'll replace all your Facebook use cases". If Diaspora can't show a reasonable path to get a critical mass of users, then it's not worth to invest time and emotions in posting there. I'd say if one doesn't share the sentiment of the author of that article (i.e. understanding of the need for free social networks), then one won't find reasons to invest time and effort in it already now. But the article isn't addressed to such people on the other hand.
- Tloewald 14y agoIt seems like the only way to fight Facebook would be to embrace (er wait, leverage) it ... Something that simply crossposts to your account but draws anyone interested out. Whether the tool is like FB or G+ or Twitter or something else is irrelevant, it needs to integrate with all of the above while holding YOUR stuff outside.
- dllthomas 14y agoI... think you miss the parent's point, which is that the features a social network provides to an individual user aren't just technological. The point is connecting people to other people and almost always that means to specific other people, and if those specific other people aren't on the new network that's not a feature the new network provides until they migrate, and that's not something you can fix with just tech (except maybe by automating crossposts? hmm...) Edited to add: Joining a social network is, therefore, adding features (when viewed through this lens) without doing any coding.
- dspillett 14y agoI keep considering making an effort to investigate Diaspora, either as just a user but preferably by running my own pod. Two of the key features I want to see before I make that effort though were heavily talked about at the start but are still listed as "coming soon": "export your data" and "move pods". If the data is locked to a pod, mine or anyone else's, many of my contacts will see that as no different to facebook. I know there is facebook integration so I can play without needing anyone else to move over, but I'd rather wait until what (for me) are key items driving the desire for something else (i.e. addressing control/ownership issues) are actually working features rather than aspirations.
- nathan_long 14y agohttps://joindiaspora.org/ https://joindiaspora.org/ is linked in the article and gives me giant security certificate warnings. https://joindiaspora.com/ https://joindiaspora.com/ looks like a real site. https://diasporafoundation.org/ https://diasporafoundation.org/ (linked from the .com) also has giant warnings. I'm hesitant to accept the security promises of sites who don't bother to get their certs set up correctly.
- klez 14y ago> I'm hesitant to accept the security promises of sites who don't bother to get their certs set up correctly. Or that just don't want to pay to have a shiny certificate that won't trigger alerts in your browser. The certificate is just self-signed, not necessarily invalid or dangerous.
- marcosdumay 14y agoNot dangerous, but completely useless. Self signed certificates are only usefull if you communicate them by another medium. And even then, browsers make it quite hard to manually add certificates.
- pseudonym 14y agoBy that logic, why bother paying for a shiny domain name? Why not just post the IP address on HackerNews and have people go to it directly? The value that Diaspora would have is in getting people to use it, not in the actual software; and that includes people who aren't necessarily tech-savvy. If your browser throws out a giant red page talking about an untrusted page, how many of those people do you really think you're going to get?
- bstpierre 14y agoActually, it's not "just self-signed", it's long since expired: The certificate expired on 01/30/2009 10:59 AM. and: The certificate is only valid for plesk
- shmerl 14y agoThose sites are outdated, since article isn't very recent. Here are the up to date sites: * https://joindiaspora.com https://joindiaspora.com (developers pod) * https://diaspora-project.org https://diaspora-project.org (project community site) List of pods: * https://diasp.eu/stats.html https://diasp.eu/stats.html * http://podupti.me http://podupti.me
- webreac 14y agoDiaspora is not as good social network as facebook and can not be very good at privacy because personnal user data stored in a pod are not encrypted and can be read by the pod owner. Encrypt/decrypt should be performed only at the browser level. I think diaspora should first start building a good cryptographic framework. Once the foundations are ok, they will find people to help for pretty features. The problem is that a social network that respect privacy would be a paradise for bad guys.
- bunderbunder 14y ago> Diaspora is not as good social network as facebook and can not be very good at privacy because personnal user data stored in a pod are not encrypted and can be read by the pod owner. Encrypt/decrypt should be performed only at the browser level. That would probably kill Diaspora's most realistic (obvious) option for scaling up to the size of a major social network. Right now it's small enough that it's reasonable for individuals to run pods altruistically. But if it gets big, that's going to get expensive. Somebody will have to pay for all that hardware, electricity and bandwidth. Nobody wants to pay to use social networks, so it sure won't be the users. At least not directly. A much more feasible option is to aggregate all the data you're privy to as a pod operator and use it for advertising purposes.
- shmerl 14y agoWell, encryption doesn't increase the cost much and is only welcome. The way to deal with increased user base is to even out the federation - i.e. in ideal case the pod will run on user's own computer, and thus will reduce the cost of hosting to virtually the cost of Internet connectivity, which is already paid by the user. Of course in practice it's not always the case, but quite a number of such pods already exist.
- bunderbunder 14y agoUnless there's a clever scheme I don't know of, encryption that prevents pod operators from reading content would increase the cost by making the system significantly more complicated. If the data you post to your network is encrypted, then that means anyone who wants to see it needs to have a key to decrypt it. Which might not be terrible as long as posting stuff to the network is all-or-nothing. But if the network needs to have support for allowing different acquaintances access to different content depending on your personal desires then it would become morass. You'd need to encrypt everything differently for each of the different combinations of people or groups of people that you might want to share with, and every time you friend someone, unfriend someone, or rearrange your sharing settings for a person, you'd potentially have to generate and distribute new keys. As far as self-hosting pods, that's fine as long as you want to limit your social network to people who are in a position to host their own pods. But that's got to be a fraction of a percent of all Internet users.
- i04n 14y agoI took a pod from the list: http://podupti.me/ http://podupti.me/ Went to sign up: https://poddery.com/users/sign_up https://poddery.com/users/sign_up There is no way to use my facebook or google account to sign up! IMHO, The barrier of entry for regular people is too high...
- voidlogic 14y agoIs there a Diaspora spec / pod-to-pod API spec so people can write other interoperable implementations that are compatible with the current Ruby one?
- shmerl 14y agoI think it's being ironed out now. You can contact the development team at: https://groups.google.com/forum/?fromgroups#!forum/diaspora-dev https://groups.google.com/forum/?fromgroups#!forum/diaspora-...
- digitalzombie 14y agoIt's ok. I joined Diaspora a couple of weeks ago and the functionality isn't there. I wanted some album feature so I can put my photos. I'm in the middle of researching Friendica and it seems like that would be better. I still have to try it out first.
- itisbiz 14y agoRecent article on Fitbit "can I have my data please" .. resonates here too .. the better use case and business opportunity for Diaspora model is for healthcare and personal medical data.
- beagle3 14y agoThat's the wrong solution to a problem. Even if you get people on Diaspora, they'll now have both Diaspora AND Facebook (and Google+) because that's where their friends are. The real way to defang facebook for the majority of the population is to make them be able to consume facebook without knowing that's what they are doing (e.g. with a specialized client that makes every effort to post to diaspora or friendica and will only post to facebook as a last resort, but without too many hardships). Unlike myspace, facebook with it's email, events and identity authority is too entrentched to be replaced in a short time -- the only way to deal with it is to make it interoperable but increasingly irrelevant - like the internet did to AOL some 10-15 years ago.