2 ms·
To me, transistors are the best example of how hard EE can be. I heard "transistor is a switch" or "transistor is an amplifier". So I bought some MOSFETs and
by dekhn 7d ago
To me, transistors are the best example of how hard EE can be. I heard "transistor is a switch" or "transistor is an amplifier". So I bought some MOSFETs and tried to use them. No go. Well, I had to learn (through random web pages and some books) that microcontrollers struggle to switch mosfets. Fine. I'll get a gate driver. Then I have to very carefully pick a bunch of resistor values that make my system behave. Eventually, I learn that transistors aren't switches at all, but can be coerced into sort of behaving like switches, but in reality, there is always leakage and a hundred other variables you have to understasnd and control for. You can see one of my threads here: https://www.reddit.com/r/AskElectronics/comments/1omqn4d/convert_switchcontrolled_rc_circuit_to/ https://www.reddit.com/r/AskElectronics/comments/1omqn4d/con...
- dgellow 7d agoYeah, I went through almost the same process :) For transistors vs MOSFET I really liked https://youtu.be/DKYguNg1vmk https://youtu.be/DKYguNg1vmk as an overview
- IAmBroom 5d ago> I heard "transistor is a switch" or "transistor is an amplifier". As an EE, those statements sound so ridiculously reductive. It's like saying, "An oven is a cake-baker." And it results in confusion for both EE students and non-EE hobbyists who aren't baking cakes - or who don't know about timers and temperature dials.