3 ms·
When I was younger I realized I was falling into specific intellectual traps, and I've noticed LLMs adopt every one I attempted to thoughtfully eradicate in my
by futhey 14d ago
When I was younger I realized I was falling into specific intellectual traps, and I've noticed LLMs adopt every one I attempted to thoughtfully eradicate in my own reasoning. You can often sound smart by adopting a contrarian position without actually putting a lot of thinking effort into what you're considering. It's a quick escape hatch to sound intelligent; quickly identify a contradiction or a counterargument and state it confidently. Adopt a contrarian viewpoint. You don't have to be right but often you will sound intelligent.
I assume this is just the natural result of asking LLMs to produce text and paying someone three cents to evaluate if it's a good response or not.
- simonwsimonwsim 14d ago[dead]
- lolakutty 14d ago>quickly identify a contradiction or a counterargument and state it confidently. How does this make this a "contrarian position"? At least I don't understand the negative connotation. To me this makes this "contrarian" at least a bit smarter than the one parroting the popular opinion...
- debo_ 14d agoI like this notion of being contrarian in what it means to be contrarian.
- LPisGood 14d agoThe smarter thing to do would be to steelman the original position and not assume that the weakest of counterarguments — stated confidently and without much further analysis — sufficiently refute it.
- porkshoe 14d ago[dead]
- chairmansteve 13d ago>To me this makes this "contrarian" at least a bit smarter than the one parroting the popular opinion... If it is kneejerk contrarianism how is it smarter?
- lolakutty 13d agoBecause they spotted a contradiction in the original argument that the other person did not consider before making their argument?
- xboxnolifes 13d agoIt's like reading an entire article and pointing out a typo without engaging with any of the context. It's easy to find a single fault and point it out loudly, but if you don't even try to engage with the intent of the message, you aren't providing anything of substance.
- lolakutty 13d agoI would not consider typo to be a contradiction.
- tsunamifury 14d agoIt took a long time for me to fully learn the difference between being contrarian and being constructive.
- ambicapter 14d agoTotally, so many people like to bring up a counter-argument and expect you to fully disarm it, but very few people will justify whether their argument is actually relevant or reasonable to the discussion at hand.