3 ms·
Google stole open source code without crediting the authors (Artemis/Minitap)
- pmkary 2mo agoWhen you say "don't be evil"; just where is your threshold Google?
- cortesoft 2mo agoThey removed that years ago.
- dietr1ch 2mo agoNot around since 2015, and desperately needed since around 2018-2019 with those military contracts and silos. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Don%27t_be_evil https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Don%27t_be_evil
- dataflow 2mo ago> Not around since 2015 > "but retained it in the last sentence"
- dataflow 2mo ago> The author history was harder to understand. An earlier package file listed Pierre-Louis Favreau, Jean-Pierre Lo, and Nicolas Dehandschoewercker. The version that replaced it removed all three names and substituted another author. The only change to the files was the author list. GitHub’s activity record shows that the replacement happened through a force push in August, before our investigation this September. Wow, this looks pretty damning. I can't imagine Google seeing this as worth the risks. Is an innocent explanation possible here?
- gr71 2mo agoThis !
- VoidWhisperer 2mo agoIf there is an innocent explanation, I'd love to hear it, because it kind of reads like the force push was done to move the commit with the attribution change out of the public eye so it wasnt clear what they had done. Maybe it is possible the google engineer didn't understand how open source licenses work, or didn't care since maybe it was supposed to be an internal project first that eventually ended up open sourced?
- dataflow 2mo agoGiven the replacement author and email seem like a random person rather than an employee, I wonder if whomever did this thought they had found the "real" author and that somehow the others were incorrect? It's confusing, I don't know.
- soraminazuki 2mo agoFor over a decade at least, Google has been a hostile entity hoarding trillion dollar's worth of wealth at the expense of everyone else's freedom and well-being. We don't need to embolden them any further by hunting for excuses.
- eadwu 2mo agoNot Google or related to any of the projects. This is normal (specific to pyproject.toml overwriting authors). I am not sure about pyproject.toml conventions but I would have done the same. This is the equivalent of telling you who the maintainers of the project are. Usually what you see in the code is the retention of Copyright statements on source code and LICENSE with some reference on README.
- polotics 2mo ago[dead]
- 420official 2mo agoThe point is that the plagiarism is evident and they took steps to hide it, not that the authors should have been left as is. The lack of any attribution at all is the ultimate issue like you point out, but the force push demonstrates intent over honest mistake in my opinion.
- jacquesm 2mo agoYou can just add a line to clarify. You can't just wipe out other people's names.
- jacquesm 2mo agoI think that in case of large multinationals you don't need to search for innocent explanations, as a rule they are perfectly aware of what they're doing and that you are in no position to make them pay for it. Might makes right, and these companies have more power than a whole raft of nation states. They act with complete assurance that absolutely nothing will come of it.
- nvarsj 2mo agoThis kind of thing is almost always a result of the performance culture. There are a lot of promo oriented people in big tech who just want money and have no ethics (or engineering competency usually), sadly. These people have no issue at all plagiarising or stealing credit to get themselves more money and success. And it works.
- de6u99er 2mo agoI'd like to know how many imposters work in big tech.
- harshavamsi 2mo agohttps://github.com/google/artemis/commit/371aa6df56880643da57b30da936e9812fb0ec66 https://github.com/google/artemis/commit/371aa6df56880643da5... They're trying to cover it up now
- rkagerer 2mo agoIs that a coverup - eg. are they retroactively rewriting old comments - or are they simply jumping on this and trying to correct the problem? (Although I would say it isn't a very good-faith effort to address the issue if they don't put back the author attributions they removed).
- SillyUsername 2mo agoThey've so far ignored the ticket https://github.com/google/artemis/issues/40 https://github.com/google/artemis/issues/40 to potentially avoid the Streisand Effect (drawing attention to it), yet started work fixing it. That reads like a coverup as open discourse would have admitted a mea culpa and apology. I predict they will close the issue without discussion, citing this PR as the fix, potentially associating the fix with a less guilty looking duplicate ticket. I'd like to be wrong but this is what other commercial projects do when they are called out on a shady practice.
- justinclift 2mo agoYeah, they closed and locked that issue about an hour ago. :(
- lunchbucket 2mo agoAnd if they had instead chosen to remain silent on the origin of the code, how would you have characterized their actions then?
- m00x 2mo agoThey only did it because minitap called them out? It's in the post. They were in clear violation of Apache 2.0
- bilekas 2mo agoWell I am shocked, who would have thought, an advertising company who prides themselves on not being evil, used code that wasn't credited. I mean, if that's the case, we better start a revolution.
- RossBencina 2mo agoFlagging because the title here on HN is editorializing. The actual page title is "I expected better from Google" I was going to comment on the title's perpetuation of big IPs stealing/theft meme but it turns out that TFA did not use those words.
- neilv 2mo agoRegardless of whether or not Google is liable, what would be interesting to me is how this happened, the role(s) at Google that were involved, when each knew of the problem, and what each did. (I'm interested in what this says about current culture.)
- RossBencina 2mo agoHere's the force pushed pyproject.toml with the new author if anyone cares: https://github.com/google/artemis/compare/14e02c4c27bc5b3c0d07e9a7b3b20141d6af9348...206a9ce921367ca10091c79ad00e116f195850ff#diff-50c86b7ed8ac2cf95bd48334961bf0530cdc77b5a56f852c5c61b89d735fd711 https://github.com/google/artemis/compare/14e02c4c27bc5b3c0d... + authors = [ + { name = "somew1nd", email = "[REDACTED]@outlook.com" }, + ] Seems legit
- camgunz 2mo agoIs it even possible to steal this code? How much of it is uncopyrightable LLM output?
- mam2 2mo agoI do not believe in IP. Credit should be assigned tho.
- ryanmerket 2mo ago[dead]
- justinclift 2mo agoLooks like the GitHub repo added some minimal attribution a few days ago: https://github.com/google/artemis/commit/371aa6df56880643da57b30da936e9812fb0ec66 https://github.com/google/artemis/commit/371aa6df56880643da5... They've also closed the reporting issue, and pro-actively locked it without any kind of explanation or apology: https://github.com/google/artemis/issues/40#issuecomment-5689548916 https://github.com/google/artemis/issues/40#issuecomment-568... That they didn't even bother to apologise or explain their actions seems pretty shitty. :(
- gravifer 2mo agoThe MO is so recognizable so I digged around. This maintainer <https://github.com/somew1nd https://github.com/somew1nd> is shady as hell. It looks like the profile is a recent Chinese graduate, who have been working on a "challenge cup" <https://www.tiaozhanbei.net https://www.tiaozhanbei.net> robot project not very long ago. Personally, I know that lot to appropriate stuff for themselves without blinking an eye. Believe me when I say I know. Also, the OP seem to have been heavily downvoted, which I believe have been fudged. Reporting this twit to his manager may be the right way to go.
- gravifer 2mo agoLook here https://github.com/OpenMind/OM1/pull/2517 https://github.com/OpenMind/OM1/pull/2517