7 ms·
Hepburn Romanization: How to Read Japanese in the Latin Alphabet
- motionlessveloc 2mo agoAs someone intimately familiar with this topic, the article here is mostly correct but gets a lot of the small details wrong. Probably the most important missing part here is the reason non-Hepburn systems like Kunrei stuck around for so long: they were designed to replace the Japanese script completely. This sounds outlandish today, but they were invented during the early Meiji years when Japan was adopting Western innovations and abandoning ancient traditions at breakneck speed. And because their target was thus Japanese people, not foreigners, they didn't need to worry about English phonology. Incidentally, the Chinese pinyin system was also designed to replace Chinese writing, and Mao came quite close to abolishing Chinese characters entirely during the Cultural Revolution. Which also explains why it uses letters like x, c and q in ways that English readers find wildly unintuitive.
- canjobear 2mo ago> Mao came quite close to abolishing Chinese characters entirely during the Cultural Revolution This was indeed the Communists’ original plan, but the real story is more interesting. Before taking over the country the plan was to replace characters with a pinyin-like system Latinxua Sin Wenz[1] and a whole generation in the north was taught to read this. After 1949, Mao was talked out of Romanization by none other than Stalin, who told him the Chinese language deserves its own script. Pinyin was designed after that, officially as a teaching tool, but probably by people who secretly still believed in more radical writing reform. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Latinxua_Sin_Wenz https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Latinxua_Sin_Wenz
- quuxplusone 2mo agoHighly recommend on this subject John DeFrancis' "The Chinese Language: Fact and Fantasy" (1984)! https://archive.org/details/chineselanguagef0000defr/ https://archive.org/details/chineselanguagef0000defr/
- Thrymr 2mo agoIt is remarkable that some countries actually have switched writing systems in modern times. Turkey did it in the 1920s after the fall of the Ottoman Empire, for example (replaces an Arabic alphabet with a Roman one).
- jhbadger 2mo agoNot to mention numerous ex-Soviet countries have replaced their Cyrillic system for Latin ones to demonstrate their independence from Russian colonialism.
- motionlessveloc 2mo agoAnd many of those Cyrillic systems had in turn replaced previous Arabic/Persian-based writing systems.
- Lumich 2mo agoI'm wondering what script the North American Indians† would have replaced the one given to them by their English-speaking colonizers with had they been given any in the first place and not been all but exterminated instead. Well, anyway … “evil Russians colonialists”. † I know the PC term in North America is “first nations” or some such but for those outside NA using the old term is perfectly fine.
- gucci-on-fleek 2mo ago> I'm wondering what script the North American Indians The Cherokee syllabary [0] and the Canadian Aboriginal Syllabics [1] are both scripts designed for use with North American indigenous languages, and both are still widely used (relative to the usage of indigenous languages in general). > the one given to them by their English-speaking colonizers with had they been given any in the first place Well, history is complicated: it's certainly true that the vast majority of the colonizers were trying to ban the indigenous languages, but there have always been a few people working with the local groups to understand and develop their languages, even hundreds of years ago. And over the last 50 years or so, there's been lots of support for language preservation and education. > and not been all but exterminated instead I'm not sure if you're talking about the languages or the people here, but there are some 6 million Indigenous people [2] and 700k speakers of indigenous languages [3] [4] [5] in North America today, so I wouldn't quite call either "all but exterminated". [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cherokee_syllabary https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cherokee_syllabary [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Canadian_Aboriginal_syllabics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Canadian_Aboriginal_syllabics [2]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indigenous_peoples_of_the_Americas https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indigenous_peoples_of_the_Amer... [3]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indigenous_languages_of_the_Americas#Northern_America https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indigenous_languages_of_the_Am... [4]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Languages_of_Canada#/media/File:Indigenous_language_speakers_in_Canada-3.png https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Languages_of_Canada#/media/Fil... [5]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Languages_of_the_United_States#List_of_Native_American_languages https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Languages_of_the_United_States...
- lyall 2mo agoI'm surprised that articles like this that are pretty clearly AI-generated get any sort of traction here. Is it because people think the topic is interesting but don't actually care about the content? > Three Japanese words, three Hepburn transcriptions. The letters you already know, telling you what they sound like. I mean come on.
- refactor_master 2mo ago> The letters you already know, telling you what they sound like So… letters?
- japgolly 2mo agoDetecting AI writing is a skill that not everyone has.
- Timwi 2mo ago> Is it because people think the topic is interesting but don't actually care about the content? I'm having difficulty seeing where you draw the line between “topic” and “content”. I found the article interesting as it taught me a few things that I didn't already know. I did notice the one egregious AIism that you pointed out, but the rest was readable and informative. (Although I stopped at the point where it started talking about their software Fink.)
- rkido 2mo agoMinor correction on the article: Kunrei-shiki doesn't have a 1-to-1 mapping between kana and letters. You can see that directly in the table they show. Only Nihon-shiki does. Kunrei-shiki is the worst of both worlds. That's why Nihon-shiki is and will likely always remain the best system for serious students of Japanese - if you even need it at all. But then again, if you're just starting out, the best place to start is usually to immediately start learning kana.
- kps 2mo agoWhat surprises me (only a little) is that Japan continues to use Chinese characters when they've got a perfectly good native syllabary.
- nrr 2mo agoI don't know if this is from the perspective of having learned Mandarin in elementary school first or if Japanese folks feel similarly, but reading words like, e.g., だいがくいんせい versus 大学院生 is actually a little more annoying because I have to scan more of the line to read the word in question. This is notwithstanding the effect that hiragana has in highlighting grammatical structures; it's a lot like setting off Finnish case endings and verb conjugations in a different color. At least, that's the reason why I prefer still having kanji around.
- fenomas 2mo agoJapanese as it currently exists is just really hard to read when written without kanji. A couple reasons: it has TONS of homophones, and it doesn't use spaces, and also it has lots of common words that are only 1 or 2 characters long. So if you're parsing a stream of kana, in the general case there will be several different ways to interpret the next couple characters and you'll constantly be backtracking. So at a minimum, dropping kanji would mean the language needed to develop a system for where spaces go (which is less trivial than it sounds IMO). But also it would need to abandon a lot of homophones or find some way to disambiguate them. It could happen I guess, but I'm not sure how it could happen gradually.
- yongjik 2mo agoKorean could serve as a point of comparison, as modern Korean is written mostly without Chinese characters (you could mix them in if you really want to, but approximately nobody bothers), but it does have spaces between words. And yes, when you have a highly inflecting language, "where do the spaces go" is a very nontrivial problem. It's a bit easier for Korean as it has far more available syllables (so fewer homonyms), but you could easily imagine these languages making different tradeoffs and ending up in different places.
- pmcarlton 2mo agoYes, several things are just wrong here, e.g. "…久保 becomes "Kubo" without the long vowel marked at all…" -- there is no long vowel! Just plain Kubo is correct. "Nihon-shiki and Kunrei-shiki optimize for a systematic, one-to-one mapping between kana and romanization. One kana, one romanization, always, with no exceptions." (Kunrei-shiki: exceptions! 猫は庭へ魚を運ぶ Neko wa niwa e sakana o hakobu) Also: "Romanization is a scaffold, not a destination." ? I TOO AM A HUMAN WRITER WHO WRITES WITH MY OWN FINGERS. But the history of the Romaji movement is indeed interesting - there were influential people who were quite serious about moving entirely to romaji at one point! It would have changed everything.
- japgolly 2mo ago> Kunreisiki is also better for serious Japanese learners as it greatly simplifies the description of Japanese grammar: cf. matu/matte/matimasu (all with the same verb stem mat-) vs. Hepburn matsu/matte/machimasu (with 3 different verb stems)." This is a silly argument because anyone learning Japanese is going to need to learn how to pronounce it anyway. Also "serious Japanese learners" would likely be using kana.
- archargelod 2mo agoAbsolutely agree. Romaji was absolutely pointless for me and probably a detriment overall to learning a language. Japanese uses consonant + vowel pairs as a rule, and the faster you train your intuition for this, the better. Remembering both Hiragana and Katakana took me no more than a day each. Although I have to admit that I already tried learning them around 5 years ago and gave up back then out of lack of motivation.
- danabramov 2mo agoHave you considered that different things are difficult for different people? Learning hiragana and katakana has taken me about a month, and I found it very difficult. There is no need to make it prerequisite for starting to learn grammar, forming sentences, or pronunciation.
- deleted 2mo ago[deleted]
- klodolph 2mo agoIf you want to learn pronunciation you should be listening to audio. Sure, maybe don’t force people to learn kana first. But Hepburn is kind of the worst of all worlds, it is just a waste of time to learn Hepburn.
- archargelod 2mo agoNotice how I didn't say that I "learned" both in a day, I "remembered" them. Of course actual learning will take some time, especially with less used characters. But remembering shapes and differentiating between them using mnemonics should not be too hard for most people.
- flufluflufluffy 2mo agoIf any aspiring Japanese learners read this, forget this article. Just start learning hiragana/katakana from the get-go. You’re going to have to eventually, assuming you want read anything (and anything worth reading certainly won’t be written in romaji). But beyond that, you want to start breaking down your instinctual pronunciations and biases that appear when reading letters you know, so that you can more accurately and efficiently learn the correct pronunciations.
- danabramov 2mo agoThis is unnecessarily pedantic advice, and I encourage fellow learners of Japanese to ignore it. You will definitely need to learn hiragana and katakana but you can do it at your own pace, and it is orthogonal to learning the basics of grammar, forming sentences, and pronunciation, so you definitely don't need to think of it as an obstacle. For pronunciation in particular, obviously watching Japanese movies etc helps. And yes, I have a native Japanese teacher who recommends the same.
- jimbokun 2mo agoLearning kana is the single fastest way to internalize the Japanese phonetic system and pronunciation, in my opinion.
- jimbokun 2mo agoYes, learning kana is the fastest way to internalize the Japanese phonetic system. Learning the katakana pronunciation of English learn words can be fun. There was a popular TV commercial jingle for “McDonald’s” that only works in Japanese because “makudonarudo” has more syllables.
- stumulo_rob 2mo agoAI slop aside, everybody seems to talk about romanization exclusively from the perspective of Japanese learners, while the biggest problem with Kunrei-shiki and Nihon-shiki is how they've been sabotaging Japanese people's ability to learn and pronounce English correctly. Hepburn is anglocentric and that makes perfect sense given how deeply embedded English is in modern Japanese.
- adrian_b 2mo agoBoth Hepburn and the fact that English is deeply embedded in modern Japanese make sense only because USA has won the War (which is a good thing otherwise, but some of its effects on Japanese are less desirable). Besides this historical motivation, there exists no technical argument in favor of any of them. I do not agree at all that Nihon-shiki can sabotage the ability of Japanese people to learn and pronounce English. Except for the native English speakers, all the other people of the World who are familiar with other languages besides their own are also familiar with the fact that every language has its own system of writing and pronunciation, whose rules you must learn, including the alphabet variations. It is the dominance of English in the international relations after WWII which sabotages the ability of most native English speakers to learn other languages, especially to learn how they are pronounced, so in foreign countries the native English speakers usually stand out much more than the native speakers of any other languages, because of their pronunciation, which is found funny by the locals. Making the rules for writing your own language more complex for your own country and for most other countries of the World, just to make them simpler for the citizens of a certain privileged country, is not a behavior that I can approve, because I find it too subservient.
- stumulo_rob 2mo agoIncredibly arrogant/racist take that reduces Japanese people to passive recipients of Western influence as if they had no agency of their own for more than half a century.
- Lumich 2mo agoIncredibly stupid and misleading comment of yours, slily insinuating Adrian has taken an "arrogant/racist" attitude towards the Japanese, when in fact not the slightest trace of such an attitude can be found in his comment. Rather, he (rightfully) criticized the generally negative effect caused by the deployment of anglocentric teaching methods (exclusively for the convenience of the Anglo world). In addition, he observed a negative feedback of such strategems on the Anglo world itself, in as much as it forms an "impediment by convenience" for them to learn about other cultures (and thus rise a bit on the scale of human development). So in a way what he said is the opposite of what you claim he did. Might that have been what triggered your inadequate reaction? As for "arrogance", you stated that Kunrei/Nihon have been "sabotaging Japanese people's ability to learn and pronounce English correctly", as if there was any value in that for a civilization that culturally stands much higher than, say, the USA. And as for "racism", it is well known that was an important factor on the "no prisoners" approach the US took against Japan, and also in terroristically and sadistically napalming one city after another (then repeated in Korea and Vietnam).
- hatthew 2mo agoMaybe the subset of japanese content I'm exposed to is biased, but personally I encounter doubled vowels (obaasan) more often than macron vowels (obāsan). The latter is explicitly "modified hepburn romanization". Even if the latter is more common in general, it's worth noting that the former is the original. The article seems to say that the former is weird and nonstandard, which afaik is completely false. Also, the particles は を へ aren't always romanized the way they're pronounced; I can think of several places I've seen を written as wo despite being used as a particle.
- adrian_b 2mo agoUsing doubled vowels instead of diacritics is just one more concession to Americans, who are unfamiliar with the use of diacritics and whose software frequently does not work correctly when text contains characters with diacritics. Hepburn is an inappropriate method of writing Japanese, which nonetheless has become the dominant way of writing Japanese, just because it caters to the inability of most Americans to learn how other languages than English are written and pronounced.
- hatthew 2mo agoOk?
- Timwi 2mo agoYou make it sound like you think “modified” means “degraded” and the original is always superior just for being the original.
- timcobb 2mo agoThis is interesting but as always these days the slop effect just makes it feel like I'm reading Claude which sucks too much and makes me not want to read this. Add to that that this is content marketing, and the whole thing really collapses. I'll consume interesting content marketing, I may even consume interesting slop, but I can't consume slop content marketing.
- kazinator 2mo ago> The principle comes with a trade-off. Hepburn is phonetic for English speakers, not systematic for kana. While that is true, the kana themselves are not fully systematic for capturing Japanese. Hepburn can capture features that kana do not! How about this set of examples, which shows both an advantage and drawback of Hepburn. The hiragana sequence こうり (ko-u-ri) could be several things. one is 小売 (retail) where the division is こ・うり. Or it could be 公理 (axiom, self-evident truth) where the dividion is こう・り. Here the う in こう is no longer u but a vowel lengthening mark. Hepburn spells these words differnetly: kouri and kōri. Now, within this same example cluster we ecounter this: the word for ice is こおり (ko-o-ri). Unfortunately, Hepburn has this as kõri, creating an ambiguity not found in kana. A modification to Hepburn allowing (or rather requiring) the spelling koori would resolve that.
- belviewreview 2mo agoAbout a decade ago I became a fan of the young Japanese drum prodigy Kanade Sato. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XYpFL08m5fQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XYpFL08m5fQ This lead to me learning the amazing fact that Japanese has 4 writing systems: kanji, hiragana, katakana, and romaji. And now I am learning that there are actually several different romanization systems. What a confusing situation.
- Timwi 2mo agoI don't think most Japanese speakers would characterize their language as having “four writing systems”. They would say three and not include Romaji in the count. This is not to say they don't use Romaji, but it's not considered part of the official orthography. There are no words or sentences that can't officially be written without Romaji. The same is true with English and emoji. We do use emoji to augment the language, but that doesn't tempt us to consider emoji part of our alphabet. The analogy is weak of course, because English doesn't have an equivalent official transcription into another writing system. But you get the point. If the roles were reversed and global culture and the Internet were all in Japanese first and foremost, and most languages based their writing on kana and/or kanji so much so that you can't avoid it when traveling, then English would get an official transcription into that.
- poppafuze 2mo agoslop tells.