3 ms·
My best guess is that from the perspective of the OpenAI people, Buckmaster was letting his paranoia about OpenAI training tank his opportunity to receive the C
by ummonk 2mo ago
My best guess is that from the perspective of the OpenAI people, Buckmaster was letting his paranoia about OpenAI training tank his opportunity to receive the Clay Prize (it seems like Buckmaster and Alpoge's result isn't quite the full result required for the Clay Prize, whereas apparently OpenAI does have that full result worked out, using the same approach that Buckmaster and Alpoge had been exploring).
Whether the Codex sessions could have indeed made their way into Astra training data is something I can only speculate on though.
- az226 2mo agoZero data retention, wink. No looksies, wink. No trainsies, wink.
- ngomez 2mo agoWell, Buckmaster says both his and Alpöge's use of Codex was non-institutional, and OpenAI claims the right to train their models on inputs and outputs of non-enterprise users in their service policies [0]. So I'm not sure they were even promised that. [0] https://openai.com/policies/how-your-data-is-used-to-improve-model-performance/ https://openai.com/policies/how-your-data-is-used-to-improve...
- senordevnyc 2mo agoOnly for ChatGPT, if the user hasn’t opted out. Would mathematicians be using ChatGPT for this kind of work? Genuinely asking, I know nothing about this!
- hodgehog11 2mo agoYes, mathematicians are. And yes, most of my colleagues did not even know the opt-out was an option.
- Readerium 2mo agoQuestion is what does that button do. I bet a lot of lawyers are salivating at this question too.
- Certhas 2mo agoIf I am reading your question correctly you are asking about chat interface Vs Codex/Claude code? If so, in my experience Codex/Claude code use is widespread for mathematicians who are seriously using these tools.
- tempfile 2mo agoIt isn't relevant whether they were promised that. Indeed I think the assumption must be that they were not promised that, since otherwise the author asking if they were would not make much sense. If OpenAI did use the conversations from Buckmaster and Alpoge, then not disclosing it, explicitly, is plagiarism. If they planned to use that plagiarism to pressure the authors to publish, that is even more unethical. What the terms of use say does not make it any more or less ethical.
- YeGoblynQueenne 2mo agoThat's absolutely right. Why the downvotes? If OpenAI are using but not acknowledging the work of others that's plagiarism. If they don't know for sure, but aren't performing due dilligence to make sure they aren't, that's also plagiarism.
- tempfile 2mo agoI can imagine excuses for unknowing plagiarism in this case. What is described in the article seems much more serious: a research program that was only initiated following reports of the author's similar program. In this case no excuses of "I didn't know" can apply, it is not like this revealed some obscure work from the 1980s nobody could reasonably have foreseen. And as far as I can tell this program was only really initiated to apply pressure to the researchers, without their knowledge/consent. It looks very weird. > Why the downvotes? I think there was only ever one. Not sure why.
- YeGoblynQueenne 2mo agoYour comment was greyed out when I saw it earlier, maybe you missed some downvotes? About the plagiarism issue, I model it as OpenAI being an advisor and their AI a PhD student. If the advisor puts their name on a paper behind that of their PhD and it turns out the PhD copied the text of the paper from somewhere else the advisor is also responsible of plagiarism, not just the student. The least the advisor can do is withdraw their authorship from the paper. But, yeah, point well made: it could be much worse than that. Like an advisor instructing a student to copy someone else's paper.
- deleted 2mo ago[deleted]
- Semkas 2mo ago"using the same approach that Buckmaster and Alpoge had been exploring" is imo mealy wording: it seems fairly likely that OA heard Buckmaster and Alpoge were close to a breakthrough, and decided to use their unlimited compute to quickly prompt based on their assumptions about B&As work.
- dekhn 2mo agoIs that necessarily wrong, so long as the original innovators get a citation credit?
- dmkolobov 2mo agoCitation of what? this was unpublished work! This computational blitz really just reads as "might makes right" on OpenAi's part... which isn't surprising, but they should probably be honest about what they've done here.
- stevemk14ebr 2mo agoYes. Quite simply yes. It's unethical. And it's a dick move
- curt15 2mo agoBuckmaster is already an established world expert at these sorts of problems. Declining the Clay prize would hardly dent his career.
- dandanua 2mo agoCan you call paranoia a fear of something which is happening? OpenAI uses user chats for training and they are "open" about it.
- qnleigh 2mo agoHe doesn't seem to be after the prize himself. In this statement he credits the approach of another two researchers: > I believe Luis Mart´ınez-Zoroa deserves a Fields Medal.