4 ms·
Arm Mali G2-Ultra NX GPU: desktop-class mobile gameplay with AI-native graphics
- eptcyka 2mo agoWhat about support in mesa?
- bigbaguette 2mo agoGive it a couple years before Valve starts sponsoring someone to reverse-engineer it
- eptcyka 2mo agoI do not understand why vendors believe their software stack is a moat. It is an obstacle to me.
- krautsauer 2mo agoopens wikipedia (Emphasis mine:) > Moats were excavated around castles and other fortifications as part of the defensive system as an obstacle immediately outside the walls. Unfortunate wording?
- dbdr 2mo agoMoats are supposed to be obstacles for your competitors, not your consumers.
- ImHereToVote 2mo agoIt's akin to building a moat inside the castle.
- wang_li 2mo agoThat's called a Lazy River.
- buran77 2mo agoMoats are obstacles against something you're trying to avoid. It can be competitors coming in, or customers going out. A moat could surround a prison to keep prisoners in. Some companies just choose to treat their customers as prisoners.
- entrope 2mo agoThe usual metaphor for keeping customers is a walled garden, right? I think it's useful to distinguish them by default.
- pjmlp 2mo agoBecause most game developers aren't religious about APIs, they implement an abstraction layer in their engine, a practice since the heterogeneous 8 and 16 bit days, where all major games were mostly coded in Assembly, and move on. Any conference talk schedule at one of these conferences (https://gameconfguide.com https://gameconfguide.com) will prove the point of how little they care. It is all about gameplay, taking advantage of gaming IP, franchaises, how to squeeze the ultimate performance out of specific hardware, user engagement,.... You will find an occasional talk about open APIs, probably even done by some Khronos folks, and that's it.
- david-gpu 2mo agoIf they open-sourced their userland drivers, and/or released their internal technical documentation, which would have a similar effect, they would open themselves to at least two big problems. First, they would spill all of their secret sauce for others to "draw inspiration" from. And there is a lot of expensive secret sauce in there. Not all of it is protected by parents either; more on that below. Second, they would make it a lot easier for competitors and patent trolls alike to seek litigation. One of the criteria thech companies have for filing a patent is how easy is it to detect when it is being violated. Open source your stuff, and you make it much easier for the competition to detect any violation. And it is not like these companies are violating patents intentionally; much the opposite. But there are only so many ways to implement Vulkan or DirectX, and completely independent teams will come up with similar enough solutions, and with broad enough patents, that there will be overlap every now and then. That is why they file patents in the first place. Only the high cost of litigation and the risk of mutually-assured destruction keeps legitimate vendors from rattling sabers more often. Then you have NVidia with their immense investment and advantage on the software side, from the CUDA runtime to countless libraries like CUBLAS and cuDNN. That investment goes much beyond a relatively simple Vulkan/DirectX driver. So the question is less "why don't more of them open-source userland". The question is "why do any of them do it"? Source: former insider with enough patents under my belt that I lost count.
- eptcyka 2mo agoDo you have any thoughts on the question you posed? Amdgpu and mesa is working out fairly well for amd, but yes, there is also still a proprietary userland for it too. Intel I think is using mesa code for their Windows drivers too. How are they different?
- david-gpu 2mo agoI genuinely don't know. They are smart people, they know the game. They must have figured out that there is an upside for them. Just speculating here. Maybe they have big customers that communicated to them that they will choose them over the competition if they open more of their software stack. Maybe they are less afraid of being sued because they are the underdog and they believe that the authorities would not be kind to a behemoth suing them, or they believe that the behemoth would not sue them because of the bad press it would generate vs the settlement they would get. I actually don't know. But I am sure they have good reasons, just like the corps that keep it closed also have good reasons. It is not "good" vs "evil".
- deleted 2mo ago[deleted]
- throwa356262 2mo agoWhy? I thought these GPU were open source with mainline kernel support?
- adrian_b 2mo agoAll the mainline kernel support is reverse-engineered. No help from Arm. Thus there is a considerable lag for the support of newer Mali generations. Some Linux distributions for various embedded computers with Arm-based CPUs and GPUs use closed-source GPU drivers from Arm, not the reverse-engineered Linux drivers, when the Mali versions are newer than supported by the kernel and Mesa. The Arm GPUs do not have public technical documentation, not even at the level of NVIDIA, much less something comparable with AMD and Intel.
- ginko 2mo ago>All the mainline kernel support is reverse-engineered. No help from Arm. That's not true. Arm has been supporting the open source driver effort for the last couple years, but it's still behind the closed source one in terms of performance, features, and HW support.
- fuzzfactor 2mo agoI liked it better when electronic components which didn't have very thorough detailed documentation were instantly recognizable as completely unsuitable for a production BOM. :\
- throwa356262 2mo agoI think you are confusing Apple and Arm. Mali drivers are contributed by Arm: https://github.com/torvalds/linux/blob/master/MAINTAINERS https://github.com/torvalds/linux/blob/master/MAINTAINERS
- adrian_b 2mo agoMost Mali drivers from the kernel are not contributed by Arm, but you are right that nowadays some contributors from Arm have appeared for the older reverse-engineered GPU drivers, like Panfrost and Panthor, and now there are also a few GPU-related drivers, like HDLCD and MALI-DP, which have indeed been contributed by Arm. Besides the Mali generations that are supported in the mainline kernel, there are many other Mali generations for which Arm has not provided anything else except closed-source drivers for Android, in a few cases also closed-source drivers for Linux. However, there are many other reverse-engineered Mali drivers, besides those from the mainline kernel. It is good that Arm has begun to contribute to the kernel DRM drivers, but these drivers do little else except providing the means to communicate with the GPUs. The complex work is done in the user-space GPU drivers from Mesa. The Mesa Lima driver, for older generations of Mali, does not have any contribution from Arm. In the past, Mesa Panfrost was also completely reverse-engineered. Seeing that now Arm has begun to contribute to the kernel Panfrost DRM, I do not know whether they have started to contribute also to the Mesa Panfrost. In any case, while some contributions to the previously reverse-engineered drivers are much better than nothing, what would have been much better is to publish the technical documentation of the Mali GPUs, in which case it would not have mattered whether Arm contributes something or not, as anyone could have written the drivers.
- ksec 2mo agoWith IMG PowerVR mostly gone from Mediatek roadmap. Which means ARM Mali is effectively the GPU IP on Android, excluding Qualcomm Adreno which its market continue to shrink and concentrate on premium segment. I wonder how far or how good Mali is now compared to others. I wish Chip and Cheese do compassion on GPU as well.
- teki_one 2mo agoGoogle just switched to PowerVR, didn't they?
- throwa356262 2mo agoGiven the horrible GPU performance as well as thermal issues in Tensor G5 and G6, Google will have to switch back to Arm in G7. Example benchmark showing how extremely far Google is behind: GeekBench 6 Compute Score (GPU): Xring O3. 36901. (the GPU in this announcement) Snapdragon 8 Elite G5 27501. (Adreno 840) Dimensity 9500M. 23753. (Mali-G1 Ultra MP11). Tensor G6. 6216. (PowerVR CXTP-48-1536)
- MindSpunk 2mo agoThe Pixel 10 and 11 GPUs are offensively bad. Not only are the Power VR GPUs slow, and less capable feature wise than Mali and Adreno (Xclipse is still around too!), but the tile Google put in the Pixel 11 is actually an _older_ design than what they put in the Pixel 10. They just clocked it higher to make up the performance difference. And then Google has the gall to charge basically flagship prices for their under powered junk. Personally I don't buy flagship phones because I don't use their full compute capabilities anyway, but a Pixel 11 would cost 2x what I paid for my Pixel 8. For 0 GPU performance improvement.
- Fr0styMatt88 2mo agoI have fond memories from back when Pixels were actually flagship. The Pixel 2 is my nostalgic pinnacle. I'd totally forgotten about that squeeze gesture until I got my old Pixel 2 out to erase.
- cubefox 2mo agoThis should have happened years ago.
- curiobleak 2mo agoThe headline seems like a way to set themselves up to fail. The advancements are great, those features are definitely something a lot of developers and players are interested in, but comparing it to desktop immediately just sets the bar too high.
- swiftcoder 2mo agoThe average desktop has an anaemic integrated GPU - so it sort of depends how one defines "desktop-class"
- gitowiec 2mo agoThe worst opening ever "Demands from mobile users continue to grow.". I stopped reading bullshit
- chromehearts 2mo agoThis is probably not about "mobile users" as in Android Phones & iPhone users .. but about the current (trendy) rise of handheld consoles ? Atleast that's what I think
- mrheosuper 2mo agoWhy is it bullshit ? Just because you dont need does not mean it’s not real
- f6v 2mo agoWhat's up with that? Younger generations don't even play on PCs anymore.
- pjmlp 2mo agoWhat I find funny is the whole "PC gaming is growing" kind of speech, as some generations abandon consoles for PCs. I and most of my peers have been playing home computers, since the 8 bit days, eventually moved into PC gaming with a 386SX in 1991. While I owned a few consoles, the PC remained the main gaming platform. Do agree that younger generations are mostly playing mobile games.
- alescalaios 2mo ago[dead]
- pavlov 2mo agoAll the hoopla about "neural graphics" just seems to mean various forms of upscaling (spatial, temporal, denoising). I guess that's nice and makes sense on mobile, but it somehow feels a bit disappointing that realtime 3D is shifting from modeling to slop filters.
- cubefox 2mo agoThese three forms are trained in order to approximate the ground truth, and they perform significantly better than their non-neural counterparts which do the same thing but worse. Moreover, neither of them is a pure postprocess, since they receive various rendering passes as input, like the depth buffer. They don't really hallucinate anything, just interpolate. This is another story with DLSS 5, which doesn't reconstruct some ground truth and which is a pure post-processing effect. It just makes the final image look more photo-like in a vague sense. This is more of a "slop filter".
- mepian 2mo agoPretty much all of graphics research now revolves around machine learning, whether it’s neural networks or something like Gaussian splatting.
- zamadatix 2mo agoYou can always run with those features disabled if you find it less disappointing.
- touisteur 2mo agoAny foundry in Europe able or going to manufacture a chip with this on ?
- peacefulnerd 2mo ago"European Semiconductor Manufacturing Company (ESMC) is a joint venture between TSMC, Bosch, Infineon and NXP to establish an advanced semiconductor fab in Dresden, Saxony, Germany." https://www.esmc.eu/en/index.html https://www.esmc.eu/en/index.html If that's the best ARM chip (not counting Intel Ireland) factory in Europe, it's 12 nanometers. That's a decade obsolete and I'm not sure the blueprints were designed for such an old foundry.
- touisteur 2mo agoThanks. I was just wondering, since I think I saw NXP had Arm SKUs with Mali GPU and had some hope someone here would Cunningham's Law me.
- mschuster91 2mo ago"AI-native graphics" good lord, this just reeks of "we're doing something with AI, give us some of that money".
- BoingBoomTschak 2mo agoFun thing, both SA and ChipsAndChesse similarly dunked on that presentation: https://www.semiaccurate.com/2026/09/07/arms-2026-tech-day-is-a-self-inflicted-wound/ https://www.semiaccurate.com/2026/09/07/arms-2026-tech-day-i... https://chipsandcheese.com/p/arms-c2-ultra-g2-ultra-nx-and-css https://chipsandcheese.com/p/arms-c2-ultra-g2-ultra-nx-and-c...
- jlg23 2mo agoOnce one is over the odor of the headline, the announcement reads: * Neural Super Sampling (NSS) reconstructs higher-resolution images from lower-resolution renders, reducing the amount of conventional rendering work needed to produce a high-quality final image. * Neural Frame Rate Upscaling (NFRU) generates intermediate frames to increase frame rates and deliver smoother gameplay. * Neural Super Sampling and Denoising (NSSD) combines neural upscaling with denoising to improve image quality in demanding ray-traced scenes with complex lighting and shadows.
- mschuster91 2mo agoSo yeah, more uncanny valley garbage. Yuck.
- chrisjj 2mo agoSo, image processing and no intelligence. And nor is reconstructs true.
- SideQuark 2mo agoPretty much all cutting edge graphics papers now use some form of NN. To ignore the techniques and gains at the cutting edge would leave any hardware mfr behind. It’s not nonsense or marketing speak. It’s genuine capability improving technology. To see a representative stream of papers, go to arxiv and look through the recent graphics papers.
- HNSheldonImpost 2mo ago"Ai-NaTiVe"
- broken-kebab 2mo agoWhat are dedicated neural accelerators? What exactly do they accelerate?
- yhjc2692 2mo agoMatrix multiply-accumulate operations, possibly at reduced precision (8- or 16-bit). The most common name for this is NPU but the description applies to other things too (eg NVIDIA’s tensor cores, Google’s TPUs, Apple’s ANE to a lesser extent, etc)
- jasomill 2mo agoIt's hard for me to imagine desktop-class GPU performance on a mobile power/thermal budget. If true, why aren't they marketing it to datacenters?
- SideQuark 2mo agoDatacenters don’t run on desktop class GPUs. They’re well past that. It’s why NVidia moved most production of desktop GPUs to data center class hardware.