8 ms·
Blue-collar knowledge workers will save the economy
- cvursache 14y agoThat is an interesting wide political vision of how the current society could change into something a lot better by following an idea. It also sounds a bit like Frederick Engels. Good read, anyways.
- xarien 14y agoThe cost of automating car construction is quite costly. The cost of automating website construction is near zero. That is the number 1 reason why you can't compare these apples and oranges. One of the top reasons why blue collared labor is being phased out is not only due to outsourcing, but also from the installation of robotic workers (i.e. Amazon's warehouse infrastructure). One of the fundamentals of programming or software engineering is the ability to reuse code, modules, frameworks, you name it. With this level of automation already in place and still growing, there's absolutely zero need for this class of blue collared knowledge workers as you've described.
- jfarmer 14y agoI grew up in rural northern Michigan in a village of ~1,500 people. It's the largest municipality in its county, if you can believe it. My senior year of high school was the first year my high school ever offered calculus. The annual unemployment rate in Antrim county for the last three years has been between 12% and 15%. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elk_Rapids,_Michigan http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elk_Rapids,_Michigan http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Antrim_County,_Michigan http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Antrim_County,_Michigan Unemployment stats: http://bit.ly/12HtfrM http://bit.ly/12HtfrM I've now been in the SF Bay Area for six years and have co-founded three companies: Adonomics, Everlane, and Dev Bootcamp. I'm living on Fantasy Island, but there were plenty of people I went to high school with who would be equally or more capable of doing any of the things I did. But when you're "inside" a place with a devastated economy, you're understandably myopic. You're asking yourself things like "What do I do if I get sick or get laid off and lose my health insurance? How am I going to afford next month's rent? How will I get my car's heater repaired before winter?" The world of technology is so far outside your realm of experience that the opportunity it might provide doesn't even register. When people talk about the "bubble" in Silicon Valley, they usually mean a capital bubble. I think the more relevant one is the complete disconnect between how people in the SF Bay Area live (or "the tech industry" more broadly) and the reality experienced by most people outside. This experience is one of the main things that drove me to help start Dev Bootcamp (http://devbootcamp.com http://devbootcamp.com).
- prostoalex 14y agoI think the behavior that you describe is http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Loss_aversion http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Loss_aversion
- jfarmer 14y agoYes indeed, but it can be dangerous to intellectualize it. Encapsulating what people in that situation experience as "loss aversion" confuses reality for a model of reality, IMO. I'm not saying you are, but most people I know who talk in those terms forget that. Ceci n'est pas une pipe, the map is not the terrain, etc. etc. At the extreme, the subjective experience is something like this: http://whatever.scalzi.com/2005/09/03/being-poor/ http://whatever.scalzi.com/2005/09/03/being-poor/
- codewright 14y agoI'm from Ohio, a poor and rural area (not quite that bad buuuut)...I work in startups now. Even have a few side projects rolling around. I'm incredibly fortunate but the people I encounter in the bay area who are completely oblivious to what poverty really is do a lot to dishearten me. Good to know somebody from the sort of place I'm from made it out here. Cheers.
- Crake 14y agoI'm from a poor rural area of Ohio too! Unfortunately, I don't have a success story (yet). It's great to hear about people escaping this awful state.
- codewright 14y agoI lived in NYC (Ohio -> NYC -> Cali) before moving to the bay area! If you want any pointers on NYC or with your programming studies let me know. Cheers and good luck either way :)
- jaggederest 14y agoThe only reason salaries in SF are ridiculous is because they base hiring on which degree you have, compete for the new graduates so they can work them to death, and only look for people in the SF bay. If you relax any of those criteria, you suddenly don't have a programmer shortage anymore. In addition, programming is inherently not something you can have masses of blue-collar people doing. Once you program something once, there's zero cost to make a copy. That's why blue collar jobs are dying in all sorts of industries where things can be automated - they soon will be automated. The idea of websites that are 'factory produced' is called facebook pages or any of a number of other as-a-service setups that give you a domain, some pages, and a form-based interface to fill them out. There's again no need to go bringing a bunch of people into the equation - those sass businesses need virtually no human sales or support compared to a car dealership in every city over 10k people. You can sell your product everywhere on earth with a sales and support system of ~100 people, if you really want to hold a lot of hands.
- tibbon 14y agoYes, there is still a developer shortage, at least for certain technologies. I'm in Columbus, Ohio, and its near impossible still to find a local Rails & Backbone developer who is looking for work and does a good job. I'm not going to work them to death, and i'd be willing to pay a decent salary. Friends in NY, Boston, Austin, Chicago and DC have reported similar findings in looking for qualified individuals. These people aren't looking for rockstars, but often just someone who will do the job well. If you're willing to hire remote, it still isn't always easy to find someone, but it does get much easier comparatively.
- jfarmer 14y agoOne of our summer Dev Bootcamp students moved back to Columbus, Ohio. Shoot me an email at jesse@devbootcamp.com and I'm happy to put you two in touch. :) Can't promise he's what you or anyone you know is looking for in terms of a potential employee, but it might be nice from a community-building standpoint!
- 14y ago
- cadlin 14y agoThe graph in the post indicates that unemployment in all sectors went up after the financial crash, some were just hit by it more than others. Specifically, those who worked in construction suffered the worst from a collapse in real estate. Also, that jobs that require "worthless" college degrees and/or oversaturated professional degrees (e.g. law grads) still have more job security than those with little to no post-secondary education. It would be interesting to see a similar graph-by-occupation when the dot-com bubble burst. Would you see the exact opposite trend?
- tibbon 14y agoI've tried to get a few friends into development who aren't developers. These are people working at $8-10/hr, often upward of 50 hours a week. Even moving up to $25/hr would be a massive life change for them, and given hiring trends in tech I thought it would be a great move for them, even if they weren't great at it for a few years. Its been a miserable failure. I've come to the conclusion that programming is hard, and I've been incredibly privileged by having a computer since I was 2 (C64!) and I have so much built in knowledge that I don't even realize I have. Also, this stuff just isn't fun for a lot of people. Sometimes its downright painful for them and they just can't push themselves through the tough parts motivation-wise. I can imagine it being a bit like doing Crossfit (or any exercise). I know I'd be a lot healthier if I did it for a year. But the upfront expense, the pain, and being incredibly bad at it for the first few months just makes it so I don't even try- even though I know the benefits could be life changing. I bought a copy of Agile Development on Rails and gave it to such a friend. He didn't know how to pull up a command prompt, and I realized that he didn't know what a text editor was. Or that you'd run things from the terminal, and type them in the text editor. I helped him get past that, but he never focused in on it and never saw the beautiful and amazing parts of it. Another friend got a little farther. But I soon realized how much 'background' knowledge he was missing. I pointed him toward some free online CS courses, which helped. But life got in the way and it just wasn't the #1 thing for him, so he got distracted and quit when he moved to a new (small) city. Another friend wanted help getting started. He was motivated, but we hit a major problem. He's a student with an older iBook. We had huge issues setting up Ruby due to various environmental problems. I didn't have the time to really redo his entire system, but I wasn't able to get Ruby installed easily since he was on 10.3 or something ancient. Just telling people that there are boatloads of money to be had, and that there are tons of resources out there doesn't always work. They really have to love it to get through that first painful year or so. Now perhaps having more jobs (these knowledge factories) that will give people an environment to work in, the tools, the training, etc... might help. But otherwise, I've just seen that I have personally been a complete and utter failure at helping friends get into programming. I'm thankful that I have a background that makes it easy for me to do and learn, but many just don't have that background and I don't know how to help them get past that.
- tsotha 14y ago
- dizzystar 14y agoEvery single one of these articles are missing an element that I believe will prevent US production from ever returning: the supply chain is way longer from US -> US than it is from China -> US. This sounds absolutely absurd, I know, but it is the truth. If you go to China, you can practically buy direct from many factories, or you can go through a broker who actually does know the source factory. This does not happen in America, at least in my brief experience. I used to be responsible for finding US sources for certain products. If you aren't aware, you'd think that the price of a US-made product is 10x that of China, when in reality, it is just the supply chain that is 5 people deep, but only if you really work at getting it that low. The amount of "middle men" is absurd. I reversed engineered quite a few supply chains, and even managed to get in contact with the source, but there I was blocked. I had to go one person higher, but that person refused to speak to my company. I then had to go one person higher, and they refused to talk to me. I ultimately ended up going up 5 levels away from the source, but even that is not a chain, but more like a web. If I was able to buy from the source, or even two levels away, the price of the products would be cheaper than China. The final slap was that the person I finally managed to get a "yes" from was not willing to work with me unless I worked specifically on their terms. I won't go into detail, but their term was 100% unreasonable. The fact is that the supply chain in the US is far to complex and it is based on protecting profits. US-made items are not inherently more expensive than Chinese products, but even those with clout have to deal with long response times and an ever-growing web of middle-men. Simply hiring a Mandarin speaker to call China is far quicker and easier.
- TheCowboy 14y agoWould you mind elaborating and specifying which industries or resources you experienced these problems? This sounds like something that a startup could target.
- dizzystar 14y agoI would say look up consumer-plastics, like high-quality cups and pens. I'm not talking about the use once and toss away stuff: think Tervis-style items or things made with tritan. It gets considerably more complex if you only target items that are eco-friendly, then add in imprinting and the world gets exceptionally complicated. Another issue is mold-creation, which is separated from manufacturing in many cases and also very expensive. The piece-counts are usually tolerable. The fact is that China can do custom molding much cheaper and many US companies refuse to do it at all. I've also discovered that many companies will straight-up lie to you about USA-made items as well. The company I worked for recently caught one person lying about this stuff, so there's that element as well.
- necolas 14y agoThe analogies and conclusions are based on false assumptions about the driving forces and consequences of the "machine revolution". You can expect fewer jobs and the accumulation of more wealth concentrated in the hands of fewer people as a result of increased automation and the creation of more efficient "digital production lines".
- toyg 14y agoWe keep looking at XIX century models and try to map them to the present day; that is just wrong. The fundamental shift in production models that full automation is bringing is still poorly understood. Even worse, we keep looking at percentages of growing populations, with no regard for absolute limits: we assume our models will grow forever, that we'll produce an infinite number of physical objects (houses, cars) in a finite space. You cannot expect the construction sector to grow forever. You cannot expect factories to stop using better and better robots. You cannot expect developers to stop automating more and more processes, including their own job. The only sectors were you can try to create "infinite employment growth" are social: healthcare, education, some creative industries. These sectors have hard dependencies on their customers/workers ratio, and are forced to grow and shrink in tune with actual population numbers. Unfortunately, these are also sectors we undervalue and underfund, with very sensitive boundaries, and where classic capitalistic paradigms don't work well. There is a lot of work to do.
- Crake 14y agoHumans don't like to think about the fact that everything will end for them someday. Most people can barely plan for a week, much less for a century from now. Humanity's downfall will almost certainly stem from the shortsightedness of the majority.
- rossjudson 14y agoYou can't increase the bandwidth of the programming industry by lowering salaries. If we're doing well right now, so be it. There's always another crash around the corner, and next time we may not be lucky.
- ilaksh 14y agoHe makes some good points. In particular the idea that web sites and other common applications don't need to be hand-crafted at a low level for each individual customer and instead can be built by configuring and combining components with graphical interactive tools. This type of component-based software development has been available for years. It just hasn't become popular with programmers, because configuring components isn't considered programming since it doesn't involve typing cryptic ASCII code. This is the main issue holding back software development. Also, the idea that you shouldn't have to write code to position text and graphical elements on a page, I think would be obvious to more programmers if it weren't for the HTML+CSS tradition that has been built up and become ensconced.
- spitfire 14y agoYou couldn't be more right. We're still working with such low level tools it's embarrassing. The worst part is, I think this is because of a sort of job security mentality. We had real working RAD tools in the 90's (NeXT/Apple enterprise object frameworks). Systems with databases built into the OS in the 80's (AS/400), and so on. But we've abandoned all of those. >I think would be obvious to more programmers if it weren't for the HTML+CSS tradition that has been built up and become ensconced. HTML/CSS and in fact the entire web stack is a horrible monster. It's essentially programming in assembly to put dialogs up on a screen. The only real saving grace is reach. Here's an experiment, put up a modal dialog up in your GUI. One line. Now do the same in a webpage.
- rizzom5000 14y agoIt's possible to compare writing software to writing literature. In the end, it doesn't matter how huge the demand for good literature is; the number of people capable of writing a good novel will remain roughly the same. If anything, smart software will put mediocre programmers (and novelists) out of work. It seems unlikely, however, that we'll ever see a significant number of unskilled workers in the tech sector.
- lgleason 14y agoThere are two issues with this article. One, writing software is not like producing things on an assembly line. This is why we have come to realize that CMM is not effective, and Agile/Lean works.....Writing software is analogous to designing a product, not mass producing it. In the same way that the economy went through a transition during the beginning of the industrial revolution, the same is happening today.......granted I would love to see things move towards a resource based economy ala the zeitgeist movement.....but that is another discussion.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- ajlai 14y agoWhat you are calling for is http://www.wix.com/ http://www.wix.com/.