3 ms·
"Free Market" is a consistent term that refers to a set of laws that allow commerce to happen with as few restrictions as possible. I agree that some people for
by 1123581321 14y ago
"Free Market" is a consistent term that refers to a set of laws that allow commerce to happen with as few restrictions as possible. I agree that some people forget that those basic laws, such as property rights, are required. However, those laws are so simple compared to the current state of commercial regulation that the free market is often called regulation-free as shorthand.
That said, I personally do not think software patents have a place in either what is conventionally called a free market or in a well-regulated market.
- rayiner 14y agoIt's not "shorthand" it's "intellectually dishonest." It's an attempt to hide the fact that what you're really asserting isn't that "regulation is bad" but rather "I think these particular regulations are bad, but I'm very much attached to these other regulations." It's a lazy attempt to get out of arguing against the merits of particular regulation through an appeal to the theoretical merits of an "unregulated market."
- 1123581321 14y agoI think it's more like calling someone a good person even though everyone understands a good person has flaws, or calling someone a bad person even though they've done a few good things, if you like. Regardless of your personal feelings, when someone advocates a regulation-free environment, they mean one with those minimal market regulations. This is understood in any conventional( * ), practical discussion as well as most philosophical, legal and economic debates. If all parties understand this, and would prefer to use shorthand in order to quickly arrive at the heart of a particular matter, then I question whether it can be considered dishonest. * By conventional, I mean to exclude, for example, a discussion between two anarchists -- I mean a mainstream discussion taking place in Western civilization. Edit: I need to clarify that while this is all understood, it may be forgotten by someone in any particular moment. However, if reminded they will likely have no objection. This is what I meant when referring to people who forget in my earlier post.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]