13 ms·
Congress Is Quietly Abandoning the 5th Amendment
- rdl 14y agoThere seems to be some political calculus where it makes sense to pass unconstitutional but popular laws, then let the courts strike them down. Frequently vs. the 1st, now against the 2nd, 4th, and 5th. Of course, the courts never really seem to rule for the 9th or 10th.
- mtgx 14y agoI hope you're not suggesting they are doing this for the people. Because the people weren't even aware they introduced this provision in the NDAA 2012, so it's not like it would've scored them any brownie points with the "kill the muslims" crowd. They tried to do it in secret, but civil libertarians found out about it, and then some backlash started. Now the House passed NDAA 2013 with the same provision as in 2012, and the Senate adopted an amendment that banned that "indefinite detention without trial" provision. But the negotiators for the two bills eliminated that at the last moment. So indefinite detention without trial is back. So now it's up to Obama to reject it, but I hope there are no illusions, like last year, that he will actually reject it. He won't.
- jbooth 14y agoI wonder if these senators are the kinds of people who believe that a cop would never lie on the stand.
- thirdtruck 14y agoHumans as a species are rather more credulous of others than warranted by the inherit limitations of our perception, cognition, and retention abilities, even before factoring in deliberate deception. In short, I can believe that.
- rdl 14y agoIt's done for a variety of reasons -- ignorance, special interests, or pandering -- but the same enabler -- not caring so much about the constitutionality of the laws passed. Congress should have a legal duty to uphold the constitution.
- JoeAltmaier 14y agoIt doesn't work like that. The judiciary does that.
- jbooth 14y agoThey actually do typically swear to support the constitution as part of their oath of office.
- jug6ernaut 14y agoAs we all know saying one thing and actually doing it are two totally different things. Sadly.
- BerislavLopac 14y agoIt would be interested to see what would happen if it was upheld that a sworn official who passes (or votes for) a law that is later deemed unconstitutional has to step down. I don't believe such a principle would ever be approved by official bodies, but it would certainly have an interesting effect, one way or another.
- pdonis 14y agos/typically/always/
- quonn 14y agoI agree with the grandparent. It's the same thing here in Germany: The parlament has passed many, many unconstitutional laws throughout the last decade. Courts invalidated them later. There are two main issues: 1. Those laws set expectations to what is acceptable. Constitutional but extreme laws later pass as "moderate" in the opinion of the public. 2. Respect for the constitution gradually erodes. 2. Lots of energy is wasted, because EFF type of organizations need to go to court, collect evidence, testify, etc.
- jivatmanx 14y agoSounds like they're spamming knowingly unconstitutional provisions that have already been struck down, in an attempt to overwhelm the supreme court's finite capacity to enforce them.
- enraged_camel 14y agoNot sure if it's intentional, but yes, the effect seems to be a form of denial of service.
- anigbrowl 14y agoThey tried to do it in secret, but civil libertarians found out about it, and then some backlash started. No they didn't. Not putting out a press release doesn't mean you're trying to do stuff in secret. The reality is that most people just don't care much about the intended targets of this legislation.
- rayiner 14y agoThe 9th amendment is merely interpretive guidance, and the 10th amendment is a tautology. Also, what is happening with the NDAA is not Congress passing an unconstitutional law. It's Congress passing a law with a potentially unconstitutional interpretation, and both Congressional and Presidential guidance that such interpretation is not intended. Such guidance carries great weight in the court. It's a non-issue really.
- Strang 14y agoThe Tenth Amendment is only now interpreted as a tautology for political convenience. The text reads: The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States respectively, or to the people. Just because it is now ignored by our government doesn't make it a tautology. It's still the law of the land; it's just being willfully misinterpreted.
- rayiner 14y agoThat's incorrect. It's actually "only now" that the 10th amendment is being interpreted as an affirmative limitation on federal power. Historically, the 10th amendment was considered a mere truism. U.S. v. Darby (1941). Conceptually, how the Constitution works is as follows. The states inherited the sovereignty and unlimited power of the British parliament. In aggreeing to the Constitution, the states delegated some of that power to the federal government, and agreed to refrain from the exercise of certain other powers. The clauses of the Constitution outline the powers delegated and prohibited. All the 10th amendment says is that anything that hasn't been delegated or prohibited hasn't been delegated or prohibited. Which is tautological. The mere face of the text cannot support an interpretation that the 10th amendment does anything other than state the obvious. If a federal action is otherwise Constitutional, by virtue of falling into one of the delegations, then it is by definition something that has not been reserved to the state.
- Strang 14y agoThe Progressive movement's attempts to circumvent federalism date to the beginning of the 20th century, so you can hardly cite a 1941 case to defend your assertion. That was four years after FDR's court packing scheme and eight years after the formation of the National Recovery Administration. As far as I can tell, you only see the Tenth Amendment as a tautology because you take for granted the makeup and principles of the American government. It was not at all a given at the time that the Federal government would leave sovereignity to the states and only exercise certain defined powers. For example, it has largely ceased to do so today, in violation of the Tenth Amendment.
- sigkill 14y agoYours is neither the first, nor will be the last comment I hear sharing this common theme, but I strongly feel that EAFP holds truer in the real world that contains people than our world that contains electrons and holes.
- cpursley 14y agoConsidering we're now on track to lose the 2nd Amendment in the USA, the 1th and 4th are considered optional, they might as well just shred the entire document. What's the point of pretending any more?
- short_circut 14y agoPoliticians thrive on control and power. All of this is a way of controlling people.
- rayiner 14y agoJust two years ago the Supreme Court reached back across 200 years of history to expand the 2nd amendment and strike down state legislation that would have been unambiguously Constitutional at the time of the founding. So tell me again how we're in danger of losing the 2nd amendment.
- king_jester 14y agoThe 2nd amendment is not being discarded even with gun control legislation, so this is hyperbole. A right to gun ownership doesn't mean that there cannot be sensible regulation of guns.
- exabrial 14y agoWe already have an assault weapons ban: Civilians cannot own ridiculous calibers of weapons/cannons/explosives, nor can they own automatic weapons (without extensive licensure), and no _new_ automatic weapons can be manufactured and sold to civilians. As a result of these regulations, one or two crimes have been committed with 'real' assault weapons in the last 50 years. Further regulation at this point is unneeded and pointless. What IS needed is stricter background checks, a background check on private sales (this is called 'transferring through an FFL'), and we need the experts to come up with a strategy to help keep ALL weapons (not just guns) out of the hands of the mentally ill. What's being proposed is a general reduction in weapons that 'look like' military assault weapons, which is pointless and will ultimately accomplish nothing (as it has in the past).
- short_circut 14y agoI don't want to sound like a negative nancy, but anyone who as been paying attention since the early 2000's (probably before but that was when I started paying attention) is well aware of this. Historically this shouldn't be surprising aswell as all great "empires" have begun their decline in similar ways. I can't say for sure that it will keep moving in that direction but it wouldn't surprise me. Some United Stations (americans for all those of you who forget the rest of the Americas) will eventually rebel against this. Then who knows whatwould happen. BUt then again they might not. Maybe Huxley was right!
- acuozzo 14y ago> BUt then again they might not. This seems more likely to me, considering that most Americans (of which I am one) I know* prefer getting lost in the latest iGadget to dealing with real life. (* I am __not__ asserting that this is necessarily true of all Americans, but for those with whom I interact, at least, it is.)
- pixl97 14y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bread_and_circuses http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bread_and_circuses
- betterunix 14y agoEarly 2000s? We have been chipping away at the bill of rights for decades. Things may seem extreme in this decade, but CALEA was passed in the early 90s, paramilitary police forces became common in the 1980s (with budgets that need not be approved by Congress every two years; in fact, some of these forces pay themselves with the proceeds from arrests, via a law passed by Congress), and the executive branch gained the power to declare drugs to be illegal without democratic process in the 1970s. In the early 1960s, the Kennedy administration was sending soldiers to Vietnam without a declaration of war by Congress. What happened in the early 2000s would not have been possible with the decades of build-up. Without a standing army, without so much executive power, without such a vast and powerful law enforcement system, and without the already-established systems of domestic and global surveillance, it would have been much harder to see the provisions of the PATRIOT act or NDAA actually go through. One of the few limits on government power that has any meaning in this day and age is the prohibition on granting titles of nobility. I suppose that is a good thing.
- pbateman 14y agoWell of course. Defending due process is a hard sell politically, beating up on an unpopular boogeyman to "keep america safe" isn't.
- berntb 14y agoIt seems democracies with terrorism problems tend to throw out the law book and human rights. Examples are afaik US, Germany, Italy, Israel, GB, Spain, etc. Doing everything possible (and illegal) to stop terrorism is a logical result of two facts: 1. Politicians want to be reelected, so they want to keep the voters relatively happy. 2. The whole point of terrorism is to scare civilians in democracies -- that makes them distinctly unhappy. (Disclaimer: I have no political science background, this is my own conclusion from everything I've read on the subject. If this cynical view is wrong, I'd love to see references.)
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- jasonkolb 14y agoAlso, Rome. They had a history of appointing dictators periodically in times of national crisis.
- a-priori 14y agoTechnically true, but I think that's misleading. The office of dictator in the Roman Republic wasn't something extraordinary. There were at least 76 appointments over the ~450 years that the office was used, or about one every 6 years on average. The term was time-limited, and for a specific purpose. During their term, they would have imperium (basically, the power to command any army and issue any law), but at the end of the term or when the cause was dealt with, the dictator would step down and the normal processes would resume. Yes, dictators were appointed during times of war and sedition. But also for mundane reasons, such as to coordinate elections and run games.
- kh_hk 14y agoSome people say one of the differences between some modern democracies and a dictatorship is that on the latter, you know where your limits of freedom are. You are not acting on behalf of the government? Guess what: terrorism. I would also throw the "media" word on your country list. For having a successful terrorist threat, you need control over media and free speech, and laws that allow that control.
- mchusma 14y agoI care about this issue a lot, but I don't see why this should be on Hacker News. I like HN because it provides a very different set of news items than other sites, with particular focuses on startups, technology, and science. I get the argument that "this affects everyone, including startups", but if too much of this hits the homepage than we will loose access to the stories that set HN apart.
- wmeredith 14y agoGo to the new page, upvote stories you think should be on HN.
- sneak 14y agoYou are optimizing prematurely.
- achille 14y agoI agree, and the solution is simple: upvote all other stories that fit your desired HN content and leave this story unvoted. There was a paper a while back that explained how with the current algorithms, upvoting neighboring stories has largely the same effect as downvoting.
- aristidb 14y agoCivil liberties is another topic that HN cares about.
- betterunix 14y agoWell, right now, this is the only political story I see on the front page. The rest are about startups, technology, the goings-on of well-known websites, etc.
- DanBC 14y agoI agree. Flag the not-fitting stories (if you have flag privileges); upvote the good stories; submit great articles. http://ycombinator.com/newswelcome.html http://ycombinator.com/newswelcome.html http://ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html http://ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html http://ycombinator.com/newsfaq.html http://ycombinator.com/newsfaq.html
- dkhenry 14y agoWhen we as a nation are willfully abandoning the 1st why should we care that congress is abandoning the 5th ?
- crusso 14y agoActually, the Freedom of the Press part of the first is the only thing that has been sacrosanct in the Bill of Rights. Really, we've abandoned the 9th and 10th almost completely. The 4th has been under assault for ages. The 2nd is being paired back even more with the New Town tragedy. One day, when most of the amendments have no real weight in our society, then the Freedom of the Press will be extinguished as well. Americans have let the Federal Government divide us and work themselves into the cracks between us. Lately, the divide has been between the "rich" and the "poor"... voters really lapped that one up. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First_they_came.. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First_they_came...
- dkhenry 14y agoIts not just the press. We have systematically abandoned almost every clause of the first amendment.
- alan_cx 14y agoGranted Im not an American, and I dont know the details, but as I read this, Americans are some how different to non-Americans. Is that correct? It reads like Americans get special protection that non Americans cant get in the hands of US law? Seems some what odd to me that all this is about Americans being held indefinitely with out trial, but for foreigners, do what you like. Aren't humans equal to Americans or US law? Seems to me that this stealthy legislation simply makes all human beings equal in US law, or at least closes the gap. How is that wrong? It just means Americans will also suffer at the hands of the US government, like non Americans do. Fair enough, no? I note there is no concern to afford non-Americans the same protections Americans get. Besides, from abroad, it very much looks like Americans are more concerned about keeping hold of hard core military weapons in their homes to be used against the odd burglar, than freedom, health, etc. Like I say, Im not an American and I really don't know the subtleties, but it all seems a bit skewed to me.
- carbocation 14y agoThis seems like a caricature so I'm hesitant to respond in the length that this would otherwise merit. (Not saying that you know everything you claim to be ignorant on, but rather that you are caricaturing the American people which makes it difficult to know where your knowledge ends and your ignorance begins.) It also has the kind of political overtones that I'd love to discuss elsewhere, just not on HN.
- candybar 14y agoThis is a weird tangent - is this not true where you're from? Every single country treats its citizens differently than non-citizens.
- regularfry 14y agoThat's what this bit was about: Civil liberties groups "aren't shedding any tears over the demise of the Feinstein-Lee amendment," because they objected to the fact that it protected only U.S. citizens and permanent residents, rather than all persons present in the United States.
- Jun8 14y ago
- DamnYuppie 14y agoI stoutly maintain that we need to strongly enforce term limits on all politicians and have tighter regulation and control as to how they are funded. If you tackle these two problems you will get better government, and less special interest which are the two things crippling us at the moment.
- davidw 14y agoLots of glib one-liners demonstrate exactly why articles like this are not germane to this site and should be flagged and removed. HN is not for politics.
- patmcguire 14y agoI wish there were an organization as effective at defending the other 9 amendments in the bill of rights as the NRA is at defending the 2nd.
- liber8 14y agoThe reason the NRA has been so effective is because they understand the old truism "give them an inch and they'll take a mile." When anybody brings up otherwise reasonable limits (no heavy weaponry, no automatic assault weapons for civilians) the NRA immediately responds with by shouting "fuck you" through a bullhorn on the Capitol steps. They commit to spending serious money opposing even these "reasonable" limits, and they don't mind being despised by half the country for doing so. By refusing to cede on even the seemingly obvious issues, they make it politically impossible for opponents to slowly take away the rights they actually care about. The problem is that very few organizations are willing to take this hard line the NRA has adopted for 75 years now. Look at the smoking industry as an example: first you couldn't smoke on planes. (Alright, that seems reasonable, we don't want fires on airplanes.) Then it was hospitals. (Ok, also reasonable, there's sick people there.) Then it was workplaces. (Well, you should have a right to work without someone blowing smoke in your face.) Then it was restaurants. (Ehh..) Then it was bars. (Wait...) Then it was the outside areas of restaurants and bars. (Huh?) Then it was beaches and other outdoor gathering areas. (Well, hold on....) Now entire cities have banned outdoor smoking. Literally the only place you can smoke is in your home (assuming you don't employ anybody). This is exactly how rights are systematically chipped away. Even the organizations that are willing to take stands and be despised often get sidetracked. Look at the ACLU. In the last 20 years, they’ve more often represented high-profile criminals in low-value cases (constitutionally speaking) than taken on serious civil liberty issues like the PATRIOT act, drone strikes, state-ordered killings of US Citizens, etc., etc.. This problem only gets worse when “their guy” is in office. People often deride “insane” organizations like the NRA, but unfortunately, most of the time “insane” is what’s necessary to combat the usurpation of rights that appears “prudent” at any given moment in time.
- johnny22 14y agorestaurants and bars are workplaces.. that was the rationale in most places. no need to separate them.
- exabrial 14y agoThey're also abandoning the 2nd Amendment... Which is perhaps the most important one, since it gives you the right to defend your other amendments.
- suprgeek 14y agoTechnically the fifth amendment was abandoned the Minute the US began imprisoning/killing people without trials. the drone wars are a great example of this. The fifth amendment uses the word "PERSON" not citizen. So in some sense this is just a continuation of the same - what is applicable to a "military age male" in Afghanistan is now applicable to a American Joe Q Public. This is an excellent wake-up call - do not gut American values to (notionally) protect the American People.
- rayiner 14y agoNobody thinks the framers intended the 5th amendment to cover military age males in Afghanistan. That's just ridiculous.
- gknoy 14y agoWhen I read the text of the amendment, I think that they very much would have considered it to cover everyone. "No person shall be held to answer for a capital, or otherwise infamous crime, unless on a presentment or indictment of a Grand Jury, except in cases arising in the land or naval forces, or in the Militia, when in actual service in time of War or public danger;" Our declaration of independence says that "We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal" -- ALL men. Not just American men. I think those two, taken together, imply that the founders would have meant for the 5th amendment to cover American men, Englishmen, Frenchmen, and natives of foreign lands which they had not heard of yet.
- cynicalkane 14y agoPeople do this thing where they say the Constitution plainly says X and then quote it where it says Y. What do you think the clause except in cases arising in the land or naval forces means?
- georgemcbay 14y agoIf you want to be completely literal and pedantic about it, drones are neither land nor naval forces.
- grego 14y agoPrisoners in the US serving lifetime without parole: 41000, prisoners in the UK serving lifetime without parole: 41 When imprisoning people so easily is the new normal, it is no wonder the public is not so alert about new laws.
- arjn 14y agoDid you take into account the population difference between the two countries ?
- GFischer 14y agoPopulation of the United Kingdom: 61 million Population of the United States: 315 million He's saying there's a thousand times as many lifetime inmates, but only 5 times the population. It's still a huge number.
- Aloisius 14y agoFor people who haven't read the 5th amendment in a while: No person shall be held to answer for a capital, or otherwise infamous crime, unless on a presentment or indictment of a Grand Jury, except in cases arising in the land or naval forces, or in the Militia, when in actual service in time of War or public danger; nor shall any person be subject for the same offense to be twice put in jeopardy of life or limb; nor shall be compelled in any criminal case to be a witness against himself, nor be deprived of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law; nor shall private property be taken for public use, without just compensation.
- rprasad 14y agoThis would apply to Guantanamo but not to the drone strikes. The difference is that we are alleging crimes against the Guantannamo detainees, but not against drone targets. The drone targets are regarded as military targets, so the international conventions on warfare and the treatment of POWs applies.
- rayiner 14y agoThe Constitutional fuss about Guantanamo was because: 1) one of the first detainees that filed suit was actually an American; 2) it was arguably U.S. soil. The Constitutional issues with Guantanamo were resolved: the Court said that Americans clearly had habeas rights and that by virtue of being U.S. soil, non-Americans in Guantanamo also had certain rights. As a result, all the U.S. citizens were quickly transferred to the civilian court system, and the courts started hearing habeas petitions from other detainees. The drone strikes are not on U.S. soil, and only in one case do they involve a U.S. citizen (Al Awlaki). The Constitution is therefore inapplicable. Now, the strikes may be a violation of international conventions on war, but they're not a violation of the Constitution.
- danenania 14y agoIn a constitutional sense, how could drone victims possibly be military targets when the US has not declared war? You're trying to play by the rules that suit you and ignore the ones that don't.
- salimmadjd 14y agoCan some help me understand why this organization has been lobbying for NDAA in the last few years? http://firststreetresearch.cqpress.com/2012/03/08/aipac-still-commands-attention-among-movers-and-shakers/ http://firststreetresearch.cqpress.com/2012/03/08/aipac-stil... How are they benefiting from this?
- imran 14y agoThere is increase in poverty for the poor AND increase in wealth for the rich. Now the rich people can get away from any suspicion but the poor can't. New laws like NDAA makes it worse for the common american people. Only american people themselves can solve this by atleast getting aware and fighting for their rights!
- aneth4 14y agoThe amendment should have been dropped. More importantly than what it disallowed, it allows Congress to authorize indefinite detention - "unless an Act of Congress expressly authorizes such detention." A bill that authorizes Congress to do something unconstitutional is both unconstitutional and sets a very bad precedent. Congress quite clearly can not authorize such detention. "An authorization to use military force, a declaration of war, or any similar authority shall not authorize the detention without charge or trial of a citizen or lawful permanent resident of the United States apprehended in the United States, unless an Act of Congress expressly authorizes such detention."
- thoughtcriminal 14y agoGet your digs in now people, raise your voices, because once this thing passes, you might... disappear.
- tsewlliw 14y agoWow, this is truly absurd. Just the other day an article at theatlantic.com was posted here (http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4935679 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4935679) and it was advocating exactly this kind of constitutional circumvention behavior. I think this is the business model devaluing the product. "the Atlantic" both in name and typography wants to evoke a newspaper, but the internet broke the model that allowed newspapers to do real journalism.
- hsitz 14y agoSpeaking as a lawyer, I would say that upwards of 99% of the comments in this thread are full of crap; people confidently throwing around opinions or even supposed-knowledge without any real knowledge of constitutional law. The disheartening thing is, I know HN participants tend to be more intelligent than the average person. It makes me marvel at how our nation functions at all.
- lhnn 14y agoCare to type up a paragraph of the most egregious misunderstandings? BTW broadly speaking, I agree. I see smart people saying really frightening things, then think about all the not-smart people.
- hsitz 14y agoYes, and I used 'smart' but what I actually meant is 'well-informed'. Doesn't even matter if they're smart, but a well-informed person should have a basic grasp of how constitutional law works. Some basic problems in this thread: 1. The U.S. Constitution does not exist in a vacuum. You can't just read it and make a pronouncement on what it means. It has been applied and interpreted by the courts for over two hundred years, and case law, especially Supreme Court cases, are necessary parts of understanding the Constitution. I'd have to look again, but I don't think there's a single comment in this thread where case law is used to provide authority/support for someone's assertions. In other words, people are just spouting off with irrelevant crap. (All of this is true regardless of what Scalia or anyone else says about "plain meaning"; their plain meaning is often not plain to others (need to look at cases), and/or they pick and choose what they think is plain and what's not). 2. It may seem counterintuitive, but there is no such thing as an "absolute" right. At least not in any human legal system. Rights sometimes conflict with other rights (in which case at least one needs to be limited), rights are (and always have been) limited when they conflict with what courts determine to be a "compelling" government interest (need to read case law and reason by legal analogy to understand if any particular situation may rise to level of "compelling" interest), and they can be limited in less restrictive ways when the government's interest does not rise to the level of being "compelling". In other cases we may speak of a right as being absolute, e.g., right against "cruel and unusual punishment", but it should be obvious to anyone in U.S. over last ten years that that right depends on how courts interpret "cruel and unusual", i.e, it's flexible. Those, I think, are two main things. But, really, without my even saying those it should be clear to anyone reading this thread that it's conducted at the level of two (earnest but uninformed and perhaps inebriated) college freshman debating late at night in their dorm room. 3. Another smaller thing. In some cases people in this thread have tried to interpet the language of the Constitution. Many of these attempts at interpretation are laughably bad, don't involve careful reading. If people coded with such little attention to detail programs would be crashing right and left. (Of course, the text of the Constitution is not program code, like any laws laid out in human language they're subject to interpretation, often misinterpretation.)