4 ms·
You know what's worse than patent trolls gaming the system? It's all of those people in the world who say, "Yeah, IV is smart. They've found a loophole and are
by javajosh 14y ago
You know what's worse than patent trolls gaming the system? It's all of those people in the world who say, "Yeah, IV is smart. They've found a loophole and are exploiting it. Nothing to be done."
Wrong. Who runs this place? You and me. And if enough of us want to change the law to put IV and it's clones out of business, we can do it. This place is our home, our nation, and we get to decide what's allowed here. Our biggest challenge is not IV, but all of those people in the world who give IV and people like them a nod, a kind of respect, an admiring acknowledgement that they've abused the system and gotten away with it. It's the same respect given to influential bankers in Wall St and London, it was the same respect given to Bush, the same respect given to wealthy men accused of rape and murder who never serve time. Any and every action taken against these entities seems to either melt away entirely or result in a slap on the wrist. Meanwhile people who hack celebrity emails get 10 years hard time. People making $20k a year get audited and go to prison.
It is not okay. There is nothing to admire, and patent trolls are merely smug abusers of our society. Organizations that follow the letter of the law but ignore the principles behind them should inspire our strongest contempt. Their existence's only positive value is as a clarion call to vigorous action by our legislators to amend the law to close the gap between the letter and spirit. The longer we wait, the less legitimacy the rule of law has.
Our elected officials, the people we keep voting into office cycle after cycle, are far more interested in playing their political games. They do have some time leftover to actually govern. But governing takes common sense, and whatever they have is shattered by lobbyists who's only job is to undermine common-sense with smooth-sounding arguments - or, if that doesn't work, threats of withdrawing campaign support. Our leaders are dazzled by arguments of complexity when the heart of the problem is genuinely, truly simple:
Introduce and pass a bill to eliminate software patents, retroactively, and do it now.
- lifeisstillgood 14y agoI was reading an interview with Charlie Munger yesterday who was talking about why they gave Salmon Bros CEO the push in 1991 (he did not fire a trader who had been fraudulently trading). Munger said it was the same as when you find a little old lady with her hands in the till and she says it was the first time - you have to prosecute be aide if you don't it infects the whole system as corrupt The USA has been amazingly lucky in eventually prosecuting its corruption (boss tweed, al Capone) but it feels that it is slipping. Keep pushing
- w_t_payne 14y agoActually, the USA has an abysmal and depressing culture of corruption and venality. The casual attitude to petty (and not-so-petty) corruption in the USA is endemic, and extremely damaging. The media have a role to play in combating this, as does the general public.
- nathanhammond 14y agoAs a point of agreement, the US DOJ's current interaction with HSBC for laundering drug money, as documented by Rolling Stone: http://www.rollingstone.com/politics/blogs/taibblog/outrageous-hsbc-settlement-proves-the-drug-war-is-a-joke-20121213 http://www.rollingstone.com/politics/blogs/taibblog/outrageo...
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- 1337biz 14y agoI am not quite sure if things are really that bad for the US as you describe. You are absolutely right on most points, but I think that the US is in general more tolerant towards people operating in gray areas or gaming the system. I also would argue that this is the basis for many disruptive innovations and startups like Uber or Airbnb would have had a hard time growing up in stronger regulated environments. Of cause this doesn't change the fact that patent trolls are a menace to innovation.
- narag 14y agoA difference: IV works because there is a disfunctional regulation in place, while the others work despite the regulations.
- law 14y ago> Organizations that follow the letter of the law but ignore the principles behind them should inspire our strongest contempt. And who establishes these principles? To suggest that an organization must additionally follow some ambiguous set of principles putatively inspiring an established law is the pinnacle of arrogance. How can a country function if its members (citizens and organizations alike) cannot look to the letter of the law to decide whether their conduct conforms therewith? If you don't like the fact that some companies are legally engaging in contemptuous behavior, then change the law. That's the whole point of Congress--to legislate. Suggesting that laws additionally be subject to motivating principles comports with judicial supremacy, which is to say it's the courts (rather than our elected officials) who decide what the law is. That's not how this country is supposed to work.
- morsch 14y agoHe's not saying they must conform with these ambiguous rules. But if they don't, it's fair to be contemptuous of them. There is nothing at all unusual about this, there are lots of actions that won't get you in jail but will get you punished in various social manners. Social pressure can later be codified into a legal solution, but in some cases the rules are necessarily ambiguous and resist codification, in which case social pressure is the next best thing.
- law 14y ago> He's not saying they must conform with these ambiguous rules. But if they don't, it's fair to be contemptuous of them. There is nothing at all unusual about this, there are lots of actions that won't get you in jail but will get you punished in various social manners. I disagree, though. They're following the law as written, which the vast majority of people and organizations do daily. The distinction is that by doing so, they've found a "bug" in the system, and that's something that deserves admiration rather than contempt. Here's the analogy: someone spots a bug in a program, and they're exploiting that bug in a way that's harming other users. Who deserves those users contempt more: (1) the hacker who found & exploits the bug; or (2) or the quiescent software developer who fails to timely patch that bug? I think it's (2), which is why I'm reluctant to socially punish NPEs. They're publicizing flaws in patent legislation to the detriment to many innocents. Consider this akin to "crowdsourcing" Congress, subject to a cost function (namely, the magnitude of harm suffered by the innocents). It's Congress' continued inaction that deserves the magnitude of our contempt; socially vilifying the 'hacker' is just a band-aid solution.
- arbuge 14y agoThis post says it. "Introduce and pass a bill to eliminate software patents, retroactively, and do it now." --- agreed, 100% Even more frustrating than the current situation is the fact that it's likely to continue for the forseeable future unless we do something about patent trolls. As hinted at in the original article, the legislation in progress now is pretty much useless and not going to make much difference at all as far as trolling is concerned. Far more powerful stuff is needed. Aside: it's mentioned in that article that if IV personally filed all its suits, the courts would likely consider it a vexatious litigant. If so, shouldn't the cheap gimmick of using shell companies to get around this be seen through and ruled ineffective by the courts?
- monochromatic 14y agoYou lose credibility when you compare president Bush to rapists and murderers. A lot of people don't like him, I get that... but you sound like an ideologue.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- javajosh 14y agoThen ignore that part. But I stand by it: in my opinion George W. Bush, and the total lack of response to his gross misdeeds, did more damage to America and the American spirit than any single event in US history. We are still paying for our unwillingness to censure or impeach a President who abused his power like Bush did. He misled us into a bloody, expensive, unnecessary war (Iraq), legalized torture, legalized indefinite imprisonment without trial (Gitmo), outed a CIA operative to punish a political enemy, got an old pal to take the heat for it, then commuted the pal's sentence when he was convicted (Scooter Libby), implemented a warrantless wiretapping program at the NSA, he praised the grossly incompetent head of FEMA (who's inaction cost lives) during Katrina. That's just off the top of my head. These aren't accusations, or 'fanciful theories' (the defining characteristic of an ideologue - I looked it up), they are just things that Bush did, which he did openly and which are a matter of public record. Bush set the example that many leaders both public and private are still following to this day. I credit Bush with one thing though: I never identified strongly as an American before his presidency. Before Bush I never really stopped to think what being American meant, I just took it for granted, and it only made sense to me when, one by one, the tenets that had been so strongly ingrained in me, beliefs that I didn't even know were there, were taken away. Americans don't torture people. We don't initiate wars (well, we do, but not on my watch). We don't imprison people indefinitely without trial. We don't invade people's privacy without a warrant. We don't degrade and demean our citizens for security theater. And we don't let people who produce nothing but paperwork extort money from those who create real wealth.
- sillysaurus 14y agoCareful. Righteousness has a way of turning on itself. You should ask yourself what exactly you want to accomplish here, because nothing will be accomplished here. So if that's true, then ask yourself, "Why am I spending time making these posts?" If you examine your reasoning, you'll be forced to conclude that you spend your time on this because it makes you feel good, and for no other tangible reason. So, if that's true, then a better question to focus on is "Why do we choose to be ineffective?"
- IheartApplesDix 14y agoThat's not going to happen until all the largest software companies have shored up their infrastructure to the point that they can start ripping off inventors easily by having served them the resources needed to get off the ground and control the internet portals required to do business (by law, because you know fraud and terrorism). That's when software patents will be eliminated and not a minute sooner.