3 ms·
All of this is truly bizarre, I hope that we can make sense of this craze in the future. Maybe it will be seen similarly to the dancing crazes of the Middle Ag
by gherkinnn 3mo ago
All of this is truly bizarre, I hope that we can make sense of this craze in the future.
Maybe it will be seen similarly to the dancing crazes of the Middle Ages.
- glhaynes 3mo agoOr maybe it's not just a craze and we'll soon look back and think "I wonder what we might've done differently if we'd been clear-eyed about what was happening."
- matherial 3mo agoShow me a person who truly revised their priors to put forward a novel solution to AI that isn't just "do the thing that I like and that benefits me in some way". The discourse around all this is a mix of quasi-religious beliefs (pro and con) and blatant opportunism. For Dario and Sam, the solution is "give us a monopoly on this tech". For Gates, it's "create an supranational organization with unprecedented taxation and regulatory powers" - world AI police, presumably staffed by technocrats like him. What's your take? Do the ideas put forward by Gates strike you as worth pursuing? What are the trade-offs - how can they go wrong?
- ryeights 3mo agohttps://www.pacingthefrontier.com/ https://www.pacingthefrontier.com/ https://ai-2040.com https://ai-2040.com Can you describe a method of slowing frontier AI development that you yourself would not classify as monopoly-seeking by US AI companies or power-seeking by governments and technocrats? Limiting the development of powerful AI requires restricting free enterprise in some way, backed by the threat of force; hence, there will always be a cynical framing available.
- pona-a 3mo agoIn the case of the US AI industry, how about some stricter banking laws to forbid its current circular financing?
- harimau777 3mo agoMany people would be fine with restricting free enterprise. It hasn't exactly given us great quality of life, at least in America.
- dgellow 3mo ago> Do the ideas put forward by Gates strike you as worth pursuing? What are the trade-offs - how can they go wrong? I agree. However, why aren’t we applying the same standard to AI technologies themselves? That doesn’t strike me as worth pursuing, the article discusses all the ways that is and will go wrong
- outworlder 3mo agoUnless there's another significant breakthrough, LLMs will only get incremental improvements.
- reasonableklout 3mo agoDo they need more than incremental breakthroughs to transform society?
- dgellow 3mo agoThey don’t even need breakthroughs, it’s already damaging to societies
- ChaitanyaSai 3mo agoI could google this, but what are these dancing crazes?
- dgellow 3mo agoI think it will be seen similar to the crypto craze to be honest. People on this very site, with an actual reputation, were telling us non stop how we were losers who were going to be left behind and stay poor. They never had to apologize for being obnoxious when that didn’t happen
- azan_ 3mo agoComparing AI to crypto makes zero sense. We get tremendous use from AI right now, while 2 decades after invention of crypto there are still basically zero legitimate use cases. I repeat - the utility of AI is not some hypothetical but something that happens right now at very large scale (so please don't reply with something in line "well, crypto was supposed to have lots of uses also").
- dgellow 3mo agoThat’s irrelevant… I’m talking about the craze, not the technology
- azan_ 3mo agoBut that doesn't make sense. How can you evaluate if craze is warranted without evaluating underlying technology?
- dgellow 3mo agoI’m very familiar with both technologies, but it’s not what my comment was about. The crypto craze would have been the same if we would have ended with some actual use cases for cryptocurrencies. The level of frenzy was completely out of proportion, very aggressive, with that same attitude of „we will impose something on you, change the world, you will be left behind and stay poor forever for having not been a believer“
- azan_ 3mo agoThe thing is - with AI the position that everything will change is reasonable, with crypto not.
- atleastoptimal 3mo agoYou really think that legitimate concern about AI is equivalent to mass hysteria? Do you think AI will just stop getting better?