5 ms·
Nice of them to invalidate them - now - after they already passed them and Apple already used them in lawsuits - and won with them. But better late than never,
by mtgx 14y ago
Nice of them to invalidate them - now - after they already passed them and Apple already used them in lawsuits - and won with them. But better late than never, I guess.
- fusiongyro 14y agoI'm hoping it's a sign of change within the Patent Office. If this becomes a regular occurrence I'll be extremely happy.
- michaelhoffman 14y agoThis isn't something that was initiated within the patent office. An external attorney filed a reexamination request, paid for it (thousands in fees), and included literally hundreds of pages of explanation as to why the patent should be struck down, with references to hundreds of pages of prior art. From that, it is much easier for an examiner to determine whether the patent should be struck down. This is not something that a patent examiner has the tools, training, and, most importantly, time to do on initial application. So I wouldn't expect any changes from the patent office itself.
- jpdoctor 14y ago> This is not something that a patent examiner has the tools, training, and, most importantly, time to do on initial application. ... which then begs the question: If the USPTO cannot do adequate research for granting a valid patent, then why are they granting patents?
- belriosity 14y agoThey have a mandate to grant patents. They have a certain budget to fulfill that mandate. I imagine (although I don't know) that they do the best they can to grant valid patents within those constraints.
- fauigerzigerk 14y agoI don't think the patent office is under any obligation to grant any particular patent. If they are unable to properly process a patent application, the consequence should be a decade long backlog that forces lawmakers to make a more sensible law, not a mountain of bogus patents that are worse than useless.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- rossjudson 14y agoThose fees, at least, should be charged back to the filer of the original patent, who should have supplied the necessary references in their initial patent application. Which they don't want to do, of course.
- rhizome 14y agoCompanies should be securing clawbacks in patent settlements upon invalidation.
- stock_toaster 14y agoDoes it work like that? If you were bootlegging during prohibition, and convicted, would your conviction be repealed afterwards? It was technically illegal at the time. Maybe someone with more knowledge of law on here knows if this is the case with patent law or not.
- michaelhoffman 14y agorhizome appears to be talking about people negotiating settlement agreements where the payments are clawed back when a patent is later found invalid. This would take agreement on both sides before the settlement, and I doubt patent holders would go for it. Worth a try though.
- stock_toaster 14y agoAha. That makes more sense. Thanks.
- takluyver 14y agoIn your analogy, the activity was illegal until the law was changed. If a patent is declared invalid, then it shouldn't have been valid when it was used in prosecution, so it's logical for the defendant to ask for some kind of redress. Whether the law actually works like that, I don't know.
- brown9-2 14y agoSeems to me like it would be hard to get the side who would lose in the clawback to agree to do that when they had the upper hand when the settlement was made.