14 ms·
Mark Zuckerberg donates $500 million
- mochizuki 14y agoI don't entirely understand why he donated shares of Facebook instead of dollars, can they sell the shares all at once and use the money or is there a catch to that? Did it cost him less money to donate shares in the long run? It's probably my lack of understanding of stocks and economics but it seems like it would be easier for everyone to just donate money.
- philipn 14y agoCommunity Foundations[1] such as the Silicon Valley Community Foundation can receive stock donations that are tax-deductible to the owner. If the donation was in dollars it would also be deductible for the owner, but the owner would need to sell the stock first, which would mean paying capital gains taxes. 1. Differences between Community Foundations / donor-advised funds and Private Foundations can be found here: http://www.programforgiving.org/charitable/pages/consideringDonorAdvisedFund.jsp http://www.programforgiving.org/charitable/pages/considering...
- Eliezer 14y agoFoundations can get tax-deductible gifts, they just have slightly different other rules.
- philipn 14y agoYou're right - updated comment
- law 14y agoAdditionally, if the entities receiving the shares happen to be C corporations (which I believe can have 501(c)(3) status), they can deduct the lesser of: (i) 70% of dividends received on the stock; or (ii) 70% of the corporation's taxable income. As such, the implied tax rate on any dividends received from the shares would only be 11.88% (30% * 39.6%), assuming the corporation is in the 35% ordinary income bracket. This is important for 501(c)(3)'s, too, because there are plenty of exceptions to the general notion of "tax exemption" associated with that code section (See, e.g., 26 USC §§ 507-09, 511-15, and 527). EDIT: of course, this only applies if the company issues a dividend
- brianpan 14y agoI'm not sure if the organization has the option to keep or sell the stock (I think they can do either). For the donor, there are tax benefits- besides the usual lowering of adjusted gross income, you don't have to pay capital gains on stock you donate. Let's say Mark plans on donating $500M to an organization and this month he also wants to buy $300M of Christmas presents. He only has about $600M lying around, but he has a lot of FB stock. He can donate $500M cash, then sell stock to have enough money to buy the presents but he'll pay capital gains. Or he can donate the stock, avoid taxes, and use his cash for the presents instead.
- wilfra 14y agoStock can be used as collateral to get a bank loan (the uber rich use this to avoid capital gains taxes). I would imagine that is what they'll do to generate cash for disbursements from the foundation (they have to pay out at least 5% per year). I would be shocked to find they sold the shares. I'm sure them keeping them for a long period of time (possibly forever) and Zuck retaining voting power over them was a key part of this transaction.
- epaga 14y agoI'm getting a bit miffed at the comments talking about this being a "PR move" or helpful for a "tax break". Did I read this wrong or did it not say 500. MILLION. dollars? The cynicism must be pretty darn strong to try and explain that away by anything other than Zuck wanting to do some good with his shares and money. We should be applauding it, not over-analyzing it for how it benefits him.
- crististm 14y agoWhy would such moves be automatically altruistic?
- Swizec 14y agoWhy would it matter if they're altruistic or not? It's a move, it's going to help. Who the fuck cares why? The saying goes "Don't look a gift horse in the mouth"
- dexcs 14y ago"shares worth $500 million" They are it worth today. Who knows what they are worth in a year :-)
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- bksenior 14y agoHe gets a bad wrap, but as far as a role model for continued commitment to self betterment and helping other within a positon of power he has done an incredible job.
- cdooh 14y agoWhether it's a PR stunt or not, if the money is used well it'll do a lot of good
- NatW 14y agomillionaires and billionaires who donate their wealth to philanthropic causes deserve to be upvoted and recognized.
- aw3c2 14y agoI would always prefer the wealth coming from inside the system, not being first taken by individuals and then spread at their whim. Such wealth would much rather be a sustainable source. A well functioning society/government would know exactly how to spend it well. In many cases, to me, the good the rich do does not nearly weigh in for their wrongdoings.
- natrius 14y agoYour comment has been downvoted, but there isn't yet an explanation of why it is incorrect. I'll provide my perspective. 1) Zuckerberg didn't "take" wealth. He created it. 2) Governments don't have particular insight into the best ways to spend resources. We spent a couple of decades comparing market economies with command economies, and market economies won.
- rms 14y agoI'm curious for someone to explain the choice of charity. It looks like Silicon Valley Community Foundation is an organization that specializes in helping people and companies set up large spendings of charitable donations. Does anyone else do that on this scale? It seems the alternative is spending a fair amount of mental overhead to set up a charitable foundation or donating to an existing foundation institutionally equipped to spend that much money as a non-profit (the Gates Foundation).
- philipn 14y agoSilicon Valley Community Foundation is a Community Foundation (in contrast to a Private Foundation), which means that they manage lots of different pools of money from different sources. It also means that donations to them are tax-deductible in the exact same way it is with other charities[1]. I'm not familar with the specifics of the Silicon Valley Community Foundation, but it looks like SV Community Foundation, similar to most Community Foundations, does a lot of work managing what are known as donor-advised funds. Check out this Wikipedia page for some good info: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Donor_advised_fund http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Donor_advised_fund 1. Private Foundations have a few different rules in place, including lower maximum deductibility for donors, required 5% funds disbursement to charitable organizations, etc. Check out this link for a comparison http://www.programforgiving.org/charitable/pages/consideringDonorAdvisedFund.jsp http://www.programforgiving.org/charitable/pages/considering...
- chalst 14y agoIt's not a normal charitable foundation, but it's more like a fund that donors house their donations, and that then act as a sort of clearing house to match up these donations with grant applicants, where the donor keep a directorial role. The SVCF doesn't seem to have much in the way of limits on the kind of charitable projects they support - from what I can see, the money might go to malaria prevention in the Congo or it might go to funding prestigious professorial chairs. I guess Zuckerberg likes the kind of projects the SVCF has funded in the past and the way the donor-applicant matching works. Recall that Zuckerberg has already pledged half his wealth to charity: http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2010-12-09/seventeen-of-wealthiest-u-s-families-take-buffett-gates-giving-pledge-.html http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2010-12-09/seventeen-of-wealth...
- heymishy 14y agoperhaps im being naive (or biased), but why donate $500m to a SV foundation rather than say use that money to address those in more needier positions? Maybe I'm misinterpreting the 'Giving Pledge' ideals but I believe they were meaning donate to those in need for day to day life - rather than funding a community of a relatively well-off community. I understand the desire to give back to your community but 500 million can make a large dent into some bigger issues. 1st world vs. developing world problems I guess..
- jfaucett 14y agoPeople can say what they want about Zuckerberg, maybe he doesn't have the amazing charisma of Jobs, or the genius of Torvalds, and Facebook gets constantly hammered in the press (and him as well), but this is a great gesture on his part, I applaud him.
- meaty 14y agoWell he deserves the hammering. The guy is clearly immoral and has damaged people's privacy and the world wide web forever. $500mil doesn't suddenly make that ok, especially considering the charity is basically a quango.
- jfoster 14y agoWhy do you think he's immoral? If you equate "enabled people to share more of their lives more broadly" with "damaged people's privacy" then I agree, but I'm not sure even a majority would agree with a sentiment of that necessarily being a bad thing. People share what they feel comfortable with, don't they?
- meaty 14y agoIt's not about what but to whom. To whom is hard to control and is made harder on purpose as after all, their entire model is based on encouraging sharing legitimately or otherwise. Don't underestimate the power of the majority to make a crap decision. That's why we have privacy and data protection laws in the EU: to protect people from predatory information gathering and sharing.
- VMG 14y agoWho's privacy was damaged in a way where the victim didn't voluntarily give it up?
- patd 14y agoGuys like these maybe : http://blogs.sfweekly.com/thesnitch/2012/10/facebook_bobbi_duncan_taylor_mccormick.php http://blogs.sfweekly.com/thesnitch/2012/10/facebook_bobbi_d...
- Syssiphus 14y agoWell, lets wait and see if the money is really going to be used, or if it just lies there.
- z00mer 14y agoI think the title needs the distinction that it's that amount in shares, not in cash. I appreciate it could go up, but the more likely is the opposite.
- saurik 14y agoI'm somewhat confused. If $500 million in shares are donated by Zuckerberg, does that mean a tax write-off of that amount? Also, to verify, the foundation would have to liquidize the shares, right? That kind of instant sell-off would cause massive drops in price... I really hate to ask this (as I honestly don't have anything against Zuckerberg, and really don't feel that "rich people" or "all companies" are evil or anything, as I know some people do), but is this not a massive tax arbitrage? Especially so, given that many people feel that Facebook's stock is overvalued (trading at almost $30 when it "should" trade for less than $10)? Even without any possible benefits to Zuckerberg (which I don't particularly really care about, and which brianpam had an interesting explanation for in his comment elsewhere on this post), doesn't that make this number sound much larger than it would ever really mean to the foundation's bottom line, making this insanely large number somewhat for show? (Seriously: please tell me I'm wrong; I just want to better understand these things.) (Although, thinking more, maybe the "show" is also in the benefit of the foundation, as having a massive donation, the largest in the foundation's history, also looks very good for it, even if the money deflates quite a bit in the process of turning it into cash.) (edit: Someone, in person, points out they could hold onto the stock and sell it off slowly, or keep it for dividends; I don't think this stock has dividends, and maybe it is actually maintaining its value well--my comment was based somewhat on the premise that the various "overvalued" comments from a few months ago would continue into ever-decreasing prices, but in fact the stock went up at some point from its low-point, so maybe that's where I'm wrong?)
- loceng 14y agoI'm curious about if this benefits him (and/or the company) with tax writeoffs. Just want a clear picture to understand.
- ry0ohki 14y agoDonating stock is not that uncommon, the receiver can choose to sell, hold, or some combination. I'm not an accountant but he should be able to write off the taxes for the market value of the stock at the time of the donation? "Many people" may think the stock is overvalued, but the open market is valuing it at it's current price, so that's what it's worth right now.
- 14y ago
- theklub 14y agoThe part we should be talking about is the people who run these "non-profits" who line their pockets with money. Not saying this one does but MANY of them do.
- habosa 14y agoThese comments are so pathetic it kills me. This man just donated half of a billion dollars to a good cause. There is absolutely no way around the fact that a donation of that size is an incredible act of generosity. If he did it to get a tax break or to impress his neighbor it wouldn't change a thing.
- saosebastiao 14y agoGave half a billion dollars? Awesome! To what cause? We have no clue!
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- isabre 14y agoI don't think he cares about the money at all. From the start, Mark was always interested in building a cool product. It's a great gesture on his part.
- VonGuard 14y agoThis is awesome. So happy to see it. It does make me jealous, though, as my non-profit www.themade.org could run for 3 years on a decimal percentage of that donation. Wish it was being spread around more.
- dcaranda 14y agoMany people are asking "why?" Too often we take for granted why we should give to charity, so it's a valid question. Some quotes below on why. "The world is complex, and it can't be entirely fair from a what you contribute to what you get - it's very very uneven." - Ben Horowitz (source: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sqI7fa04atc&t=106m0s http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sqI7fa04atc&t=106m0s see 1:46:00) "I've worked in an economy that rewards someone who saves the lives of others on a battlefield with a medal, rewards a great teacher with thank-you notes from parents, but rewards those who can detect the mispricing of securities with sums reaching into the billions. In short, fate's distribution of long straws is wildly capricious." - Warren Buffet (source: http://givingpledge.org/#warren_buffett http://givingpledge.org/#warren_buffett)
- ChrisNorstrom 14y agoVery nice. It's good to see a lot of rich folks, both young and old (Buffet, Bloomberg, Gates) donating their money. When you're young it's all about accumulating as much money as you can from others in the form of businesses. Then as you get old, you start asking yourself what good all that money is when you're going to rot away in the ground like everyone else. After you win "the game" and enjoy the prize, you might as well disperse it. No use holding onto green paper if it doesn't change the world or make it better. At least Mark, at his young age, will get to see his donation actually used over the next few decades.
- joey_muller 14y agoI'd rather be discussing Ron Conway's decision to put his muscle -- and money -- behind efforts to stop gun violence.
- Tycho 14y agoHe probably did it just to wind up the haters on HN.
- dennisgorelik 14y agoMark Zuckerberg helped society a lot more by building Facebook (and making these billions) than he ever would by giving away his wealth to charitable causes.