4 ms·
I am because Claude has figured out I am a biochemist and therefore even asking Fable what the weather is gets me bumped back to Opus, sometimes even Opus 4.8 i
by colingauvin 2mo ago
I am because Claude has figured out I am a biochemist and therefore even asking Fable what the weather is gets me bumped back to Opus, sometimes even Opus 4.8 instead of 5. Kimi? GLM 5.3? DeepSeek? No such problem.
I can literally open a new chat with just "Hello" and it gets bumped.
- felixgallo 2mo ago[flagged]
- dgellow 2mo agoFable guardrails are insanely restrictive, are you denying that’s the case?
- felixgallo 2mo ago[flagged]
- colingauvin 2mo agoIt has figured it out through the software that I work on, data that I analyze, questions I ask, etc. I guess I can't prove it's because I'm a biochemist, but that's the only thing that makes any sense. Either way it won't let me use Fable.
- kami23 2mo agoYes that is exactly what's happening. Claude keeps track of memory if you've turned that on so all conversations are somehow tracked over time Claude randomly will mention that I'm a developer while I'm asking unrelated questions and say oh because you're a developer you might like this or because of my background and infrastructure you might find this interesting and I always get creeped out by it. They have the concept of incognito chats, but I can see those being worse without context from other conversations happening.
- felixgallo 2mo ago[flagged]
- deleted 2mo ago[deleted]
- alightsoul 2mo agoDario is that you?
- dgellow 2mo agoIm starting to doubt you actually used fable
- MagicMoonlight 2mo ago[dead]
- not_a9 2mo agoMemories break Fable 5 for me as well in chatbot. I ask Opus a lot of sec related stuff and now if I even type “hello” in chat it gets insta-downgraded to Opus 5.
- jaykru 2mo agoWow, that's totally crazy. Does it happen even if you clear out the "offending" memory entries?