5 ms·
Author asks: "I would start by measuring the magnitude of mass shootings as a problem. How does it compare to other issues such as preventable diseases, regula
by mc32 14y ago
Author asks:
"I would start by measuring the magnitude of mass shootings as a problem. How does it compare to other issues such as preventable diseases, regular crime, terrorism?"
But is that the best comparison?
What about comparing it to frequency and impact in other countries?
When we want to evaluate the effectiveness of a treatment, we don't measure efficacy against the treatment to a completely different disease. So here, I think it would be more informative to have comparative study done across countries, societies rather than this distraction.
Author is basically saying, anything that is statistically small, does not deserve attention. So research into any low probability disease should be ended because there bigger fish to fry. I think we can do both.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- Daishiman 14y agoHe's saying that things that have such a low occurrence that they're indistinguishable from statistical outliers are not good targets for generalized public policy, since the benefits are not provable.
- sp332 14y agoI don't understand your question. Mass shootings seem to be more rare in e.g. Europe. But how does that help anything?
- Turing_Machine 14y ago"Mass shootings seem to be more rare in e.g. Europe." History indicates otherwise. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_conflicts_in_Europe http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_conflicts_in_Europe
- sp332 14y agoI can't downvote you, but that's a useless comment and you know it.
- Turing_Machine 14y agoDon't worry. Your cobelievers already did it. I guess I just don't have the "sophisticated" European point of view that says that millions killed by government don't count.
- sp332 14y agoIt's not relevant to the conversation. We're talking about individuals. Edit: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Timeline_of_United_States_military_operations https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Timeline_of_United_States_mili... seems to have a lot more action than the part of your page since the late 18th century, so I think you're wrong either way.
- throwit1979 14y agoIt's absolutely relevant, since the purpose of the Second amendment is largely protection against governments, not critters, varmints, or even criminals.
- sp332 14y agoSo... your argument is that tightening gun control would lead to more wars?
- Turing_Machine 14y agoThe death toll from the European wars is in the millions. In addition to the wars per se, European governments have killed millions of their own citizens, and they've been at it for centuries.
- jbellis 14y ago"If you look at a per capita rate, the rate of multiple-victim public shootings in Europe and the United States over the last 10 years have been fairly similar to each other. A couple of years ago you had a couple of big shootings in Finland. About two-and-a-half years ago you had a big shooting in the U.K., 12 people were killed. "You had Norway last year [where 77 died]. Two years ago, you had the shooting in Austria at a Sikh Temple. There have been several multiple-victim public shootings in France over the last couple of years. Over the last decade, you’ve had a couple of big school shootings in Germany." http://www.newsmax.com/Headline/Lott-guns-Connecticut-shooting/2012/12/15/id/467903#ixzz2FLSccAKl http://www.newsmax.com/Headline/Lott-guns-Connecticut-shooti...
- thezilch 14y agoSort of; the author does go onto say how R&D could help "solve" both mental illness and mass shootings. There is definitely a cap on what can be done, so the suggestion is to bake the cost into issues that are already more statistically large and probably solvable. Theoretically, he does compare to other countries, as the statistic is a rounding error -- not statistically relevant.
- ollysb 14y agoI visited Phoenix a couple of weeks ago and was shown a gun collection owned by a previous member of the army. I was shown a pistol collection, then rifles, then semi-automatics. Really a quite staggering amount of hardware. When I asked what license was required to own this type of equipment he replied none. Without making a judgement on whether or not civilians should be allowed to own this type of equipment in the first place, should it not be an absolute minimum that people first obtain a licence to purchase guns. We don't allow people on the roads without a licence and they're not even designed to kill. A simple first step would seem to be requiring basic equipment/awareness training and a licensing process.
- bdunbar 14y ago> We don't allow people on the roads without a licence I'm not convinced by this argument. Firearms are not used in public spaces, but in private land, or on club-owned property.
- justincormack 14y agoFirearms are never used in public? Ever?
- hga 14y agoBoth Clayton Cramer and the US Government Accountability Office ("Investigative arm of Congress charged with examining matters relating to the receipt and payment of public funds.") this summer estimated there are outstanding around 8 million licenses to carry concealed. I can't speak for others, but I can say that almost every time I walk outside I've carrying a M1911 (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/M1911_pistol http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/M1911_pistol).
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- bdunbar 14y agoThe only occasion I can think of where a private citizen would use a firearm in a public area is a city-owned gun range, or hunting on public land.
- stfu 14y agoAuthor is basically saying, anything that is statistically small, does not deserve attention. No, he is not. He is saying, anything that is statistically small, and the elimination thereof would substantially restrain the rights and freedom of others, should be questioned. No matter how you are going to argue, there is at least "some" purpose for guns - for self protection, etc. If the discussion were really about saving lifes, it makes no sense why not putting a ban on smoking, something that clearly has no purpose at all.
- csense 14y ago> But is that the best comparison? Yes, it is. You have a limited amount of resources -- in this case, tax dollars and political capital. If you're spending dollars or votes to save lives, you should spend them on the thing which saves the most lives per dollar spent. > What about comparing it to frequency and impact in other countries? Another commenter on this article said that this comparison indicates that gun control doesn't really help [1]. To this, I'd add that most countries that have a strong gun control never had the situation of the US: millions of guns already in public circulation; many pro-gun individuals and a powerful political faction; and a very difficult procedure (amending the Constitution) required for changing policy. These obstacles are pretty much insurmountable right now; you'd be well-advised to spend your political capital on an issue where you have a decent chance of winning. [1] http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4934323 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4934323
- mc32 14y agoI think that makes sense. I think what I was reading sounded like "there might be less gun violence over there, but don't look into why, it's not worth your while". My thought was that maybe it is worth our while to look into why. when one decides upon controlling guns, it would be prudent to grandparent people in. New rights revocation would only be applied to the upcoming generations. This way you don't alienate a population from something they hold dear, but would ensure whatever you're enacting becomes effective over time.
- hga 14y agoYou think parents and grandparents care that little about their descendents' future? That they're that selfish? (Do note we apparently have very different worldviews, my side sees widespread gun ownership as a good thing; you don't have to agree with that, just agree that there are 10s of millions like me.) I'm afraid you're wrong, and are proposing just another way to spark the 2nd American Civil War, which I'd rather avoid. (I'm assuming you won't repeal the 2nd Amendment first, since I can't see that happening politically in the foreseeable future.)