4 ms·
The failed drug war... I find it particularly amusing that many of the people I hear calling for the legalization of all drugs on the grounds that banning them
by sliverstorm 14y ago
The failed drug war...
I find it particularly amusing that many of the people I hear calling for the legalization of all drugs on the grounds that banning them doesn't work, are the same people calling for the outlawing of all guns.
- DigitalSea 14y agoNo part of my comment mentioned calling for the legalisation of drugs nor am I calling for the outlawing of guns. Please do not misconstrue my words, and lets not confuse the real issue here. We are talking about people being able to potentially print functional firearms in the comfort of their own home using a 3D printer.
- sliverstorm 14y agoSorry, I did not mean to imply anything about you. Just a passing observation tangential to your comment.
- Daishiman 14y agoExcept that gun control laws can actually be extremely effective, and the same cannot be said for drug prohibition. And, honestly, there is nontrivial difference the ability to consume certain substances and owning instruments made explicitly to kill.
- jessedhillon 14y agoAdditionally, there is a very good argument for being free to take substances which release/alter your voluntary control of self. What are the arguments to own any gun? Imaginary civil war, fantasy home defense, pride of ownership, and practicing marksmanship? For this, we have to suffer the fact that any crazy can buy push-button killing machines, or that any sane owner thereof can subsequently lose his shit and kill the rest of us? There doesn't seem to be much of an upside for the rest of us.
- sliverstorm 14y agoSome folks hunt as a way to put protein on the table.
- jessedhillon 14y agoYep. A long-barreled rifle, of small-ish calibre (.223 maybe) and with a fixed 5-shot magazine should be good enough for them. A determined person can hold up a mini-mart with that, but he'll be much less effective if he tries to go on a spree. Any features you add to such a weapon are, essentially, for the purposes of increasing its lethality to humans.
- sliverstorm 14y agoYou've jumped from "What are the arguments to own any gun" implying 'No guns' to 'Some guns are ok but not others'. Which is actually your belief?
- jessedhillon 14y agoIt's a good point. I actually would advocate no guns, but I could find it acceptable to compromise with hunting rifles only. But still, apart from hunting rifles then, what are the arguments to own any gun?
- sliverstorm 14y agoHunting, recreation, self defense, home defense. Those are the main arguments I know. This generally corresponds to rifles/shotguns, plinking/antique guns, handguns, and shotguns/handguns respectively. It's also sort of in the roots of the country, so you could say it's sort of patriotic to own a gun and train yourself in its use, but that is of course not a cold, practical argument. Note: "Self defense" may have raised eyebrows; in particular, I am referring to people like judges and police officers who handle violent criminals. Typically these people are allowed to carry just about anywhere even off-duty. Note2: In case you aren't actually aware, shotguns are commonly used for hunting, typically for small game and birds. Note3: Skeet shooting is an Olympic sport. :)
- sliverstorm 14y agoAre you talking about gun control or gun banning? I've come to develop the POV that we should focus on ensuring that the gun control laws we already have are made effective. When murderers keep showing up with automatic weaponry (when automatic weaponry is basically outlawed) we should start by figuring out how they are getting automatic weaponry.
- saraid216 14y agoPeople who do "life enhancement" being against murder. How strange.
- jlgreco 14y agoAre they really the same people? Gun ownership isn't something I am interested in, but neither does it frighten me. My drug if choice is already legal in my state.. and federally, but I think drugs should be legal. I don't know.. maybe I just universally underestimate risk, but the targets of these bans or proposed bans all seem motivated by the irrational fear of tragic edge-cases.