4 ms·
These demographic trends are, unfortunately, only temporary. From the point of view of evolution, birth control is a disaster. I have done exactly the activit
by btilly 14y ago
These demographic trends are, unfortunately, only temporary.
From the point of view of evolution, birth control is a disaster. I have done exactly the activity evolution has programmed me to do to continue the species, regularly, for over 20 years. Only twice did it result in children, and both times were conscious choices on my part.
However evolution knows how to face these disasters. There is a small minority of people who have the option of birth control, who have all of the same economic incentives that I do, yet choose to have lots of children. Their children are less likely to want to use birth control than mine. Thanks to exponential growth, that minority that chooses to have children regardless will become a majority. And after that point, voluntary birth control and economic incentives will not suffice to keep the population from growing.
This is literally evolution in action.
- zeteo 14y agoYou said it, brother (sister?). In each country there are subcultures (religious fundamentalists, usually) that have birth rates well above replacement. Secular culture has managed to peel away many of their kids in recent decades but, with the kind of uninspiring, plasticky productions currently streaming out of Hollywood / big label music, that process is about to change. Let's just say, your radio is likely to play a lot more Christian rock in your old age.
- wilfra 14y agoI'd say it's a lot more likely to be playing Mariachi than Christian rock...
- w1ntermute 14y agoYou forget that Hispanics are also quite religious.
- wilfra 14y agoBut do they listen to 'Christian Rock'?
- yummyfajitas 14y agoIt isn't just religious fundamentalists - it's also people with low conscientiousness. They have no moral aversion to birth control, they just don't think too hard about the consequences of unprotected sex (it feels nicer, and condoms are at the drugstore three blocks away). And while Mormon's rapid breeding might prevent demographic malaise, the rapid breeding of low conscientiousness people won't - the very trait that causes them to breed rapidly also causes them to be generally unproductive.
- sridhar_vembu 14y agoI have to call bullshit on this one. Most of us here, supposedly "conscientious" people, can trace our being here (in the existential sense of "being") to some ancestor with "low consciousness". Birthrates are falling rapidly around the world, yes, including in places you may think are populated with "low conscious" people. The reason is very prosaic: urbanization. As people get crammed into smaller areas, they naturally start to reproduce less. It goes back to the fundamental human urge to take care of our offspring: an overcrowded city is also a highly competitive city (Tokyo, Hong Kong, New York etc illustrate this best) so people who live in that environment that don't want to bring more offspring into the world. Even in a country like India, the population growth is almost all rural. The birth rate of city-natives in big cities has dropped well below replacement level, and cities are gaining population because of immigration and within one generation those rural-turned-city-dwellers have low birth rate.
- yummyfajitas 14y agoBoth zeteo and myself are discussing differential birthrates between populations. If population A (e.g. mormons, people of low conscientiousness) has a birthrate of X, and B (everyone else) has a birthrate of Y, with X > Y, then population A will eventually become the entire population. The eventual birthrate will be X. Even if both birthrates are reduced by some exogenous factor K (e.g. urbanization, reducing from X -> K x X, Y -> K x Y), this fact doesn't change.
- btilly 14y ago
- greenyoda 14y agoIt's not really evolution, strictly speaking, unless you believe that the choice to avoid using birth control is somehow determined by a person's genes.
- JoeAltmaier 14y agoCultural evolution? Cultures certainly behave like organisms. A culture of birth control could easily get out of hand and exterminate the group the espoused it. E.g. Shakers.
- btilly 14y agoWeaker than that. Not determined, but just affected. As a random example it is known that genes play a big role in causing ADHD, which is associated with a variety of risky behaviors, which might conceivably be correlated with increased reproduction rates. If ADHD people has kids 10% faster than the rest of the population, then in something 30 generations, we'd expect over half the population to have ADHD. That's about 750 years. (I do not know if this is the case with ADHD. I'm throwing it out as a random example. For all I know there is no real difference. Or, in the presence of birth control, a 20% difference.) It isn't just ADHD, though. Every possible genetically determined characteristic that limits how effectively birth control prevents you from having children is now being aggressively selected for. All else remaining equal, in a few hundred years we are likely to see significant behavior shifts in our species.