14 ms·
Massive New Surveillance Program Uncovered by Wall Street Journal
- nnq 14y ago> allow databases about U.S. civilians to be handed over to foreign governments for analysis, presumably so that they too can attempt to determine future criminal actions ...where on the line did these guys lost the "innocent until proven guilty" part?! (the possibility of your government handing personal data of innocent civilians to foreign governments sounds "out of your freakyn minds" even for a foreigner like me! Imagine someone coming to the US in attempt to flee from an oppressive government and data about his whereabouts getting to a contract killer via an "en masse" exchange of data about "suspicious" civilians between governments...) ...keep it like this and the USA will be the last place on Earth someone would want to emigrate to, either to work or to open a business!!!
- buro9 14y agoIt's been happening in the other direction for a number of years now. My brother was turned back when he flew to Miami with his family to take his children to Disney World. It turned out that because he had been arrested aged 19 and failed to declare it that the border people felt that he had answered fraudulantly when challenged on "Have you ever been arrested?". My brother answered no because whilst he was arrested he was never charged or convicted. He had attended a demonstration in the North of England and when a few people caused trouble the police had just arrested everyone only to release the vast majority some hours later. He'd forgotten about this because nothing had ever actually come of it and it was over 20 years ago, yet there he was being confronted by it at a US border. Clearly the UK authorities already share data with the USA on its citizens, even those never charged or convicted. That it may happen more does not surprise me the least. The only part that surprises me is that the data flow might go the other way too.
- Semiapies 14y agoPolice records are routinely exchanged between various countries. This is an entirely different matter.
- Create 14y agoI suspect it only goes the other way mainly in such minor, insignificant cases to build up the stats to satisfy the bilateral agreements, which go back for a long time. This is what Churchill meant by "special relationship" and the agreement which Tony Benn oversaw when he was in office. The price set for the Polaris was Her Majesty's subjects' data. All of it. My brother answered no because whilst he was arrested he was never charged or convicted -> http://craphound.com/littlebrother/ http://craphound.com/littlebrother/ http://techtv.mit.edu/videos/21783-the-government-is-profiling-you http://techtv.mit.edu/videos/21783-the-government-is-profili...
- standingstone 14y agoTony Blair I'd say. Not Tony Benn's sort of thing at all!
- Create 14y agoLike most politicians, Tony Benn changed with time. Although in the unlikely way: the other way around. Tony Blair wasn't around Nassau (Trident, the successor to Polaris, was signed off by Thatcher, and it also precedes Blair). youtu.be/rokTiJfL4WY
- standingstone 14y agoSorry, I was about as wrong as is possible!
- Create 14y agono problem, History isn't simple (for many reasons) Certainly, the presence of nuclear weapons on their territory involves, for Europeans, multiple risks. Many of them are similar to the risks and dangers faced by the citizens of any of the countries possessing an atomic arsenal. The usefulness and desirability of which may be subject to debate. Including whether the risks are worth to be taken in the service of a politico-military strategy of national defence (or, conversely, must be rejected in view of universal peace and total disarmament). It is up to each and everyone to take a stance according to their beliefs, their world views, their perception and ranking of hazards, et cetera. For us here, all this is irrelevant. Because in this case, the question does not even arise. Thanks to another dimension of NATO nuclear "sharing", which is highly reflective of transatlantic relations. Whereas in the nuclear power countries the debate can focus on the articulation of the nuclear force with an overall strategy (importance attributed, or not, to the concept of deterrence), here, to the contrary, the (U.S.) nuclear force, and the myth of the protective umbrella that accompanies it, is a pretext used to justify the lack of (European) strategy. As well as providing a comfortable smokescreen that allows the governments of the old continent to stay, ultimately, flawlessly aligned on the United States – even if this means to become accomplices of a nuclear strategy in the development and implementation of which they cannot even dream of having a little bit of say. Alas, they already feel happy when they are, more or less correctly and more or less timely, informed on the subject.
- barking 14y agoIt turned out that because he had been arrested aged 19 and failed to declare it that the border people felt that he had answered fraudulantly when challenged on "Have you ever been arrested?". What interpretation should they have taken from it?
- Create 14y agoFor example, that since Clinton also answered fraudulently when challenged, he shouldn't be allowed to fly either. Nixon got caught too -- I presume he also did fly afterwards. But obviously some are more equal; 1984 Was Not Supposed To Be An Instruction Manual.
- chrisbennet 14y agoHe was turned back because he lied (unknowingly) when the asked him if he'd been arrested.
- betterunix 14y agoI have to wonder if they actually expect people to be honest about that. You paid a lot for that plane ticket, and these people can turn you away for what amounts to any arbitrary reason. Would you really want to tell them about how "undesirable" you are?
- brian_cloutier 14y agoApparently they do, if you are turned away for not being honest.
- jacquesm 14y agoYou're phrasing this as if he was dishonest, but he may have been merely forgetful. Ask me what I did 20 years ago and I probably wouldn't know either. Was that time I got taken into a police station for driving a French car in the Netherlands an arrest or not? I really don't know and I think if I judged that I'd never been arrested (not charged, nothing heard from since) that I would be on the right side of that line. So this could easily happen to me. Or, it could happen to me if I still came to the US, which I don't.
- nikcub 14y agoIt sucks that this is how it works, but that is what the survey is for. They already know all the answers, they just want to see how you respond. For eg. they already know the date, your flight number, your passport number, your history - it is all about getting you in a situation where you answer questions and can be analyzed. The Isrealis are really good at it. They realized that security through innspecting every person and every square centimeter of luggage is too expensive and isn't as effective. A lot of their security at airports depends on picking out people and just asking them a random question or two ('why are you here') and seeing the response. If you have ever been asked the time, or the directions to the mens room, or about a flight from a tourist looking person at an Israel airport, chances are that they may have been an agent. There is a front-line of plain clothed who look around on the ground and pass on potential targets to uniformed officers. There was a paper I remember reading sub-titled "Can you really catch terrorist by asking them if they are terrorists" and the conclusion was that yes, you can - and you do - and not because you know they will answer 'no', but by how they answer and their body language, among other factors (much of which modern governments keep secret). There was sometime in how your brother answered that steered them towards not allowing him in. There are a lot of people who also make similar mistakes on immigration forms and are still let in.
- alastair 14y agoArticle is here if anyone is interested (saves you a google) - http://www.dailymail.co.uk/home/moslive/article-1336571/Terrorism-Can-really-stop-bomber-asking-Are-terrorist.html http://www.dailymail.co.uk/home/moslive/article-1336571/Terr...
- godDLL 14y agoIt works so well for us because nobody, and I literally mean no other state in the world speaks THE LANGUAGE. When you grow up here you get used to being around all kinds that you previously never fully visualized as actual, walking-talking flesh-and-blood people. There's the Russian-speaking section to which I belong, the local Palestinians, the Ethiopian section, quite a lot of the Moroccan people, as well as many small _Iraqi / Druzi / some part of Europe that speaks not-quite-Russian_ escapees. They all have their quirky chains of characteristic behaviours and you sort of learn to place people in those groups pretty fast. And yes, all of them have children that've grown up here, and fuck all knows what group any of them belong to (unless they look and act like their parents). Israel is a sort of an ISLAND, and as anyone who visited Japan will tell you islanders are WEIRD. And sensitive to foreigners.
- tsotha 14y agoWell, it's hard for me to feel much sympathy for him. They didn't ask if he was convicted, right? They asked if he'd been arrested. And he lied.
- mtgx 14y agoIf I want to fly to Latin America from Europe, I'd rather make the stop for the second plane in Europe, and then go straight to Latin America, than make the stop in US. I just don't want to deal with TSA in any way, especially after stories that now they even have data on what you tweeted and stuff like that, and they can take you aside or even arrest you for a while because of that. Will TSA consider me "suspicious" just because I tweeted articles such as this one? Or maybe some Wikileaks-related articles or some OWS articles? That is ridiculous, and I don't even want to risk that by flying through the country, let alone want to live there (which is something I really wanted to do before). The world's view on America is changing fast and the view is increasingly more negative. The world wants America to be its role model, something to aspire to, and a place where they want to live in. It doesn't want to see an America as the bully of the world, or a bully even of its own citizens. So yes, I do think this will impact tourism, cloud businesses, as well as other type of businesses, if they keep going down this road of increasing surveillance and more government abuses, not only against Americans, but against foreigners, too.
- barking 14y agoOTOH they've been pretty successful at preventing attacks on America since 9/11.
- oelmekki 14y agoWell, they've been very good at preventing attacks before 9/11, too.
- keithpeter 14y agoThere has not been a major attack on US soil since 9/11. This may or may not be because of the level of security apparent in airports. You can't tell.
- a3_nm 14y agoDo you have any evidence to suggest that the absence of 9/11-like attacks has anything to do with the TSA?
- propercoil 14y agoAssume everything is recorded. don't expect anything less
- Devilboy 14y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Room_641A http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Room_641A
- meaty 14y agoAnd here's the Western European version which is much scarier: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/RAF_Menwith_Hill http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/RAF_Menwith_Hill I went on site there to install some engineering management software and you are escorted around with an SA80 pointing at you most of the time and told "no questions".
- rdl 14y agoIt's the responsibility of people in technology to design systems to defeat passive surveillance as a baseline. Defeating simple active-attack assisted monitoring (mitm with a different cert, etc.) is a nice additional step, and being able to resist targeted attack is basically beyond what we can do now, most of the time, but we should try.
- meaty 14y agoUniversal point to point encryption with pre-shared keys would solve this instantly.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- dendory 14y ago"Pre-crime" You thought it was a movie, now it's reality. Soon, it'll be something you get arrested for. Mark my words.
- barking 14y agoIf you have a record then isn't it understandable that you might attract more attention than someone with a blameless past? It seems logical to me anyway. Obviously not to the extent that you'd be held but keeping an eye on you is fair enough imo.
- dirtyaura 14y agoDo you really think that a previous record and terrorist acts correlate significantly?
- barking 14y agoYes. Membership of the domestic terrorist groups in my country correlates very strongly with a history of juvenile anti-social behaviour. These youngsters frequently come into contact with these groups either when subject to vigilante punishment or 'get taken under their wing'. Most terrorists aren't university graduates
- pcvarmint 14y agoNothing new, move on :(
- pcvarmint 14y agoNot sure why this was downvoted, but those of us who have been reading Naomi Wolf, Glenn Greenwald, et al. have known about this. This is merely the logical extension of the Patriot Act, Military Commissions Act, Telecom Immunity, NDAA, etc. I hope this federal Leviathan collapses, and we return to liberty someday, but I fear there will be a lot of casualties before that happens.
- shmerl 14y agoNot surprising. Consider the government to be dreaming about 1984 and prepare to deal with it now.
- conradfr 14y ago1984 in the back and A Brave New World in the front :)
- oelmekki 14y ago> using “predictive pattern-matching,” to analyze it for suspicious patterns of behavior Here we are again : authoritarianism being rationalized.
- chmike 14y agoThis has nothing to do with authoritarism. It is method to detect behaviour not mathching "normal" pattern. This is used as a heuristic to detect suspicious behavior.
- oelmekki 14y agoThanks for confirming my point.
- dalke 14y agoAn issue is that they are only an _approximate_ heuristic. What is the likelihood that an unusual behavior is suspicious? The level of false negatives is, as this article points out, very high. That's because it's essentially impossible to define "normal" behavior. "Normal" behavior doesn't include jumping off a bridge. But I and friends have, as a lark. Is that then suspicious? Or from the article, normal people don't buy explosive chemicals and a timer in the same week ... except if the person's teen wants the chemicals for a science experiment and the timer replaces the broken one for the lawn irrigation system. There are a huge number of these low-probability events, and it overwhelms the signal of any truly suspicions behavior. Should the authorities investigate all of these? Some of these? What sets the limit? The lack of funding or the law? "Authoritarianism" comes into play because the authorities do come in and investigate. That's their mandate. And innocent citizens are compelled to submit to the investigation, or at the least get the clear signal that the government thinks they are suspicious. Some will stop doing legal things (like traveling by air) in order to not be subject to increased scrutiny by the authorities. This might be low-level authoritarianism, but it still is a higher level of submission to authority than I would like. There's always going to be some false positives, where innocent citizens are investigated, accused, and even put into prison, so it's not like I'm saying that we can have a non-authoritarian government. But do say that this has nothing to do with authoritarianism is only focusing on the collection of the data, and not the likelihood that someone in authority will do something with it.
- chmike 14y agoI don't understand the critics. Do you think that terrorists or criminals are detected by oracles ? You ridiculed the security agencies after 911 for not beeing able to detect such a plot and now you are in shock because they do their job ? There is no way to detect a plot while staying eyes shut. There is a problem, more precisely a risk, but it is not in collecting the data and processing it to detect a plot. It is in the usage and control of usage of the data. This is the heart of the problem and the secrecy around this information gathering and processing is not a good sign. Who controlls and how is this information controlled are the core problem which is absolutely not properly addressed. The need to collect the information to ensure security is on the other hand obvious, at least to me. Not doing this is stupid.
- slyn 14y agoTarget knows you're pregnant, Facebook knows you're gay, now the government is working on knowing if you're a terrorist. Big data isn't the future, its today.
- peterhost 14y agoOk, you're my target cause this comment is so obviously being uttered by someone who hasn't studied history in his/her whole life... Jeez ! (whom i don't believe in btw) Hacker new indeed.... Has anyone's been following dunno, wikileaks or Appelbaum or... Hacker news that are not on hackernews (which usurpates its name because what it really is is startup news) ? Eagle, the Athen Affair (http://spectrum.ieee.org/telecom/security/the-athens-affair/0 http://spectrum.ieee.org/telecom/security/the-athens-affair/...), or more generally this : http://wikileaks.org/the-spyfiles.html http://wikileaks.org/the-spyfiles.html ? It's our liberty that's slipping out of the (gaping a..)hole of democracies, which is not democracies fault because they are by definition are "representative governements", based on election. Tocqueville knew that back in the XIXth, so did all theoreticians of "governance", and not a single one called a "representative government" a "democracy". Anyway. What it boils down to is : if you're not strictly speaking living in a democracy (which i'm sorry, the US, UK, France,... Aren't by historical, philosophical, and semantic definition), the only thing that matters is keeping power at bay. Try and elect representatives who truly understand that too much power in to few hands always leads to disaster. Only. There are none. There haven't been for decades. The latest in france was General de Gaulle (though his ego was high, he was the sort able to step down from power after a people's vote) , and I guess, on the US side, Kennedy. I wouldn't trust my shoes to the state. And to facebook ? (non existing) Jeez again ! This is so scary to realize nobody - at large - realizes... WWII is far away, the days of the cold war too, and people become lazy. Even (so called) hackers.
- eyeareque 14y agoHome of the free, right?
- adventured 14y agoGive a government trillions to spend in an era of massive government programs and vast new storage & surveillance technology, and it should be obvious what you're going to get. The only possible way to stop it is to starve the beast of funds to spend. Cut the government in half, and let's see if they can still afford all the shiny new big brother toys.
- Create 14y agoYou can do anything with bayonets except sit on them.
- stygianguest 14y agoBy this logic Europeans should be a total police state. To find a solution we need to discover what makes Americans so afraid that no gun is big enough, no military powerful enough, and due process can be suspended.
- tomjen3 14y agoAs a European I would argue that we are already living in a police state -- there is so much surveillance here, so many things that would be a violation of the 4th admentment if we had one, so many things that would be a violation of the first admentment -- it is just that we don't like putting people in prison for very long and our media love to take up stories so most of this shit doesn't happen too openly.
- Vivtek 14y agoFirst, it hasn't been so long since Europeans had police states, and people in Europe actually remember it. Second, "Europeans" are a myth. The French, Germans, Italians, Danes, Brits, Spaniards, Hungarians, Greeks, Czechs, Slovaks, Poles, Romanians, Dutch, Belgians, Irish, and so on trust each other about as far as they can collectively throw one another. No one country can possibly get much centralized control. Not that they don't try. Third, Americans have that exceptionalism thing: no matter how dangerous a course of action is, an American will succeed because, gosh darn it, God loves us and we're great! So something like TIA, well, sure, if Castro tried it or even some trustworthy but lesser nation like English did, it'd be terrible tyranny - but we can be trusted because we're Americans.
- mcantelon 14y agoWSJ didn't uncover it. It has been talked about since October in the context of the "disposition matrix", which is to be used to search out possible candidates for the extrajudicial "kill list". >The central role played by the NCTC in determining who should be killed ... the NCTC operates a gigantic data-mining operation, in which all sorts of information about innocent Americans is systematically monitored, stored, and analyzed http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/2012/oct/24/obama-terrorism-kill-list http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/2012/oct/24/obama-te...
- HannibalLecter 14y agoI don't see the problem with this. The US seems to be building the pioneering efforts of a pre-crime unit. The philosophy is that if we're in the era of information whoever has the most information wins. What's wrong with USA taking all the info they can get? Anyone here could do the same thing. Don't use the word innocent. Nobody is innocent.
- Vivtek 14y ago"Reminiscent" of Total Information Awareness? It is TIA - and did anybody ever actually think they'd not implement TIA just because it was found out?
- hermannj314 14y agoI have an aquaintance that was falsely accused of vehicular homicide because he had a car whose description was close enough for the police and he had to spend a decade in the legal system fighting for his freedom. And all of this is made possible because the police have access to records of which cars are owned and by whom and they can look at it. Should we not let the police use this information since this one individual was the victim of a false positive match and it cost him 10 years proving it? I mean, he never committed a crime in his life, and yet the police had access to his vehicle driving history / cars registered to him / etc. The had collected that information in advance. But no one called it a "massive surveillance program" So where does it stop? Phone records. Addresses. Aliases. Friends. Fingerprints. Is it wrong that they want to put in all in place? Would we be happier if they had to run around to 25 different government agencies / 25 private corporations to get the information? What if the information is lost before the need to use it to aid an investigation. Wouldn't it be easier if they just aggregated it ahead of time and looked at it when they needed it? I guess personally I'm just not seeing the problem. As long as they are simply gathering all information that is legally knowable, what do I care? Why should I care? I'd like to know I have the freedom to do the same thing and I assume large corporations are doing it already. Should it be illegal to gather information on people simply because they didn't authorize it? Should individuals have the power to control what others do with the information that is publically knowable about them? I, personally, say no.
- ThomPete 14y agoProblem is that errors are always going to occur. the stronger the data sets the harder it can be to prove your innocence. We have rights and the law not to prevent the bad guys from doing bad things, but to protect the citizens from the potential misuse of the governmental system.
- 18pfsmt 14y ago>Is it wrong that they want to put in all in place? You seem to be operating under the assumption that there is a definitive answer here. There isn't, and this is completely subjective. The idea that 300M+ people will agree on such a question, to me, is ridiculous. It is really a matter of 2 questions: 1) How many false positives are acceptable? 2) Are we willing to accept the consequences if this information falls into the wrong hands? Reasonable people will disagree on the answers, and I believe the U.S. was the last country founded (granted, on the lands of others') upon the idea that freedom and individual rights (over the collective) should be maximized. More and more, as the U.S. has matured we've seen and continue to see the collective rights being prioritized. To be clear, I am not sure where I stand personally, but I am simply trying to objectively point out what I see.
- kmfrk 14y agoSo this is how the world ends, not with a bang, but muffled behind a paywall.
- Zenst 14y agoOne way I'm reading this is that in effect it is illegal to hack a computer without permision; YET a computer can hack you without permision. When you think of it like that it does appear one-sided. This data centre could indicate you thru false positives of a crime and even present enough data to potentualy incriminate you even if you are innocent. Whilst we have managed to lock up innocent people in the past indicating the system is not perfect, the prospect of stepping closer towards automating that does not bode well. That all said I understand what they are doing and why and it does make sence and if anything will make people realise that online is the same as in person, just better documented.
- paganel 14y ago> The aim of the TIA initiative was essentially to create a kind of ubiquitous pre-crime surveillance regime monitoring public and private databases. I Ctrl+F-ed for Philip K. Dick's name, didn't find anything, I'll be the first one to copy-paste this: > Paradoxes and alternate realities are created by the precognition of crimes when the chief of police intercepts a precognition that he is about to murder a man he has never met. (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Minority_Report https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Minority_Report)
- mtgx 14y agoPeople have warned that this will happen eventually, but I don't think that many believed it. We're witnessing the first real steps towards making pre-crime recognition a reality in the country. Good bye "innocent until proven guilty". Cory Doctorow has said in his "war against general computation" talk [1] that it's becoming cheaper and easier for authorities to just monitor everyone and store information about everyone, and then use algorithms to catch them, than focusing on who they they need to catch and following just that one. Now it's up to the people to stop this from becoming legal or from being done even illegally, not just in US, but in all countries, as I'm sure many others will try doing it, too. The ironic part is that the developed "democratic" countries may be the first to do it, because they are more advanced technologically. [1] http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gbYXBJOFgeI http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gbYXBJOFgeI
- lunchladydoris 14y agoI'm assuming the OP posted a link to Slate instead of the Wall Street Journal because the article is gated at the latter. In which case, let me show you a little trick (in case you haven't come across it). Just Google the full title of the WSJ article and the WSJ link in the search results will let you read the whole thing.
- wtfus 14y ago<strike>Innocent until proven guilty.</strike> <strike>Innocent until "terrorist".</strike> <strike>Innocent until suspected "terrorist".</strike> <strike>Innocent until surveillance indicates you use encryption, therefore "terrorist".</strike> <strike>Innocent until our surveillance predicts you might commit some sort of crime, therefore "terrorist".</strike> Innocent until we say so. All animals are equal, but some animals are more equal than others.
- zactral 14y agoYour tax dollars at work, powered by machine learning(tm)
- SideburnsOfDoom 14y agoNot another one!
- rglover 14y agoAre we so spooked as a nation that we're really considering precognition-style crime fighting? Liberties aside, this really makes me wonder what the atmosphere is like inside the government. With all of this paranoia, only two paths come to mind: 1.) They're aware of a future threat so large that it threatens the stability of the country, or 2.) They're planning something internally to "take over" the country one way or another. In another view, you have to ask what this would do to society? A public so paranoid of being harassed by the government that they barely do anything, or, actually do go out and commit crimes. Despite our "intelligence" we're still animals and will behave so put under the right amount of strain. This is a time bomb.
- orangecat 14y agoWith all of this paranoia, only two paths come to mind I think it's just that they place zero or negative value on privacy, so any perceived incremental increase in identifying threats justifies any amount of increased surveillance.
- blueprint 14y agoOur society would be extremely foolish to believe that we've not already been under deep surveillance by the government for quite a long time.
- aswanson 14y agoThey're probably using Palantir. I wonder how Thiel resolves his libertarian/freedom philosophy with supplying the government with such a powerful oppressive tool.
- wyck 14y agoWell there is also this company https://www.recordedfuture.com/ https://www.recordedfuture.com/ which has the CIA and Google as investors, like anything political the grey area covers a lot.
- magicalist 14y ago"We constantly collect news, blogs, and public social media. We identify the events: past, present, and future. We help you find predictive signals in the noise of the web." sounds like...anyone doing information extraction or sentiment analysis from the web? If investment is the only thing to raise a red flag, you have to worry about a lot more companies than that: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/In-Q-Tel#Investments http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/In-Q-Tel#Investments
- cheeseprocedure 14y agoI had a chance to speak to one of the lead developers at Palantir a couple years back, and asked him about this apparent conflict of political ideals. His answer: by enabling agencies to properly apply the data they already have, Palantir's products reduce the pressure to further erode civil liberties in the pursuit of more data.
- shmerl 14y agoDidn't IBM help we know whom to sort their victims' data during the WWII? This kind of argument doesn't work.
- cheeseprocedure 14y agoI'm not sure that comparison is in the same ballpark. (I'm also not supporting his stance.)
- dreamdu5t 14y agoWhy I'm worried about a surveillance state? Because the people in charge will have their records protected while everyone else gets the surveillance. Our president committed crimes his justice department jails people for (illegal drugs). Drug testing is a perfect example of the surveillance state. The people who don't get tested? The testers. The legislators. The people in charge. I know there are technical problems with that analogy - but you get the point.
- ClayM 14y agoso, "who watches the watchers" ?
- ragmondo 14y agoCase in point - the uk "contactpoint" database - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ContactPoint http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ContactPoint - a database mandated by MPs that should contains all information about every child under the age of 18. Anyone excluded? Yep you guessed it - MP's children.
- jacquesm 14y agoI read that whole thing. Pretty amazing it got as far as it did, and from what I understood reading the article it was the children of celebrities that were going to be excluded. Which makes me wonder what would be considered a celebrity.
- gtirloni 14y agoAnyone with power/influence enough. Like it has always been. It doesn't matter if the person is known to the general public or not. Money/power/influence is what matters in our present world.
- pstuart 14y agoThey need to lead by example. After all, what do they have to hide?
- joshuahedlund 14y ago
- lucian303 14y agoIf it was just revealed, it's been going on in some way or another for the last two decades plus.
- pluc 14y agoPhilip K. Dick called...
- varelse 14y agoSince the predictive algorithms in use mostly come down to glorified dot products, I question their general validity. Sure, it works sometimes, but just look at some of the wacky stuff Amazon, Google, and Netflix derive from such things. Now replace search results and product recommendations with waterboarding and extraordinary rendition based on the results of those dot products and hilarity ensues...
- yid 14y agoAnd those dot products come down to glorified FMUL and FADD machine instructions! Specious reductionism goes all the way down.
- varelse 14y agoAnd those FMUL and FADD instructions could either be fused multiply/add or separate multiplies and adds with twice the truncation issues, Holy FPRE! But I'm curious as to why you place such faith in the sooper top sekrit(tm) basis vectors for these dot products? It seems to me that it's politically expedient for such a system to generate false positives rather than risk letting the terrorists win(tm) and that's where I think things go wrong. Because it would appear from the outside that the powers-that-be have decreed that it's better to torture the occasional innocent than risk letting the guilty slip through their fingers.
- yid 14y agoI think you might be a bit too wrapped up in conspiracy theories, friend.
- d0ne 14y agoMy company will sponsor $5,000 for the best idea submission for mitigation techniques against these types of systems. Any suggestion on the best service to use host this / receive submissions? We will: 1) Open source all submitted ideas. 2) Let the community choose the top 5 and we will hold an internal review process for the top spot. 3) Fly the winner(s) to our office in Atlanta, GA to discuss the winning submission in details with some of the top information security experts in the world. 4) Work to get press around the winning idea. 5) If we get north of 50 submissions we will help seed (with an additional $5,000) an IndieGoGo campaign to see the idea developed. Email me (adam | socialfortress.com) or respond here to discuss.
- jacquesm 14y ago> Fly the winner(s) to our office in Atlanta, GA to discuss the winning submission in details with some of the top information security experts in the world. That may be a bit prohibitive, given that they will still have to use air travel, possibly to and at least within the USA. I figure the people that come up with a mitigation against a system like this would be very smart to stay the hell away from claiming credit for it. And the top information security experts in the world are working for what we'll loosely designate 'the other side' here, I don't think they'll be on your discussion panel.
- mindcrime 14y agoAnd the top information security experts in the world are working for what we'll loosely designate 'the other side' here I think that would be accurate if it read: And some of the top information security experts in the world are working for what we'll loosely designate 'the other side' here There are some pretty goddamned smart people in the cypherpunk / hacker community, who would (and do) find this kind of surveillance crap abhorrent and who will work to resist it. I certainly would not say that all of the best people are on "the other side". Maybe time will prove me wrong, but I doubt it.
- jacquesm 14y agoI'm with you on the 'some', I should have been more careful with the wording there. Yes, there are indeed lots of smart people who find this crap abhorrent and who will work to resist it. But I don't think they're the majority. Not even close. Individuals such as Phil Zimmerman are making a real difference. But money is a powerful motivator. Lots of people will do very stupid things when offered enough money. Governments print money. Nationalism is another such powerful motivator. Press the combined buttons of nationalism and piles of cash and a lot of people will start seeing things your way. The NSA is currently the largest employer of mathematicians in the United States, and that probably makes them the largest employer of mathematicians planet wide. There are lots of counterparts of the NSA in other countries. And those mathematicians are not too upset about not being able to publish their results, so I'm thinking there is something to counterbalance that, such as abundant financial compensation. For now this is an unbalanced situation.
- AutoKorrect 14y agoladies and gentlemen we have here a clear case where the people in charge have failed to uphold the Constitution of the United States. These people must be forced out of government, and prosecuted for their crimes. Please vote, and please run for office if you have the fortitude to help us deal with this problem.