3 ms·

https://archive.is/p1ehR https://archive.is/p1ehR The essay from Zuckerberg

by rufasterisco 2mo ago

sammyteee 2mo ago
God, it's a bit War and Peace...
antonmks 2mo ago
So many em dashes...
- wolttam 2mo ago
  There really wasn’t that many and this did not have the voice of written-by-an-LLM to me And they’re not em-dashes -- they’re double hyphens.
  - vehemenz 2mo ago
    This is unneedfully obtuse. Double hyphens are a stand-in for em dashes in most contexts.
    - efromvt 2mo ago
      I think the context here is that em dashes are usually generated verbatim from LLMs? I haven't seen them generate a lot of double hyphens; I suppose the post could be laundering them to double dashes, but if you're gonna try to hide LLM prose just drop them entirely? [please correct me if I'm wrong and double dashes are also an LLM tell - genuinely don't know]
      - wolttam 2mo ago
        My comment was trying to point on the inanity of calling out "so many em-dashes" on a post where it doesn't seem that obvious it was LLM generated. I added some of my own inanity with my remark about them being double-dashes, even though some people undoubtedly find-and-replace the em-dashes in their LLM-generated content something else to try and make it appear more authentic. But perhaps the best approach would have been to down-vote and move on.
- deleted 2mo ago
  [deleted]
ipsum2 2mo ago
Non-archived version: https://www.meta.com/thefutureisforeveryone/ https://www.meta.com/thefutureisforeveryone/ since its not paywalled.
riazrizvi 2mo ago
Thank you! Okay yes well this manifesto is a contradiction. Yes good let's keep empowering ppl by putting AI into their hands, I love the opening. No bad we don't do that by handing you all our personal context to make these agents "work for us 24/7 to better our lives". I'm the agent doing that in my life, that's my fucking job. I will continue to use dumb agents that I direct, because only I retain ownership and sole rights to my personal context on which my decisions are based.
- rufasterisco 2mo ago
  I don’t understand. The model is open, you can host it and use it without giving Meta anything. I’m not saying Meta is not eager to syphon data from users, but I don’t see how this happens via this specific product.
  - riazrizvi 2mo ago
    The intention is in black and white. The precedent of prior product design backs that up. The open models are great on their own but they are not the biggest part of the manifesto.

https://archive.is/p1ehR https://archive.is/p1ehR The essay from Zuckerberg

sammyteee 2mo ago

God, it's a bit War and Peace...

antonmks 2mo ago

So many em dashes...

wolttam 2mo ago
There really wasn’t that many and this did not have the voice of written-by-an-LLM to me And they’re not em-dashes -- they’re double hyphens.
- vehemenz 2mo ago
  This is unneedfully obtuse. Double hyphens are a stand-in for em dashes in most contexts.
  - efromvt 2mo ago
    I think the context here is that em dashes are usually generated verbatim from LLMs? I haven't seen them generate a lot of double hyphens; I suppose the post could be laundering them to double dashes, but if you're gonna try to hide LLM prose just drop them entirely? [please correct me if I'm wrong and double dashes are also an LLM tell - genuinely don't know]
    - wolttam 2mo ago
      My comment was trying to point on the inanity of calling out "so many em-dashes" on a post where it doesn't seem that obvious it was LLM generated. I added some of my own inanity with my remark about them being double-dashes, even though some people undoubtedly find-and-replace the em-dashes in their LLM-generated content something else to try and make it appear more authentic. But perhaps the best approach would have been to down-vote and move on.
deleted 2mo ago
[deleted]

ipsum2 2mo ago

Non-archived version: https://www.meta.com/thefutureisforeveryone/ https://www.meta.com/thefutureisforeveryone/ since its not paywalled.

riazrizvi 2mo ago

Thank you! Okay yes well this manifesto is a contradiction. Yes good let's keep empowering ppl by putting AI into their hands, I love the opening. No bad we don't do that by handing you all our personal context to make these agents "work for us 24/7 to better our lives". I'm the agent doing that in my life, that's my fucking job. I will continue to use dumb agents that I direct, because only I retain ownership and sole rights to my personal context on which my decisions are based.

rufasterisco 2mo ago
I don’t understand. The model is open, you can host it and use it without giving Meta anything. I’m not saying Meta is not eager to syphon data from users, but I don’t see how this happens via this specific product.
- riazrizvi 2mo ago
  The intention is in black and white. The precedent of prior product design backs that up. The open models are great on their own but they are not the biggest part of the manifesto.