10 ms·
TSA Privatization Returns Airport Security to a Dangerous Past
- dfxm12 2mo agoThis is going to be end up being like the reflecting pool, but on a grander scale. Tax payers are going to end up paying Trump's incompetent friends a ton of money to just make flying an even worse experience.
- nekusar 2mo agoThe REAL airline security benefit was 2 things: Locks on cockpit doors Vigilant passengers. That's it. All the security theater is exactly that - it's a theater production. The TSA can't even detect guns reliably. In 2023, they failed 95% of gun tests. https://www.travelcodex.com/tsa-misses-95-of-weapons-in-its-own-tests/ https://www.travelcodex.com/tsa-misses-95-of-weapons-in-its-... Or different sites require laptops in separate boxes, but this site is fine. Or shoes on, or shoes off. Porno scanners. Basically the TSA was a big corporate donation to security appratus, and a huge worthless make-work operation. And if they're really worried about terrorism, it's still beyond stupid. There's still long lines BEFORE security that they could target. But you know, that person with a small pocketknife is a "REAL DANGER" so the government thieves those evil weapons or how dare they bring 2.5 ounces! Its stupid idiot theater all around.
- dcrazy 2mo agoSFO has had private airport security (Covenant) instead of TSA since 9/11. It’s been great.
- Brendinooo 2mo agoFrom the article: >Covenant Aviation Security was another early winner, getting $19 million for unspecified airport security services in 2005. Since then, it’s gotten an ever-increasing amount, including $773 million in 2021 to support security screening at San Francisco International Airport (SFO) until the end of this year; taxpayers have spent about $1.5 billion on that company, mainly for security at SFO. That airport is held out as the exemplar of how well private companies manage security, which labor leaders say is the case because Covenant workers at SFO are unionized; as a result, they are better paid than security contractors elsewhere and can more strongly influence practices. But even so, the FBI found that some of Covenant’s security personnel helped smugglers traffic cocaine between 2013 and 2014 by allowing them “to pass through the x-ray machine at a security checkpoint line without adequately screening the luggage for explosives, incendiaries, weapons, or other threats to security,” as the Department of Justice wrote. Just hard to get anything useful out of this article. Privatization returns us to a dangerous past, but we already privatize, and it's really good, but it's only because of unions, but despite that it's still bad, but I guess it must not be too bad because we haven't had any terrorist attacks since 9/11, which is the reason why it's bad to privatize.
- W3cUYxYwmXb5c 2mo agoThe TSA has always been taxpayer-funded security theater, and routinely fails at it's own job. Airports and Airliners should be paying for their own security.
- tmaly 2mo agoI think I would prefer more accountability, if a private firm can do that, than I see no issue.
- Zigurd 2mo agoThis is the key insight: it's not a question of better or worse security. Airport screening doesn't enhance security. This can even be experimentally measured. Bottles of liquid get screened reliably while weapons don't get detected because it's rare for a weapon to pass through the baggage screening machine. The correct response to a lose lose situation like that is to minimize the cost and friction until someday it's announced that a magical technology can do mass walk-through "screenings," and we can stop paying the shampoo bottle screeners.
- general1465 2mo agoIn Europe you have often private companies like G4S as a security with police doing only supervision and passport control.
- dcrazy 2mo agoSpeaking of Europe, when the topic of airport security comes up I often think about how many European countries use the gendarmerie for public security. We explicitly do not have any such thing here in the U.S., so we wind up with all of these fragmented police forces like ICE with varying degrees of heavy arms.
- josefritzishere 2mo agowe're taking security theatre and giving it to profiteers. That's awful.