6 ms·
That's the idealized assumption in a simple supply/demand, all-else-equal model, but there's actually little empirical evidence that minimum wages, at least at
by _delirium 14y ago
That's the idealized assumption in a simple supply/demand, all-else-equal model, but there's actually little empirical evidence that minimum wages, at least at the level contemplated in the U.S., actually do have an impact on unemployment in the world world, except on part-time work by teenagers. So economists' consensus has weakened on that from what it was if you had polled them 30-40 years ago.
One among many possible positive effects of higher minimum wages is to shift the threshold at which it becomes profitable to upgrade low-tech processes to computerized ones, which can modernize sectors of the economy, and create some highly paid jobs [1]. Another positive effect is to redistribute more money to people in the remaining low-end jobs. But economies are complex and full of feedback loops, so those aren't really well established either.
[1] As an AI researcher, of course, this benefits me: humans undercutting us is one of our top problems with deploying research in the real world.
- magila 14y agoWell yeah, that's because most people who are making minimum wage are... teenagers working part-time. At its current level the US minimum wage has very little impact on anything, positive or negative. Very few jobs are worth so little, and most of them are being worked by immigrants who get paid under-the-table anyways.
- sukuriant 14y agoKnowing a few people that make or have made approximately minimum wage for the time I've known them, and seeing the age of people working at various low-end jobs, I would like to see some statistics to compare to your statement to my anecdotal evidence.
- specialist 14y agoI'd also like to see underemployment / multiple job stats too. All this talk about minimum wage, haven't seen mention of living wage.
- slurgfest 14y agoThe number of jobs worked by immigrants paid under the table is not 'very few'.
- lostlogin 14y agoNot sure it applies everywhere, but non-immigrants receiving under the table pay would dwarf the number of immigrants doing the same in New Zealand.
- drivebyacct2 14y agoThat's so wildly untrue.
- jfoutz 14y agoAbout half (of 3.8M) are under 25. Not sure about "very few", it's one in twenty jobs. http://www.bls.gov/cps/minwage2011.htm http://www.bls.gov/cps/minwage2011.htm
- ef4 14y agoOne in twenty hourly-paid jobs. But hourly-paid jobs represent only 59.1% of all jobs. So it's actually only 3.1% of jobs that pay (Federal) minimum wage.
- jfoutz 14y agoI'd like to see your math. http://data.bls.gov/timeseries/LNS11300000 http://data.bls.gov/timeseries/LNS11300000 says 64 million at the end of 2011, 3.8M/64M = 5.9% No? I might have mis googled those statistics though.
- jspaur 14y agoMILLIONS (3+ in California alone [1]) of retail workers make nothing more than minimum wage (with hours cut strategically short by 1-2 of the company benefit plan requirements). Walk into any Gap, Walmart, Gamestop, mall, etc. and most of them _are not_ teenagers. If anything they're 1/5th college grads who just put 45k into the economy through 'education') Sure the skillset might be considered less valuable, but is their actual life (and quality of it?). [1] http://www.retailmeansjobs.com/data/CA/0 http://www.retailmeansjobs.com/data/CA/0 - even if the numbers are off by 300% it's still millions
- FireBeyond 14y ago"At its current level the US minimum wage has very little impact on anything, positive or negative. Very few jobs are worth so little" Hah. Most of the EMTs not related to a fire department, that take you to hospital when you call 911 are on, well... minimum wage. How's that for unsettling?
- lilsunnybee 14y agoVery few jobs? What country do you live in? That isn't the case in the US.
- Dove 14y agoThat's the idealized assumption . . . I think the data supports it pretty well, too. Minimum wage is reasonably well correlated with unemployment among lower-educated workers. http://www.learnliberty.org/sites/default/files/Davies_0.pdf http://www.learnliberty.org/sites/default/files/Davies_0.pdf
- _delirium 14y agoAfaict, this PDF makes a "correlation=causation" assertion, and doesn't even attempt to account for any other variables of the past 40 years, implicitly attributing all employment variation from 1970s to the present on minimum wage levels... One of these studies might be a better starting point: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Minimum_wage#Empirical_studies http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Minimum_wage#Empirical_studies
- wtvanhest 14y agoLuckily we now have a way to test it... This machine.
- saraid216 14y agoI'd rather take the machine.
- Dove 14y agoCorrelation may not equal causation, but it does definitely count as empirical support. The slides I posted may not prove that minimum wage causes unemployment among the lower skilled, but they certainly support the idea. At a minimum, they move it away from "idealized assumption" toward "something that survived contact with the data". And really, does economics ever get much better than that? I think it rarely gets even that good. When you have a correlation, the logical possibilities are that A causes B, B causes A, C causes both, or the correlation isn't real -- just random noise. I think the last option is pretty unlikely, and I'm having a very hard time imagining how unemployment among lower skilled workers would cause minimum wage increases, or what in the world would cause both. Particularly persuasive to me is that the strength of the relationship changes with education level -- exactly what I'd expect. No, I suppose I don't know for sure. It's always possible something else causes both, and sure, the dots are all over the map even if there is a relationship; it is a complex system. But to be honest, I really do find that data pretty persuasive. I didn't see anything in the Wikipedia entry that changed my mind much, either. Mostly it was unrelated to what I posted: studies specifically on teenagers (which showed more or less what I'd expect, that minimum wage increases decreased employment), and a comment that in a complex system, lots of factors affect unemployment. (Sure, of course). I don't know, it says "Economists now disagree", but it doesn't say much about what changed their minds. I don't feel bound to change mine just because they did, though it's certainly something to take seriously.
- bmmayer1 14y ago"except on part-time work by teenagers" <= that's really important and shouldn't be dismissed so quickly. Teenagers working part time jobs is where most people, especially the poor, acquire skills and training that they can use to get better paid jobs later on.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- pmorici 14y agoWouldn't you have to take things like the employer's half of Social Security tax and unemployment tax into account as well since they, like the minimum wage, also artificially increase the cost of unskilled labor to an employer?
- yummyfajitas 14y ago...there's actually little empirical evidence that minimum wages, at least at the level contemplated in the U.S., actually do have an impact on unemployment in the world... Minimum wages are usually set at rates well below market. I.e., it's a law that says "keep doing what you are doing" for the vast majority of workers. In the rare cases when the minimum wage law changes behavior, unemployment is the typical result (see American Samoa's recent troubles, for example).
- _delirium 14y agoIn the rare cases when the minimum wage law changes behavior, unemployment is the typical result (see American Samoa's recent troubles, for example). Well, while we're exchanging anecdotes, we've got an $18/hr minimum wage here in Denmark, and unemployment is quite low. The main effect is that wages are more compressed than in the US. It does help that there's an aggressive upskilling program, so people automated out of a job get free education to move up to sectors with more demand. One way of thinking of it is that a higher minimum wage, coupled with technological advancement and a strong education system, just accelerates the automation curve. Today's $10/hr labor will be tomorrow's automatable-for-$2/hr labor anyway. So people in those jobs are going to have to switch to something else in the near future. Why not automate 'em a few years earlier, and get a jump on both deploying new tech and moving people into something better? Then you can export the resulting tech, too.
- yummyfajitas 14y agoI'm not referring to levels, but to rates of change. When the min wage was recently raised in American Samoa, large employers (e.g. Chicken of the Sea) immediately made plans to shutter their facilities and replace humans with machines. Why not automate 'em a few years earlier, and get a jump on both deploying new tech and moving people into something better? Because it would be more efficient to invest in automating other processes? Suppose you have two processes - one process (call it A) costs a human $12/hour, another (B) costs a human $6/hour. You only have enough money to invest in automating one. It's obviously more efficient to automate A. If the minimum wage is raised to $12/hour, then the market signal to automate A preferably to B is lost.
- htf 14y ago> there's actually little empirical evidence that minimum wages, at least at the level contemplated in the U.S., actually do have an impact on unemployment in the world world, except on part-time work by teenagers. There are unemployed people today who would like to have a job. Isn't that sufficient empirical evidence? > No, because lowering the minimum wage, empirically, does not produce new jobs. But it does. As the minimum wage goes to zero, I could personally create a larger and larger number of jobs.
- _delirium 14y agoNo, because lowering the minimum wage, empirically, does not produce more jobs, aggregated across the economy.
- chii 14y agois that really true? i don't believe so. Lets say a restraunt owner didn't have to pay minimum wage to a cleaner, vs one who had to pay minimum wage. The one who has to pay more might decide that they don't need cleaning as much, and so forego the job offer, while the one who didn't have to pay minimum could offer a really low amount, and someone might take them up on that job.
- ianfernz 14y agoOne could view the outsourcing of jobs overseas as upgrading processes as well, if you view the process as a black box where orders go in and product goes out.