6 ms·
FedEx Overcharged Customers for Years, Sealed E-Mail Says
- jrockway 14y agoThis doesn't seem that damning to me. It probably costs FedEx the same regardless of whether or not the address is business or residential these days, and it's not like there's some law that requires FedEx to charge a certain rate. The lawsuit could easily be worded "FedEx systematically undercharging residential customers for years, sealed e-mail says." The tone of the article indicates that I'm supposed to be angry about this, but I'm just not feeling it today. Sorry.
- prawks 14y agoThis is how I interpreted it as well, but I'm not a lawyer, either.
- DannyBee 14y agoFedex publishes rates and is supposed to be bound by them. Here you go, from http://www.fedex.com/us/service-guide/terms/express-ground/index.html http://www.fedex.com/us/service-guide/terms/express-ground/i...: "Rates and service quotations by our employees and agents are estimates and will be based upon information provided by you, but final rates and service charges may vary from the quotes based upon the characteristics of the shipment actually tendered to us. Any conflict or inconsistency between the FedEx Service Guide and other written or oral statements or quotes (except those found in a FedEx Sales or FedEx Express Customer Automation agreement) concerning the rates, features of service, and terms and conditions applicable to FedEx Express service will be controlled by the FedEx Service Guide, as modified, amended, changed or supplemented. " Note: Rate differences are controlled by the service guide. If the service guide says there should be no residential delivery charge, and they are adding one, that's a problem. They also only reserve the right to charge the residential surcharge on certain places: "We reserve the right to assess a Residential Delivery surcharge on any shipment delivered to a home or private residence, including locations where a business is operated from a home, or on any shipment in which the shipper has designated the delivery address as a residence, including shipments where the delivery location has been designated as Residential Delivery in error. " The last part is what part of their defense will almost certainly be. As this email shows, however, they've apparently deliberately designated a large number of shipment delivery locations as residential delivery, meaning it was not "in error", but intentional. Ignoring all of this, they are also usually forming binding rate contracts with businesses and governments (IE you agree to ship this many packages a year, we agree to charge you the rates in this service guide with 80% discount). Throw on top of that that deliberately overcharging the government is serious business in the US. It's often criminal, and IIRC, even in the civil side, you can keep a percentage of the money you recover by suing on their behalf.
- sethg 14y agothey've apparently deliberately designated a large number of shipment delivery locations as residential delivery More likely: they have a database or some other kind of service that maps addresses onto “residential” or “not residential”, and either they put off upgrading the database or have some flakiness in their code, so that a lot of addresses get incorrectly marked “residential”, and, well, when you’re prioritizing which bugs you need to fix, the bugs that make your company more money than it deserves usually don’t end up at the top of the list.
- IanDrake 14y agoSame. I read it and though, if they didn't like the price they should have used UPS or USPS.
- thedufer 14y agoThe problem is that they were tacking surcharges on that didn't apply after signing an agreement. That's breach of contract, which is somewhat different from just charging high prices.
- pixl97 14y agoI want you for a customer. I'll sign a contract to bill you for $100 an hour. Then when I send you the bill I'll make sure it's for $125, because hey if you don't like the price, you should have used someone else.
- rscale 14y agoThe allegation is that FedEx established contracts with customers with a rate schedule that included surcharges for residential and extended-range delivery, then improperly charged those surcharges on deliveries to commercial/government locations where they did not apply, and did so knowingly and repeatedly. Systematically overcharging customers strikes me as a valid tort.
- mikeash 14y agoThere is a law that says FedEx has to charge the rates they advertise, though. I believe that is what is at issue here.
- mikeryan 14y agoIt probably costs FedEx the same regardless of whether or not the address is business or residential these days, I sincerely doubt this is true. There's probably significant economies of scale when delivering to commercial properties where the drivers can drop off multiple deliveries at once as opposed to home deliveries which would usually get a single package per stop. Id think that the drivers that deliver to offices can drop 5-10x as many deliveries in a day compared to the residential drivers
- cdcarter 14y agoAdditionally, a commercial delivery has a lot lower chance of a delivery exception.
- Alaskan005 14y ago“My belief is that we are choosing not to fix this issue because it is worth so much money to FedEx,” They will pay some money to make the lawyers rich, no one goes to jail and FedEx will repeat it again after a few years. Rinse, repeat. Cost of doing business.
- TDL 14y agoIt's a civil issue why would anyone go to jail?
- Alaskan005 14y agoThis is civil, but if they broke the law (overcharging the Government on purpose) it can go criminal. If they want to pursue it of course.
- TDL 14y agoDefinitely a good point in that regard. Note: I certainly am not excusing this behavior; ethics matter.
- notJim 14y agoOr maybe, having been called out, they'll pay whatever it costs, and then fix it once, and it won't happen again? Sorry, but I'm not impressed by mindless cynicism.
- Alaskan005 14y agoAnyway, they were called out before being sued but did nothing about it. I am cynic because many big corps still have this attitude. See http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-18866018 http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-18866018 and http://www.latimes.com/business/money/la-fi-mo-hsbc-confirms-192-billion-settlement-in-moneylaundering-probe-20121211,0,487098.story http://www.latimes.com/business/money/la-fi-mo-hsbc-confirms...
- Shivetya 14y agoThis would be an issue if they were the only game in town, last time I checked they have some pretty stiff competition in package delivery, UPS being the one that comes to mind. Look at it this way, if they are overcharging for delivery but are still getting business then they are charging appropriately for their market.
- wting 14y agoThe presence of competition does not imply a fairly priced market, e.g. US telecom companies.
- paulgb 14y agoFedEx were sued for breach of contract. Presumably the plaintiffs shopped around and compared rates before entering a contract with FedEx.
- spoiledtechie 14y agoIf all companies that deal with governments should be sued for going over budget or charging too much after a contract was set in place, then federal contractors would all be in court.
- paulgb 14y agoThere's a difference between going over budget and systematically overcharging. A major government contract should have provisions for the former, but if someone systematically overcharges they should be in court.
- aptwebapps 14y agoNot all government contracts are the same. Many of them have provisions for going over budget.
- fleitz 14y agoIt's an issue of charging for a service that was not provided, doing something like this is called fraud when done intentionally. An officer of the company knowing about the issue and not doing anything about it would generally be the nail in the coffin.
- notJim 14y agoCan anyone explain this? If you tell me a candy bar costs $2 (e.g., that's the posted price), and then at the register, you actually charge me $10 and I don't say anything, can I sue you later? I realize that's a ridiculously simplified example, but it seems in principal/by analogy the same.
- DannyBee 14y agoLike anything in law, it depends. To answer, I'd first need a clearer example. Define "didn't say anything". Did you notice there was a problem, but didn't say anything Or did you not notice until later?
- debacle 14y agoBusinesses are huge, and contract law isn't that simple. The reality is that the person sending the package is not the person who brokers the relationship with FedEx - they're paid mailroom wages (10-15 an hour).
- ericcholis 14y agoClose, but not really the same. FedEx and UPS tack additional fees on to packages for various delivery scenarios. In this example, they were charging a "Residential" delivery fee for places that were clearly not residences. I'm not sure how it works with FedEx, but with UPS you can override this fee when creating the shipment...but you could get charged anyway as a correction on your bill.
- maratd 14y agoThat's far too simplistic. FedEx, UPS, and other couriers charge more for residential deliveries. This is fine, because it is more difficult to deliver to a residence. However, frequently, these couriers charge a base rate and then tack on a residential "surcharge" at a later time. Most shipments aren't paid for at the counter. You get a weekly bill. If you ship more than a few packages a week, it's very difficult to tell which surcharge is attached to which shipment. All they give you is a tracking number and unless you spend all day memorizing their tracking numbers, you won't know which end is up. Also, are you going to spend 15 minutes on the phone every time you get dinged for two bucks unfairly? No thanks. At this point, it's not so much ripping off ... everybody knows it's happening. Just a hidden cost of shipping.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- Coax 14y agoWhen will the lawsuits begin?
- rsbrown 14y agoThere are businesses whose sole offering is a service to audit your shipping invoices to ensure that you are not being overcharged. One, started in Memphis in the late 90s to specifically audit FedEx deliveries, is now a division of IronData: http://transportation.irondata.com http://transportation.irondata.com
- bdcravens 14y agoI guess it'd be remiss of me to not link to Refund Retriever, the company I've developed software for: http://www.refund-retriever.com http://www.refund-retriever.com
- DavidBradbury 14y ago"The e-mails were unsealed yesterday in a class-action, or group, lawsuit claiming FedEx Corp. and FedEx Corporate Services Inc. overcharged commercial and government customers as much as $3 each for millions of packages delivered." Come on Bloomberg, don't talk to me like I'm five.
- the_economist 14y agoHaving run an import / distribution operation for over 10 years, I can say a high degree of confidence that this practice is widespread across the industry. The "mistakes" are frequent, and they error on the financial side of the freight company approximately 95% of the time.