10 ms·
Psy Makes $8.1 Million By Ignoring Copyright Infringements Of Gangnam Style
- kristopher 14y ago"Ignoring" might be too strong a word here. Licensing is in play, but they are not going after individual infringers.
- spin 14y agoFrom the article, some of his money comes from Youtube ads, which I don't think would exist if it weren't for traditional copyright laws. (ie, Youtube wouldn't be giving him a cut of the ad revenue if it weren't for copyright.) Still... Kudos to him for not using draconian enforcement, yet still making lots of money.
- andrewflnr 14y agoSimilarly, he wouldn't get any money from people making commercials without copyright law. They would simply rip it off without asking.
- njharman 14y agoThe point is; no one would being paying anything unless it got so popular. And, it was allowd to get so popular because no one pettily went after "small fry" infringers. They let (encouraged probably) it go "viral". Let it be mixed, shared, performed, Let it become part of our culture, almost in The Commons. And when it was good enough to be shared, massively, they reaped the just rewards.
- andrewflnr 14y agoRight, it's stupid to go after the small fry, but nor is this evidence that copyright in general should be abolished, as some think. The balance is somewhere in the middle.
- yeonhoyoon 14y agomaking the downloading & sharing songs easier and earning profits from live performances is the way to go for the music industry.
- camus 14y agook , let me enjoy your work for free , you should be lucky i'm sharing it ? let's apply that fact to developers then.
- unfed 14y agoUmm would you also pay to watch my live coding session?
- camus 14y agoif you are naked with 3 girls pouring some cream on you maybe ^_^ .
- Kim_Bruning 14y agoYes, that's where it started. :-)
- Natsu 14y agoYou're talking to an audience where the average person has a Github account and loves FOSS.
- sp332 14y agoThat argument has been used for about 4 decades now http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Open_Letter_to_Hobbyists http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Open_Letter_to_Hobbyists and yet corporations still contribute huge amounts of code to free and open-source projects. e.g. http://www.linuxfoundation.org/news-media/announcements/2012/04/linux-foundation-releases-annual-linux-development-report http://www.linuxfoundation.org/news-media/announcements/2012...
- smackfu 14y agoI think the current YouTube system is pretty good. YouTube detects you are using copyrighted music, and the copyright owner can choose to block it or allow it but gets the money for the ads. Most of them seem to be choosing the second.
- zlotty 14y agoNote to self: it's as simple as creating the most popular YouTube video of all time. Done and done. Say you're independent and have a decent hit -- 100,000 views. Earnings: $870.
- Danieru 14y ago100,000 views isn't much. I think my silly videos of Sid Meier's Railroads[1][2] have more than that. These are things I put together in a day and edited in windows movie maker. When youtube offered adding ads I ignored them thinking it would never amount to anything. At $8.7 ECPM I feel absurd having skipped the chance! For an independent band 1k means vital equipment and capital to sell fan goods. For a "Let's play" gamer it means a better microphone and subsidizes the cost of games. Many large websites run on rates far lower, and those have to provide their own traffic. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zYgCwYfVkQ8&list=UUQ7Hrhc5iE7qzLldCKGdU9w&index=9 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zYgCwYfVkQ8&list=UUQ7Hrh... [2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fUXL-zua9ho&list=UUQ7Hrhc5iE7qzLldCKGdU9w&index=10 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fUXL-zua9ho&list=UUQ7Hrh...
- gabemart 14y ago>These are things I put together in a day and edited in windows movie maker. When youtube offered adding ads I ignored them thinking it would never amount to anything. At $8.7 ECPM I feel absurd having skipped the chance! Presumably, you would not be able to show ads on those videos because they use IP you don't have the rights to. They're popular (again, presumably) because people search for footage of those copyright games and enjoy the first copyright music track. It's fairly easy to put something together "in a day" that becomes popular when you're not constricted by the rules of copyright and can piggyback on the popularity of existing content. I'm not criticizing - I have a viral video on youtube that's within spitting distance of a million views, but I would never be able to show ads on it because I don't have permission to use the footage or the music. And yes, it seems that presently most video games companies generally turn a blind eye to people posting footage from their games. But you'd be foolhardy indeed to start to rely on advertising revenue that was built entirely on the goodwill of a diverse group of for-profit companies. There are a host of semi- and fully-professional video game personalities whose livelihood could be shut down overnight if a few companies decided to enforce their copyrights.
- jQueryIsAwesome 14y agoLets do the math: 800 million views for 8 million dollars; so to make $8.000 you need 800.000 Youtube views... this is in no way an example for other artists; and "Gangman style" is a exception in music popularity grow, like "Asereje", "Macarena", "Smells like teen spirit" or "Mambo #5" (is just that YouTube didn't exist back then).
- zalew 14y agowhat's "Smells like teen spirit" doing on that list? Nirvana weren't one hit wonders.
- jaredsohn 14y agoThe list seems to be of very popular songs; it just so happens that many of the songs are one-hit wonders.
- rgbrenner 14y ago800mil/8mil=100 views per $ so to make $8, you would need 800 page views That's $10CPM, which is a very reasonable rate.
- tokenadult 14y agoThe song industry includes singer-songwriters, and it also includes specialist singers and specialist songwriters. A healthy industry will support people who create music but who do not necessarily perform it in public performances.
- npsimons 14y agoA healthy industry will support people who create music but who do not necessarily perform it in public performances. That's your opinion, and you're certainly entitled to it, but it doesn't make it true. While I don't want to discourage anyone composing/songwriting, keep in mind that separate singers and songwriters are what gave us Britney Spears, and the sheet music guild is at least as bad as RIAA (charging non-profit performing charities per performance for sheet music they've already paid for).
- w1ntermute 14y agoAs explained on The Verge[0], the internet has been essential to the rise of K-pop, and the K-pop industry is not nearly as strict about piracy as the American music industry is. 0: http://www.theverge.com/2012/10/18/3516562/k-pop-invades-america-south-korea-pop-music-factory http://www.theverge.com/2012/10/18/3516562/k-pop-invades-ame...
- ineedtosleep 14y agoThough I'm not really riding on the South Korean wave, I have a huge amount of respect for Korea's music labels (at least when it comes to how they release their content). If one takes a look at YouTube channels for the South Korean labels, the videos the provide are almost always high quality -- both in terms of actual video quality and content that they release (e.g. LOEN[1] and SMTOWN[2]). On the other side of the sea, you have Japan. From the US side, it seems that Japanese labels haven't been too generous with releasing their content overseas. Universal Music Japan has been the only big label (IMO) that has been great with releasing content. The other end of the spectrum, you have Sony Music...and they've been pretty quick to bring down videos as well. [1] https://www.youtube.com/user/LOENENT/videos?view=0 https://www.youtube.com/user/LOENENT/videos?view=0 [2] https://www.youtube.com/user/SMTOWN https://www.youtube.com/user/SMTOWN [3] https://www.youtube.com/user/universalmusicjapan https://www.youtube.com/user/universalmusicjapan [4] https://www.youtube.com/user/sonymusicnetwork https://www.youtube.com/user/sonymusicnetwork
- w1ntermute 14y ago> On the other side of the sea, you have Japan. From the US side, it seems that Japanese labels haven't been too generous with releasing their content overseas. As explained in this article by The Verge[0], the Japanese are still very much tethered to physical media. They regularly rent/buy CDs, DVDs, and Blu-ray discs, for reasons discussed in the article, which has kept profits high in the Japanese entertainment industry, compared to the West. Physical album sales have actually risen 11% in Japan in 2012, compared to 2011[1]. This, combined with the Japanese market's size and the almost complete absence of piracy there, has obviated the need for Japanese artists to embrace the internet or market their products abroad. Korea, on the other hand, has a much smaller population, and one for which piracy is a way of life. Korean artists are thus forced to market abroad, and in fact get 80% of their profits from Japan[1]. Among domestic Japanese groups, on the other hand, there has also been a reliance on various gimmicks to boost physical single and album sales. For example, AKB48, a girl pop group with dozens of members (originally 48 of them), holds yearly elections (senbatsu) to determine the order in which the members are ranked. You get one voting code for each physical copy of a particular single/album that you buy. There are crazy fans that will literally buy thousands of copies of a single CD in order to repeatedly vote for their favorite member, so that member wins[2,3]. 0: http://www.theverge.com/2012/11/15/3628376/japan-digital-content-ecosystem-hulu-country-future http://www.theverge.com/2012/11/15/3628376/japan-digital-con... 1: http://seoulbeats.com/2012/12/worry-for-the-right-reasons-k-pop-and-kohaku/ http://seoulbeats.com/2012/12/worry-for-the-right-reasons-k-... 2: http://blog.livedoor.jp/kinisoku/archives/3425353.html http://blog.livedoor.jp/kinisoku/archives/3425353.html 3: http://getnews.jp/archives/119107 http://getnews.jp/archives/119107
- ladzoppelin 14y agoGangnam Style is a horrible example of "... a shift in how money is being made in the music business". Psy deserves every bit of it but the popularity of that song is a freak incident.
- scotty79 14y agoI think same can be said about almost anything vastly popular.
- CamperBob2 14y agoAlong the same lines, it's interesting that not only has Constantin Film apparently stopped issuing DMCA notices on the Untergang (Downfall) parody videos, but some of the older ones that were previously DMCA'ed off of YouTube seem to have come back. Maybe it finally occurred to someone at Constantin how many viewers those unlicensed parodies have attracted to their excellent but otherwise obscure movie over the past few years. I posted one a couple of years ago, myself. It stayed up for about a year, then was yanked in response to a DMCA complaint from Constantin. About a year after that -- meaning just a few weeks ago -- I started getting notifications of user comments again. The video had magically reappeared on YouTube with no intervention or counterclaim on my part.
- GigabyteCoin 14y agoPerhaps YouTube has a re-inclusion program?
- chris_wot 14y agoI doubt it. That would most definitely violate the DMCA.
- EvilLook 14y agoDMCA counternotices violate the DMCA? See http://www.chillingeffects.org/question.cgi?QuestionID=132 http://www.chillingeffects.org/question.cgi?QuestionID=132
- GigabyteCoin 14y agoWhat if the original DMCA complainant noticed negative results form the DMCA and wished to reverse it? Surely that would be possible.
- bgentry 14y agoI recently watched this film on Netflix and it was great! I knew nothing about it before seeing some parodies pop up a few years back.
- jamesmcn 14y agoDevil's advocate: where do you draw the line? MIT did a Gangnam style video, did they pay Psy for the right to do so? If BMW were to do a Gangnam style video, surely Psy would expect to be paid, right? Why BMW and why not MIT? We are in a liminal period where copyright is sometimes enforced, and sometimes not. Social pressure and business inertia causes some people to play by the rules. Risk taking, greed, and ignorance causes other people to not do so. Where this ends up is anyone's guess, but it isn't likely to stay this way for long. [That said, I'll reiterate my previous comment about record labels who bring hundred-million-dollar suits against their fans: fuck them.]
- primatology 14y agoBMW is a for-profit business. MIT is a non-profit educational institution. I'll agree that copyright in the digital era is a mess, but the line in this case is fairly clear. Yes, fair use (regarding parodies/satires) is convoluted, but the general rule makes intuitive sense to me: unless your parody is blatantly for-profit/self-advancement, you're covered.
- jamesmcn 14y agoSo, what if BMW kicked the BMWCCA a few bills to make a "parody" video of their own?
- rmc 14y agoIt's up to judges to decide if they have broken the law and if it's an actual commercial. You can't just claim an advert is a parody and get away with it, it has to be an actual parody.
- gadders 14y agoA non-profit with $15b in total assets and endowments. http://web.mit.edu/newsoffice/2012/institute-endowment-figures-0914.html http://web.mit.edu/newsoffice/2012/institute-endowment-figur...
- 14y ago
- kyllo 14y agoHonestly, who (outside of Korea) would even buy an entire PSY record, though? I don't think album sales are a very big revenue stream for such a novelty act. Single-song downloads, advertisements, and talk show and event appearances are of course where the money is at for him. Nice to see that he isn't trying to "charge for smells" though.
- mxxx 14y agoThe article implies that if you just let anybody infringe on your copyright and play/use your work however they feel, it'll pay off in the long run because you gain exposure. Seems like a _reasonable_ assumption, but I don't really think that PSY is a good example. They mention he's been hired to do ads for Samsung, etc, but is that really a feasible endgame for the majority of artists? Quite apart from the fact that 0.00001% are going to ever be _asked_ to appear in commercials, how many would actually want to? Not exactly a shining example of artistic integrity, is it? I feel like they're kind of clutching at straws here, probably because articles like this are so popular with readers - have a browse through the comments to see how much everybody enjoys sticking the boot into the record companies. Anyway, good for him. It's nice to hear that there are other ways to be successful, I suppose.
- pretoriusB 14y ago>Psy Makes $8.1 Million By Ignoring Copyright Infringements Of Gangnam Style Really? Why not: "Psy Makes $8.1 Million DESPITE Ignoring Copyright Infringements Of Gangnam Style"
- josephlord 14y agoYep the old correlation is not causation fallacy with the correlation calculated from a single datapoint for extra validity. Now it may be that permissive distribution was key to the success but it is not shown by this article.
- shuzchen 14y agoBecause your edit implies that Psy's success was solely on the merits of his music video and official marketing, and that infringing parodies were not able to dent that success. The original (and the one I prefer) implies that Psy's success was due in part of the infringing parodies, because of the network effects created by these parodies.
- polymatter 14y agoOr just "Psy makes $8.1 million and has ignored copyright infringements of Gangnam Style" which states the facts without putting a spin on it.
- chris_wot 14y agoBecause that's not the central thrust of the article. He has actually grown his fan base hugely by allowing copying, which is how he got to promote himself in ads, etc. outside of his music video. Your headline implies that the copying is still bad for him, and without I he would have been even more successful, but in fact that's no the case. If he had cracked down on copyright violations, his video probably wouldn't have gone viral (i.e. celebs saw it on YouTube in copyright violation form, they tweeted it, it went viral).
- tlianza 14y agoOr how about "Psy Makes ONLY $8.1 Million..." Is this a lot of money for the most viewed video in the history of the Internet and the most popular song worldwide?
- beerglass 14y agoAs a counterpoint, this letter from songwriter Tom Waits written over 10 years ago is a solid rebuttal to the practice of artists making money from commercials while giving away their copyrights for free. Here it goes - http://www.lettersofnote.com/2012/12/its-virus.html http://www.lettersofnote.com/2012/12/its-virus.html
- belorn 14y agoTom Waits sounds awful close to John Phillip Sousa testament before the US Congress 1906 if you swap talking machines with songs in commercials.
- illuminate 14y ago"When I was a boy . . . in front of every house in the summer evenings you would find young people together singing the songs of the day or the old songs. Today you hear these infernal machines going night and day. We will not have a vocal cord left. The vocal cords will be eliminated by a process of evolution, as was the tail of man when he came from the ape”" I really don't see how. Waits is making an appeal to art and integrity, Sousa is decrying the act and presentation of mechanical reproduction.
- darushimo 14y agoThis isn't a "new way" for artists to make money. This is how one-hit wonders bank off their popular songs. Hasn't changed.
- petrel 14y agoMicrosoft Windows has already gone in same way. Piracy has actually made Windows so popular and inevitable also. You can not ignore and you can not live without Windows, atleast for now. Here in India, computing is a Windows though the most of the PC are running on pirated Windows. Piracy has it won benefits.
- madaxe 14y agoSurely if Psy condones piracy, the RIAA should be going after him with their black helicopters, ricin umbrellas and polonium pills. Wait, I've confused them with the NKVD, haven't I? Ah well, it'll do.
- mtgx 14y agoWasn't there a lot of "innovation" in jazz in the early days when it was very popular, because no one copyrighted their jazz songs? I remember watching something about this. I might've seen it in one of the Everything is a Remix videos: http://www.everythingisaremix.info/everything-is-a-remix-part-1/ http://www.everythingisaremix.info/everything-is-a-remix-par...
- laumars 14y agoThere's a similar case with dance (club) music. eg the "Amen Break": http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5SaFTm2bcac http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5SaFTm2bcac
- tjr 14y agoA lot of somewhat early jazz (bebop) initially used popular showtunes as the base composition, and then improvised solos off those. But precisely because of not wanting to deal with the copyright on the showtune compositions, jazz players began composing their own music. They used the same chord progressions so that the improvisations stayed the same, but a different melody, so it legally was a different piece of music.
- othello 14y agoThose $8.1 million did not come from Youtube advertisement: according to the original AP article, only $870,000 did. https://www.google.com/hostednews/ap/article/ALeqM5jlcpd0qGl9nCp3TCqM1DYdAgbzFQ?docId=b70ddece35724815a3fc351a7bb06c0b https://www.google.com/hostednews/ap/article/ALeqM5jlcpd0qGl... This estimate seems to be based on views for all of PSY's channel, i.e. 1.3 billion views. That works out as a $0.7 eCPM, which seems more credible than the $8 floated below in this thread.
- pixl97 14y ago"From just those sources, PSY and his camp will rake in at least $8.1 million this year, according to an analysis by The Associated Press of publicly available information and industry estimates. But for online music sales in South Korea, he'll earn less than $60,000." This is the important part of the article. He earns around US$0.00015 per song sold in his own country via online sales. He earns a hell of a lot more via Youtube and iTunes. What gets him up to 8M is other advertizing deals.
- 89a 14y agoDoesn't seem like much for something so huge
- marijn 14y agoHah. Tried opening the Youtube link in Germany. Got "Unfortunately, this video is not available in Germany because it may contain music for which GEMA has not granted the respective music rights." The GEMA situation is completely out of control here -- it often feels like half of Youtube is blocked, including many things that obviously don't infringe.
- akie 14y agoInstall ProxMate or ProxTube to get around this.
- meerita 14y agoJust wait he rans out of money. Then it will become a copytroll :)