4 ms·
Is the idea that a code base reset makes something stop being open source? Or that the number of people doing the reset matters? I don't see why either of tho
by Dylan16807 3mo ago
Is the idea that a code base reset makes something stop being open source? Or that the number of people doing the reset matters?
I don't see why either of those would be true. The project isn't dead just because it's in a different language now, and for liveness purposes it doesn't matter how it got to that different language.
- avianlyric 3mo agoI think the point is that an “open source project” is more than just the code and license, it’s also the community that builds and maintains it. A fast rewrite of Bun in Rust has effectively alienated most of the people in the Bun community, so in that sense the “open source project” has died. It’s no longer a community project, it’s just become a personal project again.
- Dylan16807 3mo agoA reset is very different from not being open source any more. If losing most of the community would mark a project dead in open source terms, then every new project would be dead on arrival. And that would just be silly.
- Tadpole9181 3mo agoJust so everyone know, Bun is and has always been owned by a YC funded org with full time employees. The overwhelming majority of commits came from them.