3 ms·
It's important to remember this is for TEDx, which can be put on by some small, humble groups. My city (hardly a scientific or academic hub) just held a TEDx an
by 1123581321 14y ago
It's important to remember this is for TEDx, which can be put on by some small, humble groups. My city (hardly a scientific or academic hub) just held a TEDx and the planning committee was only able to secure one talk from someone outside of the planning committee and its immediate circle. If someone outside the area peddling bunk had applied, the committee would have probably not looked over them too closely. Additionally, the bulk of the committee members would not have had the knowledge to evaluate the scientific claims. Guidelines such as having a degree in the field about which the topic is concerned, publishing peer-reviewed and others are bright lights to help guide people who cannot discern the quality of the actual content and lack the motivation to spend a lot of time trying to find faults in a presenter.
Organizers of prestigious TEDx events, and of TED itself, have many more interesting submissions to choose from and are more qualified and more motivated to examine the quality of submitted talks, so the selection committees are more easily able to welcome quality extra-disciplinary presentations and minority opinions because they can sufficiently evaluate the actual content to be presented.
- pharrington 14y agoExactly. I think alot of the kneejerk reactions to this post are because people don't know the context of TEDx events. The post suggests these guidelines (and they are just that, guidelines, not rules) and gives warnings about reiki and free energy and crystals because quality control has been thin to non-existent, and fraudsters giving BS presentations is a real problem.
- SilasX 14y agoI've also seen cases of legitimate science that is nonetheless way too out-dated and unsurprising. For example, one TEDx speaker presented a bold, "game-changing" (eye-roll) presentation on how charging for roads at peak times reduces traffic. Wow, charging for a scarce good ... why didn't I think of that???