14 ms·
A letter to the TEDx community on TEDx and bad science
- ypeterholmes 14y ago"Marks of bad science: Has failed to convince many mainstream scientists of its truth" This is wrong. From Copernicus to Einstein to many others, agreeing with the "mainstream" has very little to do with science.
- Symmetry 14y agoNobody agree with Einstein and few with Copernicus before they published there work, but both were able to convince many mainstream scientists quite rapidly. In Copernicus's case not a majority, but to be fair he was fighting political oppression that doesn't exist today. And despite his theory's elegance (and ultimate truth) it was less successful at predicting the positions of planets in the heaven's than the overfited theories of his opponents with their epicycles. It wasn't until Kepler figured out how planets actually moved in ellipses (not perfect circles) that heliocentric theories provided superior experimental predictions to geocentric ones.
- driverdan 14y agoThis is a list of potential red flags. The vast majority of people making claims that aren't accepted by mainstream science are wrong. The small percentage that are correct need to convince the scientific community before presenting at a conference like TED or TEDx.
- sdafdasdfasdf 14y ago"Marks of good science: ... It does not fly in the face of the broad existing body of scientific knowledge" Um... that's not very progressive science. So, the sun revolves around us, right?
- jerf 14y agoFirst, there's a continuum here, with perpetual motion and crystals on one end, and "bacteria cause ulcers" on the other. We aren't required to toss out all judgment just because some bits of the line may be true. I myself have some beliefs that I would currently put around "bacteria cause ulcers" on the line, but that doesn't mean I have to believe in crystal healing. Second, this is not a scientific forum. It's an educational one. It is not particularly obligated to give equal airing to any ideas. The ones in the "bacteria cause cancer" area can make for very interesting talks, especially if the presenter passes the test mentioned in the article (secure enough to acknowledge doubts), but if they choose to close the door on those so they can avoid crystal healing, that's a fine and valid choice.
- fatbird 14y agoAgreed, and I'd go further than you in saying that TEDx has a duty not to try to lead scientific discussion or research by presenting cutting edge information. They rightly identify that they have a role as a credible purveyor of science, but lack the domain expertise to do more than popularize the scientific consensus. Which is fine: If they do nothing more than make the current consensus more easily available to everyone, that's a worthwhile activity in itself.
- skylan_q 14y agoWhat also bothered me is the notion that consensus determines what's good science. (If we all agree to something, then it must be true!)
- Symmetry 14y agoGood science isn't identical to the truth. Rather, science is a social process whereby large groups of imperfect humans with their various vanities and weaknesses can eventually converge on the truth. Someone might come up with an idea that happens to be true, but until it's tested it isn't good science - and we have easy way to know it's true.
- Aykroyd 14y agoRight. It's a tricky line to walk. But the TedX name grants a certain level of mainstream acceptance to ideas. And it seems like they're trying to prevent people from taking advantage of that to pimp their latest miracle, effort free, libido enhancing, hair increasing, bicep growing treatment. An earlier comment mentioned that it's a question of what's the right forum to debate new ideas. Going to direct to the public is probably not the right one. Another hallmark of these hoaxes tends to be the notion that "main stream scientists don't want you to know" etc... It's trash. I wish the letter had ended by admitting that it's tough to exactly define bad science but it's a lot like porn, you know it when you see it.
- fatbird 14y agoFor a popularizer of science, sticking to current consensus is fine, and a good way to avoid promoting pseudoscience. No one's claiming TEDx is the last word on these topics, or on science in general, and if they accomplish nothing more than making mainstream science more accessible, that's pretty good by itself.
- rscale 14y agoScientific consensus isn't "we believe"; it's "the results of widespread, independent, carefully executed, controlled experiments show." Further, it doesn't mean that it "must be true" but rather that it is more likely to true.
- Symmetry 14y agoTEDx talks aren't science, they're popularization. Whereas investigating new and untried ideas scientifically is important, promulgating them to laymen isn't. When Galileo made his discoveries he didn't start handing out pamphlets in the city square, he worked to persuade other astronomers first. It isn't as if scientific discourse is off limits to non-professionals. Many journals are free, and you can probably get most at a good public library. But if you find journals to be too hard to read, then you don't know enough about the field to usefully have an opinion on heterodox viewpoints in it.
- btilly 14y agoWhen Galileo made his discoveries he didn't start handing out pamphlets in the city square, he worked to persuade other astronomers first. And when he failed at that, he did the equivalent of handing out pamphlets in the city square - he wrote a popular book. That is what he got punished for. See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dialogue_Concerning_the_Two_Chief_World_Systems http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dialogue_Concerning_the_Two_Chi... for the book.
- ricardobeat 14y agoThe thing that makes TED(x) interesting is the broad range of topics, new ideas and unknown facts being presented, even if they are on the fringe of science. It's supposed to provoke thought, questioning and insights. If instead it becomes just another platform for established, proven ideas, what makes it different from a guest speaker round in a local school?
- bathat 14y agoNow granted, I'm still in (probably) the first third of my life, but one thing I've come to realize is that there is too much stuff for me to learn. Even if all I ever did was sit in a room and learn stuff, I would never learn it all. Not just that, but if I sat in a room and learned only the interesting stuff, I'd still probably croak from natural causes before finishing. And even if that was all I did, why would I want to just sit in a room learning stuff if I never had time to apply it and build interesting things? Maybe you learn faster than me. So be it. But, given all that--that I don't even have enough time in my life to learn all the interesting, no, fascinating, things that are so boring as to be considered the current scientific consensus--why should I want to waste my time listening to things that are likely to be bullshit? I don't. I don't have time for bullshit, and neither should you. But the thing is this: Just because you exclude the bullshit it doesn't follow that you can't have talks that cover the cutting edge of research in science and the humanities.
- napoleond 14y agoIt's basically impossible for people outside the scientific community related to a specific field to independently test or verify extremely progressive science in that field; if scientists working in that field are unable or unwilling to validate extremely progressive theories that is a separate problem from the fact that, to the layman, those theories are entirely indistinguishable from pseudo-science. I can understand why an organisation like TED would prefer to err on the side of false positives over true negatives when it comes to their bullshit detector.
- greenyoda 14y ago"It's basically impossible for people outside the scientific community related to a specific field to independently test or verify extremely progressive science in that field..." That's not necessarily true. For example, a statistician may not know anything about biology or medicine, but she could prove that a paper in a biomedical research journal was worthless by showing that the authors didn't get statistically significant results or made errors in their statistical computations. Or someone with no knowledge of the field at all could notice that a paper that was cited as a supporting reference for a claim had been later withdrawn by its authors after being busted for scientific misconduct.
- nollidge 14y ago99.9999% of scientific discovery is incremental progress. Even general relativity didn't throw out Newton's work - it just added an entire new dimension to it (so to speak).
- protomyth 14y agoSo, discuss the next Willow bark extract at a different forum first.
- Symmetry 14y agoI suspect you're being sarcastic or flippant there, but yes that is precisely what you should do if you've got a new Willow bark extract. Some forum with the sort of medical expertise to compare your extract to current treatments.
- protomyth 14y agoNot really being sarcastic or flippant, willow bark extract figures prominently in the history of aspirin and I would suspect something similar might happen again. I would suggest picking a different forum. Personally, given the list, I would think TEDx would be better off discussing anything but science. It would save on staff time and possible future embarrassment. There are many topics that could fill the gap that don't often have a forum.
- Symmetry 14y agoYes, I know how willow bark extract relates to aspirin. And if you think you've made a similarly important medical discovery you really shouldn't be making TED talks, but rather publishing in a journal first, and then maybe founding a medical startup to produce a medicine based on it. Until you've demonstrated that you can actually make a safe and effective medicine based off of your discovery there really isn't much point in doing a TED or TEDx talk.
- protomyth 14y agoand that's what I said - twice - don't use TEDx for the next science discovery I happened to use "willow bark extract" as my example because it would have been a red flag in the guidelines and last month was "Native American Heritage Month" in the US and it happened to come up as a bit of trivia. I really don't know what you seem to think I am saying other than repeating what I said as some opposition. Whatever point seems to resonate with someone given my down votes.
- jhawk28 14y agoThis removes any talks related to evolution unless it is "micro evolution": "Is not based on experiments that can be reproduced by others"
- estel 14y agoIt doesn't remove those talks at all, it says that these are factors to consider when trying to determine if a talk is likely to perpetuate a hoax or not. Just because there are exceptions to any of these flags doesn't mean they aren't valid criteria.
- splawn 14y ago"experiments that can be reproduced by others" is just one example of a theory making a prediction, imo. Effects of "macro evolution" (macro vs micro is usually a distinction only made by creationists) have made such predictions. Here is a famous example: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Xanthopan_morgani http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Xanthopan_morgani
- tokenadult 14y agoThe scientific theory of macroevolution makes a series of interconnected testable predictions, all of which have held up as new natural history discoveries and controlled experiments have been made over the last century and a half. http://www.talkorigins.org/faqs/comdesc/ http://www.talkorigins.org/faqs/comdesc/
- mogrim 14y agoEscherichia coli. Go look it up.
- evv 14y agoI hate the phrase "bad science." Can't we just call this not science?
- marekmroz 14y agoPseudoscience would also work, and is easier to say than non-science.
- hdctambien 14y agoI agree with ChuckMcM's comment above, but I like how "non-science" sounds like "nonsense" when you say it out loud.
- ChuckMcM 14y agoExcept a number of these folks think of themselves as doing "science" they have "experiments" and "controls" and "theories" and more confirmation bias than is healthy. But they miss the bit about the 'review' and 'challenge' aspects of 'Good' science. There is "bad science" done by earnest people, just like there is "bad music" created by earnest musicians. Properly labeling it as "bad" indicates that with work it can become "good" through better education about the scientific method, labeling it as "psudeo" dismisses the work outright and thus discourages folks who might actually have something from learning how to test whether or not they really do.
- sunwooz 14y ago"Holds a nonstandard degree. For instance, if the physics-related speaker has a degree in engineering, not physics; if the medical researcher does not have an M.D. or Ph.D.; if the affiliated university does not have a solid reputation. This is not snobbery; if a scientist truly wishes to make an advance in their chosen field, they’ll make an effort to engage with other scholars" What? Not having a degree in something disallows you to "make an effort to engage with other scholars"? Just saying you're not snobbery does not make it "not snobbery".
- jpdoctor 14y ago> For instance, if the physics-related speaker has a degree in engineering, not physics; Yeah, that set off my WTF alarm too. I don't think it's news to TED admins that the line between physics and engineering is messy (I worked on quantum devices but (surprise!) engineering degrees paid substantially more in the 80s so my PhD is engineering.) I'm gonna guess there's a backstory and they got burned hard.
- jlgreco 14y agoNo so much a back-story as several back-stories all with the common theme of quacks, sometimes with degrees in irrelevant fields, making plainly false claims.
- theorique 14y agoLikewise - my PhD is engineering, but my advisor was cross-appointed and I published primarily in Physics journals. Any due diligence done by a TEDx committee should find this, though.
- bryze 14y agoAlong the same vein: "The proposed speaker works for a university and/or has a phD or other bona fide high level scientific qualification". Many of the points they list are valid, but this conspicuous appeal to authority makes me much less inclined to watch the talks.
- 14y ago
- dpapathanasiou 14y agoIronically enough, the current issue of Wired magazine has an article praising TED for creating the TEDx franchise and allowing anyone to use its brand: http://www.wired.com/business/2012/11/ff-tedx/ http://www.wired.com/business/2012/11/ff-tedx/
- omnisci 14y ago"It has been published in a peer reviewed journal (but beware… there are some dodgy journals out there that seem credible, but aren’t.)" Dodgy journals should be omitted from everything relating to science. It's a shame that many of them get picked up by the mass media and blown out of proportion. Also, the peer review system is so faulted that even bad studies make it into good journals due to politics. Thanks for the post OP, it continues to drive me to get my company started which will hopefully reduce the amount of "bad science" data out there.
- pbharrin 14y agoThe TED community is full of snobbery. HOWEVER: I'm glad they are blowing the whistle on pseudo science related to GMO food.
- zzzeek 14y agosome good articles and analysis regarding GMO, generally opposed to it as performed in practice (not necessarily in theory), from the Union of Concerned Scientists: http://www.ucsusa.org/food_and_agriculture/our-failing-food-system/genetic-engineering/ http://www.ucsusa.org/food_and_agriculture/our-failing-food-... > We see that the technology has potential benefits, but we are critics of its commercial application and regulation to date. GE has proved valuable in some areas (as in the contained use of engineered bacteria in pharmaceutical development), and some GE applications could turn out to play a useful role in food production. > However, its applications in agriculture so far have fallen short of expectations, and in some cases have caused serious problems. Rather than supporting a more sustainable agriculture and food system with broad societal benefits, the technology has been employed in ways that reinforce problematic industrial approaches to agriculture. Policy decisions about the use of GE have too often been driven by biotech industry PR campaigns, rather than by what science tells us about the most cost-effective ways to produce abundant food and preserve the health of our farmland. these are the real reasons GMO is better off being opposed, as long as companies like Monsanto are in charge of it.
- mseebach 14y agoThis is a political argument masked as a scientific one. Unless they have peer reviewed research to back up their opinion, it's irrelevant to the point of dishonesty (appeal to authority) that they are scientists.
- zzzeek 14y agoum. did you read any of the articles linked from that page. They are all based on factual evidence and peer-reviewed research. are you saying the union of concerned scientists just makes things up ? or that expert opinions are useless by the fact that they are opinions ? edit: here's a summation of much of what's linked from that page from wikipedia: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Genetically_modified_food_controversies#Yield http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Genetically_modified_food_contr... > In 2009 the Union of Concerned Scientists summarized numerous peer-reviewed studies on the yield contribution of genetic engineering in the United States. This report examined the two most widely grown engineered crops—soybeans and maize (corn).[211] The report found that engineered herbicide tolerant soy and maize did not increase yield at the national, aggregate level. Maize engineered with Bt insect resistance genes increased national yield by about 3 to 4 percent. Engineered crops increased net yield in all cases. The study concluded that in the United States, other agricultural methods have made a much greater contribution to national crop yield increases in recent years than genetic engineering. United States Department of Agriculture data record maize yield increases of about 28 percent since engineered varieties were first commercialized in the mid 1990s. The yield contribution of engineered genes has therefore been a modest fraction—about 14 percent—of the maize yield increase since the mid 1990s.
- SeanLuke 14y agoWhy not just peer-review the Tedx proposals?
- jpdoctor 14y agoWho will peer-review the peer reviewers?
- toddmorey 14y agoI'm curious if any knows of a particular talk that prompted this response. I did a brieft search but didn't uncover much.
- rm999 14y agoThe article links to a reddit thread that links to this thread: http://www.reddit.com/r/tedtalks/comments/1443ke/the_ted_name_is_being_dragged_through_the_mud_in/ http://www.reddit.com/r/tedtalks/comments/1443ke/the_ted_nam... It looks like the issue was with the speakers at a specific event, not just a specific talk.
- shrikant 14y agoThis probably didn't prompt the proposal (given that this speech was in June 2011), but at the time certainly contributed to the loss of TEDx credibility: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YtNRHo_AMfM http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YtNRHo_AMfM > Conventional medicine failed to help him, but an introduction to nutrition and alternative health care completely changed the quality of his life and health forever. A homeopathic doctor, Lindsey opened Home Nutrition Clinic in Santa Monica, California in 1985.
- DanBC 14y agoDepressing that a list of calm mostly common-sense suggestions is seen as some deeply flawed oppressive list. The HN kneejerk contrarianism is a bit frustrating.
- jlgreco 14y agoQuite so. They are not proposing a blacklist of all people without degrees in their subject matter.. they are presenting general guidelines to skepticism to a group of people (TEDx organizers) who seem to have forgotten their skeptics cap at home a few times too often. There should be nothing controversial about telling people to be on their toes when somebody without a relevant degree tries to tell you something fantastic.
- sliverstorm 14y agoYou may not have noticed, but HN is fairly negative about college degrees, so many people probably see the bit about degrees as a personal attack on their beliefs.
- reinhardt 14y agoThis. Not just their beliefs but their lack of said degrees.
- DanBC 14y agoBut on HN people tend to show their working, rather than using an irrelevant degree as a badge of authority. There's a difference between saying "I think this is the case; here's why I think it; it needs a bit of iteration" and "I have a degree (in X); here's the truth about Y; some people disagree but they are wrong; I tried to publish this on Z but they are controlled by shills of the big industry and they squashed my free speech rights".
- tokenadult 14y agoOther comments in this thread helpfully explain the context of these recommendations. The TEDx brand name is now used to label local events set up by busy volunteers who need criteria for evaluating speaking proposals. The majority of the criteria are sensible and helpful, but I see one criterion that is overly broad, as another subthread first noted. "Holds a nonstandard degree. For instance, if the physics-related speaker has a degree in engineering, not physics; if the medical researcher does not have an M.D. or Ph.D.; if the affiliated university does not have a solid reputation. This is not snobbery; if a scientist truly wishes to make an advance in their chosen field, they’ll make an effort to engage with other scholars." Well, unless what is meant here by "make an effort to engage with other scholars" is publish in the same peer-reviewed journals as the scholars with the expected credentials, this criterion sweeps up too many path-breaking scientists. I will give one famous example. James R. Flynn is a researcher on human intelligence who has had several peer-reviewed publications in Psychological Bulletin, the premier research journal on psychology in the United States. http://scholar.google.com/scholar?q=author%3AJames+author%3AR+author%3AFlynn+IQ&btnG=&hl=en&as_sdt=0%2C24 http://scholar.google.com/scholar?q=author%3AJames+author%3A... But Flynn's Ph.D. degree is in sociology, not in psychology. He looks at the discipline of psychology as an outsider, and it is precisely that outsider's view that helped him make a discovery missed by dozens of psychologists. He discovered that IQ scores have been rising in national populations all over the world during the last century, and that trend of rising raw scores on IQ tests is now called the "Flynn effect" in his honor. Here is what the late psychologist Arthur Jensen said about Flynn back in the 1980s: "Now and then I am asked . . . who, in my opinion, are the most respectable critics of my position on the race-IQ issue? The name James R. Flynn is by far the first that comes to mind." Modgil, Sohan & Modgil, Celia (Eds.) (1987) Arthur Jensen: Concensus and Controversy New York: Falmer. Here's what Charles Murray (all right, not a psychologist nor a geneticist) says in his back cover blurb for Flynn's book What Is Intelligence?: http://www.amazon.com/What-Intelligence-Beyond-Flynn-Effect/dp/0521741475 http://www.amazon.com/What-Intelligence-Beyond-Flynn-Effect/... "This book is a gold mine of pointers to interesting work, much of which was new to me. All of us who wrestle with the extraordinarily difficult questions about intelligence that Flynn discusses are in his debt." As psychologist N. J. Mackintosh (1998, p. 104) writes about the data Flynn found: "the data are surprising, demolish some long-cherished beliefs, and raise a number of other interesting issues along the way." Flynn has earned the respect and praise of any honest researcher who takes time to read the primary source literature. Robert Sternberg, Ian Deary, Stephen Pinker, Stephen Ceci, Sir Michael Rutter, and plenty of other eminent psychologists recommend Flynn's research. So, yes, sometimes "an effort to engage with other scholars" will happen after a scholar has already earned his last academic degree, and a scholar that has an important concept named after himself by people who have the standard degree will never have the standard degree for the field in which he made his mark. EDIT PROMPTED BY SECOND REPLY: I'll attempt to be clear here. If the TEDx criteria included "has never been published in any major journal related to their chosen field" rather than "holds a nonstandard degree" not related to their chosen field (to speak about), I might have fully agreed with the criteria from the get-go. But degrees are both an overinclusive criterion and an underinclusive criterion. In other words, using degrees as a criterion for vetting speakers lacks both sensitivity and specificity. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sensitivity_and_specificity http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sensitivity_and_specificity Instead, look at publications as the relevant criterion. A person who has peer-reviewed publications in a good-quality medical journal is competent to speak on the issues discussed in that person's publications, with or without a medical degree, while a person with the M.D. degree who has never published in anything but "alternative medicine" journals is not well qualified to speak about medicine. Publications matter more than degrees, as the example of James R. Flynn I gave in the original edit of this post shows. On the broader "demarcation problem" of distinguishing science from pseudoscience, a really valuable recently published book is The Pseudoscience Wars: Immanuel Velikovsky and the Birth of the Modern Fringe by Michael D. Gordin, http://www.amazon.com/dp/0226304426 http://www.amazon.com/dp/0226304426 which I found to be quite an interesting read, full of historical and ideological connections I had not heard about before. The author, a historian of science based at Princeton University, makes clear that demarcating between "science" and "pseudoscience" is not at all easy in any era. Reviewers generally like this book, as I did. http://www.timeshighereducation.co.uk/story.asp?storycode=421339 http://www.timeshighereducation.co.uk/story.asp?storycode=42... http://www.tnr.com/book/review/pseudoscience-wars-michael-gordin# http://www.tnr.com/book/review/pseudoscience-wars-michael-go... http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10000872396390444709004577651741918258080.html http://online.wsj.com/article/SB1000087239639044470900457765... http://www.lrb.co.uk/v34/n21/steven-shapin/catastrophism http://www.lrb.co.uk/v34/n21/steven-shapin/catastrophism
- jaredcwhite 14y agoWhy is it bad science to be radically questioning the status quo? For centuries many major scientific breakthroughs have been in spite of the dogma of the scientific community of its day. Statements like good science = "It does not fly in the face of the broad existing body of scientific knowledge" or bad science = "Has failed to convince many mainstream scientists of its truth" is just garbage. Sickening to me, in fact. Everything that so-called "fringe psuedoscientists" complain about in regards to the arrogant elitism of the self-proclaimed gatekeepers of science are validated with this kind of letter. Dislike.
- jlgreco 14y agoIt isn't "bad science" to be suggesting something radical... but it is suspicious. > "Everything that so-called "fringe psuedoscientists" complain about in regards to the arrogant elitism" Either you are not very familiar with the claims many psuedoscientists make about that, or you are using a very loose definition of "everything". There is no conspiracy to silence anybody. TED is just advocating very basic common sense and skepticism.
- lutusp 14y ago> Why is it bad science to be radically questioning the status quo? It's not bad science unless the "questioning" isn't accompanied by evidence. Science is not steered by authority, but by evidence. If you have authority but no evidence, scientists won't listen to you. Example Nobel Prizewinner Linus Pauling's claims about vitamin C and the common cold. If you have evidence but no authority, scientists will listen to you. Example Albert Einstein, who as a lowly patent clerk overthrew much of the physics of his day -- but only after evidence and observation began to support his theories. In science, evidence means everything, reputation means nothing. The greatest amount of scientific eminence is trumped by the smallest amount of scientific evidence.
- mogrim 14y ago> In science, evidence means everything, reputation means nothing. That's a bit optimistic, in the long run it may be true, but over shorter time periods reputation and authority often discourage proper criticism.
- 1123581321 14y agoIt's important to remember this is for TEDx, which can be put on by some small, humble groups. My city (hardly a scientific or academic hub) just held a TEDx and the planning committee was only able to secure one talk from someone outside of the planning committee and its immediate circle. If someone outside the area peddling bunk had applied, the committee would have probably not looked over them too closely. Additionally, the bulk of the committee members would not have had the knowledge to evaluate the scientific claims. Guidelines such as having a degree in the field about which the topic is concerned, publishing peer-reviewed and others are bright lights to help guide people who cannot discern the quality of the actual content and lack the motivation to spend a lot of time trying to find faults in a presenter. Organizers of prestigious TEDx events, and of TED itself, have many more interesting submissions to choose from and are more qualified and more motivated to examine the quality of submitted talks, so the selection committees are more easily able to welcome quality extra-disciplinary presentations and minority opinions because they can sufficiently evaluate the actual content to be presented.
- pharrington 14y agoExactly. I think alot of the kneejerk reactions to this post are because people don't know the context of TEDx events. The post suggests these guidelines (and they are just that, guidelines, not rules) and gives warnings about reiki and free energy and crystals because quality control has been thin to non-existent, and fraudsters giving BS presentations is a real problem.
- SilasX 14y agoI've also seen cases of legitimate science that is nonetheless way too out-dated and unsurprising. For example, one TEDx speaker presented a bold, "game-changing" (eye-roll) presentation on how charging for roads at peak times reduces traffic. Wow, charging for a scarce good ... why didn't I think of that???
- hoverkraft 14y ago"The neuroscience of [fill in the blank] — not saying this will all be non-legitimate, but that it’s a field where a lot of goofballs are right now". Love it.
- CarlosOnline 14y agoI value TED for bringing me new info. Sure some of it is not applicable, yet. However I am glad to see this info. As to its results, I take a wait and see attitude. As to the intentions be good this letter, I find it suspect. Frankly the critics should stay away from censoring TED.
- pella 14y agoIs Ignaz Semmelweis a TEDx compatible person? http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ignaz_Semmelweis http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ignaz_Semmelweis 'The Semmelweis reflex or "Semmelweis effect" is a metaphor for the reflex-like tendency to reject new evidence or new knowledge because it contradicts established norms, beliefs or paradigms.' http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Semmelweis_reflex http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Semmelweis_reflex
- wwalker3 14y agoWhen I saw the TEDx guys' caution about a "physics-related speaker [who] has a degree in engineering, not physics", it struck a bit of a nerve for me. My Ph.D. is in electrical engineering, not physics. I recently got a computational physics paper accepted in a peer-reviewed journal, and I'm hard at work on a second paper. And in a different world, I could speak at a conference and no one would have to worry about my bona fides. But I think the TEDx caution is well-founded. Engineers are often accustomed to knowing more about science than the average person. It can be very easy for them, with the best of intentions, to convince themselves and others that they know more than they really do. It's easy to think you've got some great new idea if you don't engage existing experts in the field via peer review and reading papers. This is not to say electrical engineers can't be authorities on physics topics -- quite the contrary! But I agree with the TEDx guys that it does merit a bit of extra checking, especially in their situation.
- lutusp 14y ago> Engineers are often accustomed to knowing more about science than the average person. It can be very easy for them, with the best of intentions, to convince themselves and others that they know more than they really do. I agree, but that's true of scientists also, many of whom have a very narrow specialty in modern times and may not be qualified to speak outside their field of expertise. Example Nobel Prizewinner William Shockley and his now-infamous lectures on the topic of race: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/William_Shockley#Statements_about_populations_and_genetics http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/William_Shockley#Statements_abo... BTW I agree with you that one can make too much of a person's degree, especially when compared to actually understanding the topic to be discussed.
- likpok 14y agoThere was some discussion a while ago about the tendency of Nobel prizewinners to go off into crazyland (see Linus Pauling, others [1]). I recall hearing some speculation that this was (somewhat) inherent to getting a prize. I think the willful ignorance of established thought (to make the great discovery) plus the feedback loop of the prize made Nobel winners uniquely confident in their more off-the-wall theories. [1]: http://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Nobel_disease http://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Nobel_disease
- mansoor-s 14y agoNo moere "'Free energy' and perpetual motion machines, alchemy, time travel" ? Well... I no longer have any reason to watch ted videos
- _pferreir_ 14y agoThis was inevitable. I've seen several speakers of dubious credibility in local TEDx events. Not necessarily people advocating unscientific things, but clearly individuals whose authority in their field of work has yet to be proven. It would be just a matter of time till TEDx became a perfect stage for self-help gurus and bad science in general. I like the idea of spreading the TED philosophy to local communities, but they should try to make a clear distinction between the "official" TED events and TEDx. I believe most people end up thinking it's the same thing (I've seen it happen IRL). Otherwise, just follow up with the local communities more closely. In the end, it's the TED brand that loses credibility. It's a pity since it's been doing a really nice job in the "Pop science" front...