5 ms·
please explain how a truly fiat currency without a national bank defending it against wild speculation is better than the currently existing alternatives? i und
by baq 14y ago
please explain how a truly fiat currency without a national bank defending it against wild speculation is better than the currently existing alternatives? i understand the desire of creator and all miners to be able to easily liquidate their bitcoins, but i don't understand why other people would want something like this. could somebody point out what i'm missing?
- duaneb 14y agoDigital cash is pretty powerful. Drugs, illegal activity, probably money laundering.
- kirian 14y agoAlso accept payments from any where in the world, lower fees, financial privacy, open protocol allowing open competition. Many, many positives, not just illicit reasons.
- superuser2 14y ago> financial privacy I agree with you on simplifying payment processing, but what exactly is financial privacy good for except tax evasion? Is there an epidemic of Visa/Mastercard/AMEX selling purchase histories to advertisers or something? Isn't that illegal?
- mahyarm 14y agoWhat good is it to not let people know how much you make, how much is in your bank account or not wear a rolex in a ghetto? Tax evasion is not the only reason why you want your finances private.
- lmm 14y ago>What good is it to not let people know how much you make, how much is in your bank account or not wear a rolex in a ghetto? It helps protect the establishment and preserve the status quo. That's about it. It would be in most people's interest for these things to be public.
- laSeek 14y agoPrivacy is privacy - you don't know how important it is until you don't have it. The main payment processors operate a mafia of sorts - it's a closed shop - tx fees are fixed and determined by them. One aspect of bitcoin is that is allows the person sending a payment & the person processing that payment (the mining pools) to negotiate the price. The theory being that transactions with a better tx fee will be included in blocks quicker than those that don't. By freeing up these aspects of the systems we use to send & receive payment - you allow other forces to come into play.
- laSeek 14y agoUSD has been the currency of choice for decades for this.. What's the difference? Cash is anon as cryptocoins are.
- jlgreco 14y agoCan't shove a dollar bill down a Cat 5 cable. If you could, I am sure few people would have bothered with crypto-currencies, or for that matter, paypal...
- duaneb 14y agoSending cash is slow, prone to failure (compared to bitcoin, at least), and still potentially trackable.
- laSeek 14y agoBitcoin is slow - the accepted "confirmation" for a payment is 6 confirmations - best case (a tx just before a block is formed and it's included in the block) it'll take an hour. Worst case it's a couple of hours. If you're sane and keep backups then your wallet is safe.. Your HD crashes and you don't have backup.. bye bye funds. Bitcoin in many ways is equiv to cash - just electronic - it's an anon as cash is, as mutable as cash and prone to loss if you don't take care of it. I like it - as a concept it has some nice attributes.
- finnw 14y ago> probably money laundering. If you want to launder money, it's extremely stupid to use a form of digital cash in which all transactions are public and any amateur data miner can have a go at tracing the transactions.
- brian_cloutier 14y agoTo add to this point, bitcoin transactions are not just public, they're permanently verifiable. By making a transaction with an address you're not just telling anybody who knows you own that address that you've made a transaction; you've allowed anyone who later discovers you owned that address to prove you made that transaction, for the rest of history.
- Permit 14y agoCouldn't you launder them through places like Silk Road? Set up a number of fake buyer/seller accounts and complete fake trades. I think the transactions go through a centralized escrow account which means they'd get mixed up with other people's? If you made your transactions equal in price to those of other users, it would make it pretty difficult to tell how the coins moved in and out.
- dmix 14y agoIt's called bitcoin tumbling. There a quite a few services that obscure the transfer of bitcoins by trasnfering randomized amounts to hundreds of different wallets before sending it to a central account. But as someone pointed out in another HN thread, there is always a risk the tumbling service could be a legal risk if it's even taken over by a state entity, because they could technically know which wallets are being used.
- narrator 14y agoWhen someone sends bitcoins and is provided with a product or service they cannot ask for more of that product or service unless they have provided a product or service that some other member of the bitcoin community deems worthy of their bitcoins. This is not the case with fiat money where governments can print money and demand you take it in exchange for products and services. In high inflation economies like Argentina for example where foreign currency is strictly controlled, people are starting to save in bitcoin to preserve their wealth. I've heard that one can get a very good exchange rate for bitcoins in Argentina.
- Dylan16807 14y agoI..what? Nobody can demand you take anything in exchange for products and services. The meaning of legal tender is that you have to take it for debt, but nothing forces you to be a debtor, or to do business with anyone at all. The only way the government can hurt you with money is to devalue it by printing too much.
- transpostmeta 14y agoAnd with bitcoins, nobody can print money. That is the advantage.
- jlgreco 14y agoWell no, anybody can print money, but only at predetermined rate.
- mtgx 14y agoThe value of Bitcoin is also rising much faster than its tiny "inflation" that comes from mining more Bitcoins right now, therefore, even though Bitcoin hasn't reached its maximum number, it still doesn't have inflation right now.
- bencoder 14y agoMostly you're correct, but not entirely: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eminent_domain http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eminent_domain
- noarchy 14y agoI know that for some, bitcoin seems to be a solution looking for a problem. But there are those for whom the idea of a currency that is disconnected from a national bank is very attractive. The idea of a "free money" (free as in freedom) has long been a dream of many anarchists/libertarians. This is not to suggest that Bitcoin is a final answer to that issue, but it has proven that the concept has a chance to succeed in the real world, and not just in the writings of idealists.
- dmix 14y ago> has long been a dream of many anarchists/libertarians Crypto-anarchism to be exact. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crypto-anarchism http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crypto-anarchism
- noarchy 14y agoAnarchists such as Benjamin Tucker were advocates of "free money" at least as far back as the 19th century. Of course there was no way for them to have imagined an implementation like Bitcoin.
- jdlshore 14y agoSpeaking purely from a business perspective, if I implemented support for accepting BitCoin in my subscription service, it would be for two reasons: lower transaction costs and potential publicity with my target audience. I can't speak for others, but both of those (particularly the former) make /accepting/ BC interesting to me. Although, admittedly, not so interesting that I'm seriously pursuing it yet. The more traction BC gets, the higher it goes on my priority list.
- foxylad 14y agoThis. As a non-US entity, we pay a substantial tax to PayPal/Visa/Mastercard for US-denominated payments. I don't mind paying taxes to the government for civilisation, but I do object paying large corporates for what is in essence toggling two numbers in the bank's database. Bitcoin could potentially increase efficiency of almost every business by up to 5%. From my (admittedly naive) viewpoint, the elephant in the room is the anonymity. Governments won't like this because it makes it harder for them to monitor and catch bad people, and to ensure I'm paying my taxes. So when governments become aware of bitcoin there is going to be huge pressure to shut it down. And they could do it, no matter how decentralised and trans-national bitcoin is. Imagine MAFIAA tactics but ten times worse, with constant media reports of how bitcoin is the currency of the terrorists and child pornographers. But that's where this announcement is exciting. By tying your bitcoin address to a bank account, you lose anonymity but gain legitimacy. And governments then have the option to selectively legislate, instead of simply killing bitcoin completely. Interesting times...