7 ms·
Soliciting donations for something you made using someone else's IP without permission seems like it is absolutely crossing the line. This is a cool demo and I
by kevingadd 14y ago
Soliciting donations for something you made using someone else's IP without permission seems like it is absolutely crossing the line. This is a cool demo and I like the trend of people porting classic games to the browser, but you absolutely shouldn't have a 'give me money for this' button sitting there. It's just asking for trouble.
- yebyen 14y agoBut they're going to need that money to pay the lawyer/settlement...
- adventureloop 14y agoThe precedent is in place. Prior to the release of C&C4 EA release the original games for free online. Many different sites have hosted the files, everyone I have seen has had ads.
- rprasad 14y agoThat's not how copyright works. Copyright is specific to the manifestation. EA gave its blessing for sites to host the game install files as part of its promotion. EA does not appear to have given its permission to host this game. As long as this game is merely a tech demo, it is arguably covered by fair use to some degree (i.e., as educational). However, once you add in attempts to derive revenue the fair use analysis tips toward commercial considerations which are far less forgiving.
- belorn 14y agoDonations does not automatically mean a for-profit venture, nor does it has any affect on the legality of the use of the work in regard to fair use. Fair use in the US, as any legal interpenetration can only be made in a local sense, the fair use in the US has some prior cases where the affect on the market is used to determine if a fair use case is valid or not, but that doesn't require money to change hand.
- smartwater 14y agoCollecting any amount of money changes the entire situation. If you're making money off their stuff, they care a whole lot more. Also, making money from it leaves a trail. Just follow the money.
- rprasad 14y agoDonations does not automatically mean a for-profit venture, nor does it has any affect on the legality of the use of the work in regard to fair use. Donations do not mean a for-profit venture, but collecting cash for distributing someone else's IP does change the (1) how the IP holder will respond and (2) how the courts weight the fair use factors. The fair use factors are not determinative; it is a balancing test that looks at all the facts and circumstances surrounding the use of someone else's IP. Fair use in the US, as any legal interpenetration can only be made in a local sense, the fair use in the US has some prior cases where the affect on the market is used to determine if a fair use case is valid or not, but that doesn't require money to change hand. IP law is not as local as you think it is. All parties to the Berne Convention must honor the IP rights of an IP holder belonging to any other Berne signatory. In other words, the law of American copyright belongs to works created by American citizens, in any other nation which signed the Berne Convention (which is every nation that matters). Effect on the market is not a factor of the fair use test; that is a factor for determining the amount of damages to award for a violation of IP rights. But attempting to commercialize or otherwise monetize the distribution of someone else's IP is a factor that courts look at.
- Strshps1MoreTim 14y agoGood think people like Isaac Newton (standing on the shoulders of giants) did not know about IP, or the humankind would still live in caves.
- danso 14y agoThat's a bit of a simplification of the whole IP debate. It's not an either-or thing.
- Strshps1MoreTim 14y agoSo you're saying: "It's very complicated, you won't understand my arguments." It is simple, IP laws lead to slower development of science and industry and accumulation of huge amounts of money and power in the hands of a few. Classical example is 19th and early 20th century British Empire - it's IP laws are what to a big degree allowed US and Germany to catch up and surpass it.
- danso 14y agoI don't think America surpassing Britain in any category was solely due to copyright laws. I would bet it was more of an issue of the UK absorbing a huge brunt of the wartime activity during that period. To use two Asian countries: it's my understanding that Japan has had a lot of technological success while at the same time employing copy-protection practices (from what I remember in my Nintendo days). China is not at Japan's development stage yet but do you believe China, barring a change in how they enforce copyright, will be as much of an innovations leader as Japan was in its heyday?
- TeeDub 14y ago>"I don't think America surpassing Britain in any category was solely due to copyright laws." This may be incorrect, at least for one category (literature). There's actually some really interesting lit that argues that lax/nonexistent copyright laws of the revolutionary period are the reason that the publishing industry ever took off in America. And these same laws, it could be argued, are how American literature got its start. (Sorry, this is skeevy, but I can't remember the title of the book that articulates this argument for the life of me... Will post it if it comes to me.) As to your second argument: Are there other aspects of Japanese society that could influence their innovation that go beyond intellectual property? I'm not going to deny that IP protections could play a role in innovation, but I could certainly imagine two countries with identical IP regimes having RADICALLY different levels of innovation. (Education, culture, etc could all create positive impacts on innovation... and these effects may even outweigh any effect produced by an IP regime.) Are there any metrics for innovation as a whole? This would be an interesting thing to look into...