4 ms·
Alpha Colony fails to meet Kickstarter funding goal by $28
- petercooper 14y agoAw, if I'd known about this I would have kicked in. I guess publicity and outreach is a problem with Kickstarter campaigns as much as anything else.
- njharman 14y agoFunding goals for (all KS I've contributed to) are bare, bare minimums. Better to miss by $28, than make it by $28.
- goldfeld 14y agoActually, I've read somewhere that a really low percentage of projects are substantially overfunded.
- rdl 14y agoMost kickstarters are someone's small art project or something, though. The only ones "we" really care about are the big ones like Pebble. (I've also funded small art projects of my friends, but I wouldn't expect the greater community to really care about them.)
- eropple 14y agoThe thing is, for games at least, "overfunded" is probably closer to "the right funding." It's a balancing act - you often can't really-really ask for the amount you actually need, because fewer people will put money in, but if you aren't overfunded you end up in a situation where you may not actually be able to make it at all. The whole thing ends up predicated on being the Big Popular Kickstarter that goes over budget and it really sucks. I think that maybe having two numbers on a Kickstarter page would be a good idea: "Minimum Funding LEvel" and "Optimal Funding Level", or something.
- Axsuul 14y agoLook at this way. If there was enough interest out there, this wouldn't have been a problem.
- byoung2 14y agoThere is an "ending soon" filter on Kickstarter, but no "almost funded" option. They should consider adding that in the future.
- xanadohnt 14y agoHow can you not get yourself (OK, maybe there are validation checks) or a single friend to cover the last $28?
- codewright 14y ago>Looks like in the final second, they were still $828 short, but someone chipped in $800... Weird.
- nostromo 14y agoPony up $28 yourself, get $50,000. What were they thinking?
- byoung2 14y agoAmazon has strict rules about sending yourself money through Amazon payments. Visa/Mastercard see it as an illegal cash advance, or money laundering. They could step into the gray area and pay someone cash to back their project, or promise to repay them later. If I were in this situation, I feel confident that I could call someone and ask for a $28 pledge. A post on Reddit or HN would have done the trick most likely.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- Moto7451 14y agoI think the simple way around that mess is to give $28 to your friend, brother, aunt, uncle, girlfriend, or anyone else you know with a pulse that will follow through. I'm a little confused as to why they wouldn't have done exactly that.
- byoung2 14y agoIt's been pointed out in other comments that they were $828 down in the final seconds, and someone pledged $800. It could be that they did reach out to someone for that pledge. Though if that were the case, why didn't that person pledge $828? This was a rare feat to come so close to the goal and fall short (http://www.kickstarter.com/help/stats http://www.kickstarter.com/help/stats). 81% of projects that reach 20% are ultimately successful, and only 0.005% of failed projects reach 81%-99% of their goal. I think the real failure was not making a stronger final push in the last few days of the campaign instead of the last few seconds. They also should have timed the ending better. Saturday night is when people go out. Sunday evening people are online, and Monday morning after the first of the month is good because a lot of people will be online at work right after payday.
- 14y ago
- goldfeld 14y agoI bet this guy would have amassed far more funds if his pledge texts hadn't been so uninvitingly big. Kickstarter should really offer a best practices on this: 1) make it simple and easy to understand each level--make your levels cumulative best as you can and then simply say "plus all previous tiers." 2) don't waste your first level on a $1 "get mentioned" reward--you're just sacrificing your above-the-fold real state with something that, from most projects I've seen, doesn't amount to a single decent level pledge (i.e. all those $1 added together make up something like twenty bucks). Drumming up interest is as much about marketing as it is about content.
- richforrester 14y agoLooks like in the final second, they were still $828 short, but someone chipped in $800... Weird.
- mylittlepony 14y agoThat's some high level troll right there.
- zachinglis 14y agoProject gets $49,972 out of $50,000 goal. Creator says "clearly there simply isn't that much interest in building the kind of game I envisioned." o.O;
- johnpmayer 14y agoWell, that is only enough money for a single programmer to work 9-5 for somewhere between 6-12 months.
- taytus 14y agoYeah, but that's the money they were asking for.
- vacri 14y agoThe bare minimum. If there was a lot of interest, it would have been easily covered.
- eropple 14y agoThe thing is, that's all you can ask for or you look like a scam artist or an idiot because you're over-asking. People, for better or worse, take into account how much you're asking for relative to what you promise, and fund or don't fund based on that. The unfortunate thing about game development Kickstarters is that the worst thing that can happen is that you make exactly your goal.
- zachinglis 14y agoYou also get relative too though. If you ask for $5000. Chances are you're going to get closer to that, than $50,000. If you ask for $500,000. Chances are you're going to get higher than the $5,000. Plenty of people have gone for the big dollars. http://www.kickstarter.com/projects/obsidian/project-eternity http://www.kickstarter.com/projects/obsidian/project-eternit... Granted it's Obsidian, but people still blew it out the water.
- meric 14y agoIf you are interested in a sequel of M.U.L.E: http://www.planetmule.com/about http://www.planetmule.com/about
- thedz 14y agoFrom a comment on the Kickstarter page, it looks like someone was trolling by donating almost enough at the last second: My wife continued watching, as I went off to bed, and I heard a loud gasp... (her hands were up on her face as I walked back in). The final bump that put it up to $49972 appeared to come from one backer's pledge raise in the final seconds, when nobody could do anything at all (like single digits of seconds). That person raised by over $800 at once, but chose (WHY?!) not to go in another $28. My perspective is that it was on purpose, they did not have the funds available, and they wanted to make a point. Otherwise that pledge (and a corresponding comment!) could have come with a minute to go, and a chance for me (or others watching) to kick in the final dollars.
- goldfeld 14y agoOr they were really trying to make a point and/or help a cause they knew, by then, that was failing. In which case it seems to have worked. I think this wouldn't be as newsworthy had it fallen short by a thousand dollars. And the publicity the project owner will be getting could still be channelled into a happy ending.
- georgeorwell 14y agoMy feeling is that more than anything, better artwork would have helped here. I just personally don't like looking at those screenshots with the bright colours and drab hex-grid landscape, never mind what the gameplay is about. Maybe it would help if Kickstarter had a kind of pledge that said, "Only if this project would not otherwise be funded."
- Moto7451 14y agoAside from the already asked question of why didn't they pony up the $28, the second thought that hits me is perhaps Kickstarter should have a margin where they will allow the project to continue at the digression of the project management? I.e. if you're within 1% of your stated goal ($500 in this case) you can choose to continue. I could see projects that perhaps really had loftier goals and set a low number to try to encourage people to commit bow out it they were within the 1% threshold. Meanwhile being less than a tenth of a percent from your goal and not making it really sucks and likely isn't beneficial for anyone involved. edit: Another thought: If KS still wants a hard cutoff, give the project another 6 hours or something to make that 1%.
- connortomas 14y agoFrom the stats Kickstarter have released previously, situations like this (in which a project just barely doesn't reach its target) seem extremely rare. Kickstarter works because the model is simple: a hard deadline, a hard target, and go. It sucks that they were so close, but I don't think it would be in Kickstarter's interests to tweak the system to assist almost-made-it edge cases like this.
- lamestergame 14y agoGames are such a waste of capital & neurons. Make something that actually helps humanity not just lines your pockets, and wastes other humans neuron potential.
- eropple 14y agoI realize that you're really just a troll and that I shouldn't give you the satisfaction, but I am just compelled to play word substitution with what you've said: Painting is such a waste of capital & neurons. Sculpture is such a waste of capital & neurons. Fiction is such a waste of capital & neurons. Music is such a waste of capital & neurons. The ugliest part is that you know, not very deep down, that it's a dickish, indefensible statement, and that's why you made a sock-puppet account to make a shitty comment that implicitly devalues all art. It might be nonsensical and vile, but hey--you can feel good about yourself. Go to hell.
- cmaggard 14y agoThis is also the second time they've tried to do this[1]- their first goal was, shall we say, ambitious. [1] http://www.kickstarter.com/projects/1547218311/alpha-colony-a-tribute-to-mule?ref=users http://www.kickstarter.com/projects/1547218311/alpha-colony-...