7 ms·
I think this is very relevant here - interview with the NSA whistleblower, William Binney, on how NSA is storing every post people are making online, so they (a
by mtgx 14y ago
I think this is very relevant here - interview with the NSA whistleblower, William Binney, on how NSA is storing every post people are making online, so they (and FBI) can use it later:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TuET0kpHoyM http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TuET0kpHoyM
No wonder NSA and FBI want warrantless access to private companies by lobbying for new laws like CISPA, and trying to build backdoors in services like Facebook, Skype, Twitter etc. They want to know absolutely everything you do online, besides your public posts:
http://www.wired.com/threatlevel/2012/05/fbi-seeks-internet-backdoors/ http://www.wired.com/threatlevel/2012/05/fbi-seeks-internet-...
I don't know if they are doing it out of malice/power grabbing/control, or purely as a way to make their jobs more "efficient". But their #1 priority should always, always, be respecting the Constitution, and not trying to skirt around it. And I think they've forgotten all about that long ago.
- revelation 14y agoI think the point is democratic states should (need) not have intelligence agencies with unlimited powers. They corrupt the state as they establish themselves as a central pillar of power (next to the military and the government). They don't even have any historical roots in western political systems. The country with the claim to that is Russia (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Okhrana http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Okhrana), where they were commonly used to quell internal unrest and combat opposition.
- hythloday 14y agoThe role of an internal secret police goes back at least as far as the Roman Frumentarii[0] and I think you can trace a direct lineage from Walsingham's[1] operations to the CIA/NSA. [0] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Frumentarii http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Frumentarii [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Francis_Walsingham#Entrapment_of_Mary.2C_Queen_of_Scots http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Francis_Walsingham#Entrapment_o...
- xfs 14y agoThey don't mean to grab particular information about every individual. They want to ensure completeness of their data mining results.
- bluedanieru 14y agoForget about the Constitution. Rather, they should respect basic human rights and the principles of the Enlightenment. All this focus Americans put on their Constitution makes it easier for their government to become oppressive, because it encourages complacency. As though you could write the perfect set of laws, that you could define the perfect set of operating principles for your government, and in that way free yourself of tyranny forever and guarantee a free and open society for you and all your descendants. No, the price of liberty is eternal vigilance.
- wissler 14y agoInsightful. I'm curious as to what you think are the basic human rights and the principles of the Enlightenment.
- bluedanieru 14y agoDoes it matter? I'm not debating the principles of the Constitution here, but rather the American focus on the document rather than the principles themselves.
- wissler 14y agoI don't think the principles are common knowledge. Of course they matter.
- sliverstorm 14y agoI think his deflection of your question suggests he was using them as rhetorical literary devices.
- wissler 14y agoInsightful. ;) Yes, I was surprised by his responses, I thought his initial remark was great, but people mean quite different things by those lofty abstractions.
- Myrmornis 14y ago> their #1 priority should always, always, be respecting the Constitution Presumably their #1 priority can be specified in a more rational way without random worshipping of some old document? Other countries, not blessed with the Constitution of the USA, also have intelligence and law enforcement agencies.
- javert 14y agoNo. The Constitution defines the proper form and responsibility of American government. If the Constitution falls, we no longer have legitimate government. That's historical fact. Other governments' law enforcement agencies follow the laws of their own countries (or don't). Are you saying they shouldn't do that?
- andrewflnr 14y agoRight. The point of a Constitution or whatever is to have some kind of law to follow. You don't need to worship it, it's just your axioms of government. That's your "rational way" of specifying priority #1.
- oelewapperke 14y agoWeird that nobody realizes that the constitution does say that the government not only has the right to violate any (other) law to violate the constitution, but actually has the duty to do so. To protect the constitution (and it's application within it's jurisdiction), the president (ie. the government) has the right AND the duty to violate ANY American law except clause 1 and 2 of the constitution. To put it plainly : the ONLY thing the president cannot do to defend the constitution is to mess with elections. That's it. It also states that the president is the person making the assessment if an action is necessary (and thus, not the courts, though of course, the president can be removed from office for making a decision that either congress or the courts think was not reasonable. That does not change the fact that the president cannot be punished for implementing that action. The maximum penalty for any crime for the president is impeachment, unless this is specifically extended by congress). This is because article 2 of the constitution overrides every other law in the US, except article 1, including all following articles and amendments. If you think this sequence is by accident, you should talk to a lawyer about things like this. Sequence in laws, and the principle that earlier rules override later ones is extremely well established technique of law. What everybody seems to think these laws state, that you have extensive rights without any qualifications whatsoever, is just plainly not true. If you are a danger to the application of the US constitution within US borders, the president is not bound to any standard, nor does he have to respect any form of human rights in his attempts to stop you from doing so. If you think it is better in European states, think again. Specifically, read what the Dutch monarch is allowed to do (e.g. she can have someone killed - both her and the actual murderer go free, she can confiscate any amount of property - with no legal recourse for anyone, etc.). Similar things are true for other Euro countries.
- artichokeheart 14y ago"But their #1 priority should always, always, be respecting the Constitution, and not trying to skirt around it. And I think they've forgotten all about that long ago." That's the irony of the whole American security apparatus. They are in place, nominally, in order to protect American citizens rights to live with the freedoms inherently granted to them by the Constitution.
- consciousness 14y ago^ This -- nailed it.
- Ankaios 14y agoThis doesn't detract from your point, but I thought I should correct something just because there are a lot of overseas readers here who might not be very familiar with the US Constitution: The Constitution does not grant freedoms to citizens. Instead, it delegates specific powers from the citizens to the federal government.
- frozenport 14y agoThe FBI's actions aren't in any way different then Google. Who also crawl the Internet and download every post people make.
- b6 14y agoI'm sorry, but you couldn't be more wrong. The NSA's dossiers are automatically being built from data they're getting via the expensive hardware they forced telecom companies to install, not scraped data from the web. If your email, or SMS, or voice call, or fax, or IM, or whatever else they care about and know how to parse, ever goes through any of their boxes, it's stored and associated with your entity forever, and may be used to glean unknown levels of insight about you, or used against you in criminal cases.
- wildranter 14y agoSure they aren't, the difference lies on what they do with the data. While Google will use that data to show you harmless text advertisement, the FBI might use it to backup a phony case against you, that can ultimately put an end to your freedom. I'd say that's an incredible difference. Wouldn't you too?
- Draiken 14y agoStill, you cannot know everything they do with that data. They show us the advertises, but what else are they doing? What guarantees do we have that they do not sell or give out information? I'd stay both sides are bad. We may see them as completely different things, but you have to agree, in both sides, what we see is just the tip of the iceberg.
- wildranter 14y agoYes, both sides are bad. But only one of these can lock you up in jail for whatever reason they want whether or not you're guilty. Besides, if you want to avoid having your data collected and possibly sold without you conscent just stop googleling your thoughts. Now, the real question. How to avoid governments taking over our rights?
- dguido 14y agoYou know, people keep repeating this assumption that the NSA stores every post that people make online. Maybe someone should do a quick back of the envelope calculation to see how feasible that actually is? My guess is that it's nowhere near possible given the amount of network traffic coming into/out of the US and current hard drive storage technology. IMHO the extreme amount of volume and limitations of storage space should create a necessity to be at least somewhat targeted in scope. Not sure why people don't use common sense a bit more often...
- nodata 14y agoSo somebody else should do a calculation, and based on the result of that calculation which you didn't do, people should use common sense more often?
- yardie 14y ago> the extreme amount of volume and limitations of storage space. Speak for yourself then. I've already got 10TB of storage at home in a case the size of a shoebox. It's got my entire life in it (at least every file I've created since university), but most of it is storing my movie and music collection. So, realistically your entire life can fit in a 1TB drive once you exclude videos and transcode audio. 2-4TB if you're a person of interest. Do know that 1 Backblaze 4U-server holds 135TB. They are building a datacenter in Utah with 100,000sqft[1] of rackspace. 20,000 racks per floor (I don't know if there are multiple stories) gives you 29.7 petabytes if they used a Backblaze solution. So yes, if the US govt wanted to record everything you did everyday they are more than capable of doing it, now. [1]http://www.wired.com/threatlevel/2012/03/ff_nsadatacenter/ http://www.wired.com/threatlevel/2012/03/ff_nsadatacenter/
- Exabitionistic 14y agoThey are sitting on at least an Exabyte. With multiple-Yottabytes of traffic.
- yardie 14y agoYou're right, I'm off by a few magnitudes. 29.7 exabytes if they use every square foot for servers JBOD. And that is with current disk tech.
- Ntrails 14y agoI wonder how many times goatse.cx appears in that database.