3 ms·
How sure are you that 40 bits is a good number of bits? What's your justification? It takes over 30 years to deploy new bits, so you have to be really sure befo
by inigyou 5mo ago
How sure are you that 40 bits is a good number of bits? What's your justification? It takes over 30 years to deploy new bits, so you have to be really sure before you start that effort.
- ralfd 5mo ago> It takes over 30 years Only because it is overengineered. Parents pragmatic protocol would have been adopted faster
- inigyou 5mo agoIPv6 is just IPv4 with more address bits.
- comfydragon 5mo agoIt really isn't. I mean, at a very basic addressing level, sure, IPv4 addresses and IPv6 addresses are just a sequence of octets. But at a network infrastructure level they are quite different, and IPv6 is (conceptually) designed for large-scale, hands-off deployments. See: SLAAC, NDP, DAD, GUA/ULA/link-local address scopes, unicast vs. multicast vs. anycast, etc.
- sherburt3 5mo ago40 bits would've bought us a lot of time and would've kicked the can down the road several decades. People from the future would be much better equipped to design a new protocol because they understand their needs better.
- inigyou 5mo agoHow many decades? If several means six, we're already halfway there and at 50% deployment. What's the point of designing something you know will be obsolete the moment it hits 100% deployment?