4 ms·
Or make a new account?
by inigyou 5mo ago
Or make a new account?
- tartoran 5mo agoYou risk being silenly flagged and get nerfed responses. Somehting like shadow dumbed down.
- stingraycharles 5mo agoThat’s quite a claim. What’s your source for this?
- 0123456789ABCDE 5mo agoFable's model card provides the following as a relevant reference https://xcancel.com/ClaudeDevs/status/2064949876463645026 https://xcancel.com/ClaudeDevs/status/2064949876463645026
- stingraycharles 5mo agoThat’s totally unrelated. The post I was replying to claimed that if you create a new account with OpenAI and that gets detected, your whole account gets silently “nerfed”. That is not in any way related to Fable (visibly) being switched to a less strong model if you’re trying to discuss certain topics.
- 0123456789ABCDE 5mo ago> That’s totally unrelated. i disagree, but it seems clear, from how you put it, that there's no point explaining the why
- mlyle 5mo ago> That is not in any way related to Fable (visibly) being switched to a less strong model if you’re trying to discuss certain topics. We're talking about it being invisibly moved to a weaker model if it looks like you're distilling (which is best detected through something that is at least partially a reputational / account metric). Now, Anthropic stepped away from this, but it highlights one more kind of systemic risk you're exposed to when you're not running the model yourself.
- preg_match 5mo agoIt demonstrates that: 1. Anthropic certainly has the ability. 2. They’re willing to use it silently.
- anamexis 5mo agoAnd this thread is about OpenAI.
- handoflixue 5mo agoThey already reversed course on that decision a couple of days later. Trivial to find a source, but Fable is also rather notably not available to the public right now, so it's not actually a relevant threat.
- 0123456789ABCDE 5mo agoexcuse me but, is this trivial source you're referring to the url included in the post you're responding to, or did they reverse back to the original intent of keeping refusals quiet?
- shevy-java 5mo agoSo ... like reddit! :) Thankfully I don't depend on any of such services. It would make me rather angry.
- inigyou 5mo agoHN also has shadowbans. If your preferences have showdead=yes, you might see some.
- eimrine 5mo agoThat's a decent moderation, shadowban is a totally different thing. AFAIK, your karma is enough to vouch that Flagged topics or comments and return that piece into a regular displaying.
- inigyou 5mo agoThere's no difference between shadowban and moderation, shadowban is a moderation tool.
- eimrine 5mo agoShadowban and community-driven moderation are different poles. Former is a tool of shallow narcisses, latter is the best moderation strategy possible in the clearnet. Come on, commenter.
- qingcharles 5mo agoReddit is the only platform that actually tells you that you are shadowbanned, so at least they are upfront about it, but their appeal system sucks. My friend just appealed every day for just over 600 days and finally got their account un-shadowbanned.
- inigyou 5mo agoReddit doesn't tell you you're shadowbanned. You are thinking of regular banned.
- gentooflux 5mo agoThat is an inherent and unavoidable risk regardless, as things stand if you want access to frontier models you are at the mercy of their providers.
- JimDabell 5mo agoThe whole point of an identity check is that they know exactly who you are. If you tell them who you are and you fail the identity check, you can’t simply create a new account because when you go through the identity check for a second time you’ll still need to tell them exactly who you are, at which point they can match the new account to the original failure.
- polack 5mo agoSo I’ll just automate failed verifications for everyone I want to lock out?
- handoflixue 5mo agoAn empty account and an account with a year of history have very different weights in this - most people already have an account tied to their legal name, paid for with a credit card in that same legal name. Throw in some geo-location, browser fingerprinting, etc. to disambiguate the surprisingly rare case of two customers with the exact same name. For a paid product, it's really not that hard to already have a fairly solid idea of what's going on - this just ensures that a responsible adult has gone through a clear process of signing off on the identity for this specific service, rather than a kid with their parent's credit card.
- caymanjim 5mo ago> to disambiguate the surprisingly rare case of two customers with the exact same name I see you have an uncommon name. My first+last are shared by about 20,000 people in the US. From 2005-2020 I was unable to check-in for airlines online or even at the kiosk at the airport. I had to wait on line for baggage check-in despite never checking a bag, and they'd take my ID into the back room and delay me for 15 minutes and whisper and glare at me the whole time. Thankfully I can finally fly like a normal person again. When I worked at a large company, there were four other people with the same first name, middle initial, and last name. There is nothing surprising or rare about two customers having the same name.