11 ms·
Never mind talent: Practice, practice, practice
- kiba 14y agoGenius is not a thing, but a process. Genius need the proper environment to cultivate talents like our well endowed genetically engineered corns need fertilizers and pesticides. It doesn't matters if you have an IQ of 200 when you're born several thousand years too early. You never make use of your genius, except to make lot of babies and become the chief of your tribe, if you're lucky. Granted, there's lot of people who are innately smarter than you, but chance are they're also stuck in various positions of life where they can't become a genius like a job at wal-mart, or having children too early, or is stuck in a hut in a third world country somewhere. If you're reading this, chance are you have the money and the time to rearrange your environment and your behaviors to achieve mastery. The hard part is figuring out how to do that and how to sustain that.
- sown 14y ago> It doesn't matters if you have an IQ of 200 when you're born several thousand years too early. You never make use of your genius, except to make lot of babies and become the chief of your tribe, if you're lucky. If you're in a stone age tribe, that is probably the most important thing you can do. Just because some stone age chieftain can't figure out how to smelt iron doesn't mean that they failed or are wasting their talents.
- unoti 14y agoI've long felt that my intelligence is only average, and I've always tried to compensate by working hard. It had been 20 years since my last calculus class when I returned to college, and I was quite worried I'd not be able to keep up. I worked my way through most of a small calculus book before starting the class, to refresh what I'd forgotten. During the class, I spent something like 5-6 hours per day during the week working on Calculus, and around 10 hours per day on the weekends. I worked and reworked every problem until I fully understood what was going on, comparing my answers to the answer key for the odd problems, and computer algebra systems for the even ones when possible. I worked so hard it would have been embarrassing to admit it to my classmates. Only a retard would have to work so much, I thought, but I was determined to be the best I could. I ended up at the top of the class. The point is, if you're really determined, working hard can go a long way. The key is to try not to worry about the other people that make it look easy. Later I heard this quote: "If people knew how hard I had to work to gain my mastery, it would not seem so wonderful at all." - Michaelangelo
- kiba 14y agoIt had been 20 years since my last calculus class when I returned to college The greatest problem with our educational system is to neglect the fact that students begin to forget immediately after graduation. All these years in k-12 education gradually turns to dust until only reading, writing, and some basic agelbra are left, and some career related knowledge. Trignometry? Biology? Chemistry? These are subjects that all adults once know in their high school years, now all forgotten. Instead of documentaries assuming we know chemistry, or trignometery, or biology, they introduced "DNA" as if we never been in a biology class. They only skims the top of the scientific knowledge cake because they never assume everybody knows. Imagine the complexity and increased believablity of fiction and non-fiction if they have to wrestle with an audience that know those things by heart, even if they only took a chemistry class that single semester? Alas, we forgotten and our educational dollars disappeared in a puff of smoke.
- bithive123 14y agoYou seem to think education should be like putting music on an iPod. As with all skills, what doesn't find use decays. I believe education should create well rounded people by exposing them to the the breadth of human achievements in the arts as well as sciences. I don't remember all the books we read in English class either, but I appreciate literature more in general having been there. The real tragedy is that many educational programs emphasize the kind of rote learning you seem to want everyone to aspire to instead of critical thinking faculties which, properly instilled, will assert themselves for a lifetime.
- kiba 14y agoI believe education should create well rounded people by exposing them to the the breadth of human achievements in the arts as well as sciences. I don't remember all the books we read in English class either, but I appreciate literature more in general having been there. I don't particularly care about English literature or any <subject x> for the sake of building a well rounded education. The more important thing is retaining what you learned and building on that. The real tragedy is that many educational programs emphasize the kind of rote learning you seem to want everyone to aspire to instead of critical thinking faculties which, properly instilled, will assert themselves for a lifetime. To think memorization is bad is incredibly short sighted and stupid. Would you like to look up a book every time you do programming? No. You remember certain methods and certain part of the standard library so that you don't have to spend 10 minutes googling method x to accomplish result y. Principles is nice and all, but what make you an efficient problem solver is because you have access to an inner world of factoids and knowledge. Sure, memorization for the sake of memorization is useless. That's why you learn critical thinking skills that you love so much so that memorization will be useful.
- tchock23 14y agoIf anyone is curious as to the research on this topic, check out Carol Dweck's book "Mindset." It has a ton of examples from academia, sports and business on fixed vs. growth mentalities and how that plays into a person's success in life.
- _nato_ 14y agoI studied violin at Juilliard with the great Dorothy DeLay. She taught the greats such as Perlman and Midori, and she insisted that 'talent' was nothing more than a 'mood.' I will always treat her viewpoint on this as gold having taught so many youngsters over the decades. So, work hard, and think big of yourselves as your reward (although that can be so hard to do!)
- sown 14y agoSo what about when you have someone like me who works hard and still fails? I vary my methods. change my environment to make it easier, pay for training, do what ever. I examine what I did wrong, I still get it wrong, no matter what. Let me share with you an anecdote: In undergrad, I took an intro computer networking class. Everyone else could understand what was going on. There was no assigned reading material and lectures didn't follow from any text. I always was the lowest student in the class, no matter how hard I tried. Everyone else could understand it quickly. I worked hard on that class but it didn't matter. Not everyone who works hard will show positive results, I guess. I more or less flunked my way through school. Sometimes I'd work hard, sometimes not. It didn't seem to matter. Or, if I'm facing someone who has worked hard and is also very intelligent? I don't have a chance. The rhetoric of these articles and the rest of these posts here have a coded meaning behind them: there are no disadvantaged people or students -- only stupid or lazy ones. It's a corollary of Survivor Bias. If you work hard, everything will be peachy-keen OK and nothing will go wrong. If you work hard and fail, you deserve only scorn. For me, it was, never mind if you work so hard that ignored everything else, worked so hard to not get beaten by your parents, worked so hard to get mastery of material -- I must be still too lazy or stupid since I failed. I don't know what it is that I don't have that everyone else does. I'm likely to not ever know. This is a topic that I'm very familiar with so that's why I wrote a lot about it and sound perhaps a little crazy.
- namank 14y agoSo you have the practice part down, now you can work on working smarter? Should be easy for you, working smarter is easier than working hard.
- mershad 14y agoInteresting to consider, though not discussed much in the article: quality of practice is paramount. Thoughtful and deliberate generates incremental progress. Casual, mentally checked-out practice isn't practice at all. Some discussion & sources here: http://ideas.time.com/2012/01/25/the-myth-of-practice-makes-perfect/ http://ideas.time.com/2012/01/25/the-myth-of-practice-makes-... One mantra tossed around of late is "_perfect_ practice makes perfect," meaning not to never make mistakes, but to be conscious and analytical when you do.
- tokenadult 14y agoPaul Graham has mentioned similar issues several times in essays posted on his personal website. For example, he wrote in "What You'll Wish You'd Known" (January 2005), http://www.paulgraham.com/hs.html http://www.paulgraham.com/hs.html ". . . . In fact I suspect if you had the sixteen year old Shakespeare or Einstein in school with you, they'd seem impressive, but not totally unlike your other friends. "Which is an uncomfortable thought. If they were just like us, then they had to work very hard to do what they did. And that's one reason we like to believe in genius. It gives us an excuse for being lazy. . . . " In "How do Do What You Love" (January 2006), http://www.paulgraham.com/love.html http://www.paulgraham.com/love.html he wrote, "Sometimes jumping from one sort of work to another is a sign of energy, and sometimes it's a sign of laziness. Are you dropping out, or boldly carving a new path? You often can't tell yourself. Plenty of people who will later do great things seem to be disappointments early on, when they're trying to find their niche. "Is there some test you can use to keep yourself honest? One is to try to do a good job at whatever you're doing, even if you don't like it. Then at least you'll know you're not using dissatisfaction as an excuse for being lazy. Perhaps more importantly, you'll get into the habit of doing things well." And in "The Anatomy of Determination" (December 2009), http://www.paulgraham.com/determination.html http://www.paulgraham.com/determination.html he wrote, "In most domains, talent is overrated compared to determination—partly because it makes a better story, partly because it gives onlookers an excuse for being lazy, and partly because after a while determination starts to look like talent." Mathematician Hung-hsi Wu wrote an article more than a decade ago, Basic skills versus conceptual understanding: A bogus dichotomy in mathematics education, American Educator, Fall 1999, Vol. 23, No. 3, pp. 14-19, 50-52, http://www.aft.org/pdfs/americaneducator/fall1999/wu.pdf http://www.aft.org/pdfs/americaneducator/fall1999/wu.pdf to point out that any distinction between understanding a topic and having basic skills in the topic is a "bogus dichotomy." The two go together like two sides of the same coin.
- unoti 14y agoExcellent stuff. Along the same lines: Someone once told me that the difference between a professional and an amateur is that a professional keeps working on it long after it stops being fun. This is true in the discussion of Penn & Teller below, as well as game programming, and probably all worthy endeavors. Wish I could remember the reference...
- chimpinee 14y agoThis article appeals to our deepest and most widely-held educational values, which makes it all the more dangerous, being wrong in several ways. The author rightly belittles the concept of talent but it seems to have found its way in through the back door: “Two of our four turned out to be musically gifted and before long were shuttled out of Suzuki to hard-core classical violin teachers.” (Talent is just the way we describe people who have some competence in a field which is inexplicit; nobody knows why they are good, otherwise one could learn it.) Another thing to point out is that apparently none of the children have developed careers in music or composition (yet), so it remains to be seen if they have any creativity intact. Why might they have lost creativity in adulthood? Because of childhood coercion. Those long hours of practice -- children don’t do that without being forced. It can be subtle, such as the worry of a slight loss of parental affection, sibling rivalry encouraged, etc. Children will play for hours on end and this is where true learning occurs. Some children are bright enough to make their ‘practice’ a form of play, so they manage to improve despite appearances. Creative adults continue to play, it’s just that the subject matter appears more serious. But progress remains open-ended, with stops and starts, switching between activities, and unpredictable (not ‘guaranteed’) results. The unpredictable nature of achievement follows from a law of epistemology: we can’t predict future knowledge (including our own).
- osivertsson 14y agoA great book that explores this subject in more depth is Matthew Syed's book "Bounce - The myth of talent and the power of practice".
- thinkling 14y agoInterestingly, this is exactly compatible with what Andrea Dwork writes about in "Mindset" [1]: people whose identity evolves around being "smart" or "talented" are often less willing to take on risks or big projects than those who have grown up being praised for their efforts. [1] http://www.amazon.com/Mindset-Psychology-Success-Carol-Dweck/dp/0345472322/ http://www.amazon.com/Mindset-Psychology-Success-Carol-Dweck...
- unicornporn 14y agoMy girlfriend is a violinist and violin pedagogue. Everybody has always called her gifted but she has resisted every time and said: it is all about having the gift to be able to do 4 hours of intense practice each day from an early age. Not everybody has the ability to practice this hard.
- tubbo 14y agoartisticTalent = function(howMuchYouPractice, howAwareYouAreOfTheWorld);
- elliott99 14y agoHEY EVERYONE: ONE DAY, YOURE GOING TO DIE.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- Gigablah 14y agoYou have a natural talent for comedy!
- elliott99 14y agoI just feel that sometimes on HN people forget this.
- illuminate 14y agoWhat on earth does it have to do with the topic?
- elliott99 14y agoBecause I feel that people on HN try to micromanage their neurons to an extent that they evaluate themselves as if they were computer hardware.... "Well I only have so much RAM to do this task, but if increase my computer processing power through deliberate practice..." I was a bit offhand, I admit. I was in a bad mood when I made that comment. But I stand by the fact people on HN take themselves and their capabilities way too seriously, without any thought to the fact, say, that the internet and programming are only a minuscule fraction of our history as intelligent lifeforms. While I love the internet/programming/topics discussed on HN, I just think that people here are too hard on themselves. You're not a computer with specs, you are the results of hundreds of thousands of years of evolution.
- cafard 14y agoWell, yes and no. I remember reading, when I was in my teens, about a star guard in Louisiana who spent 8 or 10 hours a day playing basketball during his summers. I realized then that "adequate driveway player" was about where I was and would remain; I didn't have the drive to put in that kind of work. I realized also, though, that a) my body probably wouldn't stand up to that kind of intense work, and b) even if it did, I would be a much better but not much more than high-school JV quality. That said, the best do work damned hard.
- marcamillion 14y agoOne of my personality traits is that I don't like taking shortcuts. In fact, I hate taking them. I much prefer doing things "properly" and thoroughly. From painstakingly teaching myself programming to not incessantly 'cheesing' in SC2 to washing the dishes multiple times to brushing my teeth slowly. I am often ridiculed by my wife, and I always wondered where I got this from. This trait is something I want to teach my kids, but I never knew quite how. Until I read this article and it reminded me that I too did the Suzuki program, into classical violin after. I remembered practicing a lot - and I remember getting frustrated frequently. I also remember the short burst of adrenaline I would feel, and the overwhelming feeling of accomplishment, when I get that 'trill' just perfect or when I perfected my vibrato. Even though I have since put down the violin, I feel the same accomplishment when I tackle something hard (in programming) and I eventually figure it out. I need to remember to thank my parents for insisting that I keep at the violin, even when I was very frustrated and wanted to rage quit.
- robertk 14y agoIn light of evolutionary psychology, talent is a combination of domain-specific neural adaptations and illusions. We know from data mining and machine learning that more data equals better results. Since one example of machine learning is neural networks (i.e. you), we know that more data (i.e. practice) leads to improved performance. For example, we know that the brain implements certain cognitive adaptations multiple times in differing but co-adaptive formats. If you had four neural clusters dedicated to spatial visualization and your friend had only three, you would be better at geometry. But if your friend practiced a lot, he could repurpose chunks of his neocortex to use his three clusters and then some with finer heuristics, with the result of beating you in geometry even though you had more "talent" and potential at equivalent practice rates. Moral of the story: don't worry about talent, practice makes better, kids.
- argumentum 14y agoMy favorite PG essay: http://www.paulgraham.com/determination.html http://www.paulgraham.com/determination.html In most domains, talent is overrated compared to determination—partly because it makes a better story, partly because it gives onlookers an excuse for being lazy, and partly because *after a while determination starts to look like talent*.
- nadam 14y agoI would say you have to consider the competition. (how competitive is the market you want to participate in). If you compete with very hardworking people ('everybody in the field works hard') then talent will be a differentiator. If you compete in a competition/market where for some reason hard work is not yet common then your hard work can be your differentiator. Choose your fights wisely.
- dschiptsov 14y agoPractice in studying the most talent ones.)
- andremendes 14y ago"Me, I want to be a natural. I want to show up at the first class and discover I have a knack for whatever it is we're going to study - pottery, Japanese calligraphy, racquetball, oil painting, flute. I don't mind work, as long as it comes easily, with guaranteed results. But I'm usually the class dunce, or at least that's what it feels like as I struggle to keep up after the going gets tough. Eventually I quit, loath to spend precious effort on what could be a mediocre outcome." This almost hurt me phisically.