3 ms·

Uhhh.. for a page thats about GUIs, this seems awfully sparse for the actual look and feel of said GUIs. How about some screenshots? Its very difficult to com

Uhhh.. for a page thats about GUIs, this seems awfully sparse for the actual look and feel of said GUIs. How about some screenshots? Its very difficult to compare X to Y anywhere on this site. Its just an aggregator, not really an exemplary resource.

entrope 4mo ago
The answer to the question posed in the site's domain name is "no", unfortunately. It looks like it just grabbed the intro to each project's self-description, but blurbs like "Zero-cost ultra-high-performance declarative DOM library using FRP signals" would be worth very little even with screenshots.
- amarant 4mo ago
  "no" is reductive to the point of being misleading. Cosmic DE is built using iced which is a rust gui library. As far as native, single-platform guis go, I'd say rust is plenty mature. There's also Bevy, a rust game engine, which, if I'm not mistaken is built on egui(?), and I think supports multiple compile targets. Between a desktop environment and a game engine, I'd say rust is in a pretty decent place when it comes to gui.
  - mharrig1 4mo ago
    > There's also Bevy, a rust game engine, which, if I'm not mistaken is built on egui(?) Not entirely correct, they have bevy_ui as the in-house example but many people use the third party bevy_egui crate
  - hitekker 4mo ago
    “No” is a straightforward answer to “areweguiyet” in Rust. Many well intentioned and well-invested projects with no winning GUIs means we’re not there yet. Saying “almost” or “yes” privileges the activity and hype around Rust GUI over actual results. Bevy is the ironic example: a game engine that produces more discussion and code than, so far, one notable & good game.
hirako2000 4mo ago
Perhaps it's to show how fragmented the community is.
zipy124 4mo ago
Is that actually needed? Styling is largely a user decision. They might have defaults yes, but if you looked at a raw HTML page with no CSS styling, you might come to the conclusion that websites have an ugly GUI...
- bla3 4mo ago
  This is the mindset that gives you Java-Style GUIs.
  - whou 4mo ago
    I love Java-style GUIs though.
- qweqwe14 4mo ago
  It absolutely is. Defaults matter, most developers just want a GUI for their app that doesn't look like ass. Almost no one wants to mess with styling.
  - fragmede 4mo ago
    That's why developers have UI/UX and design experts assigned to them. That's why Figma exists. CSS was an attempt to not have to deal with styling. It failed, and landed in the other direction.
    - gordonhart 4mo ago
      > That's why developers have UI/UX and design experts assigned to them. Not everybody works in big tech.
NoboruWataya 4mo ago
Yes, I think it's trying to be comprehensive (as far as possible) rather than detailed. Given the amount of frameworks listed, including representative screenshots or comparisons for each would be a substantial effort. The best primer on the current(ish) state of GUI programming in Rust, IMO, is this article from 2025 which is linked on that page: https://www.boringcactus.com/2025/04/13/2025-survey-of-rust-gui-libraries.html https://www.boringcactus.com/2025/04/13/2025-survey-of-rust-...
- brandnewideas 4mo ago
  Opening that site prompts my browser to download a `Human_fart.wav` file.
  - IshKebab 4mo ago
    Seems like a referrer of HN triggers that. Copy & paste the URL and it works fine. Idiotic.
    - yesbabyyes 4mo ago
      Seems like it. > Idiotic. Yes, seeing how simple it seems to redirect to a page playing the sound, instead. ;)
- hitekker 4mo ago
  Almost all the screenshots in this article are “hello world”…
eviks 4mo ago
How would screenshots help you in accessing a framework? How would you know whether a button supports accessibility and whether you need to declare it as a button in code or in a DSL? Or whether text editing supports mac-specific shortcuts? At most it could give you an idea about whether some widgets are supported, but even there a list you could filter frameworks by would be worth a thousand screenshots

entrope 4mo ago

The answer to the question posed in the site's domain name is "no", unfortunately. It looks like it just grabbed the intro to each project's self-description, but blurbs like "Zero-cost ultra-high-performance declarative DOM library using FRP signals" would be worth very little even with screenshots.

amarant 4mo ago
"no" is reductive to the point of being misleading. Cosmic DE is built using iced which is a rust gui library. As far as native, single-platform guis go, I'd say rust is plenty mature. There's also Bevy, a rust game engine, which, if I'm not mistaken is built on egui(?), and I think supports multiple compile targets. Between a desktop environment and a game engine, I'd say rust is in a pretty decent place when it comes to gui.
- mharrig1 4mo ago
  > There's also Bevy, a rust game engine, which, if I'm not mistaken is built on egui(?) Not entirely correct, they have bevy_ui as the in-house example but many people use the third party bevy_egui crate
- hitekker 4mo ago
  “No” is a straightforward answer to “areweguiyet” in Rust. Many well intentioned and well-invested projects with no winning GUIs means we’re not there yet. Saying “almost” or “yes” privileges the activity and hype around Rust GUI over actual results. Bevy is the ironic example: a game engine that produces more discussion and code than, so far, one notable & good game.

hirako2000 4mo ago

Perhaps it's to show how fragmented the community is.

zipy124 4mo ago

Is that actually needed? Styling is largely a user decision. They might have defaults yes, but if you looked at a raw HTML page with no CSS styling, you might come to the conclusion that websites have an ugly GUI...

bla3 4mo ago
This is the mindset that gives you Java-Style GUIs.
- whou 4mo ago
  I love Java-style GUIs though.
qweqwe14 4mo ago
It absolutely is. Defaults matter, most developers just want a GUI for their app that doesn't look like ass. Almost no one wants to mess with styling.
- fragmede 4mo ago
  That's why developers have UI/UX and design experts assigned to them. That's why Figma exists. CSS was an attempt to not have to deal with styling. It failed, and landed in the other direction.
  - gordonhart 4mo ago
    > That's why developers have UI/UX and design experts assigned to them. Not everybody works in big tech.

NoboruWataya 4mo ago

Yes, I think it's trying to be comprehensive (as far as possible) rather than detailed. Given the amount of frameworks listed, including representative screenshots or comparisons for each would be a substantial effort. The best primer on the current(ish) state of GUI programming in Rust, IMO, is this article from 2025 which is linked on that page: https://www.boringcactus.com/2025/04/13/2025-survey-of-rust-gui-libraries.html https://www.boringcactus.com/2025/04/13/2025-survey-of-rust-...

brandnewideas 4mo ago
Opening that site prompts my browser to download a `Human_fart.wav` file.
- IshKebab 4mo ago
  Seems like a referrer of HN triggers that. Copy & paste the URL and it works fine. Idiotic.
  - yesbabyyes 4mo ago
    Seems like it. > Idiotic. Yes, seeing how simple it seems to redirect to a page playing the sound, instead. ;)
hitekker 4mo ago
Almost all the screenshots in this article are “hello world”…

eviks 4mo ago

How would screenshots help you in accessing a framework? How would you know whether a button supports accessibility and whether you need to declare it as a button in code or in a DSL? Or whether text editing supports mac-specific shortcuts? At most it could give you an idea about whether some widgets are supported, but even there a list you could filter frameworks by would be worth a thousand screenshots